A hidden beauty. A wounded beast. Can the curse threatening their happiness be broken?
There is absolutely nothing improper about Hannah Foster, the vicar of Hartley’s eldest daughter, nursing the badly wounded Viscount Blackthorn back to health—that’s if the returned officer can be saved. At twenty seven she is two years the man’s senior, a confirmed spinster, and far too sensible to develop feelings for her patient. The fact he was once her childhood friend and has grown into a fine specimen of a man—his terrible scars notwithstanding—has no bearing on the matter.
Even if the unthinkable were to happen and William was to see past her plain exterior and recognise the caring, intelligent, passionate woman beneath, he is determined to break the curse that has plagued his family for generations by letting his bloodline die out. Her best friend, Grace’s, warnings are moot. A man of Lord Blackthorn’s wealth and position would never be interested in a woman like Hannah . . . would he?
* Passion and Propriety is a stand alone story, the first in the Hearts of Honour series.
Elise began her lifelong obsession with the romance and paranormal genres when she was far too young to be reading either. After more than thirty years of marriage to her very own romantic hero, she now knows great relationships don't just happen, they take work . . . which doesn't mean writing about them can't be a whole lot of fun!
Elise likes to see her characters grow, experience passion and adventure, tackle some difficult issues, and find lasting love . . . eventually.
I loved this. That could be my entire review, right there. But I need to gush a bit more. This historical novel had everything that I want in that genre. A wounded hero. A woman with a backbone and caring heart. A bit of angst as I wonder if they will overcome the obstacles that stand in their way of true love.
Ah, yes...this was wonderful. Hannah is "on the shelf." She's been labelled a spinster by everyone in the village and her family. It doesn't sit well, but she's given up on finding a hearth and a loving man to share it with. When she finds the badly wounded William slumped at his father's graveside, she immediately rushes to help him. For his part, he's pretty sure she's an angel, well, except when she's forcing vile concoctions down his throat.
There was the correct balance between these characters as they walked that fine edge between Passion and Propriety. Their first kiss? Yeah, wowza. Hannah was pretty much blown away, as was I. Incredible, since they are both virgins. Yes, this has a virgin hero. William has a very good reason to be one, too, because there's a curse that follows his family.
The flow of the story was natural, not rushed, and I enjoyed every page. I'm very happy to hear that there will be more in Ms. de Sallier's Hearts of Honour series. I want the next one now! I really need to find out if Grace is getting her own HEA. I also want to see Hannah's sisters find their loves. Yes, I want stories for them all!
If you like historical romance, this is the book for you.
*Thank you, NetGalley and TWCS, for the opportunity to read Passion and Propriety
I wanted to read this book for some years and I’ve finally managed! I’m happy to say that it was good! :)
A very easy to read and relaxing romance without much angst and denying!
The story is straitforward and heartwarming and both the hero and the heroine were good and decent people!
Hannah, the heroine, was a competent and heardwarking girl with a big hart! William, the hero, was such a big bear with soft hart!
Their story strated while Hannah was nursing William after he almost dies in her father’s churchyard. I loved the descriptions of that nursing!
It was fun to read about the grumbly William who doesn’t want to drink the foul-tasting concotion! LOL
It was also fun to read how Hannah forces and bullies him!
Obviously the fal in love with each other, but neither reveals to the other their feelings. Each one has his or hers reason: Hannah is an older (not so much for this period, but I understand that she was almost ancient for hers ;) ) maid, a vicar’s daughter, while William is an Erl and a greviously wonded soldier.
So, you see why the title is so apt! How can a spinster of lower birth, nursing by herself a wounded Erl (and a cursed one at that!) escape the scandal? ;)
And when the tounges start waging, about how she slept in his bedroom, washed and tended him by herself, the scandal is around the corner!
And so they marry to William’s and Hannah’s joy! But still each hides from the other this joy!
I love William and his devotion and I love Hannah and her tenderness! They’re so cute together! The sweet things William did to make Hannah feel good in her new role as a Society lady, the thoughtful gifts, the tenderness, but also the passion and desire toward her were wonderful to read! And if you think that he was a virgin, it’s so much more!!!
