"Мосад. Най-великите мисии на израелските тайни служби" на Михаел Бар-Зоар и Нисим Мишал даде живот на завладяващите легендарни мисии на разузнавателната агенция на Израел и по неповторим начин разказа на читателите за опасните операции и храбрите разузнавачи, които рискуват всичко, за да изпълнят задачите си.
Сега с „Няма невъзможна мисия“ авторите се завръщат с изключително интересни и динамични разкази за трийсет от най-смелите мисии на Израелските специални части. Бар-Зоар и Мишал предават с впечатляващи подробности важни битки, рейдове във вражеска територия и смъртоносни специални мисии и в същото време докосват сърцата на читателите с лични истории на войници и командири, в които разкриват техните надежди и страхове. Често това са разкази за победи, но понякога и за големи провали, на фона на които се говори за живота и постиженията на някои от най-видните личности в Израел: Моше Даян, Ариел Шарон, братята Нетаняху, Ехуд Барак и Авигдор Каалани. Авторите проследяват живота на Шарон от близката му среща със смъртта в битката при Латрун през 1948 г. до прекосяването на Суец през 1973 г.; вървят с Ехуд Барак, маскиран като жена по улиците на Бейрут през 1973 г., когато той е начело на командосите при поредната геройска мисия, а после са с него и през 1999 г., когато е избран за министър-председател.
Освен подробности за впечатляващите крайно рисковани мисии, всяка глава съдържа и интервюта с ключов участник във въпросната операция. Сред интервюираните са някои от най-важните фигури в израелската политика. Разказът в книгата е подкрепен с впечатляващи снимки, много от които се публикуват за първи път.
„Няма невъзможна мисия“ е не само увлекателна, но и образователна книга, която ще помогне на всеки изкушен от темата за Близкия изток да разбере как тези важни събития са се отразили върху развитието на Израел и на света като цяло.
Professor Michael Bar-Zohar was a member of Knesset (Labour) and wrote the official biography of David Ben Gurion. He has written thirty non-fiction books, and has been translated into sixteen languages, winning many international prizes. He is currently working on a biography of Shimon Peres.
Michael Bar-Zohar and Nissim Mishal are prolific writers. And most of their writings are about Israel, its turbulent history, Mossad and generally about the struggles of Israel to stay alive with possibly the most hostile neighbourhood.
In 2014, I read MOSSAD – the greatest missions of the Israeli Secret Service by the same authors. You might not agree with the way, Israel and Mossad operate but if countries all around you have a stated mission of decimating and eliminating you, one probably doesn’t have much of a choice.
Their missions are well thought of, planned well and executed with a finesse that makes the CIA and MI6 look like bumbling idiots.
Unlike in MOSSAD, where each story was a complete story – the event, damage caused, the Israeli response and the aftermath, in No Mission is impossible, the focus is narrower. No details of the strategies but only about the execution by the Israeli Special Forces which is like the execution wing of Mossad.
Same stories as in Gideon’s Spies and Mossad but rich in the execution detail. An interesting addition is for each of the missions – they have interviewed someone connected to the mission – either the main guys or in some cases – their kith and kin – which lends a very personal angle to the mission and its success.
Go for it if real crime, espionage and retaliation is up your street.
מאכזב, ואפילו מרגיז. בספר מתוארים מבצעים של צה"ל, חלקם מפורסמים מאוד, חלקם מעט פחות. התיאורים מפורטים אבל קרים ויבשים, וזה צרם לי ממש, ובלט במיוחד כשבספר נכתב על מוות של חיילים ואזרחים - נזרקים מספרים כאילו זה כלום. היה חסר לי ברוב המקרים - מהו הרקע למבצע, למה הוחלט לצאת אליו, מה היו החלופות (ובכלל האם היו? האם חשבו על אופציות אחרות?), שלבי התכנון, הדיון המדיני וכיצד אושר המבצע, או בקיצור: ביקורת. what-if. כמו כן, כיצד מוציאים ספר המתאר קרבות, שאין בו ולו מפה אחת?! קראתי תיאורים מפורטים על כוח שהלך לפה והסתער לשם וכו וכו, ברמת דיוק מדוקדקת, ולא הצלחתי להבין מה ומו. מדוע לא כללו מפה עם סימונים של התקדמות הכוחות?! גם תמונות ו/או ציורים ושרטוטים של סביבת הלחימה היו יכולים לעזור ולהמחיש. כל הנ"ל בולט במיוחד לעומת ספרים דומים כמו "מלחמות הצללים" ו-"המוסד המבצעים הגדולים " שהם הרבה הרבה יותר מוצלחים. מאוד התאכזבתי ואפילו התקוממתי וכעסתי ממש במהלך הקריאה.
