This book bumped along at first as an okay if uninspiring read. Amanda seemed nice enough, and Tyler was a bit of a jerk in his lack of listening ability, though he clearly cared for his grandmother. They got together, with little to no effort needed, and the road seemed clear to HEAland. So far so normal. Except things began dragging themselves out a lot.
They’re together and things are going well. Amanda loves Marietta, she has a growing business and family nearby; Grandmother Bette has all her friends and a full life in the town; and Tyler hates where he lives and doesn’t even have a job there anymore. There really shouldn’t have been any conflict about him moving to Marietta, because he’s clearly moving somewhere and wants to be close to his grandmother (and his old business), so the answer is obvious. But no, there must be non-existent drama.
Which was, quite frankly, irritating. But wait, there’s more! Because it turns out Amanda has some real issues about her childhood poverty and the way the town treated her and how she can never get away from that stigma (just move!) and woe, woe, woe, is she, because there’s also a family secret that really has nothing to do with her but suddenly the whole thing explodes because It’s All About Amanda! No one feels pain like she does. No one feels shame like she does. All these people telling lies, being awful. It’s so unfair! She must punish everyone – including Tyler, who really is not at fault.
I wanted to drown her in Miracle Lake.
So… this book didn’t work for me, because of the unnecessary drama about whether or not Tyler would move to Marietta, followed by Amanda’s unnecessary drama which could have been quite easily solved by her moving away from Marietta, and all the stuff that really had nothing to do with her but that she made all about her because Reasons! Nope. Sorry, but nope.
(ARC provided by the publisher via NetGalley.)