What do you think?
Rate this book
Music of Hope #2
When the Heart Sings
Natia has a secret, and she’s hiding him right beneath her captor’s nose...
The Nazis have forced Natia and Teodor from their Polish farm to a labor camp. When the couple is separated, Natia is chosen to be the housekeeper for the camp’s overseer, and Teodor is sent to work in the factory. Despite the strict camp rules—and the consequences for disobeying them—Natia finds a way to communicate with Teodor by sending messages through song as she passes Teodor’s dormitory.
The stakes get higher when Natia finds a Jewish orphan on the overseer’s doorstep. She is determined to protect the boy and raise him as the child she and her husband were unable to bear— but if her German captors discover how much she’s hiding, both she and Teodor may pay the ultimate price.
The Nazis have forced Natia and Teodor from their Polish farm to a labor camp. When the couple is separated, Natia is chosen to be the housekeeper for the camp’s overseer, and Teodor is sent to work in the factory. Despite the strict camp rules—and the consequences for disobeying them—Natia finds a way to communicate with Teodor by sending messages through song as she passes Teodor’s dormitory.
The stakes get higher when Natia finds a Jewish orphan on the overseer’s doorstep. She is determined to protect the boy and raise him as the child she and her husband were unable to bear— but if her German captors discover how much she’s hiding, both she and Teodor may pay the ultimate price.
320 pages, Paperback
Published October 9, 2018
12 people are currently reading
291 people want to read
About the author
Liz Tolsma
42 books1,779 followersLiz Tolsma is the author of several WWII novels, romantic suspense novels, prairie romance novellas, and an Amish romance. She is a popular speaker and an editor and resides next to a Wisconsin farm field with her husband and their youngest daughter. Her son is a U.S. Marine, and her oldest daughter is a recent college graduate. Liz enjoys reading, walking, working in her large perennial garden, kayaking, and camping. Please visit her website at www.liztolsma.com and follow her on Facebook, Twitter (@LizTolsma), Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest. She is also the host of the Christian Historical Fiction Talk podcast.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews
October 17, 2018
Wow, I've never read this author before and this is such a powerful book. While I didn't read the first one this did read as a complete story on it's own. I've read a lot of WWII books and this one really stands out from the others. Liz has written with such heart and soul. Achingly historically accurate I felt as though I was transported in a time machine back in time and experienced these things myself. The singing is such an important part of the book. It is what keeps the couple connected and knowing the other one is safe. From the fear of the people, to hearing the slaps received and feeling the devastation of the mother's experiencing infertility the author accurately portrays it. This is so good it should be made into a movie. I absolutely need to read the first book in this series because this is as real as it gets!
Pub Date 09 Oct 2018
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Gilead Publishing through NetGalley. Thank you. All opinions expressed are my own.
Pub Date 09 Oct 2018
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Gilead Publishing through NetGalley. Thank you. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 2, 2018
In this series, the author is highlighting the plight of European Christians during WWII.
When the Heart Sings focuses on Polish Christians Teodor and Natia. They are forced from their home. Natia enjoys singing and this joy and talent impacts her story positively. The love Teodor and Natia share is true and sweet.
What I enjoyed the most about this novel was the unlikely friendship that Natia developed with a German woman. They share a common sorrow and despite a language barrier, become a source of strength for each other.
I wasn't as engaged in this second book in the Music of Hope Series as the first book. However, it is a good novel and brings to light how some Christians were impacted during WWII.
My gratitude to publisher Gilead for a complimentary NetGalley copy of When the Heart Sings. I was not required to write a review. The opinions expressed are my own.
When the Heart Sings focuses on Polish Christians Teodor and Natia. They are forced from their home. Natia enjoys singing and this joy and talent impacts her story positively. The love Teodor and Natia share is true and sweet.
What I enjoyed the most about this novel was the unlikely friendship that Natia developed with a German woman. They share a common sorrow and despite a language barrier, become a source of strength for each other.
I wasn't as engaged in this second book in the Music of Hope Series as the first book. However, it is a good novel and brings to light how some Christians were impacted during WWII.
My gratitude to publisher Gilead for a complimentary NetGalley copy of When the Heart Sings. I was not required to write a review. The opinions expressed are my own.
December 30, 2018
When the Heart Sings was the first book that I had read by Liz Tolsma but it will not be the last. I just ordered the first book in this series. However, I did not feel that it was necessary to have read the first book in this Music of Hope series before reading When the Heart Sings. I found it to be a stand alone novel but because I enjoyed reading it so much I was curious about the first book and therefore ordered it. Historical novels, especially about World War II and the Holocaust, are the genre I often gravitate towards. Where the Heart Sings opened my eyes to a whole different aspect of the camps during the Holocaust. It was beautifully written and had a way of transporting me back in time to actually feel as if I was there in the small Polish village. The raw emotions,of fear, love, friendship and hope were present throughout the book.
Natia and Teodor were living modestly on a farm in rural Poland with their immediate family living close by when the Nazis invaded Poland. They were young Christian Poles who had already experienced their share of heartbreak. Natia and Teodor had lost three babies in childbirth. Their babies' graves sat on a surrounding hillside on their farm. Natia's and Teodore's grief for the three babies they lost was raw and emotional. The Nazis were demanding that Natia, Teodor and the rest of their family vacate their farms so that good German families could be relocated there. Natia, Teodor, Natia;s brother Zygmunt, her sister Helena and her father were loaded onto cattle cars at the nearby train station and taken to a labor camp. Upon their arrival, Natia and Teodor were separated almost immediately. Natia. just recently having lost their third baby, was still recovering and was experiencing difficulty keeping up with the rigid orders that were being shouted at them. Teodor did everything he could to help her. They were determined to stay together but that was not to be. It just so happened that on that day the wife of the Nazi in charge of the local factory, Elfriede, decided to satisfy her curiosity and see for herself what happened when new prisoners arrived. She immediately noticed that Natia was in a bad way and her husband was treating her in an awful way. Elfriede came to Natia's rescue and somehow talked her husband into allowing Natia to become their servant in their home. She nursed Natia back to health. There were many obstacles to overcome for Natia and Elfriede. One of the obvious ones was language being that Elfriede spoke German and Natia spoke Polish. In time, they came to understand each other and discovered that they had both had miscarriages. This was a common bond that would later lead to friendship between the two women. Teodor was assigned to work as a laborer in the factory run by Elfriede's husband. Natia soon discovered that the factory was close to the house she was working in. On her way to the town to do errands for Elfriede she sang songs as a way to communicate to Teodor that she was fine and he would sing back to her so she knew he was alive and well. Several months after Natia began working for Elfriede and her husband, a Jewish baby was brought to the house where Natia worked. The Jewish mother was dying and her dying wish was that Natia would raise Solomon as her own. Elfriede and Natia were smitten by the baby immediately. Natia was the only one who knew of his real identity. They both knew that raising this child in the home of a Nazi officer would be challenging. Dr. Pawel Bosco was sent for to create a new identity for the child. Solomon became Dominik and he was truly loved by both women. Natia had to make sure though that she was the only one that dressed and changed Dominik so that his Jewish identity was not discovered. Dominik became the child both women had longed for and were both denied.
Although the characters in When The Heart Sings are fictitious Liz Tolsma skillfully used the characters to shed light on the many atrocities and threats the Polish citizens had to endure during the Nazi invasion of their country. The uprising of the Warsaw Ghetto and the Polish resistance were carefully intertwined marginally into the story as well. Natia's heartfelt, angelic singing brought hope and even some comfort to those who heard her. All my emotions were tapped and I could not put this book down. Liz Tolsma's own history of miscarriage was shared in the Notes of her book as well as how she became interested in this period of World War II. I am anxiously awaiting the third installment in this series.I highly recommend When the Heart Sings..
