A courageous and beautiful assertion of vulnerability
The girl-dating-and-sorting-out-her-place-in-the-big-city memoir genre has its fair share of sardonic, sarcastic, young authors. They are snappy, amusingly world-weary and precociously ‘wise’ as they navigate caddish man-boys, the dashing of rose-colored hopes, drunkenness, and failed birth control. They’re a hoot, and the arch wit that frames their receipt of spectacularly callous male behaviours as awkward, wacky-awful adventures serves to reassure readers who might struggle to maintain hope, if not self-respect in the wake of their own experiences. This is all part of being a sassy young thing!!!! They’ve certainly reassured and entertained THIS reader, anyway.
Meg Fee’s memoir covers the dating territory, through the lens of a different temperament. Pretty, intelligent and with a degree from a prestigious conservatory, Meg moves in the sort of social milieu where bumping into the ‘pre-eminent American playwright’ and discussing writing and music with him over a glass of red wine is a thing that happens. There’s no braggadocio regarding this fact, nor in the revelation that the fellow acting classmate with whom she has an on-off, never-quite-right-connection over nearly a decade is now a marquee player. For all that the men she dates may boast bylines in the Wall St Journal, sweep her off her feet at weddings, have the wherewithal to try to whip her away to Paris for a weekend, and sound scrumptious with their winter coats and mussed hair, they are essentially the type to whom the more frankly-speaking sector of the millennial/Gen Y cohort despatch with a term starting in f and ending in boi. Her attempts to forge relationships of meaning with these men who seem to tick a lot of desirable boxes are not envy-making. That these relationships don’t ever solidify makes their beautiful evocation all the more poignant. It’s all happening in an iconic, storied city, but the difficult reality of the slog it takes to make a life there is honestly detailed even as its charms are acknowledged and enjoyed.
Highly sensitive and heartbreakingly earnest, Meg looks back and unabashedly reveals her willingness to take these young men at their own estimation, and that she faults herself when they are unable to form connections that satisfy either of them. Her determination to give men the benefit of the doubt for longer than may be prudent seems evergreen, but toward the end of the book she is beginning to tire of pretenders, to see underneath their self-branding and to realise that they have benefited from her tendency to project and to hope. She begins to own her values, define for herself what she wants, what she deserves. At dinner a man she calls a friend asks what she will ‘bring to the table’ in a relationship and he meets her answer with condescension; this shifts her into a re-evaluation of the presentations of love among those around her, recognition that there is a degree of display that is intolerable to her. When her kind, happily-married, unaffected older friend takes her by the arm, looks her in the eye and firmly instructs her ‘don’t you dare settle’, she takes it in. Her critical faculties begin to be utilised not for self-castigation but for self-protection and affirmation of her selfhood— she develops a radar for those who will denigrate her seriousness, gravity, capacity for hope, and who will be intimidated by the emergence of a perspicacity she has kept thus far concealed, not least from herself. She's a far better judge of character than she once imagined.
This willingness to be so revealing about the time when one is searching for love with a hungry heart is incredibly brave. These are cynical times and derision for finer feelings hovers; men and women alike are ready to disparage rather than sympathise with the defenceless naiveté of yearning. Kudos to the publisher who saw the value in a memoir of lost loves that doesn’t conclude with its author swanning away with the dreamy mate who makes all that came before worthwhile. The publisher’s faith that a young woman’s journey to herself is more fascinating and nourishing than a redemptive meet-cute and happily-ever after has paid off. That the author will pair up suitably is an inevitabilty that belongs off the page. What we have here is an elegant, poignant account of that liminal stage when a young, talented woman awakes to her own unique gifts and potential, discovers excitement in her separateness, and takes the steps in a life path that are guided by her soul. She makes a home in her own heart.