I recently decided to start writing reviews of some books instead of just rating them. What a shame my first review has to be of “Earth Fall: Invasion”. While this is the first book I’ve read by the author, it seems he’s been quite prolific. You couldn’t tell from this amateurish attempt. It’s predictable and lacks depth, character development, and originality.
Spoilers to come.
The entire premise of the book is a rip-off of “Independence Day”. We have an alien spacecraft that crashes in Roswell in the 1940s, scientists who work in secret underground bases to reverse engineer the craft and develop new technologies, alien invaders bent on eliminating humanity, followed by the scientists figuring out how to beat the aliens when humanity is on the brink of defeat. The only thing different than the movie is the first alien craft is from a defeated enemy of the aliens who invade 80 years later, not one of the alien invaders crafts. This general theme is hardly original to “Independence Day”, so the author could be forgiven for replicating it if we were presented with original ideas and an engaging story; sadly we’re not.
One of the most baffling characters in the novel is Lisa, one of the main protagonists. Lisa is introduced to us several years before the invasion and we’re told she holds several degrees and is the best research assistant of the genius professor who, we later find out, is leading the program to develop alien technology. We’re repeatedly reminded how smart Lisa and the professor are. For reasons that are incomprehensible, the professor doesn’t tell Lisa about the alien research and have her help with his endeavors, instead he tells her to join the army and, for some reason, she abandons her scientific career and does this.
Several years later, the aliens conveniently invade just a few months before Lisa’s army time is finished and she’s tasked with observing them so she can pass crucial information to the professor; except she doesn’t, for months. They have her hide, without doing much of anything, while 80% of humanity is killed. Finally she comes out and scans a dead alien with some unexplained scanner and picks up an alien rifle with some special gloves; hardly tasks that require someone who’s so smart they’re “more important than an entire company of Army Rangers”.
Later Lisa is told about the alien research program and, for some unknowable reason, given an important position, in lieu of thousands of scientists who had been working on the program for years, even though she knows nothing about the new technology. She spends the rest of the book commenting on how cool the technology is and saying how much she has to learn. She’s a major part of the story yet contributes almost nothing.
Lisa is far from the only problem with this book however. A lot of time was spent in anticipation of things the scientists would learn from Lisa’s scans and how that would help them build new weapons and defenses. I was looking forward to some in depth discussion about these discoveries, alas it wasn’t to be. There were a total of two scientific components to the story; one was that the power supply problems were solved by wiring them in parallel (seriously?), the other was a new super-heat-resistant alloy that the humans hadn’t discovered yet still had the ability to manufacture in bulk essentially immediately.
While I would have liked more science, the science that was there was atrocious, and the scientists talked in a stilted, unbelievable way, reminiscent of a Jeff Goldblum character (more “Independence Day” references). If the author spent any time researching the science it was wasted, unless he spent that time watching Jeff Goldblum movies, in which case, well done.
The stilted speech of the scientists is emblematic of the lack of character development throughout the book. When someone expresses empathy for the massive loss of life it comes across as trite and insincere. When characters express feelings it’s never explored or affects their actions. All in all the people we meet are boring and hard to relate to.
One common theme of the book is repetition. We’re told how smart Lisa and the professor are, repeatedly. We reminded often about characters suspicions of secret research bases, so much that there’s an unrequited anticipation of something cool happening when they’re finally revealed in full. While there’s impressive detail of the weapons deployments the military uses, it gets old quickly; “More Claymores!”.
I could go on and on about the shallowness and superfluousness of this book, but I’m already shocked at the length of this review. My first one!
There is one good thing. The writing is extremely fast paced, no doubt that’s aided by the lack of character development and no impediments from having to write story arcs that make sense, but it does suck you in, at least for the first third of the book. Unfortunately, once you realize that there isn’t much there and your hope for a big payoff will not be realized, the book falls flat. It’s such a shame because the premise shows a lot of promise; quite the disappointment when all’s said and done.
Wow! I can’t believe how long this turned out to be. My disappointment must have gotten me a little worked up. I’m off to find another, better, book to read for my next, hopefully shorter, review.