Also Hannah desire to make William feel accepted, her defence of his character were admirable! She was like a mama bear with her cub when it came to defending William from Society vultures who wanted to make an orge of him because of the deeds of his ancestors!! I wanted to hug her!
What I liked less is the stubborn convinction of the existence of a curse: every bride of every heir of his family dies in childbirth leaving the man with a baby son.
As I understand dying while delivering a baby, or soon after from fever, was a common occurance in that period. But still here it was used to add to the difficulties of Hannah and William reaching their happyness!
I would also have liked an epilogue: the ending was a bit abrupt. I would have liked to see what happens in a few years. Nothing much, just a glimpse!
Still this was lovely, lovely read! If you want a nice romance, where both hero and heroine are virgins, but not prudes, where you can feel their love and not only lust, than this is a book for you!
4.5 I thought the book was very well written. The story was BEAUTIFUL. The characters very well developed. If the story had an epilogue that tied up the ending better, I would have rated it 5 stars. I will definitely read the next book in the series. ______
Changing my review from 4.5 to 5. I started book 2 and turns out an epilogue is not needed. The author does give us readers an update on William and Hannah pretty close to where book 1 leaves off.
Badly wounded H returns home to die. The h nurses him back to health but scandalises the locals so he feels obliged to arrange an MOC. There's a silly belief that his wife will die if she gets pregnant. He wants a chaste marriage but falls passionately in love. It's a sweet story as the lovers try to avoid the consequences of passion and a curse. I liked it.
Scarred military vet with dark past nursed back to health by a savvy vicar's daughter just sounded too good to pass up. I hadn't read this author before and was keen to try something new in my historical romance. I was duly impressed by the author's writing. There was a hint of the gothic right alongside social issues of the time next to an unusual, fun heated romance.
The story opens when William, the Viscount Blackthorn, comes home. He is near death from wounds sustained in the war and is not only prepared to die, but actually welcomes death. He comes from a cursed line of greedy, foul and lecherous men and he is content that his tainted bloodline will die with him. It is the only reason he has returned to the home estate that he vowed never to see again because of the pain and misery he experienced there growing up under a hateful, cruel father and treated badly by those in the neighborhood who took their revengeful anger out on him as a boy because they couldn't fight his powerful, wealthy father. But as things tend to do, his plans are not to be. Instead, due to the help of a long ago childhood friend and angel, he is nursed back from death to survive albeit scarred and a tad less than whole. Death might have been easier, but life has suddenly gotten interesting with Hannah Foster in it.
Hannah, the eldest daughter of the vicar, is resigned to her spinster status. She is content caring for her widowed father and two younger sisters, assisting her father with parish affairs, and visiting amongst her common friends in the village. Then one day a scruffy stranger looks near death where he is insensible out amongst the tombstones and she comes upon him. Only under the dirt and scruff is the young boy now a man that she took pity on and became his only friend when he was young and lonely. Hannah hasn't seen William since he was a boy sent off to school by his cruel father and she knows what everyone thinks of him for staying away so long and letting an unscrupulous estate manager strip the estate and oppress those who live on it and the village in its purview including the vicarage, but she is still determined to breach propriety and nurse him. No one else would go near him or the estate because of the black curse on his family. Hannah can tell herself that none of what she is doing for William is as bad as it seems because her intentions are good- that is until he is alert and now they have a problem.
William steps up and does the honorable thing though he hides the fact that he wants to do it. If only Hannah will learn to care for him in return and if only he didn't have this curse on his bloodline that threatens to drive a wedge between them. And if only, he had faith that his good deeds can negate the effects of the curse.
The plot on this one isn't that unusual, but set against the backdrop of the family curse, the battles against social ills such as slavery and child mineworkers and the call to faith, it takes new life. Normally, I'm not one for 'causes' of any variety in my romance reads, but when an author can blend it in without it taking over a story then I can not only tolerate, but also enjoy it. In this case, the social injustices and spiritual themes worked very well with the story. The curse was the grounds for much of what happened and I enjoyed the gothic-feel it added to the story and how it was used to set up the barriers to the romance.
The main characters were both strong, loveable and grow personally and together. They are written with depth. Hannah as an elder sister and the responsible one can be a bit bossy, but I enjoyed how that added some fun dialogue and tension between her and William, who as a military officer and aristocrat, is also used to being in charge. Both are also lonely and vulnerable opening up and relying on each other. They had their disagreements, but I enjoyed how these moments didn't string out too long.
