I have been following the "Cosmic Marvel" for a long time. Long before Dan Abnett and Andy Lanning started their excellent run of series and mini series re-establishing it. I have a lot of respect for what they did for Marvel with Nova, Guardians of the Galaxy and everything else that has occurred in the last few years. Sadly with Annihilators, the story takes a great departure from everything that came before it. I'm not speaking in regards to the change in the characters that it featured...Silver Surfer, Beta Ray Bill, Ronan, Quasar, Gladiator all on one team is fantastic and the tales that could have come from such a pair, unimaginable...especially since they took the route that the creative team decided to go with. While sparkling with some interesting ideas, the stereotype dialog, uncharacteristic dialog with Silver Surfer, with a cast of all Aliens with exception of Quasar, everything is soaked in human like attributes, emotions, and ideologies. Incredible and great threats were tackled in previous books and done so by far weaker characters while the threat the Annihilators took on was grave, it was handled in a rushed, overview like, manner. Obviously, rushed, as the previous storylines had far greater space to handle the plot than Annihilators did. Tan Eng Huat is a good artist but a better choice could have been made for the overall tone and feel of the story. With approximately 80 pages of a story, it felt like Quasars perspective of a much bigger idea...as if there were more books about the story and this was Quasars chapter. Annihilators also introduces Ikon, a Space Knight with sideways references to Rom and brings back Roms main villain race, the Dire Wraiths, Immortus and his Army of Ages, and Skrulls - all very cool...except they appear in the last handful of pages where a recap of events that leads to their appearance in the story is longer than their actual appearance - as mentioned, rushed. Doctor Dredd, a villain with potential that seems to be a throw away character that is taken out by the amazingly strong tendril of the Wraith Queen that also somehow took down Silver Surfer. Oh, also the Rigellian race appeared at the start...adding a little bit more to their make up, which is cool and realistically, I think most of my critical viewpoint is sadly easily hammered out as: a creative team on a book that has a lot of great ideas, but were not given the room to properly explore them. Not knowing the behind the scenes aspect, it seems that the ideas could have and perhaps were intended to have a lot more room devoted to them, but in the end, did not.
Meanwhile:
Now, Rocket Raccoon and Groot also are featured in what was going to be a mini series, and was thrown into the original Annihilators mini series as a back up. Same writers, different artist, this time around. The characters kept in character. More patronage to what happened in the past was made, the story was well paced and had a story and an artist that fit together. This storyline was always intended to be a mini series. And its pacing and plot shows it.
Thus why I feel the Annihilators storyline was rushed. The creative team on the book are quality professionals. I think the let down in the Annihilators was more on part of the company directive than anything else.
Lasting comment would be, with its faughts, its still worth adding to ones collection of the Cosmic Marvel. There are plenty of ideas worth revisiting and hopefully will. And if they are, hopefully it won't be so rushed.