Thank you to Gilead Publishing, LLC and Netgalley for affording me the opportunity to receive a complimentary copy of When the Hear Sings by Liz Tolsma. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Natia and Teodor were living modestly on a farm in rural Poland with their immediate family living close by when the Nazis invaded Poland. They were young Christian Poles who had already experienced their share of heartbreak. Natia and Teodor had lost three babies in childbirth. Their babies' graves sat on a surrounding hillside on their farm. Natia's and Teodore's grief for the three babies they lost was raw and emotional. The Nazis were demanding that Natia, Teodor and the rest of their family vacate their farms so that good German families could be relocated there. Natia, Teodor, Natia;s brother Zygmunt, her sister Helena and her father were loaded onto cattle cars at the nearby train station and taken to a labor camp. Upon their arrival, Natia and Teodor were separated almost immediately. Natia. just recently having lost their third baby, was still recovering and was experiencing difficulty keeping up with the rigid orders that were being shouted at them. Teodor did everything he could to help her. They were determined to stay together but that was not to be. It just so happened that on that day the wife of the Nazi in charge of the local factory, Elfriede, decided to satisfy her curiosity and see for herself what happened when new prisoners arrived. She immediately noticed that Natia was in a bad way and her husband was treating her in an awful way. Elfriede came to Natia's rescue and somehow talked her husband into allowing Natia to become their servant in their home. She nursed Natia back to health. There were many obstacles to overcome for Natia and Elfriede. One of the obvious ones was language being that Elfriede spoke German and Natia spoke Polish. In time, they came to understand each other and discovered that they had both had miscarriages. This was a common bond that would later lead to friendship between the two women. Teodor was assigned to work as a laborer in the factory run by Elfriede's husband. Natia soon discovered that the factory was close to the house she was working in. On her way to the town to do errands for Elfriede she sang songs as a way to communicate to Teodor that she was fine and he would sing back to her so she knew he was alive and well. Several months after Natia began working for Elfriede and her husband, a Jewish baby was brought to the house where Natia worked. The Jewish mother was dying and her dying wish was that Natia would raise Solomon as her own. Elfriede and Natia were smitten by the baby immediately. Natia was the only one who knew of his real identity. They both knew that raising this child in the home of a Nazi officer would be challenging. Dr. Pawel Bosco was sent for to create a new identity for the child. Solomon became Dominik and he was truly loved by both women. Natia had to make sure though that she was the only one that dressed and changed Dominik so that his Jewish identity was not discovered. Dominik became the child both women had longed for and were both denied.
Although the characters in When The Heart Sings are fictitious Liz Tolsma skillfully used the characters to shed light on the many atrocities and threats the Polish citizens had to endure during the Nazi invasion of their country. The uprising of the Warsaw Ghetto and the Polish resistance were carefully intertwined marginally into the story as well. Natia's heartfelt, angelic singing brought hope and even some comfort to those who heard her. All my emotions were tapped and I could not put this book down. Liz Tolsma's own history of miscarriage was shared in the Notes of her book as well as how she became interested in this period of World War II. I am anxiously awaiting the third installment in this series.I highly recommend When the Heart Sings..
Thank you to Gilead Publishing, LLC and Netgalley for affording me the opportunity to receive a complimentary copy of When the Hear Sings by Liz Tolsma. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
October 19, 2018
In this second book of the Music of Hope series, Tolsma takes us to Poland during World War II German occupation. Teodor and Natia's small village has just about been depleted of Poles as one by one they have been deported to be German factory workers to assist the war effort. Now Teodor and Natia have received their deportation notice. Natia is just recovering from her third miscarriage.
Tolsma's detailed and vivid descriptions of the Polish situation as Germany took over their country and either eliminated the population or deported them brought me right into World War II with its sights, smells, sounds etc. Natia was such a strong woman for the position she was placed in as servant to a German officer and his wife and separated from Teodor as he worked in the factory. Her ingenuity in both keeping in touch with Teodor through her songs even to the point of choosing songs that would let him know exactly how she was feeling and shielding Dominick's true identify from the German officer and his wife was incredible. Elfriede, the German officer's wife, grew and changed so much as she realized that Erich truly was a bad man (his atrocities and incivilities to the Poles was unimaginable) and as she watched the love and strength between Teodor and Natia.
I loved the way Tolsma used music in both of the books in this series to drive the storyline and show how it can offer hope when things feel hopeless. Her spiritual content was excellent as well.
Highly recommend this series.
** I received a complimentary copy of this book from Gilead Publishing through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
Tolsma's detailed and vivid descriptions of the Polish situation as Germany took over their country and either eliminated the population or deported them brought me right into World War II with its sights, smells, sounds etc. Natia was such a strong woman for the position she was placed in as servant to a German officer and his wife and separated from Teodor as he worked in the factory. Her ingenuity in both keeping in touch with Teodor through her songs even to the point of choosing songs that would let him know exactly how she was feeling and shielding Dominick's true identify from the German officer and his wife was incredible. Elfriede, the German officer's wife, grew and changed so much as she realized that Erich truly was a bad man (his atrocities and incivilities to the Poles was unimaginable) and as she watched the love and strength between Teodor and Natia.
I loved the way Tolsma used music in both of the books in this series to drive the storyline and show how it can offer hope when things feel hopeless. Her spiritual content was excellent as well.
Highly recommend this series.
** I received a complimentary copy of this book from Gilead Publishing through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
October 9, 2018
A book that made me feel like I was there in real life, or watching a movie, and knowing all the way that it is based on actual history, yes, it really happened.
What a wonderful job the author did telling this story, that should never be forgotten, and as she said at the end of the book Poland is not telling students of the history of what happened to them.
With all the atrocities that happen the characters have a great faith in God and country, and a lot is displayed through song.
This is a riveting page-turner, and right from the beginning you won’t know whom will survive to the end.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Gilead, and was not required to give a positive review.
What a wonderful job the author did telling this story, that should never be forgotten, and as she said at the end of the book Poland is not telling students of the history of what happened to them.
With all the atrocities that happen the characters have a great faith in God and country, and a lot is displayed through song.
This is a riveting page-turner, and right from the beginning you won’t know whom will survive to the end.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Gilead, and was not required to give a positive review.
November 26, 2018
Liz Tolsma is one of my go-to World War II authors. As one who writes in this era, I am extremely picky about who I'll trust with my reading time. Liz is an expert at finding little known stories and bringing them to light with sympathetic characters that leave me rooting for them. This novel is no different. With When the Heart Sings, she walks us into a rich story about love and forgiveness set against the backdrop of a Nazi labor camp for displaced Polish citizens. I wanted to weep and cheer as I read Natia's story. This is a gripping story that highlights the power of truth and forgiveness. A great read for those who love richly written historical settings that point the way to God.
April 20, 2019
What an amazing World War 2 story of survival and love in Nazi controlled areas of Poland. Not for the faint of heart because of the subject matter but an important read. This shines light on how vast numbers of Polish Christians were also mistreated, tortured, and killed under Nazi rule. You might think the title sounds out of place, but music and shared songs are one of the things that saw the main characters (a couple enduring separation and all kinds of loss) through their time of captivity. A well-written, gripping, and deeply emotional read. Highly recommend.
June 4, 2021
Such a powerful story set again with great historic accuracy during World War II--this time with Polish prisoners. One of my favorite authors for this time period. Liz weaves such believable circumstances and pulls you into each story as if you were there. It always breaks my heart to read of the atrocities and horrors of that war, but Liz manages to find a silver lining in each book she writes during that era.
May 2, 2025
Through singing of songs a couple found a way of staying connected even though they were separated.