As to the passionate side of things, it was a shocker to get a hold of a book with two- yep, check it- virgins. The author did a good job of balancing the obvious awkward moments that would come as a result of this with a build up of passion that would keep the reader into this couple. They were both honest and unashamed in their lovemaking and had to learn how to be together. The author also did a good job painting a true picture of a newlywed couple trying to get on together, but also get on in their community. Many authors overlook this and it was so unique and refreshing to see this aspect of a relationship included.
I should also add that the secondary characters were a plus too. There were good scenes with Hannah and her family and friend, Grace. William with his friend and also with Hannah's family was good stuff. I look forward to irascible Grace's book which is next.
In the end, I was satisfied with this one enjoying the backdrop, plot and couple. Those who enjoy historical romance with a slightly more serious tone, strong characters and dialogue and warm passion should try this one. It can be read as a standalone though it is a first book in a series.
My thanks to Net Galley for the opportunity to read this one in exchange for an honest review.
Verbose in its narcissistic triteness, insufferable in its cardboardness and vacuity ( posing as 'correctness' in gender etiquette, naturally). Hours wasted never to be regained. More detailed and condemning review of this anachronistic pile of horse manure to follow.
Oh dear Lord! What a delightful story! I literally devoured this!
The characters leap off the page, and though, in hindsight, I reckon the pace of this book is rather slow, when reading, you really do not realize and just become immersed in the plot and the characters.
Both William and Hannah were relatable characters, and Ms. de Sallier painted them both with strengths and weaknesses, with faults and virtue. In short, wholesome characters that feel real, people you could've met if you lived in those times.
I read a lot of historicals, especially Regency books, but this one takes the prize because it is a reflection of the times themselves - not just the fashion and the balls, but the real life of the 'little' people. In a way, it's almost an Upstairs,Downstairs story in that it shows William's aristocrat's life as a Viscount, and then showing Hannah in the village with the village folk, with the people who run the estates of the aristocracy and who fill their coffers. This was definitely refreshing, and eye opening, as well.
Also loved the very tender but awkward love that blossoms between these two characters. William's attempts to woo Hannah were met with a chuckle or two, and there were definitely moments that made me go, "Aww!"
This is a book to melt your heart, and I don't say this lightly. It's got everything a good historical should have - not only does it immerse you in this fascinating period, but it also bring you into the world of the characters; not just a surface depiction of heir lives.
I cannot wait now for the next book in the series! I hear it is Grace's tale... I also hope Ms. de Sallier give both Naomi and Rachel their stories - she has the makings of a very good series if she keeps up the quality and density of her writing in Passion & Propriety.
When Viscount William Blackthorn returns home, he never imagines that he will live out the week. Wounded to the point doctors wanted to amputate his arm, William expects to die in the graveyard where his parents are buried. The voice of an angel calls to him and he follows it into the nearby church where he finds his childhood friend, Hannah Foster.
At seven and twenty, the vicar's eldest daughter, Hannah, is considered a spinster. When she finds her old friend in such a state, Hannah doesn't think twice about nursing him back to health. With the occasional help of her friend and local healer, Grace, and an elderly couple, Hannah takes on the arduous task of bringing William back from the brink of death. After a few weeks tending to William, Hannah's reputation falls into serious jeopardy.
Told in third person narrative, the novel gives the reader a balanced view of both William and Hannah as they struggle with their feelings for each other. Hannah believes she is destined to lead a single life. William assumes any wife that would bare his child will die by doing so due to the fact the last five generations of Blackthorn wives had suffered the fate.
I adored William from the very first page. The instant I got a peek into his mind, I knew he would be different from his ancestors. As I read on, I wondered how it could ever be possible for Hannah and William to be together. Once on the mend, William made it clear he was not in want for a wife. Hannah understood his reasoning, but couldn't stop herself from falling for him. I could really feel their struggle as well as their joy as fate pulled them closer together.
