What do you think?
Rate this book
Ruth Galloway #11
The Stone Circle
Librarian note: See alternate cover edition here.
DCI Nelson has been receiving threatening letters telling him to 'go to the stone circle and rescue the innocent who is buried there'. He is shaken, not only because children are very much on his mind, with Michelle's baby due to be born, but because although the letters are anonymous, they are somehow familiar. They read like the letters that first drew him into the case of The Crossing Places, and to Ruth. But the author of those letters is dead. Or are they?
DCI Nelson has been receiving threatening letters telling him to 'go to the stone circle and rescue the innocent who is buried there'. He is shaken, not only because children are very much on his mind, with Michelle's baby due to be born, but because although the letters are anonymous, they are somehow familiar. They read like the letters that first drew him into the case of The Crossing Places, and to Ruth. But the author of those letters is dead. Or are they?
Meanwhile Ruth is working on a dig in the Saltmarsh - another henge, known by the archaeologists as the stone circle - trying not to think about the baby. Then bones are found on the site, and identified as those of Margaret Lacey, a twelve-year-old girl who disappeared thirty years ago.
As the Margaret Lacey case progresses, more and more aspects of it begin to hark back to that first case of The Crossing Places, and to Scarlett Henderson, the girl Nelson couldn't save. The past is reaching out for Ruth and Nelson, and its grip is deadly.
373 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 7, 2019
2694 people are currently reading
5491 people want to read
About the author
Elly Griffiths
76 books9,523 followersElly Griffiths' Ruth Galloway novels take for their inspiration Elly's husband, who gave up a city job to train as an archaeologist, and her aunt who lives on the Norfolk coast and who filled her niece's head with the myths and legends of that area. Elly has two children and lives near Brighton. Though not her first novel, The Crossing Places is her first crime novel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,696 reviews
January 24, 2019
Elly Griffiths returns us to the North Norfolk coast with her character driven series featuring academic archaeologist and single mother Dr Ruth Galloway, once again serving as a consultant for the police team run by DI Harry Nelson. This is one of my favourite comfort series, one in which I delight in returning to the familiar characters and this time we come full circle in a mystery that connects to a case from the beginning of this series. Nelson is receiving anonymous letters that echo the past, that unsettle and disturb him, the sender of the original letters, Erik Anderrsen, is dead, so who is evoking past history? Erik's son, Leif, is leading a current henge saltmarsh dig that Ruth is a part of. This is a case that takes us back over thirty years ago when a young 12 year old Margaret Lacey disappeared from a street party celebrating the ill fated wedding of Prince Charles and Diana in 1981. Margaret's bones are recovered at the site of the dig, although it looks as if they have been moved here recently from its unknown original site. No-one was charged with the murder, although the prime suspect was a local young man deemed a weirdo, John Mostyn.
The past replays itself as Nelson and his team, that includes Judy and Cloughie, revisit the cold case and reinterview the major players, particularly the Lacey family, still deeply traumatised about their devastating loss, unable to achieve any form of closure and the now elderly John Mostyn. Nelson and his wife, Michelle, are awaiting the birth of their child, both harbouring fears as to whether Nelson is the father, and how it will be unavoidably clear if he is not, as the now dead Tim was a black police officer. Nelson wants to come clean about being the father of 7 year old Kate, Ruth's daughter, to his older daughters, Laura and Rebecca, aware of the potential problems that lie ahead. A lonely Michelle, having given birth, finds herself connecting with a young mother, Star and her baby, Ava, only to discover Star is part of the younger generation of the Lacey family. In a story that takes in the network of characters that have unexpected connections with Cathbad and Leif, the police find themselves having to deal with a present day murder and the horrors of a missing child.
There are ongoing developments with the characters, such as Ruth seeking the possibility of moving on from her personal situation and wondering if she needs a new start to consolidate her career. However, it ends with her still stuck in her complicated personal life with Nelson, her roots in the Norfolk coast and her close knit and long term ties to the local community. Leif proves to have his own agenda with regard to Cathbad and Ruth, and Superintendent Jo Archer has come to be more accepted with the police team. Fans of this series will adore this addition to this series, probably for the same reason as me, to once again immerse ourselves in characters we have come to love. Many thanks to Quercus for an ARC.
The past replays itself as Nelson and his team, that includes Judy and Cloughie, revisit the cold case and reinterview the major players, particularly the Lacey family, still deeply traumatised about their devastating loss, unable to achieve any form of closure and the now elderly John Mostyn. Nelson and his wife, Michelle, are awaiting the birth of their child, both harbouring fears as to whether Nelson is the father, and how it will be unavoidably clear if he is not, as the now dead Tim was a black police officer. Nelson wants to come clean about being the father of 7 year old Kate, Ruth's daughter, to his older daughters, Laura and Rebecca, aware of the potential problems that lie ahead. A lonely Michelle, having given birth, finds herself connecting with a young mother, Star and her baby, Ava, only to discover Star is part of the younger generation of the Lacey family. In a story that takes in the network of characters that have unexpected connections with Cathbad and Leif, the police find themselves having to deal with a present day murder and the horrors of a missing child.
There are ongoing developments with the characters, such as Ruth seeking the possibility of moving on from her personal situation and wondering if she needs a new start to consolidate her career. However, it ends with her still stuck in her complicated personal life with Nelson, her roots in the Norfolk coast and her close knit and long term ties to the local community. Leif proves to have his own agenda with regard to Cathbad and Ruth, and Superintendent Jo Archer has come to be more accepted with the police team. Fans of this series will adore this addition to this series, probably for the same reason as me, to once again immerse ourselves in characters we have come to love. Many thanks to Quercus for an ARC.
September 26, 2023
EXCERPT: 12 February 2016
DCI Nelson,
Well, here we are again. Truly our end is our beginning. That corpse you buried in your garden, has it begun to sprout? Will it bloom this year? You must have wondered whether I, too, was buried deep in the earth. Oh ye of little faith. You must have known that I would rise again.
You have grown older, Harry. There is grey in your hair and you have known sadness. Joy too, but that also can bring anguish. The dark nights of the soul. You could not save Scarlet but you could save the innocent who lies within the stone circle. Believe me, Harry, I want to help.
The year is turning. The shoots rise from the grass. Imbolc is here and we dance under the stars.
Go to the stone circle.
In peace.
ABOUT THIS BOOK: Dr Ruth Galloway returns to north Norfolk in her latest chilling adventure.
DCI Nelson has been receiving threatening letters. They are anonymous, yet somehow familiar. They read like the letters that first drew him into the case of The Crossing Places, and to Ruth. But the author of those letters is dead. Or are they?
The past is reaching out for Ruth and Nelson, and its grip is deadly.
MY THOUGHTS: I can honestly say that The Stone Circle is the best book of the Ruth Galloway series that I have read so far. And the others have been good. Very good, obviously, because otherwise I wouldn't still be reading this series.
There's something about Elly Griffiths writing that draws me in, makes me feel a part of the plot, not just a reader. I love and look forward to my annual visit with Ruth and Nelson and their families, Cathbad (it's impossible not to like Cathbad) and Judy, Shona, although we don't see so much of her this visit, and Clough. The only character I have never really warmed to is Nelson's wife, Michelle, and I really don't know why.
Griffiths introduces an interesting new character in this book, Leif Andersson, son of her old mentor Erik Andersson. I hope that we have not seen the last of him.
The storyline puts me a little in mind of Scrooge's three ghosts of Christmas. But instead of ghosts, we have skeletons. There is the skeleton of the past, a bronze age skeleton of a young girl; the skeleton of the present, well maybe not quite the present, but certainly a more contemporary skeleton, again that of a young girl; and the possibility of a skeleton of the future with the abduction of a baby girl.
Elly Griffiths has written a compelling read, one that had me frantically turning the pages into the early hours of the morning. I can't wait for the next installment in this brilliant series.
I have just read this for the second time, in September 2023 as part of my challenge to this year to read the series from beginning to end, and I have enjoyed it every bit as much, possibly even more (if possible) this time round.
I would like to share another excerpt, one that never fails to make me laugh: (Ruth) has managed to forget that it is Valetine's Day on Sunday (VD she calls it in her head). In her opinion the whole thing is an abomination: the explosion of bleeding hearts in the shops, the sentimental songs on the radio, the suggestion that, if you are not in possession of a single red rose by midnight, you will die alone and be eaten by your pet cat.
💖💖💖💖💖
THE AUTHOR: Elly Griffiths' Ruth Galloway novels take for their inspiration Elly's husband, who gave up a city job to train as an archaeologist, and her aunt who lives on the Norfolk coast and who filled her niece's head with the myths and legends of that area. Elly has two children and lives near Brighton. Though not her first novel, The Crossing Places was her first crime novel.
DISCLOSURE:Thank you to Quercus Books via Netgalley for providing a digital ARC of The Stone Circle by Elly Griffiths for review. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own personal opinions.
