I think Brenda Novak easily owns the contemporary small town Americana-romance genre.
Hit or miss but she does the small towns as they are quite well - close knit communities where everyone knows everyone and their business. Warmth, fellowship, support but also that quintessential human pettiness and close-mindedness.
Just perfect for any kind of story’s setting!
I am liking the Dundee series much better than the Whiskey Creek one.
I’m not reading the books in sequence but I like that although the stories are obviously connected and the characters from the other books make an appearance, all of them aren’t good friends/a close group like in the Whiskey Creek series. So less distraction and less white noise!
As for this book *with spoilers* -
It’s as angsty and moving as all her other stories. The h is a misfit misunderstood rebellious girl turned woman who has done the most outrageous things to gain her father’s attention and approval but never succeeded. I hate such callous parents but they do so well to add to the angst. What I hate more is their (partial) redeeming and that now we are supposed to forgive them years of neglect and accept that they did in fact love their kid all along. Oh well, I’m getting ahead here.
So the h and the H have hated each other’s guts and have done some pretty nasty and malevolent things to each other for well over two decades now. The enmity is mostly fuelled and kept going by the h’s anger over her father’s apparent approval for the boy from across the street while he ignores his own daughter.
The H could never understand why she could so easily be friends with everyone else but him.
And she tries her hardest to hate and not befriend a person so likeable to everyone else.
In the present, she’s engaged to a guy from Nebraska she’s met on the net as more than anything else she wants to leave her hometown and its people behind as they still judge her for all that she did as that outrageous tomboy, while the H has a gf (more like a friday night booty call) he’s not-so-seriously considering marrying.
The spark between the h/H flared briefly and almost got out of hand one night last year but they managed to revert back to their usual antagonism, read normalcy!
Her dad gives them an ultimatum to manage a truce for few weeks till her parents’ anniversary party. And so begins the unmasking of their true feelings for each other. Of course, the path is as rocky and two-steps-back as possible. But it was fun and bittersweet to watch these two old enemies become something more and else to each other. Emotions were always high between them especially from the h’s side, just that it gets channelled differently.
I can’t say I liked his dumping her furniture out in the open as he did. Too mean for a grown up and a H. And his calling the fiancé is all wrong too but that could still fit into ‘all’s fair in love and war’. But the first came after her kindness and taking care of him when he was sick and I disliked him for it. I approve that she doesn't retaliate either time - well, not really…
Three things that are off -
I understood and do not judge her for chain smoking (since she’s 16!), and her constant quitting and then not-quitting but it’s still distracting to face a habit so abhorrent to me.
The other people needed to clear off sooner than they did. I especially din’t like that his break-off with the ow happens so late in the story. And when I wanted him to be completely crazy for the h, he’s still weighing a marriage to the ow. So the pacing could have been better.
And the final scene with her father is short, hurried and quite a non-event. Also for that matter, his parents too were quite mean to her (even in the present) and they needed to make up for it as well.
I will not bring up the sisters and Randy as they are not important.
So not as good as book #4 but still pretty darn good!
Booker needs special mention and I can’t wait to read his book - though I think his Katie is coming across as quite shallow!