Until Vasco da Gama discovered the sea-route to the East in 1497-9 almost nothing was known in the West of the exotic cultures and wealth of the Indian Ocean and its peoples. It is this civilization and its destruction at the hands of the West that Richard Hall recreates in this book. Hall's history of the exploration and exploitation by Chinese and Arab travellers, and by the Portuguese, Dutch and British alike is one of brutality, betrayal and colonial ambition.
حصلت على هذا الكتاب منذ سنوات بعيدة، ورغم حماستي له بقي مركوناً كل هذه الأعوام، ربما لحجمه المهيب، وربما لأنني رغبت في تأخيره لأيام أكون فيها متفرغاً أكثر، ولكنني تعلمت أنه لا يوجد أيام بيضاء، ولا يوجد أوقات أفضل، هي اللحظة الحاضرة إما أغتنمها أو تضيع، فلذا أحاول الآن اللحاق ونفض الغبار عن كتبي الأثيرة.
في سبعمئة صفحة، وعلى مدار ألف عام يركز ريتشارد هول على تاريخ المحيط الهندي، وتاريخ الموانئ التي كانت تستفيد من رياحه الموسمية في التجارة ما بين شرق المحيط حيث الهند والصين وكل تلك الجزر التي صارت الآن الفلبين وإندونيسيا وماليزيا، وغربه حيث موانئ جزيرة العرب وأفريقيا، ابتداءً من مسقط وعدن وكلوة وسفالة وممباسا، إنه تاريخ مهيب يحاول هول نقله لنا بكل تغيراته منذ أيام ماركو بولو وابن بطوطة، فوصول البرتغاليين وكل الفظائع التي جروها على المنطقة، ومن بعدهم الهولنديين والفرنسيين والإنجليز، يفرد فصول لمحاولات الأوربيين اكتشاف أفريقيا، وبحثهم عن مملكة الراهب يوحنا الأسطورية والذي كانوا يريدون التحالف معه للانقضاض على الإسلام من الشرق والغرب، كل هذا التاريخ شبه المجهول لي على الأقل، وربما للكثير من القراء العرب، يبسطه ريتشارد هول بجمال، يجعل من قراءة هذا الكتاب متعة فائقة، شيء يشبه حكاية خيالية صاغها كاتب عبقري.
This was a very ambitious book that was interesting but I think perhaps bit off more than it could chew. It's booked as a "History of the Indian Ocean" but it really is mostly a history of East Africa. The author lived in and covered East Africa for the Financial Times for over 20 years, and has written other books on the region, this was a book meant to contextualize East Africa within the wider Indian Ocean milieu, and this is a worthy thing to do and I think that, writ large, he succeeds in doing that.
Writing a history of East Africa is difficult because the natives of the region never developed a written language, nor was there a tradition of oral storytelling such as there was in West Africa, at least not one that has survived to the point of Arab or European contact so the historical record is entirely travelogues written by people from other civilizations and the author weaves together the stories of Marco Polo, Ibn Battuta, and the chronicler of Zheng He's voyages, so the history of the region pre Da Gama is given to us from the Italianate, Islamic and Chinese perspectives. This is interesting but since all these chronicles are themselves available to the reader, I can't say that the synopses of their East African sections, though usefully collected, are particularly illuminating.
Except for the fact that I knew nothing at all about this region and I learned quite a bit. In essence, the Islamic world captured a string of Islands down the East Coast of Africa and set up trading sultanates in each of them which exported the various products of the region to the Islamic and South Asian regions. Something I also did not know was that the East African slave trade, controlled by the Arab Sultanates pre-dated the West African slave trade to the Americas by 300 years and was on an equivalent scale. Relative to the populations as a whole, the scale might have been larger.
This is because the slave revolts that occurred in the Arab world were on a larger scale and occasionally succeeded. He tells the story of the "Revolt of the Zanj." Zanj being an Arab word for the region from which the slaves were brought, mostly what is today Eritrea, Somalia and Kenya. The Zanj were put to work in large numbers draining the swamps in southern Iraq and revolted several times with varying degrees of success. At one point, the Zanj successfully seized the whole of what is today Basrah and Nasyiria provinces in Iraq, slaughtered the local population and ruled it as an independent kingdom defeating army after army sent against them. They were eventually overcome but the Arab and Indian worlds continued to import slaves from the region for the next 300 years.