Please refer to my Goodreads.com profile page or the about page on sandysbookaday.wordpress.com for an explanation of my rating system. This review and others are also published on my webpage https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
DCI Nelson,
Well, here we are again. Truly our end is our beginning. That corpse you buried in your garden, has it begun to sprout? Will it bloom this year? You must have wondered whether I, too, was buried deep in the earth. Oh ye of little faith. You must have known that I would rise again.
You have grown older, Harry. There is grey in your hair and you have known sadness. Joy too, but that also can bring anguish. The dark nights of the soul. You could not save Scarlet but you could save the innocent who lies within the stone circle. Believe me, Harry, I want to help.
The year is turning. The shoots rise from the grass. Imbolc is here and we dance under the stars.
Go to the stone circle.
In peace.
ABOUT THIS BOOK: Dr Ruth Galloway returns to north Norfolk in her latest chilling adventure.
DCI Nelson has been receiving threatening letters. They are anonymous, yet somehow familiar. They read like the letters that first drew him into the case of The Crossing Places, and to Ruth. But the author of those letters is dead. Or are they?
The past is reaching out for Ruth and Nelson, and its grip is deadly.
MY THOUGHTS: I can honestly say that The Stone Circle is the best book of the Ruth Galloway series that I have read so far. And the others have been good. Very good, obviously, because otherwise I wouldn't still be reading this series.
There's something about Elly Griffiths writing that draws me in, makes me feel a part of the plot, not just a reader. I love and look forward to my annual visit with Ruth and Nelson and their families, Cathbad (it's impossible not to like Cathbad) and Judy, Shona, although we don't see so much of her this visit, and Clough. The only character I have never really warmed to is Nelson's wife, Michelle, and I really don't know why.
Griffiths introduces an interesting new character in this book, Leif Andersson, son of her old mentor Erik Andersson. I hope that we have not seen the last of him.
The storyline puts me a little in mind of Scrooge's three ghosts of Christmas. But instead of ghosts, we have skeletons. There is the skeleton of the past, a bronze age skeleton of a young girl; the skeleton of the present, well maybe not quite the present, but certainly a more contemporary skeleton, again that of a young girl; and the possibility of a skeleton of the future with the abduction of a baby girl.
Elly Griffiths has written a compelling read, one that had me frantically turning the pages into the early hours of the morning. I can't wait for the next installment in this brilliant series.
I have just read this for the second time, in September 2023 as part of my challenge to this year to read the series from beginning to end, and I have enjoyed it every bit as much, possibly even more (if possible) this time round.
I would like to share another excerpt, one that never fails to make me laugh: (Ruth) has managed to forget that it is Valetine's Day on Sunday (VD she calls it in her head). In her opinion the whole thing is an abomination: the explosion of bleeding hearts in the shops, the sentimental songs on the radio, the suggestion that, if you are not in possession of a single red rose by midnight, you will die alone and be eaten by your pet cat.
💖💖💖💖💖
THE AUTHOR: Elly Griffiths' Ruth Galloway novels take for their inspiration Elly's husband, who gave up a city job to train as an archaeologist, and her aunt who lives on the Norfolk coast and who filled her niece's head with the myths and legends of that area. Elly has two children and lives near Brighton. Though not her first novel, The Crossing Places was her first crime novel.
DISCLOSURE:Thank you to Quercus Books via Netgalley for providing a digital ARC of The Stone Circle by Elly Griffiths for review. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own personal opinions.
Please refer to my Goodreads.com profile page or the about page on sandysbookaday.wordpress.com for an explanation of my rating system. This review and others are also published on my webpage https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
May 5, 2019
This was my first book with Ruth Galloway, and a quite enjoyable read. Ruth gets engaged in another murder inquiry, this time it is a cold case of a murder of a teenager whose remains are uncovered on an archeological site. The plot kept me interested, however, I admit that not having read 10 Books I found it a little difficult to follow the main characters relationships as there is a lot of reference in the novel to their past. On the whole, I will read another offering by Ms Griffiths should there be such an opportunity.
*Many thanks to Elly Griffiths, Quercus Books and Netgalley for providing me with arc in exchange for my honest review.*
*Many thanks to Elly Griffiths, Quercus Books and Netgalley for providing me with arc in exchange for my honest review.*
July 12, 2022
This was an unusual experience for me. I don't create a cheat sheet for characters when I read, this was the first time. I started with a notepad then got my notebook out for more space 😀. There are soooo many secondary characters, some people are married more than once, and others have an extramarital relationship. All have children and a bunch of half-siblings .... then there are townspeople, I think. Just for giggles, I lost count after 41 characters. (Most aren't important to the story as far as I came to realize) I guess that's what I get for starting with book 11, but all is well.
I'm curious about the two main characters, the mystery was good. The foggy, rainy chilling atmosphere is enticing for another read from this series. 3.5 stars
I'm curious about the two main characters, the mystery was good. The foggy, rainy chilling atmosphere is enticing for another read from this series. 3.5 stars
April 29, 2019
We return to the world of Dr. Ruth Galloway. Dorset, the site of past Celtic civilizations, and a newly discovered stone circle. While excavating a discovery of bones, brings Ruth into the picture. An old skeleton of a girl, and a more recent one of another preteen girl. So once again, Judy, Nelson, and Ruth will share information and attempt to solve the mystery.
A new addition, an old love, a baby goes missing and the son of an old friend turned nemesis before his death. Her 11th in series, and I love them as much as I did when I first starting reading. Such a splendid mix of archeology, folklore, history and some great characters including a druid. Relationships are key here, in both the personal lives of these people, and also in the solving the mystery of the bones. I just love the atmosphere created in this series, also the fast pace, because something is always happening.
Although the case presented doesn't provide much room for humor, there is some.
Cathbad is the resident druid, "Nelson always finds it hard to imagine Cathbad sleeping. Somehow he pictures him hanging from the ceiling like a bat."
This series is good stuff, or so I think anyway
ARC from Edelweiss
A new addition, an old love, a baby goes missing and the son of an old friend turned nemesis before his death. Her 11th in series, and I love them as much as I did when I first starting reading. Such a splendid mix of archeology, folklore, history and some great characters including a druid. Relationships are key here, in both the personal lives of these people, and also in the solving the mystery of the bones. I just love the atmosphere created in this series, also the fast pace, because something is always happening.
Although the case presented doesn't provide much room for humor, there is some.
Cathbad is the resident druid, "Nelson always finds it hard to imagine Cathbad sleeping. Somehow he pictures him hanging from the ceiling like a bat."
This series is good stuff, or so I think anyway
ARC from Edelweiss
April 15, 2021
Interesting fact learned from the author's Acknowledgments page - this series was intended to be just ten books. I am very glad she changed her mind and I hope she goes to at least twenty!
I enjoy the Ruth Galloway series more with each book. It is probably because I like the characters so much and I feel invested in what happens to them. The mystery in The Stone Circle is very similar to previous books - bones are discovered and Ruth is called in to help the police with her forensic knowledge. It is fascinating and makes for good reading, but the real pull of the book is due to the ongoing domestic dramas of all our favourite people.
DO NOT read this if you are not up to #11 or further.
I enjoyed this book so much and the only thing stopping me from starting the next one straight away is that I am waiting for someone to return it to the library and he/she appears to be a slow reader.
I enjoy the Ruth Galloway series more with each book. It is probably because I like the characters so much and I feel invested in what happens to them. The mystery in The Stone Circle is very similar to previous books - bones are discovered and Ruth is called in to help the police with her forensic knowledge. It is fascinating and makes for good reading, but the real pull of the book is due to the ongoing domestic dramas of all our favourite people.
DO NOT read this if you are not up to #11 or further.
I enjoyed this book so much and the only thing stopping me from starting the next one straight away is that I am waiting for someone to return it to the library and he/she appears to be a slow reader.
May 12, 2019
Nothing like starting a series with #11. I’ve not read the first ten of the Ruth Galloway series, so it took me a while to get all the characters and their relationships straight. And trust me, some of these relationships seem very complicated with lots of siblings and half siblings to keep straight. But I will say that Ruth endeared herself to me within just a few pages. She’s a no nonsense kind of gal. A single mom, an archeologist and a police consultant.
Even the case here harkens back to a previous book. The bones of a young girl are found at a henge, called a stone circle. The girl went missing 30 years prior. There are similarities to the case in the first book in the series, including strange letters delivered to DCI Nelson and Ruth.
This is a well written book, with just a slight hint of humor. It moves quickly, and flips between characters every few pages. For a mystery, you also get little bits of history, mythology and folklore, which I appreciated. I found myself highlighting these little tidbits, like the history of Jack O’Lantern. I did have to google Stanton Drew, one of the larger stone hedges in England, so I knew what it looked like.
