During a raid, Commanche, Kiowa, and Caddo Indians in Texas kidnap nine-year-old Cynthia Ann Parker and kill her family. Adopted into the Commanche tribe, she lived a happy life until Texas Rangers recaptured her and forced her to return to live again among Anglo-Americans.
Clearly, Parker had come to think of herself as Commanche. By all accounts, her husband, a rising young warrior named Peta Nocona, treated her well, and the couple was happily married.
Returned to Anglo society against her will, Parker was taken to her uncle’s farm in Birdville, Texas, where she tried to run away several times.
Cynthia Ann Parker of legendary Ft. Worth, Texas fame was a young girl that was captured when her family was massacred by Comanche Indians. She lived with the Comanche, was adopted by them, eventually getting married and having children. She was recaptured by whites during an Indian invasion years later and taken back to white society with her youngest child. Though she tried many times to escape back to her Comanche family, she finally gave up. This story was based more on the "heroic" tales of Capt. Ross than that of Cynthia Ann, as the title would have you believe. I like it for the history but wow, it is a very biased book although for the time it was written it was more acceptable, very white society. Political gain was more important than facts in the writing of this story.
This was written so long ago and very choppy but it gives a perspective from the people who lived it and very first hand. I did enjoy it but it ended so about I was not ready.
Fascinating in part because it’s such a dated account with prejudiced language toward the Comanches and Native Americans in general, and the overblown style in which it was written. Still, that actually makes it more fascinating. And the author had nothing but great things to say about Quannah Parker and the Comanche people in general, once they had been defeated. Funny how they become more sympathetic figures once they are no longer marauding “savages.” I wish with all my heart I could have ridden with the Comanches back in the day.
I was a bit disappointed in that the book seemed to be more about the Texas Rangers and not as much about Cynthia Ann Parker. I do realize that she was a captive for a long time but devoting more time to her would've made the book better.
The new Tom Hanks movie " New of the World" to be released today. And it is sort of based on the movie " the Searchers ". John WAyne movie. Both are based on this true story of Cynthia. Ann Parker.
I had felt the Empire of the Summer Moon: Quanah Parker and the Rise and Fall of the Comanches, the Most Powerful Indian Tribe in American History was a bit racist and biased but it was nothing compared to this book. It's quite natural given the time it was written. Another thing about this book is that it doesn't have that much information to offer. Although it is supposed to be about Cynthia Ann, it gives very little about her. After mentioning her death, it talked a bit about her son Quanah. However, not much was said. This is probably for lack of information.
The book showed some respect for the "friendly" Native Americans who were used as scouts to find the Comanches. But still used stereotypical and derogatory words when describing them. In contrast, the whites are ever so brave and courageous in facing the "savages".
Nonetheless, reading these books is still interesting to see how people viewed Native Americans in the past.
Taken captive by the Comanche Indians at a young age, Cynthia Ann Parker grew up among them and married one of the Chiefs. The writer of this particular book is very biased in his views of the Indians and thus makes the story of her captivity and life less readable. The redeeming feature of the book is that the author states the facts of her case from reliable sources. With her husband's death on the battle field, Cynthia Ann is recaptured and taken to live with an uncle. Two of her young children find a home with other members of the tribe. The older child grows up to become the famous Chief, Quana Parker.
The book is advertised as a story about a captured white woman, but there is very little about her. Her life story could have been put into 4 pages. Didn't like the writing - very raciest, mixed up. Acceptable for the time it was written.
Definitely an "old world" book with the verbiage of capture being 'fate worse than death' and the heroic Texian Rangers pursuing the savages...still interesting and worth reading.