The historical record gets considerably denser once the Portuguese round the Cape of Good Hope and begin interacting directly with the Indian Ocean. The Portuguese, though intrepid navigators, Da Gama's voyage was three times the length of Columbus', do not cover themselves in glory. For one thing, they spend a huge amount of time and resources looking for a legendary Christian empire in the East with whom to ally against the Turks. It is striking how a group of people who can master experimental science well enough to advance navigation and shipbuilding in a few decades what will take relatively more culturally advanced societies hundreds of years to catch, do so in the pursuit of utterly fantastical aims.
And of course, when they do find what Columbus sought, India, instead of establishing trading relations in an effort to edge out the Turks and Venetians, they simply steal and/or destroy everything they can find. Two hundred years after the sack of Baghdad by the Mongols, the Portuguese enter the Indian Ocean as a kind of seaborne barbarian horde using the advantage of stable deck mounted cannon to become extremely effective and destructive pirates throughout the Indian Ocean. Their seizure of Goa is hotly debated simply because they prefer piracy and establishing a permanent base exposes them to expulsion from it.
The marauding and depredations of the Portuguese eventually compels the Islamic sultanates of the Deccan plateau in India to form an alliance with the Ottoman Turks who contract Venetian shipbuilders and gunsmiths to travel to Suez, and build them an oceangoing fleet with with to destroy the Portuguese. The Portuguese, come upon the Ottoman fleet anchored at Diu and, in a prequel to what Nelson would do to Napoleon at the Battle of the Nile, they destroy it entirely before it can raise anchor. Nonetheless, the resources of the Deccan Sultanates and the Ottoman Empire are large enough that they try again.
This campaign is even more interesting than the first because the Ottoman Turks actually succeed in sweeping up the Portuguese Empire in East Africa, all the way down to Mombasa where a truly astounding siege and counter siege begins. The Ottomans eject the Portuguese garrison before a relief force can arrive but then an army of cannibals sweeps down on them and they turn to defend the Arab residents of Mombasa from this new threat. Just then the Portuguese relief force arrives and temporarily forms an alliance with the cannibals and the two crush the Ottoman army between them saving the Portuguese Empire again.
But the Islamic world is not done with the Portuguese and the destruction of the Portuguese Empire in East Africa North of Mozambique falls to, the Sultan of Oman who destroyed the Portuguese garrison that had been guarding the strait of Hormuz and then sailed down the East Coast of Africa capturing all of the Portuguese forts down to Zanzibar. Once in command of the coast, the Sultanate of Oman used his connections in the Islamic world and South Asia to vastly expand the slave trade, raising exports from 30,000/yr to 100,000 yr, the same size almost exactly as the trade with the Americas. With the profits of the trade, he vastly expanded his navy, buying ships from Britain until he was the dominant naval power in African waters.
So important was the slave trade to Oman, that a subsequent sultan moved the capital of Oman form Muscat to Zanzibar where it remained until deep into the nineteenth century. British efforts to suppress the slave trade eventually bankrupted the Sultanate over which the British had established a protectorate. The terms of the protectorate were such that in the event of a succession dispute the territory would be governed by the English monarch as regent for a successor. Naturally, a polyagmous society with branches in Oman and Zanzibar lends itself to succession disputes and Britain eventually took title to Zanzibar.
The author spends relatively little time on the "Scramble for Africa" which occurred in the second half of the nineteenth century, though there is a very interesting section on the prehistory of the interior of the country which I think is largely a reference to his other work. Apparently, settled African kingdoms inland from the Arab sultanates were swept aside by barbarian invaders from the South in the preceding decades so by the time the Europeans decided to push inland there was little formal resistance to them and, what resistance there was was put down brutally in one sided battles of machine guns against muskets or spears.
European rule collapses as quickly as it began, within a single generation at least in East Africa. Western and Southern Africa having seen a much more intense European presence from the fifteenth century on.
All in all, I learned quite a lot. The Portugese Empire was really just a piratical house of cards and it was not destroyed by the Dutch and the English, but rather by an alliance of the Islamic Empires of the Near East and India. Still, the book was underwhelming. It is, in essence, a work of journalism not scholarship. It is a fine tale of folly and adventure, but it is not very illuminating about the forces at work or really about the lives of the Africans themselves though the sections on the interior are well done. The book largely serves as an advertisement for the works for Ibn Battuta and Zheng He, as well as a lure for more academic histories of Africa.