My favorite mystery series are those where I feel like I have a relationship with the characters. I’m thinking Joe Gunther, Jessica Daniels, Lucas Davenport, Armand Gamache. I can see this series fitting right in with that list. I will definitely be making time to go back and read the first ten books.
My thanks to netgalley and Quercus for an advance copy f this book.
Even the case here harkens back to a previous book. The bones of a young girl are found at a henge, called a stone circle. The girl went missing 30 years prior. There are similarities to the case in the first book in the series, including strange letters delivered to DCI Nelson and Ruth.
This is a well written book, with just a slight hint of humor. It moves quickly, and flips between characters every few pages. For a mystery, you also get little bits of history, mythology and folklore, which I appreciated. I found myself highlighting these little tidbits, like the history of Jack O’Lantern. I did have to google Stanton Drew, one of the larger stone hedges in England, so I knew what it looked like.
My favorite mystery series are those where I feel like I have a relationship with the characters. I’m thinking Joe Gunther, Jessica Daniels, Lucas Davenport, Armand Gamache. I can see this series fitting right in with that list. I will definitely be making time to go back and read the first ten books.
My thanks to netgalley and Quercus for an advance copy f this book.
March 27, 2019
Digging deep as always.
Echoes of the Bronze Age meet distinct notes of the ever present in The Stone Circle.
Dr. Ruth Galloway has been called out to the Saltmarsh near King's Lynn in Norfolk. An archaeological team has uncovered the remains of an ancient young girl within their dig. Ruth's heart always quickens with "the thrill of the dig". She's dedicated many years as a senior archaeological lecturer at the University of North Norfolk.
As the team sifts gently through the remains, they've made an additional discovery. Next to the Bronze Age girl are bones reflecting more of the modern age. From Ruth's calculations, the bones appear to be of a young girl around twelve years old. Without hesitation, DCI Harry Nelson is called in. The area is now marked off as a crime scene.
As a side note: Ruth and Harry have a history of their own. Although still unmarried, Ruth is the mother of Harry's daughter, Kate. Harry is married to Michelle who is ready to give birth any day. He's committed to his family, but there's a raging flame always burning for Ruth. They remain professional in their relationship knowing that it can never develop any further.
Back to our mystery......The bones test out as belonging to Margaret Lacey, a twelve year old girl who went missing back in 1981 at a city street fair. Her body was never found. It was always thought that a perculiar man by the name of John Mostyn was responsible. Mostyn lived with his aging mother who defended him until her death. Mostyn enjoyed showing the local children the rocks and shells that he found near the shore. With no evidence to prove otherwise, Mostyn was never charged. Was it a botched investigation or was it someone else?
Elly Griffiths reunites quite a few characters in this one. She does fill in gaps for the readers unfamiliar with this series. And as always, we are treated to folklore with stone artifacts that tell the tales along the Neolithic sites. Rocks with holes, often called witch's rocks, guard against evil. But evil still seems to take hold here after an additional body is found in a cottage nearby. Are there any connections to this one and the bones of that young girl from so long ago?
The Stone Circle delivers with its multi-faceted characters and its intriguing mystery. There are certain series that you look forward to and the Ruth Galloway Series is one of them. Elly Griffiths knows how to fast-spin a plot and to deepen the complications involved with her chosen characters. A very satisfying read for sure.
I received a copy of The Stone Circle through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishers and to Elly Griffiths for the opportunity.
Echoes of the Bronze Age meet distinct notes of the ever present in The Stone Circle.
Dr. Ruth Galloway has been called out to the Saltmarsh near King's Lynn in Norfolk. An archaeological team has uncovered the remains of an ancient young girl within their dig. Ruth's heart always quickens with "the thrill of the dig". She's dedicated many years as a senior archaeological lecturer at the University of North Norfolk.
As the team sifts gently through the remains, they've made an additional discovery. Next to the Bronze Age girl are bones reflecting more of the modern age. From Ruth's calculations, the bones appear to be of a young girl around twelve years old. Without hesitation, DCI Harry Nelson is called in. The area is now marked off as a crime scene.
As a side note: Ruth and Harry have a history of their own. Although still unmarried, Ruth is the mother of Harry's daughter, Kate. Harry is married to Michelle who is ready to give birth any day. He's committed to his family, but there's a raging flame always burning for Ruth. They remain professional in their relationship knowing that it can never develop any further.
Back to our mystery......The bones test out as belonging to Margaret Lacey, a twelve year old girl who went missing back in 1981 at a city street fair. Her body was never found. It was always thought that a perculiar man by the name of John Mostyn was responsible. Mostyn lived with his aging mother who defended him until her death. Mostyn enjoyed showing the local children the rocks and shells that he found near the shore. With no evidence to prove otherwise, Mostyn was never charged. Was it a botched investigation or was it someone else?
Elly Griffiths reunites quite a few characters in this one. She does fill in gaps for the readers unfamiliar with this series. And as always, we are treated to folklore with stone artifacts that tell the tales along the Neolithic sites. Rocks with holes, often called witch's rocks, guard against evil. But evil still seems to take hold here after an additional body is found in a cottage nearby. Are there any connections to this one and the bones of that young girl from so long ago?
The Stone Circle delivers with its multi-faceted characters and its intriguing mystery. There are certain series that you look forward to and the Ruth Galloway Series is one of them. Elly Griffiths knows how to fast-spin a plot and to deepen the complications involved with her chosen characters. A very satisfying read for sure.
I received a copy of The Stone Circle through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishers and to Elly Griffiths for the opportunity.
April 30, 2019
Ok faithful fans, cast your mind back….remember book #1? It all began with the search for a missing little girl named Lucy Downey. Now that case has come back to haunt those involved. If your memory is as dodgy as mine, no worries. Nelson & Ruth remember it well.
When a stone circle is found on the salt marshes it yields the usual grave goods plus something that triggers memories of an old case…the skeleton of a young girl. It’s like stepping back in time in more ways than one & with Michelle due any day, Nelson really doesn’t need reminders of when he met Ruth. The cryptic symbols & anonymous messages that ensue seem almost normal as Nelson’s crew begin to dig through old reports of missing children.
It’s a somber task so when Michelle & Nelson welcome a healthy baby to the family, it’s definitely good for morale. Unfortunately the celebrations are cut short when another little girl goes missing. Yup, just like old times.
All the old crew is back & they have their hands full. The historical & current investigations twist & intertwine in unexpected ways that make for a great story full of surprises & suspense. Several of the returning cast also deal with personal issues & some of the relationships are in for a shake-up. As for the new characters, you’ll be eying more than a few of them with suspicion every time they step on the page.
I really enjoyed the investigative aspects of the book, particularly the whole story surrounding the body found in the salt marsh. In some ways, this outing is all about the kids…the missing, the hidden & the newly born. For me, there was just one disappointing development. No spoilers here but I was really hoping one element of the overall story arc would remain firmly in the past. Just personal preference & no reflection on this author’s ability to spin a great tale.
Linking this book to the first in the series & tying up some plot lines gives the reader a feeling of coming full circle. By the end Ruth has a decision to make & I look forward to seeing how she fares in the next outing.
When a stone circle is found on the salt marshes it yields the usual grave goods plus something that triggers memories of an old case…the skeleton of a young girl. It’s like stepping back in time in more ways than one & with Michelle due any day, Nelson really doesn’t need reminders of when he met Ruth. The cryptic symbols & anonymous messages that ensue seem almost normal as Nelson’s crew begin to dig through old reports of missing children.
It’s a somber task so when Michelle & Nelson welcome a healthy baby to the family, it’s definitely good for morale. Unfortunately the celebrations are cut short when another little girl goes missing. Yup, just like old times.
All the old crew is back & they have their hands full. The historical & current investigations twist & intertwine in unexpected ways that make for a great story full of surprises & suspense. Several of the returning cast also deal with personal issues & some of the relationships are in for a shake-up. As for the new characters, you’ll be eying more than a few of them with suspicion every time they step on the page.
I really enjoyed the investigative aspects of the book, particularly the whole story surrounding the body found in the salt marsh. In some ways, this outing is all about the kids…the missing, the hidden & the newly born. For me, there was just one disappointing development. No spoilers here but I was really hoping one element of the overall story arc would remain firmly in the past. Just personal preference & no reflection on this author’s ability to spin a great tale.
Linking this book to the first in the series & tying up some plot lines gives the reader a feeling of coming full circle. By the end Ruth has a decision to make & I look forward to seeing how she fares in the next outing.
April 29, 2019
Oh no! I finished the book already! Now I will have to be veeeeery patient for the next one to come out.