The author again found a way to bring forth beauty in times of darkness, oppression and death. Through songs and the unconditional love and caring of a child, the characters found joy in the middle of sadness.
I like how the author used one german character to show that there were kindness and care from a group known only to show hatred and unkindness.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
The author again found a way to bring forth beauty in times of darkness, oppression and death. Through songs and the unconditional love and caring of a child, the characters found joy in the middle of sadness.
I like how the author used one german character to show that there were kindness and care from a group known only to show hatred and unkindness.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
February 28, 2019
What a haunting love story! Not a romance in the conventional sense -- in fact, I don't think When the Heart Sings is tagged as Historical Romance, but it does showcase the breadth and depth of true love -- it's the epitome of that old cliche "love conquers all."
Natia and Teodor have already endured enough tragedy in their young marriage when the Nazis confiscate their farm and send them to a work camp. Though they are separated upon their arrival, it is the power of their love that sustains them through the grueling months ahead.
Told from multiple points of view, Tolsma has brought history to life through these characters. Once again, I marvel over the new twist this author brings to the popular World War II Fiction genre -- the persecution of Polish Christians and the way she uses music to inspire hope in the most desperate of times.
I knew about the barbaric conditions of the Warsaw ghetto where Polish Jews were held captive but I didn't realize the extent of the German occupation throughout the rest of the country. Even small villages and rural communities weren't safe from Nazi barbarism. Farmland stolen from generational Polish farmers was gifted to displaced German families while the Poles were sent to work camps where they were, quite literally, worked to death.
So where is God in all this mess? That's the challenge Natia and Teodor face as they struggle to survive the deplorable conditions and the evil intentions of their captors. When the Heart Sings is a tough read but it is also an inspiring one. A real celebration of triumph and overcoming in the midst of unspeakable horror. Simply stunning!
Natia and Teodor have already endured enough tragedy in their young marriage when the Nazis confiscate their farm and send them to a work camp. Though they are separated upon their arrival, it is the power of their love that sustains them through the grueling months ahead.
Told from multiple points of view, Tolsma has brought history to life through these characters. Once again, I marvel over the new twist this author brings to the popular World War II Fiction genre -- the persecution of Polish Christians and the way she uses music to inspire hope in the most desperate of times.
I knew about the barbaric conditions of the Warsaw ghetto where Polish Jews were held captive but I didn't realize the extent of the German occupation throughout the rest of the country. Even small villages and rural communities weren't safe from Nazi barbarism. Farmland stolen from generational Polish farmers was gifted to displaced German families while the Poles were sent to work camps where they were, quite literally, worked to death.
So where is God in all this mess? That's the challenge Natia and Teodor face as they struggle to survive the deplorable conditions and the evil intentions of their captors. When the Heart Sings is a tough read but it is also an inspiring one. A real celebration of triumph and overcoming in the midst of unspeakable horror. Simply stunning!
November 21, 2018
Hope in the midst of despair; friendship and love in the midst of hatred and evil.
World War II can be a difficult time period to visit in novels. Granted, there are some amazing stories that have been told. But often they are challenging to read because we’d almost rather not know what happened during the war. And yet we must.
When the Heart Sings not only deals with the realities of life in Poland during the war, but it also delves into the emotional heartbreak of infertility and stillbirth — a struggle that bonds two unlikely women, yet might be hard for some to read. However, the understanding and hope within the story might also prove to be a healing balm.
With descriptions and pacing that will draw you right into the midst of the conflict, When the Heart Sings is an amazing story of perseverance, sacrifice, love, and hope. Prepare to have your heart seriously tugged, but don’t miss this one!
(This review was first published on my blog -- sarahruut.com. I received a complimentary copy of this novel. The thoughts expressed here are entirely my own.)
World War II can be a difficult time period to visit in novels. Granted, there are some amazing stories that have been told. But often they are challenging to read because we’d almost rather not know what happened during the war. And yet we must.
When the Heart Sings not only deals with the realities of life in Poland during the war, but it also delves into the emotional heartbreak of infertility and stillbirth — a struggle that bonds two unlikely women, yet might be hard for some to read. However, the understanding and hope within the story might also prove to be a healing balm.
With descriptions and pacing that will draw you right into the midst of the conflict, When the Heart Sings is an amazing story of perseverance, sacrifice, love, and hope. Prepare to have your heart seriously tugged, but don’t miss this one!
(This review was first published on my blog -- sarahruut.com. I received a complimentary copy of this novel. The thoughts expressed here are entirely my own.)
May 17, 2019
*thank you to Netgalley and Gilead Publishing for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review*
4 stars.
Ohh Lord. This book. It was so so good! It's such a heartfelt story. I am SO glad that I read it. Historical fiction needs to be a genre that you have to be in the mood for as if you aren't, it just doesn't work. Atleast for me anyways. Well, I admit I went into this half hearted. But pretty much, by the first chapter I was hooked. That's now good of a story this is.
WWII stories are always hard to read because of the horrors that happened during that time. I have read quiet a few of them and I'm still not at that point where the subject bores me as so many genres and topics can be like. This book won't bore or disappoint. It's well written and is interesting. I also have to mention that I really quite like the cover. Highly recommend.
4 stars.
Ohh Lord. This book. It was so so good! It's such a heartfelt story. I am SO glad that I read it. Historical fiction needs to be a genre that you have to be in the mood for as if you aren't, it just doesn't work. Atleast for me anyways. Well, I admit I went into this half hearted. But pretty much, by the first chapter I was hooked. That's now good of a story this is.
WWII stories are always hard to read because of the horrors that happened during that time. I have read quiet a few of them and I'm still not at that point where the subject bores me as so many genres and topics can be like. This book won't bore or disappoint. It's well written and is interesting. I also have to mention that I really quite like the cover. Highly recommend.
February 26, 2019
When the Heart Sings is the second book in the Music of Hope series. This was the second book that I have read by Liz Tolsma, I found it didn't engage me as much as Melody of the Soul, the first book in the series.
While it was the same appealing writing that first drew me into the first book of the series, I just didn't connect as much with it as I did the former. However, I did learn something from reading this book, and that was that I had no idea that the Polish people were forced from their homes much like the Jewish were, and made work in factories in forced labor. Over three million Christian Poles were killed by the Germans.
While it was the same appealing writing that first drew me into the first book of the series, I just didn't connect as much with it as I did the former. However, I did learn something from reading this book, and that was that I had no idea that the Polish people were forced from their homes much like the Jewish were, and made work in factories in forced labor. Over three million Christian Poles were killed by the Germans.
November 8, 2018
Having read Tolsma’s work before, I knew I was in for a difficult, emotional read, but one that would be worth the journey it would take me on. That was indeed the case; the story of Polish Christians forced from their land and into work camps was a painful story, but the glimmers of God’s goodness, even in such evil times, painted a picture of hope and resilience long after a person is pushed to what he or she believes to be the limits of endurance.
As always, the story is well-crafted and solidly written. The prose is beautiful, even as what it relates is heartbreaking. Families are torn apart for no reason other than their nationality, children are left orphaned and hunted for their religion.
But what will stick with me most from this story is how God is involved in every life, even when it seems He is so far away. It is not uncommon for someone to ask the question, “How could a loving God allow something like this?” but the characters soon begin to realize that He has never left them alone, providing in small ways to let them know that His presence can provide joy even amid suffering.
I highly recommend this book for adults and up—it is an important story that reminds us to never forget the past, to remember the sacrifices made many years ago by people we will never meet this side of Heaven. It is not easy to read but is well worth the time spent with this inspirational novel.
