I seem to like oddball, out-of-the-ordinary books. And if a premise of "famous boy band moonlights as demon slayers" isn't oddball, I don't know what is. "SLAY" promised to be entertaining, if nothing else, and I went in expecting nothing more than a fun supernatural romp perhaps tinged with the typical romance and/or love triangle so ubiquitous to YA novels. And in the end, that's pretty much what I got -- an entertaining romp that's light and fairly insubstantial given its subject matter, but still highly enjoyable and giving us some memorable characters who I wouldn't mind seeing in future installments.
The titular "Slay" is one of the biggest boy bands in the world, with legions of swooning fangirls and a tendency to give impromptu concerts throughout the world. But the band is just a cover -- for JD, Tom, Niv, Zek, and Connor are actually highly trained demon slayers, hunting down the deadly creatures and using their music as both a cover for their activities and the financial means to continue their quest to protect humankind. Millie, the sheltered daughter of an arrogant opera singer, is rudely introduced into their world when her mother is possessed by a demon, and soon finds herself traveling with the band and their enigmatic manager Gail as they hunt down the most powerful demon they've come across yet. And even as Millie finds her affections torn between the nice boy Tom and the brooding JD, she uncovers a plot to summon the strongest demon of all...
"SLAY" isn't a masterpiece -- the writing is fairly pedestrian and hits several cliches, including the ever-tiresome love triangle between the main female character and two boys with very different personalities. I didn't encounter any glaring typos or grammar errors, and the pace was kept brisk and steady throughout the novel, but for the most part the writing isn't anything to write home about. It's obviously a first novel, and it shows signs of needing some polish.
However... despite these flaws, this novel is still very entertaining. Let's face it, how can you NOT have fun with a premise like this? Kim Curran obviously did, and it shows -- the brisk pace and the various twists and turns the plot took along the way were quite enjoyable, and kept me breathlessly reading further to find out what happens next. And despite the love triangle -- something I almost always find obnoxious in writing -- the characters are a fun bunch. Each member of the boy band is given their own distinct personality, where I'm sure it would have been tempting to simply make them largely interchangeable with one another. (I especially loved Connor, the goofy and largely innocent youngest member who is nonetheless dedicated to their quest.) Millie herself is a welcome breath of fresh air after reading passive non-entities of female protagonists so often (Bella Swan of "Twilight," Alina of "Shadow and Bone," etc.), and it's nice to see her not only have a personality of her own but to not spend the entire novel pining after the boys or moping over her situation, but stepping up to the plate and actually doing something about her situation. We need more heroines like this in YA and teen fiction.
I've heard this novel described as "Supernatural" meets "One Direction," and it's an apt comparison... but rather than being full of angst and brooding like "Supernatural," "SLAY" is just fun, never pretending to be anything other than the enthusiastic escapism it is. I had a lot of fun with this novel, even if it could use some polish, and I look forward to seeing where Kim Curran goes from here.