May 19, 2019
I have to admit that I have only read the first book of this series, The Crossing Places, so I am very fortunate that this book circles back to the events of that novel. When forensic archaeologist Ruth Galloway first met DC Nelson eight years ago it was to examine some bones found in the salt marshes near an Iron Age henge. Ruth had been a member of the original archaeological team that excavated the henge. That excavation was headed by a Norwegian, Erik Anderrson and now his son Leif is back to excavate a recently discovered stone circle. When a child's bones are uncovered in the circle and identified as those of a girl who disappeared thirty years ago, Ruth finds herself once again involved a murder investigation as the Nelson and his team seek to identify where and how the girl was killed.
There are many ties to the past in this novel. Many of the characters are the same as in the initial case, although they have all moved on with their lives. Ruth now has a daughter and is thinking it could be time to move on with her career, Nelson and his wife Michelle are expecting a new baby despite their rocky marriage and Cathbad the Druid is now a responsible husband and father of two young children. Leif Andersson who looks eerily like his dead father Erik has unfinished business with Ruth and Cathbad on behalf of his father. There is a lot happening in this book. Apart from the cold case investigation and the stone circle excavation, there are anonymous letters (similar to those from the original case) a man is murdered and a baby goes missing.
As before, the book is well written and the plot driven by this cast of interesting characters. I really enjoy the mix of archaeology and mythology that Elly Griffiths provides as a background to her intriguing mysteries. Can't wait to go back and read the rest of the series.
With thanks to Netgalley and the publisher Houghton, Mifflin, Harcourt for a digital ARC to read.
There are many ties to the past in this novel. Many of the characters are the same as in the initial case, although they have all moved on with their lives. Ruth now has a daughter and is thinking it could be time to move on with her career, Nelson and his wife Michelle are expecting a new baby despite their rocky marriage and Cathbad the Druid is now a responsible husband and father of two young children. Leif Andersson who looks eerily like his dead father Erik has unfinished business with Ruth and Cathbad on behalf of his father. There is a lot happening in this book. Apart from the cold case investigation and the stone circle excavation, there are anonymous letters (similar to those from the original case) a man is murdered and a baby goes missing.
As before, the book is well written and the plot driven by this cast of interesting characters. I really enjoy the mix of archaeology and mythology that Elly Griffiths provides as a background to her intriguing mysteries. Can't wait to go back and read the rest of the series.
With thanks to Netgalley and the publisher Houghton, Mifflin, Harcourt for a digital ARC to read.
September 30, 2019
This 11th installment in the Ruth Galloway series was a great place for me to jump back into the series. I had listened to the first two on audio and really enjoyed them, I didn’t realize there were so many.
So this book takes us back to the team that was involved in the Crossing Places book. We visit the Norfolk salt marshes again where another henge has been found and the dig is being headed up by none other than Erik’s Anderssen’s son, Leif. When bones are found at the site Ruth Galloway the bone expert is once again called upon. There are bones found from the Bronze Age but then newer, more recent bones of a child, about 12 years old, are found and the dig is now officially a crime scene.
DCI Nelson has just started receiving letters again that have the same tone and context as the ones he received during the Crossing Places dig. They are foretelling and foreboding and the wording and references are similar. We know that Erik was behind the original letters but he is dead, so who is writing these new letters?
Nelson is awaiting the birth of his third child, Michelle is ready to have this pregnancy over with and see and hold her new little one, a “miracle baby” as Nelson will refer to him later. There are references to an affair that may have occurred and everyone seems to be nervous about how the child will look. What exactly are they all looking for??? Read and find out!
Eight years have gone by as Ruth and Harry’s daughter Kate is now 7 years old. Many close to the two know who the father is but it has never formally been announced. Harry wants to tell his daughters and others the truth so that he can have a closer relationship with Kate. This is a turbulent time for many on the team.
So many of the characters are back and I welcomed them like old friends. Cathbad, the ever changeable personality, from druid to intellectual on many levels. Detectives Judy and Cloughie are working the case and must revisit the past cold cases once again.
As always I enjoyed the atmospheric descriptions of the salt marsh “There are no lights, only the faint glimmer out to sea which might be late-night fishing boats, or phosphorescence or something altogether more sinister”.
There is so much to love in this series, great writing, incredibly interesting and well described characters, a mystery to solve and relationships to untangle. Anyone familiar with the series will love this new addition.
I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss.
So this book takes us back to the team that was involved in the Crossing Places book. We visit the Norfolk salt marshes again where another henge has been found and the dig is being headed up by none other than Erik’s Anderssen’s son, Leif. When bones are found at the site Ruth Galloway the bone expert is once again called upon. There are bones found from the Bronze Age but then newer, more recent bones of a child, about 12 years old, are found and the dig is now officially a crime scene.
DCI Nelson has just started receiving letters again that have the same tone and context as the ones he received during the Crossing Places dig. They are foretelling and foreboding and the wording and references are similar. We know that Erik was behind the original letters but he is dead, so who is writing these new letters?
Nelson is awaiting the birth of his third child, Michelle is ready to have this pregnancy over with and see and hold her new little one, a “miracle baby” as Nelson will refer to him later. There are references to an affair that may have occurred and everyone seems to be nervous about how the child will look. What exactly are they all looking for??? Read and find out!
Eight years have gone by as Ruth and Harry’s daughter Kate is now 7 years old. Many close to the two know who the father is but it has never formally been announced. Harry wants to tell his daughters and others the truth so that he can have a closer relationship with Kate. This is a turbulent time for many on the team.
So many of the characters are back and I welcomed them like old friends. Cathbad, the ever changeable personality, from druid to intellectual on many levels. Detectives Judy and Cloughie are working the case and must revisit the past cold cases once again.
As always I enjoyed the atmospheric descriptions of the salt marsh “There are no lights, only the faint glimmer out to sea which might be late-night fishing boats, or phosphorescence or something altogether more sinister”.
There is so much to love in this series, great writing, incredibly interesting and well described characters, a mystery to solve and relationships to untangle. Anyone familiar with the series will love this new addition.
I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss.
October 20, 2020
A perfect story; all the ingredients here to ensure another Ruth Galloway book is well received.
First the reveal. What skin tone is Michelle’s baby?
Secondly, Frank dropping in and doing Nelson’s head in. “I’ll deport him”. Love that Flint has not taken to Kate’s Dad.
Finally, everyone gets a chance to shine it isn’t just the Ruth and Nelson show.
Hard to imagine this is the 11th instalment of this originally conceived as a ‘10’ book series. Elly’s imagination is not waning as she draws in the past to present a thrilling mystery.
Another archaeological dig; Eric’s son involved. An unsolved incident, a missing child from many years ago; echoes of letters to the Police and re-opening of a cold case.
That the author can balance these characters and advance their stories against the background of child abduction shows her range of skills and sensitivity as a writer.
In this novel Michelle’s ache for Tim is sharp and love for her husband evident. As a new Mum time is given to that experience making friends and gaining confidence. Nelson adores all his children and grows tired of hiding the truth desiring to be open and honest. This is both well written and structured. He is both a lapsed Catholic and a bloke trying not to appear too emotionally open. His love for Ruth is often subtle; but at times shows open hostility to her suitors and his feelings are clear in a touching scene and conversation with Judy.
All this drama could get in the way or the crime investigation and become the story. But there is a razor-sharp plot, a wider police procedural. Development here also of the DS’s who respect and follow Nelson’s lead.
The book is not sentimental, but the hard parts of life are addressed and Nelson the policeman in touch with his parental side is a revelation.
Fans will debate if he’ll ever leave Michelle. Elly plays this aspect of the saga with extreme care and a wide grin as both scenarios drift in and out of focus.
What is certain book 12 is a done deal and that is the best reveal. This series has captured the imaginations of countless readers and won Elly deserved plaudits. Ruth is safe in her hands and while fans press her for spoilers only Book 12 will reveal. Her novels are treasured because we can identify with her characters and the crimes advanced are true to life and equally real.
First the reveal. What skin tone is Michelle’s baby?
Secondly, Frank dropping in and doing Nelson’s head in. “I’ll deport him”. Love that Flint has not taken to Kate’s Dad.
Finally, everyone gets a chance to shine it isn’t just the Ruth and Nelson show.
Hard to imagine this is the 11th instalment of this originally conceived as a ‘10’ book series. Elly’s imagination is not waning as she draws in the past to present a thrilling mystery.
Another archaeological dig; Eric’s son involved. An unsolved incident, a missing child from many years ago; echoes of letters to the Police and re-opening of a cold case.
That the author can balance these characters and advance their stories against the background of child abduction shows her range of skills and sensitivity as a writer.
In this novel Michelle’s ache for Tim is sharp and love for her husband evident. As a new Mum time is given to that experience making friends and gaining confidence. Nelson adores all his children and grows tired of hiding the truth desiring to be open and honest. This is both well written and structured. He is both a lapsed Catholic and a bloke trying not to appear too emotionally open. His love for Ruth is often subtle; but at times shows open hostility to her suitors and his feelings are clear in a touching scene and conversation with Judy.
