Gil’s World is a science fiction story written by James Murdo. We follow the mute girl Gil, who lives in a hunter-gatherer society. As she lost the ability to speak at an early age, she has a very hard time communicating with people around her, and she often feels a bit like an outsider. A huge part of her tribal life is influenced by peoples ability to access their ‘sphere’, a supernatural ability to feel and interact with each other over distances. Gil is fortunate in that respect, in that she thinks her ability to use the sphere is stronger than most other people around her.
In a parallel story, we follow a several years old machine-like entity, and its travels through the galaxy, looking for enemies. It is all powerfull, with sufficient technology on board its vessel, to destroy suns and planets.
As chance will is, the paths of Gil and the machine-like entity cross.
The book is generally well written, but I found the jumping back and forth between the two stories to ruin the flow. Every second chapter is either from Gil’s point of view, or the machine-like entity, and while the former is standard low tech fantasy, the latter is hardcore technobabble science fiction, so it was quite contrasting. And as the stories didn’t really convene at all until over halfway through the book, and even then only really took hold the last quarter of the book, it didn’t work for me at all. Gils story was the interesting one, since there was actually a character going through some issues, but much of her story was merely explaining the magic system, that affected most of her daily life. And way too much time was spend on that without progressing the story much, and that wasn’t very interesting.
I tend to love hardcore science fiction, and don’t mind techno babble and world building, so for the first five chapters of the machine like entity I was quite focused on following the story. But, as it turned out, most of the chapters was just world building, and after five more chapters I started to loose interest, and five chapters later I didn’t really care much about the ‘character’ or what it was doing, because there wasn’t much happening. There was sooo much world building which didn’t have any effect on the story, and that ruined it completely for me. Interesting, yes, but it didn’t do anything for the book. Also, since the entity was machine-like, it always referred to subparts of itself in binary, which didn’t help me at all.
As the two stories really convened at the end of the book, the amount of time spent building up to it was just way too much, so the ending felt really flat for me. I think the book would have been much better if it was cut down significantly, and the world building was spread out over more books or cut completely. Overall I found the writing nice, and it carried a lot of the book. There were definitely some good things to be found here, but ultimately it didn’t work for me, as the contrasting stories made everything very unfocused. Most of the hard science fiction chapters was one long world building info-dump, and that didn’t work for a book that tries to tell a story.
I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Rhett Samuel Price, who did a very nice job. Clear narration, and good voices, and I thought he was a nice pick for the story.
I received this audiobook for free in return for a review. I have no affiliation with the author, the narrator, the publisher, or their pets (Although I am sure the latter are quite nice!).