I received a review copy of this book from the author and publisher but was under no obligation to post a positive review. The opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
As always, the story is well-crafted and solidly written. The prose is beautiful, even as what it relates is heartbreaking. Families are torn apart for no reason other than their nationality, children are left orphaned and hunted for their religion.
But what will stick with me most from this story is how God is involved in every life, even when it seems He is so far away. It is not uncommon for someone to ask the question, “How could a loving God allow something like this?” but the characters soon begin to realize that He has never left them alone, providing in small ways to let them know that His presence can provide joy even amid suffering.
I highly recommend this book for adults and up—it is an important story that reminds us to never forget the past, to remember the sacrifices made many years ago by people we will never meet this side of Heaven. It is not easy to read but is well worth the time spent with this inspirational novel.
I received a review copy of this book from the author and publisher but was under no obligation to post a positive review. The opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
September 9, 2018
4.5 stars
Liz Tolsma powerfully conveys the emotions of a turbulent time as she tells the story of a young Polish Christian couple that had been sent to the labor camps in occupied Poland. This poignant story is mostly told from the different viewpoints of Natia and Teodor. Teodor is forced to work in the labor camp while Natia has been assigned the task of serving on the home of the camp overseer. An unlikely friendship develops between Natia and the overseer's wife. They find they share a common sorrow that unites them as they work together to save a young child. This is the kind of story that will speak to your heart. It is a story of survival during a bleak time that is filled with extreme hardship and despair. Tolsma conveys a powerful message that joy can be found in the midst of darkness. As I read this story, it made me wonder if my faith would be strong enough to find the joy amidst such tragedy.
One of my favorite quotes:
"Joy only came through dependence on the Lord and Him alone. Joy was forward looking, toward heaven."
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley and the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Liz Tolsma powerfully conveys the emotions of a turbulent time as she tells the story of a young Polish Christian couple that had been sent to the labor camps in occupied Poland. This poignant story is mostly told from the different viewpoints of Natia and Teodor. Teodor is forced to work in the labor camp while Natia has been assigned the task of serving on the home of the camp overseer. An unlikely friendship develops between Natia and the overseer's wife. They find they share a common sorrow that unites them as they work together to save a young child. This is the kind of story that will speak to your heart. It is a story of survival during a bleak time that is filled with extreme hardship and despair. Tolsma conveys a powerful message that joy can be found in the midst of darkness. As I read this story, it made me wonder if my faith would be strong enough to find the joy amidst such tragedy.
One of my favorite quotes:
"Joy only came through dependence on the Lord and Him alone. Joy was forward looking, toward heaven."
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley and the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
October 15, 2018
Another divine appointment with a book. This book is filled with excellent storytelling and takes place during WW2 in war torn Poland.
I truly cared about the characters and I related closely to parts of the storyline. The pregnancy losses and yearning for a baby were realistic and written with compassion. Because of my German and Polish heritage, I enjoyed being immersed into each of the cultures as I read this well written book.
This was such a difficult and turbulent time for Poland and it's people. Tremendous amounts of suffering and loss became routine and even expected. But somehow, those who had faith, had hope. Their persevering hope led to joy.
I was so thrilled to find that my favorite Bible verse was used to comfort the characters who were suffering greatly. Psalm 30:5 Weeping may endure for the night, but joy comes in the morning.
The word joy was used throughout the book and it just so happens to be my favorite word. Through many difficult experiences and tough lessons, the main characters learned that momentary happiness can in no way compete with or take the place of everlasting joy.
I loved how a needy, little orphan provided hope, joy and a reason to keep on living to two, sad, childless women. The horrible war set them up to be enemies, but God had other, much better plans for Natia and Elfriede.
Following the example and prodding of God to forgive the seemingly unforgivable, was a powerful and life changing experience for Teodore.
I loved how music sung from the heart was used to worship God, to encourage and communicate with others, to calm children, and to defuse ugly and volatile situations. Songs from the heart pointed those who needed it most to God. Both singers and listeners were blessed and encouraged.
Thank-you to NetGalley and Gilead Publishing for a copy of this book that touched my heart.
I truly cared about the characters and I related closely to parts of the storyline. The pregnancy losses and yearning for a baby were realistic and written with compassion. Because of my German and Polish heritage, I enjoyed being immersed into each of the cultures as I read this well written book.
This was such a difficult and turbulent time for Poland and it's people. Tremendous amounts of suffering and loss became routine and even expected. But somehow, those who had faith, had hope. Their persevering hope led to joy.
I was so thrilled to find that my favorite Bible verse was used to comfort the characters who were suffering greatly. Psalm 30:5 Weeping may endure for the night, but joy comes in the morning.
The word joy was used throughout the book and it just so happens to be my favorite word. Through many difficult experiences and tough lessons, the main characters learned that momentary happiness can in no way compete with or take the place of everlasting joy.
I loved how a needy, little orphan provided hope, joy and a reason to keep on living to two, sad, childless women. The horrible war set them up to be enemies, but God had other, much better plans for Natia and Elfriede.
Following the example and prodding of God to forgive the seemingly unforgivable, was a powerful and life changing experience for Teodore.
I loved how music sung from the heart was used to worship God, to encourage and communicate with others, to calm children, and to defuse ugly and volatile situations. Songs from the heart pointed those who needed it most to God. Both singers and listeners were blessed and encouraged.
Thank-you to NetGalley and Gilead Publishing for a copy of this book that touched my heart.
November 27, 2018
Granted, I was not a huge fan of my history classes in school, but it sometimes amazes me how there are still aspects of World War II I am unfamiliar with. I mean, I may not have paid a lot of attention in said history classes, but I’ve read a lot of World War II fiction and some non-fiction about this era.
Yet Liz Tolsma takes a piece of our past—the persecution and imprisonment of the Polish citizens (including the Christians) by Germany—and immerses her readers in that world to the point you feel like you are living in the house with Natia or in the work camp with Teodore.
In When the Heart Sings, Tolsma shines a spotlight on the evil hearts of man—seriously, the Nazi Erich Fromme is a villain to the core of his being, one that I won’t soon forget—while also exemplifying the strength, bravery, and even kindness of the human spirit. It can be beaten down, bent, buried, but there is a piece of men (and women) that fights, refuses to be broken.
This book is filled with the atrocities of the Nazi regime so it’s not a light read, but every painful minute in the story is well worth it.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including NetGalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
Yet Liz Tolsma takes a piece of our past—the persecution and imprisonment of the Polish citizens (including the Christians) by Germany—and immerses her readers in that world to the point you feel like you are living in the house with Natia or in the work camp with Teodore.
In When the Heart Sings, Tolsma shines a spotlight on the evil hearts of man—seriously, the Nazi Erich Fromme is a villain to the core of his being, one that I won’t soon forget—while also exemplifying the strength, bravery, and even kindness of the human spirit. It can be beaten down, bent, buried, but there is a piece of men (and women) that fights, refuses to be broken.
This book is filled with the atrocities of the Nazi regime so it’s not a light read, but every painful minute in the story is well worth it.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including NetGalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
October 6, 2018
This is another beautifully written story by Liz Tolsma. The storyline is both compelling and heartbreaking. It was hard for me to put the book down. I kept thinking “I’ll just finish this chapter”, then continued to read. Knowing that these characters represent the struggles that the Polish people went through during the time of war adds depth to the book. The characters are men and women of courage who cling to their faith in the most desperate of times. Natia’s songs add a poignant aspect to the story. She sings of God and His love in a place that is full of unreasonable hatred and evil. Her faith is the thread of hope that runs all the way through this book. There are terrible situations represented in this story, but the author handles these in an appropriate way. Even after I finished the book, I was still thinking about these characters and the faith and courage they represent.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
November 22, 2018
This is the first book by Liz Tolsma that I have read and I’m incredibly glad that I did. I love historical fiction/historical romance and I have found another favorite author in Liz Tolsma. Her writing style is lyrical and musical, so befitting the title of the book and the series. There is so much pain, aching sorrow, and nostalgic sadness as Teodor and Natia navigate their lives away from their hometown in Poland during WWII at/near a work camp. The heartbreak of miscarriage and infertility is gently addressed in the plot. Even in the midst of evil and atrocities against fellow man, Teodor and Natia cling to their sweet and tender love, their unbreakable bond through music, and hope that God holds out for everyone who believes. Secondary characters of Elfriede and Pawel are unforgettable.