China, in the history of thousands of years, there has never had a Haikou in the Indian Ocean. Mangshi, located in Yunnan, China, although it is called China's nearest city from the Indian Ocean, but it also reaches 600 kilometers away from the Indian Ocean, and the middle is also blocked.
Before the Millennium, from the Arabian Peninsula arrived in China, it is long and dangerous. It is necessary to travel from India to Sumamera to Sumatra, through the Malacca Strait, and finally enter the Chinese sea from the north. The whole tour takes a year and a half, On the way, not only face the storm of the sea, but also to deal with the harassment of pirates, it can be described as a life.
However, the brother is not in the rivers and lakes, and the rivers and lakes have a legend. In the Waves of the Indian Ocean, there has never lack the rumors of China. These rumors often tell the huge wealth in China. Therefore, although the journey is hard, the huge wealth in the rumors, the powerful courage to give the businessman and sailor, let them be in the waves, arrive at China's coast in the waves of the monsoon.
British historical writers Richard Hall In the "Monsoon Empire", the Western traveler's record is overview, and the legend of Ancient China is in the hearts of Westerners in Westerners. Richard Hall was born in 1925, in Australia, once served in the Royal Navy in the UK, in Oxford University, and lived in Africa for 13 years, he served on the "Daily Mail" "Zambia Times" Observe the "Financial Times" and other media, and created the "African Analysis of the Financial and Political Communique".
The "Monsoon Empire" is nearly 500,000 words, is a history of history, showing the history of the Hindu National AD 10th century to the 20th century. Richard Hall In writing a "Monsoon Empire", I have answered a lot of information, including some lonely, such as the memoirs of the Buli Ibre, Shahriar, only in a mosque in Istanbul. .
In the first part of the book, the Indian Ocean has a history of hundreds of years before invading invasion. China plays an important role, and is recorded in the memoirs of the traveler, including the Persian Director Buli Ibre, Shahria Venetian Mac, Polo and Moroccan scholar Iburn, Baotai, etc. In their narrative, China is a synonym of fate, wealth and strong.
First, the country of fate In the "Monsoon Empire", Richard Hall said the manuscript of the Persian Hull, which mentioned a Jews called Isched • Yada.
Ishag born with Oman's poor family, after he arrived in China from India, living in China for 30 years, returning to his hometown in 19912. At this time, he has become a rich businessman, not only has its own cargo ship, but also full of silk, porcelain, musk and precious gemstones.
In order to escape tariffs, Ishag, with a black porcelain vase with golden lid, bribed the local official Ahmed, Hilake. Ishag told Ahmed, which is for his "cooking fish" in China. Ahmed opened the bottle cap and saw a goldfish that was surrounded by musk. The goldfish eyes were made with ruby, and the vase estimates worth more than 50,000 yuan.
Moroccan scholar Iben Bai Titai travel to China, I met a Muslim doctor in Fuzhou, which was successful in China, and he told Iben White Thai, he had 50 white slaves and the same number of female slaves. The doctor gave Iben • Baotai 2 white slaves and 2 female slaves, there are many other gifts.
Perhaps, these rumors of the brunette, Iburn, Baotai, bring comforts for those in poverty, let them think that as long as they board the coast of China, fate will undergo a fundamental reversal. About China, people think that there is nothing wrong. Therefore, in the "Monsoon Empire", Richard Hall wrote, those travelers who can safely arrive in China, usually don't want to go back. In the past two centuries before the written written, the Perssenger and Arab people living in China have been able to launch a sea to launch a sea.
Second, the country of wealth Paris and London are contemporary fashion cities that represent the direction of popular cultural development. However, in a thousand years ago, Western countries are ignorant, Western Europe is only in the edge of the world civilization. Dan Gamma arrived in Calcat, India, visiting a local official, his gifts were: washbasin, coral necklace, hat, dark red headscarf and altar honey. Such a cold gather, has been laughed at the locals, some people say that Gamma's follow: "The gift from Mecca is also decent."
China's silk and porcelain are the luxury of that era. Perhaps, in that era, people feel like silk and porcelain, like the modern people in the modern people, such as LV, Chanel, Hermes and other brands. In Westerners record, many royal rods are used to participate in the ceremonial costume, which is silk.