This is the third book I've read by this author and I couldn't help falling in love with deSallier's characters once again. I was completely taken into the story not just by Hannah and William, but by the secondary characters at the same time. Hannah's best friend doesn't do the typical "friend" thing. Grace stands up to Hannah and I love that kind of gumption. William's friend, Mr. Loring, gives him some provocative advice that had me in stitches. Hannah sisters, Naomi and Rachel, remind me of my relationships with my own sisters, willing to do anything for them but still annoyed at times.
I really wish I could delve into some of my favorite parts, but I don't want to spoil anything for you. I will tell you, deSallier always promises a happily ever after and she delivers in spades for Hannah and William. If you enjoy Regency Romance, you will love Passion & Propriety.
Thank you to Elise deSallier, The Writer's Coffee Shop Publishing House, and NetGalley for granting my with an advanced reader's copy of Passion & Propriety in exchange for an honest review. I'm overjoyed to know deSallier will continue with the Hearts of Honour series with Grace and Loring's story, Duty & Desire, in 2015.
This is probably one of my favorite historical romances I have read this year. It features a wounded, scarred, virgin hero and a spinster vicar’s daughter who is two years his senior. They are socially mismatched. They must fight a family curse. The odds are all stacked against them. But in William’s entire life, no one has ever loved him but Hannah. And he has never cared for anyone as he cared for the childhood friend who accepted him when everyone else turned their back. (I’m starting to swoon all over again!)
As the story begins, William is seriously wounded and basically is returning home to die. But Hannah finds him crumpled in the cemetery and takes it upon herself to nurse him back to health. Since she is now a spinster at 27, she figures her reputation would be unaffected. She takes him back to his family home and with the help of a friend and healer, he recovers beyond anyone’s expectation. What she never expected was that should would develop tender feelings for her patient. And even more surprising: the Viscount would grow to care for her too.
Their feelings grow quickly, but not so quickly that it strained credibility. I believed in their growing friendship and attraction 100%. But a match between them is anything but simple. The difference in station is part of it, but the real obstacle is William’s family curse. It has caused every Blackthorne wife in five generations to die in childbirth. It has made William an outcast and it has prompted him to swear off marriage and children for life. The entire village believes in it. So how could he subject Hannah to an inevitable death?
This book isn’t really supernatural, so much as the people are superstitious. But it was a different time. “Modern” medicine often did more harm than good and women often died having babies. What’s important is that William really believes it and he struggles so much, going back and forth between his love for Hannah and his fear for her safety. He is such a great hero. And there is so much angst and sexual tension going on between him and Hannah. They want each other so much but William really believes it could destroy them.
I really liked the way the story progressed. Each step they took made sense to me and got us closer and closer to the inevitable conclusion you can see coming from the very beginning of the book. And each step satisfied. True, the ending is a little predictable, but I found that I didn’t really care since I enjoyed getting there so much.
Great character building. Engaging and emotionally compelling.
Passion and Propriety was excellent, the promise Elise de Sallier has shown in her previous work came to fruition in this outstanding Regency. The Viscount of Blackthorn returned home, something he swore never to do, to die. Gravely wounded his refusal to allow the sawbones to amputate his arm was tantamount to a death sentence. He is drawn to the village church recognizing his childhood playmate Hannah Foster daughter of the vicar. When Hannah discovers him collapsed near death in the graveyard she insists on trying to save him. To read the complete review and more please see Penny Dreadful Books Reviews.
Passion and Propriety is a very well-written and deeply felt romance, a perfect blend of strong characters, interesting story and a passionate relationship.
I absolutely loved this book and recommend it highly for everyone who loves historical romance.
My review contains spoilers and they're mostly my thoughts as I went with the book... for more, visit Punya Reviews...
I’ll start by stating that I really enjoyed Passion and Propriety by Elise De Sallier. This is also the first in the Hearts of Honour series, certainly quite the strong start to a new series! Even though, at times, the author’s writing style seemed a bit too heavy for my liking, it didn’t deter my enjoyment completely.
