I literally could not (and did not!) put this one down. It's not only my favorite of the Heartbreaker Bay series, but quite possibly my favorite Jill Shalvis book ever.
A rambling list of what I loved:
1. Molly is strong, snarky, flawed yet so fiercely loyal, passionate, smart and loving. And, as a special bonus, she adores criminal investigations as much as I do :)
2. Lucas, while not necessarily that different from Jill Shalvis's many other alpha heroes on the surface, really stole my heart. He strikes that elusive combination between relatably flawed yet still lovable and desirable. In other words, he's definitely not perfect (Molly even says so at one point in the book, which is great, because perfect heroes are dull and perfect people don't exist!). But nor is he one of those all too common romance "heroes" who has you cringing for at least 90% of the novel and thinking "argh, in real life I would advise any woman I knew to stay the heck away from this jerk." He's strong, 'tough' yet a little socially awkward in a way I found endearing (I can't do small talk with strangers either, Lucas!), seemingly stoic yet very deeply loving, brave and confident yet vulnerable. He may be my favorite 'book boyfriend' of all of Jill Shalvis's heroes.
3. Jill Shalvis's humor is particularly on point in this one. There's a line about one's life crumbling like a Nature Valley Granola bar that I'll be quoting in real life conversation and a bunch of other clever one-liners. Molly and Lucas spar and banter in a way that's sharp and which amuses and challenges each other yet never crosses the line to cruel, "do these two people even LIKE each other?!" fighting. The author also has fun with the absurdity of the book's setup: a crime involving senior citizens and Christmas elves. Speaking of which...
4. I really loved the enjoyable yet not excessive element of mystery and suspense in this one! I felt like the investigative storyline allowed our hero and heroine to get to know each other in amusing and interesting ways while giving the book an overall plot and structure beyond the usual 'will they/won't they/just get on with it already' issues between the two main characters.
5. I'm always paranoid about including spoilers, so hopefully this doesn't count as one: I love that Lucas was actually ready to commit to Molly before she had conquered her trust and pride issues enough to admit she truly loved him as well. I feel like the genders are often reversed in that scenario, and this made for a lovely change.
6. We get glimpses into the upcoming romance between Sadie and Caleb, who I already love.
7. I'm not as much a fan of sex scenes as most romance readers, but even I thought the kissing/more-than-kissing/etc. scenes in this one were great---genuinely sexy without being too crass.
8. Joe and Molly's father is such an interesting character. He was probably my favorite part of About that Kiss, the previous installment of this series, and I loved his scenes in this one as well. And speaking of the characters' family members, I really adored Lucas's family and how deeply he loved them despite sometimes keeping a self-protective distance from them. They added so much to the book for me.
9. I can be annoyingly picky, and a lot of the time I don't even buy into romance couples as truly 'happy for now', let alone as meant to be together forever. Molly and Lucas, though, struck me as such a great combination of similarities that make them compatible and complementary differences. I can truly see them together throughout their lives, solving mysteries and verbally sparring while loving each other fiercely and passionately until he end of time. *sappy sigh*
Are there minor details that I'd change? Probably, but this was such a warmhearted, funny, sexy, engaging, empowering and genuinely delightful read that the nitpicks I had ceased to matter. I very enthusiastically recommend this one!