All of the examples which are before I'd paid any attention to the situation there + I am not so familiar with Israel cartography. 1 star down. Repetition in the chapters. First the writer said all about the mission and than some participant says "almost" the same. In my opinion no need for that and the participant could be inserted in the story. 2nd star down.
The 3 stars for is for the interesting read and learning about the events. Hats off for the leadership of Israel. Not many countries can show they have this much guts. :-)
5 stars to a book that details the survival of a numerically tiny nation through ingenuity and strategy in the midst of predominantly large hostile nations despite Soviet material and technical support
It's an informative book about some of the major operations that were done by Israel. Most of them are old history and back in the early days and beginning of Israel. I wished though that it had more operations in the story, as there is more than meets the eye when it comes to Israel.
Coincidentally.... Reading this book at a time when IAF is pounding Hamas in Gaza strip. This time in Israel's history matches the title of the 25th chapter " THE NEVER ENDING STORY IN GAZA:2008, 2012, 2014".... I add 2021 to it....
So many action packed moments giving goosebumps... Some out of the world adventures.... Relentless grit, glory and sacrifice.... the determination to save each Jew, no matter where he/she is located on planet and the ability to hit the enemy of the state anywhere in the world even if they had to operate 2000 miles away from their homeland..... make them the best and the most dreaded...
A Gripping book by an author that was part of many operations himself... Brings out the valour of the IDF Special Forces soldiers, that have lead men into wars earlier during their service and lead the country later. Their current PM Bibi being one of them.
PS (or a spoiler 😉): The last chapter, chapter 26 about Jewish rescue from Ethiopia was brought to life in the 2019 movie (and one of my favorites) THE RED SEA DIVING RESORT.
I thank Micheal Bar-Zohar and Nissim Mishal for all their books, for they have given me a whole lot of exciting reads and motivation.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Pride in my people -- recommend to anyone who wants more knowledge about the history of Israel's fight for continued sovereignty.
I cried with pride at the genius, passion and commitment, I cried with sadness at the tragic losses and I smiled because Israel is a great land that will live on.
After Mossad, writers Michael Bar-Zohar and Nissim Mishal reunited for this epic narrative. It Chronicles some of the spectacular feats of the Israeli Special Forces. Like Mossad, the scenes play out as in a cinema or a TV show. And they make you wow of the Israeli populace which has shaped such a force.
Great documentary about the Israeli Special Forces. Sometimes it seems almost like a movie. In fact, I'm starting to believe that movies are actually closer to reality. If you are a fan of books about military operations, special forces, etc, then this is definitely for you. If you're not, still a pretty cool book to read due to its historical relevance.
Amazing. Just amazing. A numerically small nation with its back against the wall combatting for its very survival from day-to-day. How does it do it? Through technological and military prowess.
The narrative is uncluttered, the language free of jargon.
When I found this book at a thrift store over a year ago, I picked it up to fill in some blind spots in my reading on the IDF and their special forces units. Halfway through on October 7 , I had to put the book down for a while as the biggest security failure ever in Israel's history made the book's triumphalist style a bit hard to take. Michael Bar- Zohar and Nissim Mishal are political media celebrities in Israel and were around many of these events in professional capacities, so this book reads often more like journalism than history. The obvious stories like Entebbe and Osirak are in here, but I found the raids from the War of Attrition and the Lebanese Civil War to be the more interesting and compelling stories. General readers will find the military procedural style a bit repetitive- but military history fans will adjust pretty fast and get maximum value.
