What do you think?
Rate this book


346 pages, Paperback
Published February 1, 2018
"When will they ever learn?"
Reading this book is apt to provoke a demoralizing sense of déjà vu. It describes an (undeclared) war, prosecuted by a U.S. president, justified by false and/or misleading intelligence, and conducted with little knowledge of the history and culture of the "enemy". Not surprisingly, the outcome was exceedingly grim, but this type of scenario didn't stop with Korea. Vietnam and Iraq were to follow.--Pete Seeger, Where Have All the Flowers Gone?
The proposed dividing line was selected on 10 August 1945 by two young colonels from the State Department working late in the evening in the Pentagon. They were given half an hour for the task and a map of 'Asia and Adjacent' areas from a 1942 National Geographic magazine. One of the colonels was Dean Rusk. A few days later President Truman confirmed the selection. [p. 25]Almost inevitably, the partition evolved into two separate states, and in 1948 two republics were proclaimed, the North headed by Kim Il-sung, and the South by Syngman Rhee. Both were bent on unification by force. There were some minor border skirmishes in 1949, but in 1950, North Korea invaded the South. Within three months, the North Korean forces had been repelled, and the UN Security Council resolution calling for North Korea "to withdraw their armed forces to the 38th parallel" [p. 72] had been satisfied. However, Rhee, Truman, and General Douglas MacArthur saw this as an opportunity to "defeat Communism", and on the basis of a weak and ambiguous UN General Assembly resolution, MacArthur was given permission to lead UN Command forces in an invasion of the North. A full-throated Chinese military response was not anticipated, and when it came, the result was carnage, panic, and withdrawal, accompanied by "razing of villages along our withdrawal route and destruction of food staples" [p. 127].