All this drama could get in the way or the crime investigation and become the story. But there is a razor-sharp plot, a wider police procedural. Development here also of the DS’s who respect and follow Nelson’s lead.
The book is not sentimental, but the hard parts of life are addressed and Nelson the policeman in touch with his parental side is a revelation.
Fans will debate if he’ll ever leave Michelle. Elly plays this aspect of the saga with extreme care and a wide grin as both scenarios drift in and out of focus.
What is certain book 12 is a done deal and that is the best reveal. This series has captured the imaginations of countless readers and won Elly deserved plaudits. Ruth is safe in her hands and while fans press her for spoilers only Book 12 will reveal. Her novels are treasured because we can identify with her characters and the crimes advanced are true to life and equally real.
August 24, 2021
Read as a buddy read with Lisa Vegan, this was another hard to put down story with some great characters, old and new, an interesting mystery and as usual one that wasn't easy to solve or guess the culprit.
This story is about two missing girls and an archaeological dig where another stone circle has been found. One event happened long ago, the other more recent.
As always with this series the characters are great and it's good to come back into their lives with each book. Time has passed and the children are older. The setting is interesting to me as this is set where I live. The area is accurately observed and well described.
A downside with these books are the mistakes. A vegetarian character again is mentioned eating meat and fish, at the same time this book makes a big point about stating he's vegetarian, in fact even his meat eating partner doesn't eat meat in the house because of his beliefs but then they both go out and eat it together, no mention of why. Also a vegan character in this book eats eggs, cream and parmesan even though a few pages earlier it was mentioned that she had to have herbal tea as she couldn't have milk. Really annoying.
Also so many characters in this book eat a ridiculously unhealthy diet and unrealistically so for these characters. If you are feeling bored make a list of what these characters eat as you read the book, it will go along the lines of - macaroni cheese, wine, pizza, egg mcmuffin, wine, chocolate, chips, wine, crisps, Chinese takeaway, more wine, steak (with wine of course) McDonald's breakfast, crisps, coffee, biscuits, brownies, fish and chips......
I do enjoy this series immensely, I love the characters and look forward to the next book but I can't help thinking this author has a really problematic relationship with food and a bizarre need to make vegetarian characters eat meat!
This story is about two missing girls and an archaeological dig where another stone circle has been found. One event happened long ago, the other more recent.
As always with this series the characters are great and it's good to come back into their lives with each book. Time has passed and the children are older. The setting is interesting to me as this is set where I live. The area is accurately observed and well described.
A downside with these books are the mistakes. A vegetarian character again is mentioned eating meat and fish, at the same time this book makes a big point about stating he's vegetarian, in fact even his meat eating partner doesn't eat meat in the house because of his beliefs but then they both go out and eat it together, no mention of why. Also a vegan character in this book eats eggs, cream and parmesan even though a few pages earlier it was mentioned that she had to have herbal tea as she couldn't have milk. Really annoying.
Also so many characters in this book eat a ridiculously unhealthy diet and unrealistically so for these characters. If you are feeling bored make a list of what these characters eat as you read the book, it will go along the lines of - macaroni cheese, wine, pizza, egg mcmuffin, wine, chocolate, chips, wine, crisps, Chinese takeaway, more wine, steak (with wine of course) McDonald's breakfast, crisps, coffee, biscuits, brownies, fish and chips......
I do enjoy this series immensely, I love the characters and look forward to the next book but I can't help thinking this author has a really problematic relationship with food and a bizarre need to make vegetarian characters eat meat!
February 4, 2019
First I want to say that this is one of the best books in the series. I can be quite annoyed with both Ruth and Nelson. However, in this book both very behaving quite good. Although there are moments of when I thought; "
Come on Nelson, you can't have your cake and eat it
". Now, that I've gotten that off my chest can I return to the story of the book.
One of the reasons for me liking this series is the combination of crime and archaeology. I love that Ruth is an archaeologist that now and then get dragged into different types of crimes. Like in this book when the body of a young girl is found in a dig. And evidence point to that this is compared to the usual bodies found a fresh body. Or fresher, it's been in the ground for thirty years.
The Stone Circle is engrossing, both the case (that brings to mind the case in the first book) and everything that goes around in the characters personal lives was enjoyable to read about. I was even thrilled to wake up too early this morning so that I could finish the book before work. Also, This book actually made me think of going back and read the books from the beginning. It was so long ago that I read the first book that it would be fun to read it again.
I want to thank the publisher for providing me with a free copy through NetGalley for an honest review!
One of the reasons for me liking this series is the combination of crime and archaeology. I love that Ruth is an archaeologist that now and then get dragged into different types of crimes. Like in this book when the body of a young girl is found in a dig. And evidence point to that this is compared to the usual bodies found a fresh body. Or fresher, it's been in the ground for thirty years.
The Stone Circle is engrossing, both the case (that brings to mind the case in the first book) and everything that goes around in the characters personal lives was enjoyable to read about. I was even thrilled to wake up too early this morning so that I could finish the book before work. Also, This book actually made me think of going back and read the books from the beginning. It was so long ago that I read the first book that it would be fun to read it again.
I want to thank the publisher for providing me with a free copy through NetGalley for an honest review!
May 5, 2019
Elly Griffith’s latest addition to the Ruth Galloway series deals with an old murder of a 12-year-old girl who disappeared 30 years ago. The mystery itself is pretty entertaining, but it is dragged out more than I would have preferred. The relationship aspects of this story line across the 11 books have been extended far beyond what a reader should have to endure. I personally am ready for there to be more resolution. Hopefully that will occur in the next installment or I may have to give up.
April 10, 2022
DCI Harry Nelson is uneasy when anonymous letters arrive. The letters bear a strong resemblance to those that first drew him to Saltmarsh and his first case with archaeologist Dr Ruth Galloway. But the author of those letters is dead. Isn’t he? Then Nelson gets a call from Ruth. While she is on a dig on the site of a stone circle known as a henge, Ruth finds the bones of a young girl. The body ends up being identified as Margaret Lacey, a 12 year old who went missing 30 years earlier. That cold case is reopened by Norfolk Police. Did someone know where to find Margaret? Can they expose Margaret’s killer? This ends up not being the only crime they need to try and solve.
I have not read all this series but have read a few of them, so knew enough about the main characters of Nelson and Galloway and their complicated relationship, to fill in the blanks. I liked the way the tangled relationships were explored, the evocative setting and the way suspicion fell on a couple of characters at times. Well researched with lots of info about Christian and Druid religions, it is certainly engaging. Also appreciated that readers are not subjected to bad language and use of the first word. A very enjoyable read definitely recommended. Reads fine as a stand alone but no doubt even better if you have read some others in the series.
I have not read all this series but have read a few of them, so knew enough about the main characters of Nelson and Galloway and their complicated relationship, to fill in the blanks. I liked the way the tangled relationships were explored, the evocative setting and the way suspicion fell on a couple of characters at times. Well researched with lots of info about Christian and Druid religions, it is certainly engaging. Also appreciated that readers are not subjected to bad language and use of the first word. A very enjoyable read definitely recommended. Reads fine as a stand alone but no doubt even better if you have read some others in the series.
February 4, 2019
The 11th Ruth Galloway book may be the most perfect book in the series. Author Elly Griffiths has stolen my heart all over again with this tale. Set in Ruth’s home turf, or home marsh, this story takes us back full circle to where it all began in Crossing Places. With the Saltmarsh and Erik Anderssen and missing children and dead children and Ruth and Nelson working a case together and Cathbad the Druid involved. The very roots of this series guide this story, with ghosts of the past looming large. Truths are faced with the pain of a decade dancing around them. But, although truths are acknowledged, there is so much more story and honesty yet to deal with and look forward to. While some things are resolved, others have been opened to resolution. Elly Griffiths has given her fans a reward of immense proportions in this book. And, how lucky are those who are just beginning this series, to know that a book bringing things full circle is to be found in book eleven. Again, it’s not an ending, but a new beginning built on all the stories of the past. Only Elly Griffiths could weave a tapestry of Ruth’s story so magnificently. Trust this creator of Ruth to know where the paths must wind. If you’re trying to read between the lines in what I’ve said here, don’t. There is so much to discover in this book, and I won’t say anything to spoil the journey for others.
As often happens in the Ruth Galloway stories, the ancient, the old, and the new all come together. A new dig is in progress at the Saltmarsh near Ruth’s house, and, being the resident forensic archeology expert, Ruth is called in to examine the ancient bones of a young girl found at the Bronze Age site. It would be a routine job, except for the person heading the dig is Leif Anderssen, Erik Anderssen’s son. With the tragic circumstances surrounding Erik, who had been Ruth’s teacher and mentor, and the salt marsh, it’s an emotional meeting for Ruth when she discovers Leif is in charge. Then, DCI Harry Nelson starts receiving letters like the ones Erik had sent him in Ruth’s and Nelson’s first heartbreaking case, and it seems the ghost of Eric is very much present. When bones of another young girl, ones from a more recent past, are discovered by Ruth at the dig, déjà vu places her and Nelson directly in its crosshairs. They find themselves back where they came into one another’s lives, working on a case involving a child and confronting their eerie history with the Saltmarsh, as well as their personal history.