Until the deadly bout of murder, rape and hostage-taking that Hamas were able to inflict on 10/7/23- Israel's Intelligence Services, Police force, and IDF Special Operators had been remarkably capable of averting large scale and even smaller attacks. When possible, the IDF tried to take the initiative- preferring spoiling attacks on their opponents' home bases to ambushing raiders inside Israel. The authors trace this back through IDF history- starting with their creation in 1947. The weapons and the opponents change, but one can see the doctrine developing and evolving. For operations to work, Intel, planning, and execution must all be in sync at high level. When any one factor drops the ball- the stories are not as triumphal...
There are a few adult themes and some graphic injury descriptions , so this is a book for the Junior Reader over 12/13 years. For the Gamer/Modeler/Military Enthusiast, this is a really interesting book. For the Gamer there are many scenarios that can be gamed out in this book- although some other resources might be useful for confirming orders of battle. The modeler will find diorama and build ideas- but will also probably want more colour sources as well. The Military Enthusiast will find this book engaging- but will also probably go looking for more neutral sources -as this book is very organised for the Pro-Israel reader. A good read- but left me in the mood to read more diverse views on these topics...
Not quite what I was expecting, but a good read on various special operations or missions performed by IDF components throughout Israel's history in chronological order. Actually a concise look at the most difficult and impactful operations and into one book. In my opinion, many of the operations chronicled were not performed by Israeli SOF, but were special missions nonetheless, important to the country, and required great daring, bravery, and sacrifice. I have read many volumes about The Arab-Israeli Wars and battles and this volume motivated me to purchase volumes specific to Entebbe and the hunt for Black September; reading "Operation Thunderbolt" next.
Cartea prezintă numeroase operațiuni celebre de comando, dar fiecare expediată în câteva pagini (format foarte mic), prea pe repede înainte și atât superficial, cât și deseori incoerent. Se simte că autorii sunt soldați, nu scriitori sau jurnaliști, din moment ce nu reușesc deloc să distingă ce e important ca informație și ce nu. Drept urmare, lipsesc adesea elemente vitale de context și suntem inundați cu detalii absolut irelevante. Traducerea foarte proastă nu ajută deloc și acest aspect mă enervează tot mai tare la editurile românești, sincer să fiu. Nici eu, care de fapt le știam deja foarte bine (operațiunile), nu am rămas cu nimic. Fast food, nu recomand.
I'm giving this a 3-1/2 stars on my Reading Log. It was good/interesting & fairly informative, especially about the War 0f 1967 and the Yom Kippur War of 1973. Very interesting also to read about the Raid at Entebbe Airport & the rescue of the hostages there. A bit "outdated," as most of the operations described all occurred before 2000. I think the reason they were included is they have been "unclassified" at this point. Got the book on sale; read on my Kindle.
The book is obviously a pro-Israel propaganda piece, which isn’t surprising considering the credentials of the authors. However what was disappointing was that all of the operations described in the book were covered in very broad strokes with very little detail about the processes that went into the planning and execution of the operations. Also, a significant portion of the book was covering actions carried out by regular units, not the special operation forces of Israel.
This book is a fascinating dive into some of the most daring operations by Israel’s elite forces. It’s gripping, especially if you enjoy military history and stories about real-life espionage. Some parts feel almost like an action movie, but it’s even more incredible knowing these missions actually happened.
It's a really interesting book for anyone that didn't go to Jewish day school; but it's very tactics heavy, doesn't paint any type of story, or give any insight or opinion on any of the missions, nor does it impart any overarching wisdom or concepts on the reader
The book is almost like a sequel to the author-duo's earlier blockbuster, Mossad. This reads well in the beginning though you feel tired by the middle and want to finish it off quickly. Since I am a big fan of Mossad and the IDF operations, this is a welcome read.
Good history of the wars of Israel. It felt a bit more like a general history of the wars; than being specifically about their special forces. The stories were generally good an interesting. More high level than similar books.