Though it is not an easy read due to the nature of what Teodor and Natia have to live through, the book is a worthy read. I was given a copy of the book by Gilead Publishing via NetGalley and was not required to post a review. All comments and opinions are solely my own.
Though it is not an easy read due to the nature of what Teodor and Natia have to live through, the book is a worthy read. I was given a copy of the book by Gilead Publishing via NetGalley and was not required to post a review. All comments and opinions are solely my own.
November 16, 2018
4.5 stars
Books set in the WWII era are some of my favorite books to read. Tolsma’s latest has a slightly different perspective: Polish Jews and Christians, Polish labor camps, and the way the Polish people suffered under German occupation. This is one of the best, and most engaging, books I've read in 2018.
The love between Teodor and Natia is pure and heartwarming. I also really enjoyed the unlikely bond between Natia and Elfriede. The story demonstrates that even in the worst of circumstances, God is always present.
You can read the full review on my blog: https://lmckeeediting.blogspot.com/20...
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley, but I wasn’t required to leave a positive review.
Books set in the WWII era are some of my favorite books to read. Tolsma’s latest has a slightly different perspective: Polish Jews and Christians, Polish labor camps, and the way the Polish people suffered under German occupation. This is one of the best, and most engaging, books I've read in 2018.
The love between Teodor and Natia is pure and heartwarming. I also really enjoyed the unlikely bond between Natia and Elfriede. The story demonstrates that even in the worst of circumstances, God is always present.
You can read the full review on my blog: https://lmckeeediting.blogspot.com/20...
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley, but I wasn’t required to leave a positive review.
November 29, 2018
One of the highlights of this year was my trip to Poland in April. The experience was wonderful as we encountered beautiful cities, countryside and people. When The Heart Sings by Liz Tolsma brought all of that back to me, but through a different perspective. The novel set during WWII captures the beauty of the human spirit and its resilience in the face of extreme persecution. Just as my trip introduced me to a country with a strong cultural heritage in spite of the many hardships the people faced over the centuries, this book brought to life the ordinary people of Poland that survived the invasion of Nazi Germany. Powerful in its message and beautifully written, When The Heart Sings is a very highly recommended read.
When The Heart Sings is a small story — small in that it is set in a small town, with a small forced-labor factory, with a small cast of characters. But it certainly is not small in message. Everything about it seeks to put a face on what the people of Poland endured during the dark days of occupation. The characters could be you or me. A young couple displaced from their farm and forced to work under unimaginable circumstances, really slaves to the Nazis. A doctor who against all odds is left to live and practice medicine and do what he can to undermine the efforts of the regime. A young, naive German woman who despite indoctrination and abuse, knows deep down the right thing to do. And the cruel face of evil in the very real form of a Nazi officer. The book also examines the small actions that we can take that have big results. And under, around, and through all of the drama of the novel, God is not only present, but in control. As one of the character states: “We look at our circumstances and see things as not good. But we don’t see the picture clearly, as the Lord does. He knows what is going on.. Things happen just the way he has planned they will.” (p. 258) A hard truth to accept sometimes, but truth nonetheless. Where is God? is a question asked repeatedly, and in the end the characters and the readers know.
As you can probably guess from the title, song has a large part in the narrative. The music and words of lullabies, love songs, classical works, and hymns encourage, comfort, and help to keep sane those who find themselves in impossible situations. There is an especially moving scene in which song softens the heart of a brutal captor. Even if you have a tin ear (like me 😉 ), you will love the way Tolsma incorporates music.
I absolutely loved When The Heart Sings. It is part of a series, but the books are only connected through theme and setting and can be read as standalones. It is definitely a book you are going to talk about — great for book clubs or friends/family who love to read together.
Very Highly Recommended.
Great for Book Clubs.
Audience: adults.
(Thanks to Gilead Publishing for a complimentary copy. All opinions expressed are mine alone.)
When The Heart Sings is a small story — small in that it is set in a small town, with a small forced-labor factory, with a small cast of characters. But it certainly is not small in message. Everything about it seeks to put a face on what the people of Poland endured during the dark days of occupation. The characters could be you or me. A young couple displaced from their farm and forced to work under unimaginable circumstances, really slaves to the Nazis. A doctor who against all odds is left to live and practice medicine and do what he can to undermine the efforts of the regime. A young, naive German woman who despite indoctrination and abuse, knows deep down the right thing to do. And the cruel face of evil in the very real form of a Nazi officer. The book also examines the small actions that we can take that have big results. And under, around, and through all of the drama of the novel, God is not only present, but in control. As one of the character states: “We look at our circumstances and see things as not good. But we don’t see the picture clearly, as the Lord does. He knows what is going on.. Things happen just the way he has planned they will.” (p. 258) A hard truth to accept sometimes, but truth nonetheless. Where is God? is a question asked repeatedly, and in the end the characters and the readers know.
As you can probably guess from the title, song has a large part in the narrative. The music and words of lullabies, love songs, classical works, and hymns encourage, comfort, and help to keep sane those who find themselves in impossible situations. There is an especially moving scene in which song softens the heart of a brutal captor. Even if you have a tin ear (like me 😉 ), you will love the way Tolsma incorporates music.
I absolutely loved When The Heart Sings. It is part of a series, but the books are only connected through theme and setting and can be read as standalones. It is definitely a book you are going to talk about — great for book clubs or friends/family who love to read together.
Very Highly Recommended.
Great for Book Clubs.
Audience: adults.
(Thanks to Gilead Publishing for a complimentary copy. All opinions expressed are mine alone.)
September 13, 2018
When the Heart Sings is an emotionally charged story that takes place during one of the darkest times in history. The world knows how terribly the Jews suffered, but what is less known is how there were other peoples targeted as well. Although it was different, the Polish people were hated and mistreated by the Nazi's as well. This is a story to shed light on their plight.
What made the story even more captivating was that it was told by the perspective of both husband and wife as they are separated from each other. Their desperation to know that the other was still alive and their hope for a reunion was their driving force to persevere through their agony. Their love for each other was unquestionable. It affected how they responded to their circumstances, afraid of causing harm to the other. Natia was in Pan Fromm's home as a maid while Teodor worked under him in the factory. Knowing the connection, Fromm often used it to his advantage to make matters worse for the couple.
Without giving away any details of the story, I really liked the progression of the relationship between Natia and Elfriede, who was Pan Fromm's wife. Elfriede risked her own life by demanding her husband save Natia (a stranger at the time) from going to the camp by instead coming to stay in their home. Both women had suffered through fertility complications and miscarriages, and it formed a unique bond between them. Despite the language barriers, overtime they developed a real friendship. When the Jewish baby arrived, they both fell in love with him-- although knowing he was Jewish Natia made sure she was the only one to change his diaper hoping for his best protection. Although under different circumstances, both women were trapped in their situations and hoped for a way out.
There was so much contained in this story but I don't want to give too much away. I don't want to hinder the emotional journey for you in any way, so I will simply say that I highly recommend it and hope you take the time to check it out. Although the lives of these characters are fictional, what they suffered was true of many Polish families during the war. This was an emotional journey, but well worth the read.