The recent burial of bones at the dig site are connected to a thirty-five-year-old cold case, where a young girl went missing during a town-wide celebration of Prince Charles and Lady Diana Spenser’s wedding in July of 1981. Now, in 2016, the identification of the bones as the missing girl reveals her fate and launches the police into a murder investigation. Suspects were few concerning Margaret Lacey’s disappearance, and alibis were tight. With Ruth’s help in ascertaining what the girl’s bones have to say, DCI Nelson and his Serious Crimes Unit of Judy, Clough, and Tanya are determined to find justice for Margaret and closure for her family. There will be many theories and many twists before anyone finds peace from this nightmare.
To the delight of all readers of this series, Cathbad is quite visible in the book. His past connection to Erik is of interest to Leif, Erik’s son, and Leif has his own hidden agenda with Cathbad and Ruth. The ghost of Erik is indeed strong and far-reaching. And, no, I haven’t forgotten the new character we've all been on pins and needles to meet, Michelle's baby. Well, I can tell you now that the baby is born. That’s all you get. I wouldn’t dream of being the bearer of news about the baby’s paternity or other details.
I read lots of great stories/books, and each is unique is what touches me. Sometimes it’s the characters or the setting or the thrilling story line or a special meaning to something in my life or experience. The Stone Circle is such a complete source of satisfaction for me; it checks all the boxes. I have seldom been invested in a character like I am Ruth Galloway. She is the character in my reading that I’d most like to meet and be friends with. Her strength and resiliency make everyone’s world around her a better place, without them or her ever realizing it. Her daughter Kate, DCI Nelson, Cathbad, Judy, and Cloughie are also favorite characters who can delight, frustrate, and inspire me, too. Elly Griffiths is genius at creating such memorable characters with whom the reader becomes staunchly invested. These characters are family to fans, and we simply care deeply for them. The setting of Norfolk is as down to Earth as it gets, but the Saltmarsh is magical beyond understanding. And, like the Saltmarsh is to Ruth, this series is to me.
I received an advanced reader’s copy of The Stone Circle, and my honest review is but a humble attempt at discussing how much I enjoyed it. This book makes me want to read the whole series again. Pre-order so you don’t have to wait a minute longer than necessary to read it. Out February 5th in the UK and May 7th in the U.S.
As often happens in the Ruth Galloway stories, the ancient, the old, and the new all come together. A new dig is in progress at the Saltmarsh near Ruth’s house, and, being the resident forensic archeology expert, Ruth is called in to examine the ancient bones of a young girl found at the Bronze Age site. It would be a routine job, except for the person heading the dig is Leif Anderssen, Erik Anderssen’s son. With the tragic circumstances surrounding Erik, who had been Ruth’s teacher and mentor, and the salt marsh, it’s an emotional meeting for Ruth when she discovers Leif is in charge. Then, DCI Harry Nelson starts receiving letters like the ones Erik had sent him in Ruth’s and Nelson’s first heartbreaking case, and it seems the ghost of Eric is very much present. When bones of another young girl, ones from a more recent past, are discovered by Ruth at the dig, déjà vu places her and Nelson directly in its crosshairs. They find themselves back where they came into one another’s lives, working on a case involving a child and confronting their eerie history with the Saltmarsh, as well as their personal history.
The recent burial of bones at the dig site are connected to a thirty-five-year-old cold case, where a young girl went missing during a town-wide celebration of Prince Charles and Lady Diana Spenser’s wedding in July of 1981. Now, in 2016, the identification of the bones as the missing girl reveals her fate and launches the police into a murder investigation. Suspects were few concerning Margaret Lacey’s disappearance, and alibis were tight. With Ruth’s help in ascertaining what the girl’s bones have to say, DCI Nelson and his Serious Crimes Unit of Judy, Clough, and Tanya are determined to find justice for Margaret and closure for her family. There will be many theories and many twists before anyone finds peace from this nightmare.
To the delight of all readers of this series, Cathbad is quite visible in the book. His past connection to Erik is of interest to Leif, Erik’s son, and Leif has his own hidden agenda with Cathbad and Ruth. The ghost of Erik is indeed strong and far-reaching. And, no, I haven’t forgotten the new character we've all been on pins and needles to meet, Michelle's baby. Well, I can tell you now that the baby is born. That’s all you get. I wouldn’t dream of being the bearer of news about the baby’s paternity or other details.
I read lots of great stories/books, and each is unique is what touches me. Sometimes it’s the characters or the setting or the thrilling story line or a special meaning to something in my life or experience. The Stone Circle is such a complete source of satisfaction for me; it checks all the boxes. I have seldom been invested in a character like I am Ruth Galloway. She is the character in my reading that I’d most like to meet and be friends with. Her strength and resiliency make everyone’s world around her a better place, without them or her ever realizing it. Her daughter Kate, DCI Nelson, Cathbad, Judy, and Cloughie are also favorite characters who can delight, frustrate, and inspire me, too. Elly Griffiths is genius at creating such memorable characters with whom the reader becomes staunchly invested. These characters are family to fans, and we simply care deeply for them. The setting of Norfolk is as down to Earth as it gets, but the Saltmarsh is magical beyond understanding. And, like the Saltmarsh is to Ruth, this series is to me.
I received an advanced reader’s copy of The Stone Circle, and my honest review is but a humble attempt at discussing how much I enjoyed it. This book makes me want to read the whole series again. Pre-order so you don’t have to wait a minute longer than necessary to read it. Out February 5th in the UK and May 7th in the U.S.
January 21, 2019
Elly Griffiths can do no wrong in my eyes. I love everything she writes and The Stone Circle is no exception. As usual, the murder mystery plays second fiddle to the characters and I wouldn't have it any other way. It's an absolute pleasure to spend time with these people (and their pets). Things do move along here and I was glued to it. Review to follow shortly on For Winter Nights.
March 29, 2020
Here's the thing: when an author has a successful series their editors seem to give them a lot more leeway, because they know the books will sell even if they're not their best efforts. Diana Gabaldon is a textbook example--between the longtime fans and the new ones via the TV series, it doesn't matter if Claire and Jamie are doing things that they've already done 4 books before. If it has her name on it, it sells.
This is especially notable here, where Griffiths notes in the afterword that she had a discussion with her editor promising 10 "Ruth Galloway" books, and here we are at number 11. And maybe she should have stopped at 10.
Though the book closes a cold case that hearkens back to the original first book, there is little else that's new here. Characters come on and perform their stock routines. There is a secondary plot line, also going back to characters in the first book that looks like it has potential, but ends flat on its face. Ruth seems about to take on new challenges and new relationships, but in the end is back where she started from.
And for cripes sake, can't she get over Kate's dad calling her "Katie?" Grow up!
This is all the more disappointing because Griffith's recent, stand alone (I think) The Stranger Diaries was a terrific piece of work and her "Stephens and Mephisto" series continues to be very entertaining.
Griffiths also writes that she is far from done with the legends/archaeology of the Saltmarsh. Perhaps she has a lot more material. But if she can't make this series feel less same old, same old, perhaps she needs to let it rest for a while, and write her other books.
This is especially notable here, where Griffiths notes in the afterword that she had a discussion with her editor promising 10 "Ruth Galloway" books, and here we are at number 11. And maybe she should have stopped at 10.
Though the book closes a cold case that hearkens back to the original first book, there is little else that's new here. Characters come on and perform their stock routines. There is a secondary plot line, also going back to characters in the first book that looks like it has potential, but ends flat on its face. Ruth seems about to take on new challenges and new relationships, but in the end is back where she started from.
And for cripes sake, can't she get over Kate's dad calling her "Katie?" Grow up!
This is all the more disappointing because Griffith's recent, stand alone (I think) The Stranger Diaries was a terrific piece of work and her "Stephens and Mephisto" series continues to be very entertaining.
Griffiths also writes that she is far from done with the legends/archaeology of the Saltmarsh. Perhaps she has a lot more material. But if she can't make this series feel less same old, same old, perhaps she needs to let it rest for a while, and write her other books.
September 5, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Once again Ruth Galloway is engrossed in another murder inquiry with as always captivating characters.
Once again Ruth Galloway is engrossed in another murder inquiry with as always captivating characters.
January 11, 2020
4-1/2 stars
I’m now caught up with all the books out so far! It took only around 5 months to read the 11 books, and that’s while reading many other additional books. I flew through this one too because as usual it was hard to put down. These are truly addictive books. The twelfth book is out in the U.K. in February and in the U.S. in June, but that probably means I won’t get a library copy until July.