At that time, the Red Sea was called "China's Sea", the cargo ship full of teeth, spices and gold, from there, travel to China to exchange luxury goods. Bunzge once heard about China's news, a ruler in China, when receiving a Arab businessman, there were 500 female slaves around him, those female slaves wearing a variety of jewels. .
In the interaction with other countries, China does not seem to care about the economy, and more interested in the identity. Chinese rulers always believe that all countries should recognize China's superior position and have to return to her. Therefore, other countries give the gift of the Chinese emperor, as a tribute, China's return is much better than Gong Li.
Iben White Thae once recorded that the Sulthak Muhammad Ibrah Turku, India, and self-proclaimed "the owner of the world". He once sent 15 virgins to China. As a result, 15 gnals returned to Delhi. Brought back a lot of gifts, including 100 slaves, a lot of silk and velvet cloth, decorated with jewelry clothing, and a wide range of weapons.
Sudan may feel very unhuster, don't want to lose to China, prepare a lot of gifts, including 100 white slaves, 100 Indian dancers, 100 horses, 15 宦 宦, gold and silver candlesticks, damask robe, countless treasures, and Appointment Iben • Baotai is a ambassador, let him visit China to visit China. As a result, it was attacked by Hindu, and all the belongings were taken away.
Third, the strong country China's strong is very early by the Westerners. As early as the Saan Dynasty, when he was conquered by the Arabs, the last generation of the Saan Dynasty was sent to China to seek assistance. Mark Polo travels to the East, and is also a permanent connection in the East and West to coexue the Islamic countries. However, Chinese rulers prefer to compete in the Central Plains, and do not like to conquer the four seas. Even if Zheng He is under the West Ocean, there is no intention of aggression.
In 1405, Zheng He started from Longjiang, and he began to save the Western Ocean. In the Zheng He's fleet, "treasure ship" weighed more than 500 tons, with 12 ship sails, equipped with "rocket" filled with gunpowder, carrying a large diameter short gun with a stone. In every voyage of Zheng He, the number of big ships he led has from 40 to 100, and each big ship is also equipped with several replenishment boats. In most cases of 7 times, there are more than 300 people and 300 vessels in the Zheng He's fleet.
In contrast, in 1497, Zheng He's first flight has passed nearly nearly a century, and Gamma opened the sailing to India in Lisbon, and there were only four ships, and the crew was more than 180. The flagship "St. Cainertes" in the fleet is less than 300 tons, and another "Saint Rafael" is small, and the remaining two are ordinary light sailboats.
Zheng He Xiaoxiang, so far, there is no conclusion, there is no conclusion, there is a search for the Emperor to say, Xuanyang Weide said, Richard Hall believes in the "Monsoon Empire", it is to produce China's workplace production The remaining products seek the market. But regardless of the purpose of Zheng He's Western Ocean, at least it is clear that the Zheng He's fleet is an invincible in the Indian Ocean at the time.
The King of Ceylon refused to hand over Buddha Buddha tooth to the Chinese emperor. In 1409, Zheng He was directly attacked into the Civic Shancheng City, the capital of Silan, captured the King of Squoro, and brought him back to China to do the hostage. In addition, there is also a sect from the shore of Mogadisa in Somalia, teaching its barbaric Sudan. However, these force attacks are not intrusive, because Zheng He has never established any permanent resident deposits in the Indian Ocean area.
Liu Cixin wrote a short science fiction "Western", assuming that Zheng He has not stopped before arriving in Africa, but bypassing the good look, discovering the American continent, today's world pattern has also changed, China The colonist of the Americas. In fact, the assumption of Da Liu is wrong, because the Zheng He's fleet does not aggressive, even if you see the original state of the Americas, it may only be awarded that Tian En, not to build a colonial. However, there is no hypothesis that China is far from the Indian Ocean, suddenly ending after Zheng He's death, the tide of the Indian Ocean, leaving a legend of the Oriental. Richard Hall is in the "Monsoon Empire":
From a historical point of view, Zheng He's 7 voyage seems to be a phenomenon that is almost inefficient. The 15th century Indian Ocean is a tremendous wealth trade stage (there is no other region in the world to compare with the output of goods and raw materials). The Chinese suddenly broke into this stage, but they also stopped this action, almost did not leave a trace. Of course, Richard Hall is in ancient China in the "Monsoon Empire", mainly with the record of travelers, these records from traveler's personal experience, some from the road to talk, may not be objective. However, China's important influence on the history of the Indian Ocean is undoubted. Today, the strategic idea of the sea Silk Road in the 21st century has once sailed sail, China is the development of the Indian Ocean region, which must also make new contributions, interpretation of new historical legend.