*I received a free copy of this book through NetGalley. I was not required to give a positive review. Thoughts and opinions expressed are mine alone.
What made the story even more captivating was that it was told by the perspective of both husband and wife as they are separated from each other. Their desperation to know that the other was still alive and their hope for a reunion was their driving force to persevere through their agony. Their love for each other was unquestionable. It affected how they responded to their circumstances, afraid of causing harm to the other. Natia was in Pan Fromm's home as a maid while Teodor worked under him in the factory. Knowing the connection, Fromm often used it to his advantage to make matters worse for the couple.
Without giving away any details of the story, I really liked the progression of the relationship between Natia and Elfriede, who was Pan Fromm's wife. Elfriede risked her own life by demanding her husband save Natia (a stranger at the time) from going to the camp by instead coming to stay in their home. Both women had suffered through fertility complications and miscarriages, and it formed a unique bond between them. Despite the language barriers, overtime they developed a real friendship. When the Jewish baby arrived, they both fell in love with him-- although knowing he was Jewish Natia made sure she was the only one to change his diaper hoping for his best protection. Although under different circumstances, both women were trapped in their situations and hoped for a way out.
There was so much contained in this story but I don't want to give too much away. I don't want to hinder the emotional journey for you in any way, so I will simply say that I highly recommend it and hope you take the time to check it out. Although the lives of these characters are fictional, what they suffered was true of many Polish families during the war. This was an emotional journey, but well worth the read.
*I received a free copy of this book through NetGalley. I was not required to give a positive review. Thoughts and opinions expressed are mine alone.
February 3, 2019
Pani Rezez´nikowa says " Don't look to the things of this world to bring you joy. Only the Lord can give you a heart that is truly happy and at peace!" Oh my!! Such emotional and powerful word this author has written!!
I had to write this one down in my journal so that I can remind my myself that we are part of a big picture that our Lord sees.
I read this book in one day because silly ol me couldn't wait to see what was on the next page.
Wow such trials and tribulations that Teodor whom I kept wanting to call Theodore and Natia went through!!
Those horrible Nazi's!!! And what's sad about this whole thing was that Hitler had some Jewish blood running through his veins.
No one is exempt from being perfect. Not even the Germans!! Only one man was perfect and that was Jesus!!
I can relate to this story. I don't talk about it much but I too have had several miscarriages. Was i heartbroken yes I was. Too this day I wonder what they would've been. Have I grieved properly No. I just shut it away but it doesn't stop me from questioning God why?
2nd my grandfather fought against the Germans. He told me quite a few stories about being in the trenches and he even brought home a Nazi flag along with some other things.
I no longer have the flag. I didn't want it but I kept a few other things
Music is joy to my heart. Ive played the viola since 2001 in the community orchestra. I love it so much!! Without music I don't know what I would do!! Music has always been a vital part of my life. I've even sang in a church choir.
Natia is a brave soul in trying times as is Teodor. I rooted for them through the whole entire story!!
Erich was another matter altogether. Too bad I couldn't reach through the book and grab Erich for the evil things he did but I bided my time and I even prayed for him!! God is good indeed!! Karma comes back twice fold!!
There were some things I had a hard time in pronouncing but some of the words reminds me of Pennsylvania Dutch that the Amish speak.
This is a beautifully told story where true love remains strong and gets two of my favourite people to hold onto their Faith.
I strongly recommend this book for you will be wondering what happens to these people and here's another book you might want to grab some tissues cause you will get it's that powerful!!
I received a copy from Netgalley and no compensations were received. All opinions are my own!!!
I had to write this one down in my journal so that I can remind my myself that we are part of a big picture that our Lord sees.
I read this book in one day because silly ol me couldn't wait to see what was on the next page.
Wow such trials and tribulations that Teodor whom I kept wanting to call Theodore and Natia went through!!
Those horrible Nazi's!!! And what's sad about this whole thing was that Hitler had some Jewish blood running through his veins.
No one is exempt from being perfect. Not even the Germans!! Only one man was perfect and that was Jesus!!
I can relate to this story. I don't talk about it much but I too have had several miscarriages. Was i heartbroken yes I was. Too this day I wonder what they would've been. Have I grieved properly No. I just shut it away but it doesn't stop me from questioning God why?
2nd my grandfather fought against the Germans. He told me quite a few stories about being in the trenches and he even brought home a Nazi flag along with some other things.
I no longer have the flag. I didn't want it but I kept a few other things
Music is joy to my heart. Ive played the viola since 2001 in the community orchestra. I love it so much!! Without music I don't know what I would do!! Music has always been a vital part of my life. I've even sang in a church choir.
Natia is a brave soul in trying times as is Teodor. I rooted for them through the whole entire story!!
Erich was another matter altogether. Too bad I couldn't reach through the book and grab Erich for the evil things he did but I bided my time and I even prayed for him!! God is good indeed!! Karma comes back twice fold!!
There were some things I had a hard time in pronouncing but some of the words reminds me of Pennsylvania Dutch that the Amish speak.
This is a beautifully told story where true love remains strong and gets two of my favourite people to hold onto their Faith.
I strongly recommend this book for you will be wondering what happens to these people and here's another book you might want to grab some tissues cause you will get it's that powerful!!
I received a copy from Netgalley and no compensations were received. All opinions are my own!!!
November 28, 2018
Liz Tolsma is a specialist in writing World War Two fiction from a variety of perspectives. The characters are usually ordinary people caught up in the horror of war, both in Europe and Asia. In When the Heart Sings, Tolsma focuses on Polish Christians displaced from their farms due to the Nazi concept of Lebensraum. Still recovering from a stillbirth, Natia endured a journey through Poland via cattle car but almost collapsed on arrival in the town that would become her home. If not for Elfriede Fromm, the wife of the labor camp’s overseer, Natia would’ve probably been murdered on the spot. Others weren’t so lucky.
And so readers get their first taste of the violence that occurs throughout the book. I’m not naïve about the Nazis – my mother’s childhood friend lost family members during the Holocaust – but do I want to read about their atrocities in such graphic detail? For this reason, I could only read the book in limited portions. From start to end, this book is not easy reading: even the beginning focuses on the difficult birth of Natia’s stillborn boy. The blessing in When the Heart Sings is the friendship that develops between Natia and Elfriede. Elfriede, although technically the enemy, comes across as a sympathetic character. She lives in fear of her husband, forced to acknowledge that he’s not the man she thought she had married. All she has is her position as daughter of a high-ranking Nazi officer.
The ending focuses on Teodor and Natia, but I wanted to know what happened to a couple of the other major characters. The book ended on a hopeful note, but I knew it couldn’t be the case. Poland’s borders were changed, and the country became part of the Soviet Bloc. How did those events affect the characters I had come to know and love? Sadly, I’ll never know. But the head and the heart often see things differently. Although I thought that the resolution was slightly improbable, it created an emotion in me that I didn’t expect. I closed the book and the tears were running down my cheeks. It’s a rare book that does that.
Thank you to JustRead Publicity Tours and Gilead Publishing for my copy of When the Heart Sings. The above thoughts on this title are my own.
And so readers get their first taste of the violence that occurs throughout the book. I’m not naïve about the Nazis – my mother’s childhood friend lost family members during the Holocaust – but do I want to read about their atrocities in such graphic detail? For this reason, I could only read the book in limited portions. From start to end, this book is not easy reading: even the beginning focuses on the difficult birth of Natia’s stillborn boy. The blessing in When the Heart Sings is the friendship that develops between Natia and Elfriede. Elfriede, although technically the enemy, comes across as a sympathetic character. She lives in fear of her husband, forced to acknowledge that he’s not the man she thought she had married. All she has is her position as daughter of a high-ranking Nazi officer.