Passion and Propriety tells the story of two childhood friends who grew apart when ‘life’ happened to them. That, and their unequal social status. Years later, they’re thrown together again, as if to test to their faith in God and their love for each-other. The storyline sounded pretty original, with a younger man-older woman theme. But most importantly, this story had a really favorite theme of mine; a virgin hero. :p
William, the only heir to the Blackthorn line, hasn’t had a happy childhood. His life was mired in abuse by his alcoholic father, notorious for his lecherous lifestyle. It seems that the Blackthorn clan is not supposed to have a long and happy married life as the last couple of generations have seen their spouses dying at childbirth and leaving them with an infant; the only heir, always a boy. Thus the Blackthorn curse was born. William’s ancestors wasted away in debauchery after their spouses died, not because there was love but because they couldn’t ‘break the curse’ or so to speak. His father was no exception. And however unbelievable it sounds, he couldn’t stand William at all, citing him the reason behind his mother’s death. Everyone around the village knows of this curse. The marriage mamas do their best to keep their daughters away from this family.
William was send away to school very young. Before and after that, his only family of sort was the local vicar’s family. The Vicar, Mr. Foster, has always been kind to him. He didn’t give any credence to the curse and treated William like any other normal boy. But the one person who has always been on William’s mind was Hannah, the vicar’s eldest daughter. A kind girl, she has been his playmate. William simply worshipped Hannah but never had the courage to say anything.
When his father’s behavior went down a new level, a teenage William left home finally, never wishing to return. He has been disillusioned so early in life that he’s bitter about his legacy. William joined the army, was promoted too, through his own skills and devotion, rather than by his status. It seemed like ages passed by in between but William is still adamant of never setting foot on this pile to stone. He has appointed a land agent to take care of things. He sends money to take care of everything. According to him, he’s doing his duty.
Moreover, William also wishes to remain the last of his life, which means never to marry and beget an heir. It seemed that fate was about to grant William his wishes. He’s badly wounded in war, and without proper care and attention, he becomes very ill. This time he’ll die, and God willing, take the life-destroying curse with him to his grave. And so, William returns to his ancestral home after all. To die.
But that’s not going to happen if Hannah Foster has any say to it. When she spies on the big, scruffy, dirty looking man in the church, Hannah was preparing to be officially declared as a spinster. Now in her late 20s, she has no prospect of marrying anyone. It’s not that Hannah never wanted it but with her two very beautiful, much younger sisters, Naomi and Rachel trailing her, Hannah never got the attentions she deserved. Though their mother’s passing left a hole in their happiness, the Fosters are a close knit family and Hannah is the spinning wheel, the center of it. She’s efficient, hard working and has as much social graces as a vicar’s daughter needs to help her father in his duties. It was Hannah who practically had to be the mother to her sisters, as they were quite young at the time of their mother’s death.
Yet, even after so many years of not seeing him, Hannah hasn’t forgotten about that young boy who used to play with her once upon a time. A boy who seemed lost and alone in this world. Hannah had tried her best to be a friend but he was the heir to a viscount and she’s just the vicar’s daughter. What else she could’ve done to help his situation? That boy, now undoubtedly a man, doesn’t even visit his home anymore. The village is in shambles, thanks to the corrupt land agent but Hannah doesn’t blame William one whit. She knows about the curse too and how badly the people here treated him over the years just because he’s born a Blackthorn, an occurrence that’s not even his fault.
When Hannah sees the man, he was staring at her straight. It sends a shiver down her spine. She doesn’t know who he is so she decides to let it go. Soon afterwards, when Hannah is visiting her mother’s grave, she finds that man lying prone near a grave, that of the recently deceased old Viscount. This gives her a pause... What if? Is it...? When she looks closely, somehow, even through the blood and dirt, she recognizes William. It’s very apparent he’s gravely ill, probably dying. The recognition and that thought spring Hannah into action. She needs to help him, somehow... if she can. Even if for their long forgotten friendship; a thing of the past now.
With Hannah and her family’s help, William is taken to his rundown manor that is now operating only by the two elderly caretakers. Since she knew she can’t expect much help from the people of the village, Hannah decides to take up on the task. From the bits and pieces he, in his insensible state, blabber on, it was clear that William expected to die. But Hannah won’t have it. Now that she’s ‘officially’ a spinster, whose going to nay-say her if she decides to stay? Her father is not oppose to the idea, though her sisters and her best friend, Grace, the healer of the village, are a bit skeptical. People can be vicious in their gossip! But Hannah laughs those concerns away and soldiers on to fight for William’s life.
