Might be an enjoyable read for a young person
I spent a few moments deciding between one and two stars. I’ve read worse, and among those are stories I just stop reading and don’t finish. This one I read through, and am planning on reading the next book, to see how things turn out. That must mean that there is worth here, right.
It just feels very basic, oversimplified and immature. These stories with child heroes often suffer from this plot weakness; it’s as though all the adults can think of anything without the child figuring it out through some divine power. That’s the draw of the story, a young person’s fantasy that they might reverse the common roles and have everything suddenly hinge on them.
That doesn’t mean that the adults have to be so vapid, and naive. I found it diff to accept the premises, and so had to push myself through the story. A utopian future in which mankind has given up warring is worth trying to envision, but not by assuming they just regressed into naivite and non-aggression.
At the heart of the story is a girl coming of age into metaphysical power, and dealing with the fact that she’s more unusual than anyone expected. It expresses both the frustration of being weird and the excitement of being special. It would have been worth seeing how men can arrange themselves in support of such a discover, if everyone’s behavior could be more believable.
If I were as young as the main character, I might enjoy this romp more. But even when I was that age, I preferred more fleshed out characters, and world building that had more cohesion.
This is a good book for casual reading that involves social interactions between vanilla humans, magically gifted humans and mythic creatures; it’s probably best kept to young readers.