The ending focuses on Teodor and Natia, but I wanted to know what happened to a couple of the other major characters. The book ended on a hopeful note, but I knew it couldn’t be the case. Poland’s borders were changed, and the country became part of the Soviet Bloc. How did those events affect the characters I had come to know and love? Sadly, I’ll never know. But the head and the heart often see things differently. Although I thought that the resolution was slightly improbable, it created an emotion in me that I didn’t expect. I closed the book and the tears were running down my cheeks. It’s a rare book that does that.
Thank you to JustRead Publicity Tours and Gilead Publishing for my copy of When the Heart Sings. The above thoughts on this title are my own.
October 28, 2018
A touching and tender story
Through most of this book, I had tears threatening. The author did such a great job communicating their fears, their pains, and their hopes. Teodor and Natia are a young Polish couple who have only been married for a few years and yet in that time have experienced tremendous grief at the loss of three babies who never had a chance to breathe. When notice is given to them that they have to cede their farm to a German family and report to a labor camp, Natia has not yet even healed from her most recent miscarriage.
The love these two have for one another is so tender and sweet. It is the kind of love that every girl dreams of. The kind of love that we are told to show as husbands and wives. Their separation broke my heart.
Teodor was such an amazing, valiant hero. Before they left for the labor camp, he went to the grocer to settle his bill there. Amazing! And he ended up being a leader in the labor camp, an inspiration to the others when the Nazis attempted to divide them. Even in his weakness, he found his strength in God.
I loved the way that Natia was able to reach Teodor by singing as she walked past the factory, and how despite his lack of musical ability, he would reply. The way they knew so many songs and could communicate things through the lyrics because of that bond was touching.
Despite the fear and the uncertainty for the Polish people at the time, and despite the violence and cruelty of the Nazi officers, Natia and Teodor were able to show kindness to those around them and to spread hope. None of the events seemed unrealistic or contrived and the violence that was conveyed was done so in a manner that was not overdone or gratuitous.
Fans of Christian and historical fiction are sure to enjoy this touching and tender story.
This review was originally posted on Among the Reads
I was given a free copy of this item. This gift did not influence my opinion or review.
Through most of this book, I had tears threatening. The author did such a great job communicating their fears, their pains, and their hopes. Teodor and Natia are a young Polish couple who have only been married for a few years and yet in that time have experienced tremendous grief at the loss of three babies who never had a chance to breathe. When notice is given to them that they have to cede their farm to a German family and report to a labor camp, Natia has not yet even healed from her most recent miscarriage.
The love these two have for one another is so tender and sweet. It is the kind of love that every girl dreams of. The kind of love that we are told to show as husbands and wives. Their separation broke my heart.
Teodor was such an amazing, valiant hero. Before they left for the labor camp, he went to the grocer to settle his bill there. Amazing! And he ended up being a leader in the labor camp, an inspiration to the others when the Nazis attempted to divide them. Even in his weakness, he found his strength in God.
I loved the way that Natia was able to reach Teodor by singing as she walked past the factory, and how despite his lack of musical ability, he would reply. The way they knew so many songs and could communicate things through the lyrics because of that bond was touching.
Despite the fear and the uncertainty for the Polish people at the time, and despite the violence and cruelty of the Nazi officers, Natia and Teodor were able to show kindness to those around them and to spread hope. None of the events seemed unrealistic or contrived and the violence that was conveyed was done so in a manner that was not overdone or gratuitous.
Fans of Christian and historical fiction are sure to enjoy this touching and tender story.
This review was originally posted on Among the Reads
I was given a free copy of this item. This gift did not influence my opinion or review.
November 26, 2018
World War II novels are wonderful and one of my favorite genres. I enjoy reading about the greatest generation and the heroic acts they endured. Soldiers who went into battle just to defend Old Glory. I love their attitudes. I know with a historical romance there will be a struggle wrapped in a historical setting and filled with adventure. Liz Tolsma's newest novel When the Heart Sings does exactly that.
I love the concept of her story. Using songs to share her heroine's current situation and love for her husband and the ability to sooth the baby was a wonderful twist on a familiar topic. I flew through the story and really enjoyed it. There were moments of realistic horror that made me cringe, but I knew the reality of the treatment of Jews and Poles was horrifying. The plot moved fast, and I had a hard time putting the novel down.
The romance was between a husband and a wife. It showed how deep a romance can go even if the most horrific of places. I loved how Natia and Teodor Palinska cling to the hope of getting back together holds their hope of leaving the horrible concentration camp.
The only problem I had with the plot is being another concentration camp story. When I first started reading the World War II genre, I didn't mind, but now tons of authors have written stories on the horrors that occurred during at the concentration camps. From Kristy Cambron, Joel Rosenberg, Kate Breslin, and Tolsma among a number of others, the idea appears to be the same. How to share the horror and make the reader cringe.
Overall, When the Heart Sings by Liz Tolsma is a wonderful story blanketed with the horrors of World War II reality. The novel is fast-paced and captured my imagination. Fans of Kristy Cambron, Joel Rosenberg, Kate Breslin, and Anna Schmidt will enjoy this novel.
I received a complimentary copy of When the Heart Sings by Liz Tolsma from Gideon Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
I love the concept of her story. Using songs to share her heroine's current situation and love for her husband and the ability to sooth the baby was a wonderful twist on a familiar topic. I flew through the story and really enjoyed it. There were moments of realistic horror that made me cringe, but I knew the reality of the treatment of Jews and Poles was horrifying. The plot moved fast, and I had a hard time putting the novel down.
The romance was between a husband and a wife. It showed how deep a romance can go even if the most horrific of places. I loved how Natia and Teodor Palinska cling to the hope of getting back together holds their hope of leaving the horrible concentration camp.
The only problem I had with the plot is being another concentration camp story. When I first started reading the World War II genre, I didn't mind, but now tons of authors have written stories on the horrors that occurred during at the concentration camps. From Kristy Cambron, Joel Rosenberg, Kate Breslin, and Tolsma among a number of others, the idea appears to be the same. How to share the horror and make the reader cringe.
Overall, When the Heart Sings by Liz Tolsma is a wonderful story blanketed with the horrors of World War II reality. The novel is fast-paced and captured my imagination. Fans of Kristy Cambron, Joel Rosenberg, Kate Breslin, and Anna Schmidt will enjoy this novel.
I received a complimentary copy of When the Heart Sings by Liz Tolsma from Gideon Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
November 27, 2018
When the Heart Sings is full of universal lessons for all of us: forgiveness, patience, and finding friendship in the unlikeliest of places. When Polish Christians Natia and Teodor are forced from their home and deported to a German labor camp, they endure very different but equally heartwrenching circumstances. Teodor, always under scrutiny by Erich, the camp overseer, faces extra cruelty and work demands. Natia, living as the housekeeper in the overseer's home, faces a very different set of challenges. Home alone all day with Elfriede, Erich's wife, she is forced to take over all housework. As they slowly learn to communicate, Elfriede and Natia discover that they have more in common than they realize. When Natia brings a Jewish baby into the home, she and Elfriede are determined to love the baby and to keep it safe from Erich at all costs. The way that this plays out and the sacrifices that are made are truly inspiring.
The supporting characters in this story also portray so well those who worked secretly in the background to aid the helpless victims of the war. One of those characters in the story said my favorite line in the whole book:
"We look at our circumstances and see things as not good. But we don't see the picture clearly, as the Lord does. He knows what's going on. Things happen just the way he has planned they will. We aren't to find our joy and contentment in people or in our circumstances, but in him."