I read this as a buddy read with Hilary. I always love reading with her, all sorts of books. For a long time we were reading mostly historical fiction children’s books. We’ve read most of this series together. It’s particularly fun reading with her because they take place in her area and she’s familiar with the settings. I’m always looking up thigns as I read and after I read because I find the area so interesting.
We have this knack for often ending our sections at cliffhangers! Maybe a lot of chapters end like that and we only notice when we have to stop?
At first I wasn’t thrilled that the storyline was directly related to the one in book one. I had some worry that maybe the author was running out of story ideas. It turned out to be an exceptionally good mystery though and I had fun guessing throughout. There were lots of good and plausible red herrings. I love the complexity of the multiple mysteries. I found myself almost tearing up with emotion toward the end of this one, for a few reasons, though there is still humor throughout and I enjoy that.
It is an excellent mystery with several mysteries. It’s well constructed and believable and fun to guess throughout. I love the characters and the relationships and how they grow and change. I love the humor, I love how emotionally invested I am in people & events, I love the settings and the historical context. I enjoy “being in” Norfolk England and other parts of England. This author is an excellent storyteller and I become easily immersed in the storylines. Brilliant mystery story construction too! All the red herrings make perfect sense and I never feel irked at how things play out the way I sometimes do with other mystery series.
I love how Ruth is now reading some great books to Kate and love Kate and I’m enjoying her maturing. Now age 7.
As with the previous books, the author explains how one of the character’s names is the name of the winner of a charity auction, the proceeds going to benefit teenagers with cancer. I love this tradition, and the characters are always an asset to the story. Even though they’re minor characters and specific to only one book, they’re a true asset to the story. This was true here too.
In the same acknowledgements section in the back the author says there were supposed to be only 10 books. This is the 11th and a 12th book is supposed to be out soon, but now I’m wondering if there will be more/how many more there will be. I hope many if the quality keeps up.
Some additional notes including more gripes about (NOT) vegan/vegetarian characters that aren’t, and some real spoilers:
I’m now caught up with all the books out so far! It took only around 5 months to read the 11 books, and that’s while reading many other additional books. I flew through this one too because as usual it was hard to put down. These are truly addictive books. The twelfth book is out in the U.K. in February and in the U.S. in June, but that probably means I won’t get a library copy until July.
I read this as a buddy read with Hilary. I always love reading with her, all sorts of books. For a long time we were reading mostly historical fiction children’s books. We’ve read most of this series together. It’s particularly fun reading with her because they take place in her area and she’s familiar with the settings. I’m always looking up thigns as I read and after I read because I find the area so interesting.
We have this knack for often ending our sections at cliffhangers! Maybe a lot of chapters end like that and we only notice when we have to stop?
At first I wasn’t thrilled that the storyline was directly related to the one in book one. I had some worry that maybe the author was running out of story ideas. It turned out to be an exceptionally good mystery though and I had fun guessing throughout. There were lots of good and plausible red herrings. I love the complexity of the multiple mysteries. I found myself almost tearing up with emotion toward the end of this one, for a few reasons, though there is still humor throughout and I enjoy that.
It is an excellent mystery with several mysteries. It’s well constructed and believable and fun to guess throughout. I love the characters and the relationships and how they grow and change. I love the humor, I love how emotionally invested I am in people & events, I love the settings and the historical context. I enjoy “being in” Norfolk England and other parts of England. This author is an excellent storyteller and I become easily immersed in the storylines. Brilliant mystery story construction too! All the red herrings make perfect sense and I never feel irked at how things play out the way I sometimes do with other mystery series.
I love how Ruth is now reading some great books to Kate and love Kate and I’m enjoying her maturing. Now age 7.
As with the previous books, the author explains how one of the character’s names is the name of the winner of a charity auction, the proceeds going to benefit teenagers with cancer. I love this tradition, and the characters are always an asset to the story. Even though they’re minor characters and specific to only one book, they’re a true asset to the story. This was true here too.
In the same acknowledgements section in the back the author says there were supposed to be only 10 books. This is the 11th and a 12th book is supposed to be out soon, but now I’m wondering if there will be more/how many more there will be. I hope many if the quality keeps up.
Some additional notes including more gripes about (NOT) vegan/vegetarian characters that aren’t, and some real spoilers:
May 28, 2019
THE STONE CIRCLE by Elly Griffiths is one of the most atmospheric novels I’ve read in a while. In this, the eleventh in the series featuring archeologist Ruth Galloway and DCI Nelson, sometimes lovers who have gone their separate ways. This novel brings back memories and some characters or their relatives from earlier novels in the series. DCI Nelson has received anonymous letters in the past and is receiving similar letters now. When he follows the letters to a local archeological site he encounters two bodies, one modern, one ancient along with a son of former archeologist he and Ruth encountered in an earlier book.
As DCI Nelson and Ruth go about trying to identify the bones of the modern victim (Nelson) and the ancient ones (Ruth), the are constantly reminded of earlier cases and times when they were thrown together. Ruth and Nelson have a child together although he is married to Michelle who is in the last few weeks of her pregnancy as the novel begins. This pregnancy also goes back to an earlier case with the identity of the father being a question that will be settled once the baby is born.
The mystery of who killed the modern day victim as well as who buried her in the henge are the chief questions law enforcement are trying to answer. While Ruth and Nelson are wrapped up in those questions they are also being pulled into the past as they deal with Lief, the son and physical copy of Erik, a prominent character from an earlier novel. Are previous difficulties being reincarnated? Is he as innocent and well-meaning as he appears to be?
In addition to solving the murders, Nelson is called in on the kidnapping of a child who has ties to modern day victim. As he rushes to solve this case along with the child’s murder Ruth is drawn back into the past by Lief. To what end? Are his intentions for the good or not? The questions continue to mount as Ruth and Nelson are constantly banging up against each other then bouncing off to their separate lives.
All these questions, along with possibly as many as a dozen more await the reader as they make their way through the book. While the mystery for this book is self-contained, with so much of the information being tied to previous cases, the reader’s enjoyment might be enhanced by reading the earlier books first. My thanks to NetGalley and Houghton Mifflin Harcourt for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
As DCI Nelson and Ruth go about trying to identify the bones of the modern victim (Nelson) and the ancient ones (Ruth), the are constantly reminded of earlier cases and times when they were thrown together. Ruth and Nelson have a child together although he is married to Michelle who is in the last few weeks of her pregnancy as the novel begins. This pregnancy also goes back to an earlier case with the identity of the father being a question that will be settled once the baby is born.
The mystery of who killed the modern day victim as well as who buried her in the henge are the chief questions law enforcement are trying to answer. While Ruth and Nelson are wrapped up in those questions they are also being pulled into the past as they deal with Lief, the son and physical copy of Erik, a prominent character from an earlier novel. Are previous difficulties being reincarnated? Is he as innocent and well-meaning as he appears to be?
In addition to solving the murders, Nelson is called in on the kidnapping of a child who has ties to modern day victim. As he rushes to solve this case along with the child’s murder Ruth is drawn back into the past by Lief. To what end? Are his intentions for the good or not? The questions continue to mount as Ruth and Nelson are constantly banging up against each other then bouncing off to their separate lives.
All these questions, along with possibly as many as a dozen more await the reader as they make their way through the book. While the mystery for this book is self-contained, with so much of the information being tied to previous cases, the reader’s enjoyment might be enhanced by reading the earlier books first. My thanks to NetGalley and Houghton Mifflin Harcourt for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
January 19, 2019
I *love* Ruth Galloway but have to admit this book feels like a re-run of the first couple: *yet another* girl's body is found out on the seahenge (how many is than now?) and yet again Ruth advises the police team. A cold case is re-opened of a girl who went missing in 1981, we have more weird letters, Erik's son appears to act in a suitably sinister fashion, and everyone (it seems) has a new baby. There's even the obligatory 'face the killer alone and with no back-up' scene, followed by the killer's confession...
What makes the whole thing so enjoyable isn't the reworked plot but the characters who are a joy. Their relationships are so intertwined and complicated now that while this can be read as a stand-alone, so much of the resonance would be missing. Griffith's sly humour and fluent prose add to the pleasure.
Circles seem important: literal and material stone circles but also the circling back into the past, and relationships going round in circles... we think, briefly, that Ruth might break out, but no, there are too many things holding her where she is. This is a 'more of the same' book: if you've not gelled with this series before, this one won't change your mind. For me, I loved being back in the company of Ruth, Nelson, Cloughie and the others.
Thanks to Quercus for an ARC via NetGalley.
What makes the whole thing so enjoyable isn't the reworked plot but the characters who are a joy. Their relationships are so intertwined and complicated now that while this can be read as a stand-alone, so much of the resonance would be missing. Griffith's sly humour and fluent prose add to the pleasure.
