AN EXCELLENT HISTORY OF FELIX ADLER AND THE ETHICAL CULTURE SOCIETIES
Author Howard Radest wrote in the Introduction to this 1969 book, “the quest for certainty plagues us… One such voice is Ethical Culture. For more than ninety years now, the Ethical movement has recognized that man’s most precious values… must be separated from outworn myths and accreted metaphysics… In some thirty cities and towns of this country small groups of people have formed Ethical Culture societies… the Ethical Meeting is surrounded by no symbolic forms… The focus of the Society is the Ethical Platform, an address on themes drawn from the latest headlines or the perennial problems of men… It is both reminiscent of and yet different from the common experience of religious organizations. Indeed, there will be some in the group who will bridle at being called religious…
“They will insist that theirs is a free faith but not an atheistic one, since theist, deist, agnostic, and atheist are equally welcome… It is safe to predict that there will be resistance within Ethical Culture to an established tradition… But a human being cannot live only in the present… As important as anything in studying the history of a religious movement is the need to guard against myth and illusion. Religions are likely victims of mythologizing… Ethical Culture is characteristic of our time and responsive to our age… It is even more pragmatic and tentative in its evolution than hindsight would lead one to believe: no grand blueprint showed the way.”
He explains, “[The Ethical movement’s] history begins in the United States in the years following the Civil War…. For the moralist, it was a time of despair. Corruption crept into the highest offices of the land, as well as into the houses of business and industry.” (Pg. 7-8) He continues, “Some were willing to give up the sacred altogether… Thus the scene was set for Ethical Culture: an America filled with the dreams of continental conquest; demons exorcised in the blood of civil war; the mixed promise and threat of industrial society and the rapid growth of cities; religion, and philosophy marked by radical change; science coming close to human experience; eyes turning from some other world to this one to face, for better or worse, a secularized future.” (Pg. 13)
He recounts, “Felix Adler was born in … Germany, in 1851. His father… was a rabbi… and a leading figure in Reform Judaism in Europe… [who was] invited to become rabbi of Temple Emanu-El in New York City, he brought his young family to this country and in 1857 became rabbi of the wealthiest Jewish congregation in the United States.” (Pg. 14) He continues, “young Felix Adler was expected to succeed his father at Temple Emanu-El… Felix was invited to deliver the sabbath sermon… The young man, not yet twenty-three… rose to deliver his sermon on ‘The Judaism of the Future’… His words came as a shock and an upset. Embarrassment for the father mingled with anger at the ill manners and poor grace of the son… It was Felix Adler’s first and last sermon at Temple Emanu-El… he tried to share a newly-discovered truth with those he presumed were ready for it.” (Pg. 17-18)
He goes on, “Adler, now twenty-six years old, was invited to deliver a lecture expanding the theme of the Temple sermon… It reflected the influence of Emerson, the Judaic emphasis on the deed and on righteousness as religion, Kantian idealism mixed with an Hebraic suspicion, if not rejection, of theology… Adler’s proposal for a new movement had the virtue of completing an Americanization without betraying what his listeners regarded as the core of their Jewish faith---it prophetic tradition. Its radicalism lay in the proposal to eliminate all theological considerations, to bring into one fellowship the freethinker and the theist… It must have been pleasing and tantalizing to his audience to find these democratic values embedded in the call to a new religious movement… Gradually the decision was made to form a more permanent organization. During … 1877, Joseph Seligman announced that a Society for Ethical Culture was to be organized.” (Pg. 27-29)
He observes, “Adler had called for a movement of ‘deed, not creed’… theory and philosophic principle were to be the consequences of experience… Excluded by an alien environment, Jews, had developed habits of social welfare among themselves; the record of Judaism in self-help and mutual responsibility through the generations is brilliant. Adler and Ethical Culture in effect proposed to universalize this experience.” (Pg. 37)
He notes, “Adler and his followers sought to keep alive the concept of a fellowship of people seeking a common ground, a base for meeting the ethical challenges of the time.” (Pg. 52) “A symptom of public misunderstanding appeared in the confusion as to whether Ethical Culture was a religious movement… Adler himself seemed, at times, ambivalent about the nature of this movement; but in later life he put it clearly: … ‘The Ethical Movement is religious to those who are religiously minded… and it is simply ethical to those who are not so minded.’” (Pg. 57) He adds, “In the last decade of the nineteenth century Ethical Societies appeared in many different places… and at a rapid pace; a remarkable variety of organization and activity was undertaken in the name of an ‘ethical’ idea and ideal.” (Pg. 88-89)
A man named John Elliott became Adler’s assistant. “The contrast between the two was striking… The scholar Adler looked to the idea, whereas Elliott, never quite comfortable with his Ph.D., found pragmatic responses… Anger caused Adler to freeze and withdraw, but Elliott to raise his voice and pound the table.” (Pg. 112-113) “Elliott and Adler not only bridged the guild of their differences but worked together to build the Ethical movement and its keystone, the New York Society.” (Pg. 115) He observes, “Adler was the more astute psychologist; Elliott, the more effective social worker. While Elliott never gave up entirely Adler’s transcendent faith, his work and life challenged Adler’s austere and aristocratic view of an Ethical Culture… Elliott juggled the two in a sometimes precarious balance, and Ethical Culture inherited an uncompleted transition.” (Pg. 121)
He notes the failure of many of the Societies in different cities, and the lack of growth and later decline in the Society as a whole: “One may speculate on the reasons that prevented significant growth. Certainly a genuine national movement was never organized which was a strategic error of major proportion. No movement could hope to grow in twentieth-century America if it remained a haphazard collection of regional organizations, which is what the national federation of Ethical Societies, the American Ethical Union, amounted to.” (Pg. 161) Later, he adds, “A distinction between religion and politics was impossible for the Ethical Movement. The effort to ‘ethicize’ all the relationships of life led inevitably into the muddy waters of politics.” (Pg. 176) “The climax was the Great Depression. To the problems of an Ethical Culture movement seeking to focus itself anew… was added brutal question of economic survival.” (Pg. 206)
The movement founded a college preparatory school, the Fieldston School in Riverdale, New York. “Adler preached his vision of reform, his belief that civilization demanded and individuals responded. That was to be the pedagogical theme of the schools…. But each of these notions gave way under pressures which seemed irresistible or … educational viewpoints different in spirit from Adler’s… Perhaps Dr. Adler had been foolish, perhaps out of tune with his time, too early and too late with his educational ideas… But we will never know, for those ideas were not really tried.” (Pg. 220-222) Adler died in 1933.
He concludes, “By the seventy-fifth anniversary of the movement another step had been taken in the evolution of moral religion… To the surprise of many, the movement had survived with its integrity and character intact…. What came to be called a ‘crisis of meaning’ affected Ethical Culture, too; it was seen most clearly in … a lack of coherent overall policy and philosophy… the new era was antiheroic and contemporary personality styles almost demanded coolness of temperament… For all its disadvantage… it had at least the advantage of currency and potential relevance built into its very character… Whether the promise would be fulfilled awaited the test of generations. But that it could be fulfilled was clear from the record.” (Pg. 304-305)
This book will be “must reading” for anyone interested in the history of the Ethical Culture societies, as well as those interested in progressive Christianity/Judaism, and other contemporary spiritual and ethical movements.