The Geography of Lost Things was OK. I think I liked the concept more than the execution — Ali and her ex, Nico, hit the road with the goal of selling Ali's deceased father's vintage car, but along the way Nico decides that instead of selling the car, they are going to "trade up" to get the money Ali needs to prevent her house from being foreclosed. Starting with a rubber band, they are going to trade with strangers on Craigslist for items of increasing value. (For example, the rubber band gets them a broken "ancient" flip phone.) And in between trade-ups, Ali is contemplating the relationship she had with her mostly-absent father, Jackson, and the romance she and Nico once enjoyed until it came to fiery end a month before the book takes place.
Jackson was an alcoholic and a "groupie" of a 90s grunge band called Fear Epidemic, and when he leaves Ali and her mother, it's to follow the band around on their reunion tour. He pops back in their lives every now and then to ask for money and forgiveness, only to leave again, and Ali is tired of his lies when she cuts him off at age 13. Nico, meanwhile, was a new kid in school when he and Ali get together, and although they only date for a few months, she is intrigued by his craftsmanship and thoughtfulness — and intrigued by the parts of his life he won't let her in on, like his home, family, and past living in Reno.
There was just a lot I didn't really like about this book and not much that I did like. I found it hard to connect with both Ali and Nico; every single thing Nico does seems to trigger Ali into spiraling thoughts about what a liar he is and how similar he is to Jackson, and it got tiring to read about. Nico, as understanding and patient with Ali as he is, may have lied to her during their breakup for a reason — but he still lied to her, continued to hide things from her, and had terrible communication with her, and still expected her to trust him, so he wasn't exactly a love interest I was rooting for.
The book drags out the reason Nico and Ali broke up and Ali's full name (which she refuses to tell anyone) for so long before revealing them. This is a trend I've seen recently in books and I hate it; it's annoying and the "reveal" is never as rewarding as the buildup makes one think it will be. Some other things didn't fully land for me: "shiitake mushrooms" is the oldest "curse-without-cursing" joke in the world, and yet Ali and Nico have never heard it before? The trade-up thing has been done before, in real life, in an episode of "The Office," and more, so I don't think anything new was brought to this plot. The book's summary made it sound like the people Ali meets along the way, their stories and their possessions, would help her learn what was important in life and give her a new perspective on her dad and his most prized possession — but all the trades are pretty brief and routine, and we don't learn much of anything when it comes to Jackson and his car.
Weirdly enough, Jackson felt like the most developed character to me — the last few pages, where we find out why he kept leaving his family behind, were infuriating but heartbreaking. Ali's mother is barely mentioned at all, even though she and Ali are close. Somehow, Ali never contacts her or talks to her during her multi-day road trip? Ali's best friend June might as well have not been in the book either.
Overall...not my favorite. OK writing, forgettable characters, a pretty routine story.