For days and nights, she keeps her vigilance at his side; sometimes even helping with William’s intimate needs that a unmarried woman shouldn’t even be thinking of. And that leads to some hilarious moments when William finally opens his eyes and sees Hannah asleep on a chair near his bed. He’s so happy to see the girl he recognized as the kind vicar’s daughter. It pains him that he can’t exactly recall her name. When Hannah wakes up and he needs to take care of his… er, bladder, he’s mortified to know that she’s the one who has been taking care of him; including that. Thinking she must be married, William let her help. Still it was quite awkward. But the moment Hannah confessed that she’s unmarried, ooh boy, William’s delicate sensibilities went haywire. He’s so embarrassed that he immediately demands that she hires someone to work as his temporary valet, while she writes to his own valet to come to make himself present as soon as possible!
Hannah does what he tells her in a huff, and muttering but somehow she understood. While they’re at it, she apprises William about the state of the manor, the village and everything else, when William is strong enough to listen to them. It became clearer that the big chucks of money he send to his land agent probably fed his own pocket. As soon as he’s able, now that it’s apparent he’s not going to die, thanks to one Miss Foster, William is determined to see to his long pending duties to his people.
Though I felt that William’s old worshipful feelings about Hannah returned in full force, certainly after what she did for him, he was very much embarrassed about his looks. :( He’s a big man with a big body, which might’ve saved him in the end but he was also wounded pretty badly. His body is scarred, with a leg that formed a decided limp that might never heal. One of his arms has also been damaged. The camp doctor wanted to amputate but William didn’t let him. That one’s almost of no use to him. Then there was that scar, a big gash that permanently etched out the horrors of war on his face. William is strong but he’s also vulnerable. What good would he be to his estate with so many hindrances? Would Miss Foster think of him anything but an ugly man with what seems like an eternal curse hanging over his head? Oh he wants to find out, but he’s also afraid. William is almost certain that given the chance he’d marry her in a heartbeat but that’d be always be a fantasy that will never come true. Or so our hero thought...
The opportunity lands soon after Hannah left the manor. At home, she isn’t as happy as she used to be because Hannah begins missing William quite fierce. Oh she doesn’t care about his scars or that big gash on his face. In truth, Hannah is quite smitten with her testy patient and she finds all the talks of the curse balderdash. She doesn’t really believe in it but the people around her wouldn’t let it be. Then she begins to notice how others would deem William a monster of sort and gossip away like he doesn’t deserve even an ounce of respect. But Hannah knew better, and she couldn’t stand it any longer. Once, when Rachel, the airhead in the bunch, says something bad about William, Hannah protests quite vehemently and leaves the room. But this also reveals something rather interesting to her family members. There was no hiding now, that she harbors some sort of feeling for the man.
Grace, the village healer who helped Hannah with William’s recovery, stops by to warn her about it. Hannah can’t possibly be feeling something for that man! Not only she’s from a lower status, but also... I mean he’s cursed! And if he’d ever marry her, which would never happen, she’s bound to die in childbed! Hannah, though, doesn’t agree with Grace’s sentiment. They might never be together, but he’s a good man and treated her with respect. Grace also informs Hannah about the gossip that the busybodies were spreading over her and William’s ‘relationship’. Hannah is not that worried at the moment. After all, what can really happen to a spinster?
In the meantime, a visibly stronger William takes up on his responsibilities. He begins to take stock of things that need to be done in his own home as well as for his people. His actions were so much like the true lord of the manor that people begin wondering about him anew. It’s true that his ancestors’ track record is horrible, so William knew that his has his work cut out for him. Yet for the first time in his life, he wanted to do something for these people. Most especially, he couldn’t let Hannah’s family suffer anymore.
Of all the improvement work William starts in that short time, what inevitably catches everyone’s attention is his particular interest in the church and the vicarage. William could argue that both places needed vast repairs, which would be true, and he secretly wanted Hannah nearby while the repairs take place but the gossip would always connect them in a damaging way. Either way, vile stuff begins to fly very soon. Hannah is not worried about herself but she’s for William and how those will affect him in the long run. Yet, she can’t deny her happiness at William’s kind attention on their home... and somehow, on her too.