This is a not deep but it is thorough. I feel like the importance of the ancient and early modern traffic among India, East Africa and Oman is an often overlooked topic in world history. This book covers most of the important events from first century CE to the nineteenth century. An excellent, readable overview with lots of good references to additional readings.
Disappointing. It's inevitable with books like this that the pre-European history tends to be a quick retelling of Marco Polo and Ibn Battuta, moving swiftly on to the bit after the Europeans arrived and started documenting their unspeakable cruelty. Nevertheless, I was hoping for more about the empires and less about the Europeans. Furthermore, there is relatively limited analysis of the social conditions at any point, the currents that caused this. This is mostly big characters, doing terrible things, a big man style history with it's eye on the derring-do and not the less showy and generally more enlightening study of institutions and structures.
Read this book if you want to understand the pivotal role the Indian Ocean played in the creation of the modern world. It is also sobering to read how a such a large number of thriving people were overrun by a few small countries such that every country bordering the Indian Ocean became a colony within two hundred and fifty years of Da Gama discovery.
One of my all time favourite history books. Well written and great research. You will not be disappointed in this fascinating examination of the world of the monsoons in the Indian Ocean. I regard this book as an essential reference book in my personal library.
History books are not usually an easy read and this one was no exception. It mainly covered East African history of which I knew very little before reading this book. Well researched and certainly expanded my knowledge base significantly.
Superb coverage of early European exploration and colonisation of the Indian Ocean area. Contains many little-known details that are integrated beautifully into this robust and honest (and brutal) history of the region. No holds are barred in recounting the ruthlessness of the age and the travesties against the peoples of the region as they were slaughtered, brutalised and/or enslaved by the region's intruders. However, we soon find that the Europeans were not singular in their practices, many other kingdoms and states also considered Africa and the weaker states of the region hunting grounds for riches and slaves.
The latter third of the book pays particular attention to the colonisation of East Africa and fills a void in many western readers' knowledge of the region. This is a book to be read and re-read and in which I have stuck many little tabs to highlight details I know I will want to refer back to (as this is a particular area of interest to me). The illustrations are excellent and I wished there were more. There is also a 20-page index to help you find your way to information about specific individuals and some events, but it could have been even more robust. For example, while there is considerable information about the importance of Oman as a powerful ship-building and sea-going nation, and Christianity in Ethiopia, there are no index entries under 'Oman' or 'Ethiopia' to help you find your way back to them. If there is ever an updated edition, I petition the author for a more extensive index as the text is so rich, it deserves more accessibility. The end notes are interesting but rarely give the source of textual information, which many readers will miss. There is, however, an excellent bibliography broken down into sub-subjects as they relate to the book's chapters (helpful in identifying relevant additional reading).
This is a book full of very interesting information and covering a vast sweep of history but I just didn't feel that it lives up to its subtitle 'A History of the Indian Ocean and its Invaders'. This is not a book like Peter Frankopan's 'The Silk Road' which makes you look at history from a completely different perspective. In many ways Empires of the Moon felt more like a history of the Portuguese exploration in India and east Africa and its rise to and failure to remain an imperial power. Otherwise to much of what is covered before about Chinese voyages to the area and later British imperial interventions felt tacked on. It is not a bad book, just not one that lives up to its advertising.
An excellent overview of the long and, often, violent history of the civilizations living from the richness of the Indian Ocean, no holds barred (the early European explorers, whose exploits made them heroes in Eurocentric history books, were nothing but blood-thirsty savages). The last third of the book is more centered around Africa and forgets the other half of the Indian Ocean, but as it covers some of the ground not covered in other African history books, it still makes for riveting reading.
Excellent first read about the fascinating history of the Indian Ocean and a good antidote tot he anglo-centric history of Africa that we grew up with. It details the trade and commerce between the Eastern seaboard of Africa over the last thousand years. Highly recommended.
A wonderful book on a very interesting topic. Hall splits the book into 55 short chapters of 9-10 pages each, focussing on a specific aspect, story or person. The subject is vast, but he has covered it skilfully. The stories of European exploration never cease to amaze.