Circles seem important: literal and material stone circles but also the circling back into the past, and relationships going round in circles... we think, briefly, that Ruth might break out, but no, there are too many things holding her where she is. This is a 'more of the same' book: if you've not gelled with this series before, this one won't change your mind. For me, I loved being back in the company of Ruth, Nelson, Cloughie and the others.
Thanks to Quercus for an ARC via NetGalley.
May 8, 2019
Another great episode in Elly Griffiths’ Ruth Galloway series.
Another henge, another stone circle has been unearthed on the Saltmarsh near Ruth Galloway’s cottage. With this discovery, thoughts of the an earlier discovery, memorialized in Crossing Places the novel that introduced Ruth, D.C.I. Harry Nelson and the area of King’s Lynn, are made fresh for many people in the area.
Ruth is, once again, called on for her forensic archaeology skills to assess the very old burial at the center of this now active dig. But shocking herself and everyone present, she discovers a second, new burial which turns this ancient site into a modern crime scene.
Once again, the characters I expect have returned and there is a good amount of emotional carryover after all that happened in the last episode. There are new tensions between Ruth and Nelson due to his wife’s pregnancy. Cathbad is now a house husband. But the plot, characters and the telling work wonderfully.
This continues to be one of my favorite mystery series with an interesting and changeable setting, characters who are allowed growth and change (and human inconsistencies), and consistently good writing. The subjects centered on aspects of archaeology interest me. And there are also other minor and/or major topics spread through the story. This time there is an added subtext of fairy and folk tales that adds another dimension.
There is enough background provided to read this as a stand-alone novel but I strongly recommend you read the series to follow the lives and changes of these people.
A copy of this book was provided by the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest review.
Another henge, another stone circle has been unearthed on the Saltmarsh near Ruth Galloway’s cottage. With this discovery, thoughts of the an earlier discovery, memorialized in Crossing Places the novel that introduced Ruth, D.C.I. Harry Nelson and the area of King’s Lynn, are made fresh for many people in the area.
Ruth is, once again, called on for her forensic archaeology skills to assess the very old burial at the center of this now active dig. But shocking herself and everyone present, she discovers a second, new burial which turns this ancient site into a modern crime scene.
Once again, the characters I expect have returned and there is a good amount of emotional carryover after all that happened in the last episode. There are new tensions between Ruth and Nelson due to his wife’s pregnancy. Cathbad is now a house husband. But the plot, characters and the telling work wonderfully.
This continues to be one of my favorite mystery series with an interesting and changeable setting, characters who are allowed growth and change (and human inconsistencies), and consistently good writing. The subjects centered on aspects of archaeology interest me. And there are also other minor and/or major topics spread through the story. This time there is an added subtext of fairy and folk tales that adds another dimension.
There is enough background provided to read this as a stand-alone novel but I strongly recommend you read the series to follow the lives and changes of these people.
A copy of this book was provided by the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest review.
October 4, 2019
It took me ages to finish this book, even though I generally love the series and had really been looking forward to it! The issues for me wasn't the mystery itself, though i did think it was one of the weaker ones, but rather the personal development, or lack therof. The characters are really what draws me to this series and I feel there has been real stagnation in their development in the last two books. There was a chance to do something really interesting here, but the author chose to keep up the status quo, and I was left a little disappointed. I still really like the characters, but I don't want the next few books to be the same again in terms of their personal relationships and concerns. I will stay loyal to the series, but really hope the next book will brink a little more development. This sounds too negative a review for what is really a fairly good book, I was just hoping for something a little more exciting.
Find more reviews and bookish fun at http://www.princessandpen.com
Find more reviews and bookish fun at http://www.princessandpen.com
March 11, 2021
This is the 11th book in the series featuring the forensic archaeologist Ruth Galloway by author Elly Griiffiths.
DCI Nelson is receiving anonymous letters from someone telling him to ‘go to the stone circle and rescue the innocent who is buried there’. With his wife shortly due to have a baby, children are very much on his mind and something about the letters feels familiar. The letters remind him of the ones that first drew him into the case of The Crossing Places, but the author of those letters is dead. Ruth is working on a dig in the Saltmarsh known by the archaeologists as the stone circle when she discovers bones that are identified as those of Margaret Lacey, a twelve-year-old girl who disappeared thirty years ago.
As the Margaret Lacey case progresses, more and more aspects of it begin to hark back to that first case of The Crossing Places, and to Scarlett Henderson, the girl Nelson couldn’t save. The past is reaching out for Ruth and Nelson, and its grip is deadly.
Another cosy thriller with a host of great characters making it an entertaining read.
DCI Nelson is receiving anonymous letters from someone telling him to ‘go to the stone circle and rescue the innocent who is buried there’. With his wife shortly due to have a baby, children are very much on his mind and something about the letters feels familiar. The letters remind him of the ones that first drew him into the case of The Crossing Places, but the author of those letters is dead. Ruth is working on a dig in the Saltmarsh known by the archaeologists as the stone circle when she discovers bones that are identified as those of Margaret Lacey, a twelve-year-old girl who disappeared thirty years ago.
As the Margaret Lacey case progresses, more and more aspects of it begin to hark back to that first case of The Crossing Places, and to Scarlett Henderson, the girl Nelson couldn’t save. The past is reaching out for Ruth and Nelson, and its grip is deadly.
Another cosy thriller with a host of great characters making it an entertaining read.
June 27, 2019
I really enjoy this series! I do need some closure in the love triangle though, for reals, yo.
March 15, 2020
A solid mystery with an interesting cast of characters along with Ruth, Cathbad, Judy, Nelson and all the rest.
Several minor plot threads serve to both strengthen the story and provide some much needed red herrings.
As always, the past comes back to haunt the present. In this installment, that story line works better here.
My only disappointment is (as usual), the mysteries are solved but Ruth’s ongoing ambivalence over her personal love life continues... or does it?
Until next time— Thanks Ms Griffiths for another great read!!
Several minor plot threads serve to both strengthen the story and provide some much needed red herrings.
As always, the past comes back to haunt the present. In this installment, that story line works better here.
My only disappointment is (as usual), the mysteries are solved but Ruth’s ongoing ambivalence over her personal love life continues... or does it?
Until next time— Thanks Ms Griffiths for another great read!!
December 31, 2020
Today I’m rebelling! I don’t HAVE to write this review so I don’t quite know how it will turn out!
The case in this book harks back to the very first case that Nelson and Ruth worked together on (in The Crossing Places). Nelson receives a letter telling him to “go to the stone circle and rescue the innocent that is buried there”. The feel of the letter evokes the earlier case. A dig is already underway there overseen by Lief Anderssen, the son of Erik Anderssen, Ruth’s former mentor, who died in the first book. But when it seems there is another body also buried in the Iron Age cist in the stone circle Ruth is called in again.
The modern body turns out to be that of Margaret Lacey who disappeared during a street party in 1981. The case is re-opened and witnesses re-questioned, including previous suspect John Mostyn. He now just seems like a kindly old man. But the kindly old man is shot to death which raises some serious questions.
Michelle has had her baby and it is clear that it is Harry’s child, not Tim’s so that is like a stake through Ruth’s heart but she wishes them well. Michelle makes friends with a young mum called Star, who turns out to be related to Margaret Lacey. Then a baby is abducted and all hell breaks loose.
So that’s my crap review. I did enjoy the book though and I have one more to read before I get to read the ARC of book 13. Ruth and Nelson’s non-relationship is still on and off and I guess that’s maybe how it will always be but I live in hope (for what I’m not too sure). I am sure, however, that I love this series and will stick with it until the bitter end.
The case in this book harks back to the very first case that Nelson and Ruth worked together on (in The Crossing Places). Nelson receives a letter telling him to “go to the stone circle and rescue the innocent that is buried there”. The feel of the letter evokes the earlier case. A dig is already underway there overseen by Lief Anderssen, the son of Erik Anderssen, Ruth’s former mentor, who died in the first book. But when it seems there is another body also buried in the Iron Age cist in the stone circle Ruth is called in again.
The modern body turns out to be that of Margaret Lacey who disappeared during a street party in 1981. The case is re-opened and witnesses re-questioned, including previous suspect John Mostyn. He now just seems like a kindly old man. But the kindly old man is shot to death which raises some serious questions.
Michelle has had her baby and it is clear that it is Harry’s child, not Tim’s so that is like a stake through Ruth’s heart but she wishes them well. Michelle makes friends with a young mum called Star, who turns out to be related to Margaret Lacey. Then a baby is abducted and all hell breaks loose.
So that’s my crap review. I did enjoy the book though and I have one more to read before I get to read the ARC of book 13. Ruth and Nelson’s non-relationship is still on and off and I guess that’s maybe how it will always be but I live in hope (for what I’m not too sure). I am sure, however, that I love this series and will stick with it until the bitter end.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,696 reviews