How do you review a novel which defies classification? Gary Morgenstein’s A Mound Over Hell cannot be pigeonholed, and this is exactly what makes it so important and unique. The greatest works of science fiction were so great precisely because they did not remain with the limited definition of the genre. Think of Philip K. Dick, Stanislaw Lem, or Kurt Vonnegut and how they dealt with the nature of reality, not space travel and ray guns.
A Mound Over Hell does not occur two thousand years in the future, or in a far-away galaxy, or in an alternate universe. It is set right here on the earth we know, and only 80 years in the future – a time in which language and customs are not all that different from ours. People still talk about war, sport, and relationships in the same way, but the circumstances are nightmarish.
Is it science fiction, a dystopian novel? Yes. Radical Islam had defeated the United States in World War III. An elderly woman called “Grandma” who seems to be all love, all good, all about children and family, is the leader of the United States. Of course, the word “seems” may be important in this statement. Can she be trusted? Does she have an agenda of her own? Religion, social media, and banks are against the law. Americans hate and fear all Muslims, and no Jews are left. Robots who look like humans are also outlawed since they have lied about their identities, pretending to be humans and creating social chaos.
So it is a political commentary on our time, you say? In a way. Grandma attempts to reach moderate Muslims who hate the radical, corrupt Caliphate; together they hope to save both sides and restore decency. Narcissism is abhorred. All over the world terrorism and child trafficking are part of life. Treason is to be feared wherever you go, and no one can be trusted.
Is it a book about baseball? Of course. The protagonist, Puppy Nedick, is a baseball historian who works in Amazon Stadium, formerly Yankee Stadium, and the only ballpark not to have been destroyed by terrorism. It’s the final season, the last game. All games are usually played by robots and holograms – but not this one. Inexplicably, famous players from the past come back from the dead to play.
The author created an enormous stage, populated by a large number of personalities, all beautifully delineated to play their part in a highly complex story. Love, hate, friendship, cruelty, and evil, are all there as they always are in the vast panorama of life. Books like that do not appear often, and when they do, they should not be missed. I can’t wait for volume two. And three.