When I read that, I had to put down the book and think for a minute about how truly blessed I am. It's so easy to get caught up in my everyday problems, and some of them are genuinely stressful, but truly, there is nothing that I can't get through with the Lord's help. I've never been good at praising the Lord in times of trial, but if victims of the Holocaust can do it then so should I. I'm so grateful to Liz Tolsma for this touching reminder!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Gilead Publishing through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
The supporting characters in this story also portray so well those who worked secretly in the background to aid the helpless victims of the war. One of those characters in the story said my favorite line in the whole book:
"We look at our circumstances and see things as not good. But we don't see the picture clearly, as the Lord does. He knows what's going on. Things happen just the way he has planned they will. We aren't to find our joy and contentment in people or in our circumstances, but in him."
When I read that, I had to put down the book and think for a minute about how truly blessed I am. It's so easy to get caught up in my everyday problems, and some of them are genuinely stressful, but truly, there is nothing that I can't get through with the Lord's help. I've never been good at praising the Lord in times of trial, but if victims of the Holocaust can do it then so should I. I'm so grateful to Liz Tolsma for this touching reminder!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Gilead Publishing through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
March 16, 2019
Liz Tolsma is one of my favorite WW II fiction writers. And so, when I see another book that she has written offered, I snatch it up. I have enjoyed two of her Music of Hope series, “Melody of the Soul” and the one I’m reviewing here, “When the Heart Sings”. I intend to read all the books in the Music of Hope series.
This second novel in the series tells the story of Natia and Teodor, a farming couple living in Poland. They are forced out of the home by the invasion of the Nazis. Teodor and Natia are being forced to work for the Nazi government in factories. However, at the train station where they are waiting to be crowded into cattle cars, Natia raises such a commotion at having to leave Teodor that the factory commandant’s wife snatches her up to be her maid. Teodor is bound for factory work and Natia is surprisingly billeted in the home of the Nazi commandant.
During one of her excursions to the market, she happens upon a poor Jewish woman and her infant. She sneaks them food when she can and eventually finds this dying woman on the commandant’s doorstep. She decides that she will care for the infant and under the Nazi’s and his wife Elfriede’s noses, tends to the little Jewish lad in their home. Neither realizes that this child is not Arayn. When the secret comes out, Natia and Elfriede, who has come to love the child as her own, along with Teodor, who has escaped the factory, run for their lives.
This is another remarkably poignant novel by Ms. Tolsma. You won’t be disappointed.
You can find this review on my blog at https://wp.me/p2pjIt-xs. Other reviews can be found at http://imhookedonbooks.wordpress.com.
This second novel in the series tells the story of Natia and Teodor, a farming couple living in Poland. They are forced out of the home by the invasion of the Nazis. Teodor and Natia are being forced to work for the Nazi government in factories. However, at the train station where they are waiting to be crowded into cattle cars, Natia raises such a commotion at having to leave Teodor that the factory commandant’s wife snatches her up to be her maid. Teodor is bound for factory work and Natia is surprisingly billeted in the home of the Nazi commandant.
During one of her excursions to the market, she happens upon a poor Jewish woman and her infant. She sneaks them food when she can and eventually finds this dying woman on the commandant’s doorstep. She decides that she will care for the infant and under the Nazi’s and his wife Elfriede’s noses, tends to the little Jewish lad in their home. Neither realizes that this child is not Arayn. When the secret comes out, Natia and Elfriede, who has come to love the child as her own, along with Teodor, who has escaped the factory, run for their lives.
This is another remarkably poignant novel by Ms. Tolsma. You won’t be disappointed.
You can find this review on my blog at https://wp.me/p2pjIt-xs. Other reviews can be found at http://imhookedonbooks.wordpress.com.
November 21, 2018
Liz Tolsma has written several historical fiction books set in war-torn Europe, each illustrating the best and the worst of humanity. Hope and the courage to survive, drawn from a strong faith, are central themes of her writing. Her last two books, THE MELODY OF THE SOUL and now WHEN THE HEART SINGS, both feature music. Young marrieds, Natia and Teodor have suffered many losses -- their three stillborn infants and then their Polish farm relinquished to the Germans.
When they are sent away to work in a factory for the German war machine, Natia and Teodor are first separated from Natia's father and siblings. Then they are separated from each other. While neither can find a way to be reunited, Natia does find a way to communicate with Teodor, through songs she sings early each morning as she walks to the market.
In an unexpected turn of events, Natia finds herself a servant to a young German woman and her violent officer husband. Empty wombs and infant loss help the two women bond despite a language barrier. Later, an orphaned infant brings them closer. But Natia knows something about the babe's origins that Elfriede does not. Should Elfriede learn the truth, Natia is sure that both her life and the infant's will be in danger.
WHEN THE HEART SINGS shows how far the young Christian couple will go to help the innocent and war-weary survive. Despite its serious content, this is a book that will leave you with hope and eager to read another title by Tolsma. I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are mine.
When they are sent away to work in a factory for the German war machine, Natia and Teodor are first separated from Natia's father and siblings. Then they are separated from each other. While neither can find a way to be reunited, Natia does find a way to communicate with Teodor, through songs she sings early each morning as she walks to the market.
In an unexpected turn of events, Natia finds herself a servant to a young German woman and her violent officer husband. Empty wombs and infant loss help the two women bond despite a language barrier. Later, an orphaned infant brings them closer. But Natia knows something about the babe's origins that Elfriede does not. Should Elfriede learn the truth, Natia is sure that both her life and the infant's will be in danger.
WHEN THE HEART SINGS shows how far the young Christian couple will go to help the innocent and war-weary survive. Despite its serious content, this is a book that will leave you with hope and eager to read another title by Tolsma. I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are mine.
December 11, 2018
When the Heart Sings is the second book in Liz Tolsma's Music of Hope series, and she has done an awesome job with both stories. Both the horrific and the heroic elements of World War II and the people so drastically impacted come through in her true-to-life characters and their stories.
The awful suffering and conflict -- physical, emotional, political -- that the Germans and the Poles experience in this well-crafted story are surely representative of what was happening in the hearts and lives of people at this dreadful time in history. Life-changing and life-threatening decisions have to be made by the characters on all sides of that conflict in this story. Doing their part to fight the battle and doing the right thing takes a variety of paths and sometimes requires ignoring which side they are on. The common experiences of mothers -- and fathers -- who have lost a child bring to light the human element that is not defined by which side a person fights for in times of war.
The threads of hope in God and in their fellow men that keep them going in spite of the dark days tugged strongly at this reader's heart and mind. And the reminder of how deeply music can touch a soul was a beautiful major element of the story.
I highly recommend When the Heart Sings to anyone who is a fan of well-written WWII fiction or anyone who loves a tale of hope in the dark hours of life.
Thanks to JustRead Publicity for providing a copy of this book. I am happy to share my own thoughts in this review.
The awful suffering and conflict -- physical, emotional, political -- that the Germans and the Poles experience in this well-crafted story are surely representative of what was happening in the hearts and lives of people at this dreadful time in history. Life-changing and life-threatening decisions have to be made by the characters on all sides of that conflict in this story. Doing their part to fight the battle and doing the right thing takes a variety of paths and sometimes requires ignoring which side they are on. The common experiences of mothers -- and fathers -- who have lost a child bring to light the human element that is not defined by which side a person fights for in times of war.
The threads of hope in God and in their fellow men that keep them going in spite of the dark days tugged strongly at this reader's heart and mind. And the reminder of how deeply music can touch a soul was a beautiful major element of the story.
I highly recommend When the Heart Sings to anyone who is a fan of well-written WWII fiction or anyone who loves a tale of hope in the dark hours of life.
Thanks to JustRead Publicity for providing a copy of this book. I am happy to share my own thoughts in this review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews