I was so excited to read this book (actually listen to it as I received an audio book as an Advance Reader Copy), but my enthusiasm quickly diminished as I got into it. Some of my issues were nit picky, personal irritations—like the phrase “stretched too thin” being used far too often (I know, I know, book title and all), also “all the things” and other overused, cutesy phrases—but most of it was from lack of audience awareness, or perhaps it wasn’t lacking. Perhaps the intended audience put forth in the book should have been narrowed from the very broad “every working mother” category to the “middle/upper middle class (and ideally married) working mother” group instead. That would have made a difference in my reading experience, as my expectations would have been more in line with what I found.
Don’t get me wrong—there is a good deal of valuable information for working mothers of all economic and marital statuses in this book. Some of the tips for balancing time and prioritizing are helpful, as are the reminders that we are good mothers and loving our children well is the main standard there. I loved those parts of the book.
So here’s my issue: far too many of the suggestions and examples are only accessible to women with money (and a spouse in many cases). For instance, she mentions hiring a cleaning service to take that chore off her plate while suggesting working mothers figure out what can be similarly outsourced in their own lives. I know very few families who can afford such things, and far fewer single mothers who can. (I was a single mom for 10+ years and for many years could barely afford cleaning supplies much less a cleaning service!) Several times throughout the book she mentions taking girls trips, and not just a weekend at a local hotel but full fledged, fancy destination vacations with friends. While that sounds absolutely divine, it’s completely impractical for so many women. These are just two examples, but similar things are sprinkled throughout the book. Another issue for me was the assumption that all working mothers have offices or careers that allow for privacy, space, closed door work. I do have that kind of work environment, but I have countless friends who don’t. So many of them are working the line at fast food restaurants or registers at Target or cleaning buildings or some other job that doesn’t allow for such luxuries.
Please know that I am not bashing her or her family’s ability to afford such luxuries. I think it’s great they can! My problem with it all is this: despite all their promises to make life better and easier, so many books geared toward moms present ideas and lives that are hard to obtain/maintain, and that often leads to readers of those books being frustrated, dissatisfied, and hard on themselves for not being able to be, have, or do those things for their families. From my own experience this can be especially true for single moms with very limited resources. It can be devastating. All of this caused me to be very frustrated as I listened to the book because, for me, it fell into this trap.
Turner did mention once or twice that not everyone can afford such things and for readers to find their own shortcuts and self care strategies within their means, but it was very brief, almost an afterthought. Additionally, only once did she explicitly address single mothers, and that was when talking about a working mother’s relationship with her husband and how that chapter wasn’t for single moms. That wasn’t enough. I realize she has not been a single mother and cannot fully understand what that life entails, and I’m thankful she has not/cannot. Because of that, though, a great deal of her tips and suggestions are not practical for many single
mothers (at least the ones I know). This is yet another reason I feel the intended audience should have been more narrowly defined.
I realize my opinion of the book may very well be more clouded by my experiences and biases than I’m aware. Maybe other single moms or moms of lesser means don’t feel the same way, which is totally fine. All I know for sure is so much of the book put me right back in that place of sadness and desperation I used to find myself in as an impoverished single mother who was trying to do all these great things but failing miserably at most of them (because they weren’t realistic to begin with).
Overall, I believe this book has value. It is a good encouragement and resource for the audience it fits (and likely for those who it might not fit but go in knowing what to expect). Am I glad I read it? Sure. Will I read it again? No.