Update (27th September 2018): I decided to change my rating to 3.5 stars. When finished this book I was decently impressed by it, being a debut novel. However I then read some other authors’ debut novels and found that this was the most obviously debut out of all of them. Not to say I didn’t enjoy this book any less, I just feel like I have to dock a few points for not feeling as sophisticated as other debut novels I’ve read recently.
This book was the breath of fresh air I needed after reading so much YA trashy urban fantasy. The Three Hares: Bloodline to me is The Famous Five meets Peter Rabbit. It has the teens having planning their own adventures in wilderness and plotting to overthrow a corrupt official and the sweet innocent humour of Peter Rabbit books I read as a kid. From a literary standpoint, this book ticks all the boxes in terms of high quality writing and elements that make a good story. The had a well-developed, complex, inspiring characters, the town of Winslow Falls was well-constructed and exciting, there were a strong themes of friendship, courage and standing up for justice, I like that the book was written in third person with fantastic narration and the plot was slow at the start but built up towards the end to a epic climax.
Ethan as the main character was everything I wanted him to be, he’s witty, intelligent, courageous, sensible, loyal and a protagonist who knows his duty. Jacob and Liz model best friends who support the main character through their journey and are always there to offer advise, but also know when to back off and let the main character learn things for themselves. I love Liz, she’s a great female friend and I like how she made the main character nervous and kept him on his toes in way that’s sweet and adds humour to the story. Ethan’s character development from the beginning of the novel to the end is truly fascinating as grows from a curious, kind of bored teenager to a innovative, courageous, warrior who brought down a corrupt government. I would have appreciated a little more description of characters’ physical appearance though, I had trouble trying to imagine them since I was searching through the first few chapters trying find physical descriptions, but there weren’t very many.
There were really only factors that stopped me from giving The Three Hares the full five stars. Firstly, the start was quite slow, which I’m used to but still appreciate when it doesn’t take 50 pages to become invested in the story. Secondly, the ending left me a little confused, since it was very ambiguous and kind of left off on a subtle cliffhanger, but then again, it’s the first book in a five book series so it leaves plenty of room to expand the story. Finally, not enough physical descriptions of the main characters. My overall enjoyment level was probably around 3.5 and if I were to base my opinion entirely on writing, it would have gotten 5 stars, but factoring in enjoyment levels I have to drop the rating down to 3 stars. I feel like if I read this when was younger, maybe around upper primary school age (10-12), I would have enjoyed the book a lot more, as it reminds of Enid Blyton’s books I read at that age. So as a whole, very well-written debut novel from a literary standpoint, but with a bit of slow start, enjoyment wise, not the most enjoyable book I’ve read this year. There’s plenty of potential and room to build and expand the story and I look forward to reading the rest of the series.