It wasn’t until someone threatens Hannah of spreading the gossip and robbing her sisters’ futures that she becomes truly worried. She meets up with William in hopes for a solution. True enough, he’s angry at the culprit, promising her to take care of it. But that won’t squelch the gossip already let loose. They need to think on a solution, and fast. But what will it be?
William, of course, ends up proposing to Hannah, to her complete surprise yet secret delight. I can say the same for him because wasn’t that what he wanted all along? The kiss after her acceptance made it even more of a possibility. Even though people around Hannah try to act as if she’s going to the gallows, she’s determined to marry William. Even Grace is not supportive of her decision. She leaves in a huff after an altercation, and the tension between her and Hannah doesn’t die down for a while. Oh boy, must add that being of this century I found the whole notion of a curse so ridiculous! Hannah doesn’t care and her father, who should’ve been the one to oppose, surprises both of them by giving his blessing. Even then, the thought of the curse had William in so much distress that he was willing to do anything possible to have it removed and keep Hannah safe. He prays with the vicar, he even goes as far as to make the marriage in name only so that there’s no chance of her conceiving. But this, Hannah will NOT have. She wants children, William’s and many if possible. So we find that she’s also determined to work on it, to see if she can later sway William’s determination.
I knew that ‘marriage in name only’ thing will never ever work. For one, both were so in love with each-other, though none had any idea of the other’s feeling, how can they not want to be in each-other’s arms? Pretending was becoming difficult each passing day. Hannah was a virgin, which I knew but to my delight, I found that William too! It’s not that he doesn’t have the appetite, quite the opposite as we find out soon enough but he has been scared. Always despising the ‘legacy of lechery’ that his ancestors so lovingly(?) built while they were alive, William never felt the urge to take part in that act. But with Hannah, things are different. Not only she’s his wife, but it was also true that she felt the same way! When William is sure that things can’t go on this way, let alone a lifetime, he desperately seeks out his friend, the new land agent, Jonathan Loring’s help. Loring is a widower. He has a sickly young boy, who has accompanied him here at the estate. And though a gentleman (Grace wouldn’t agree with me I think :p), he had, by no means, lived the life of a monk. So he gives William some ideas and asks him to practice them.
Addendum here, Grace loves and practices herbal remedies while Loring doesn’t believe in it but the advanced medical stuff. So apparently, they started out on the wrong foot. He also called Grace the ‘witchy woman’ a few behind her back, a name she probably won’t appreciate. Though they’re not really given any scene together, from whatever I read, I’m sure I’d absolutely love finding out how they resolve their ‘differences’ in their own book. *heehee*
Anyhoo, I won’t be telling you what they decide on but it works out for Hannah and William so well that they begin going at it like the bunnies. LOL I really enjoyed reading how they couldn’t keep their hands off of each-other. That’s how a marriage should be IMO. ;)
The next couple of chapters seemed slow but still enjoyable because I loved seeing how beautifully Hannah and William’s relationship grew when everybody and their grandmother thought they’d never make it. It became even sweeter when they profess their love for each-other, surprised yet delighted to find that the feeling is mutual. There is no denying of William’s complete adoration of his wife. Being a lonely boy, and growing up as an equally lonely man, Hannah’s presence has been the only succor to his life throughout; even when he wasn’t living here. I knew for certain that Hannah always felt him in her heart. Now she’s just relieved that she never got married! Seems like fate has decided to throw them together again, but to what cost? Will they forever remain happy this way? Can Hannah be happy when she knows this happiness comes at a cost? That she’ll probably never have children?
TBH, I wasn’t surprised to find Hannah unhappy. And this issue was the ONLY thorn in their absolute happiness. Hannah wanted children, but the mention of it would scare the sh!t out of William. He was that jumpy, always in terror of losing Hannah forever and having to take care of an infant all on his own. Afraid that the happy memories of them together would forever haunt him. *sigh* Though I found this ridiculous, I was frustrated. It was just... so depressing!
Even after all the precautions, fate intervenes again and one thing leads to another and... well, Hannah one day finds herself pregnant. Though William takes the news stoically, his inner monologues will tell you that it’s not good. He tries to keep calm in order to keep Hannah happy but as Hannah grew bigger with each passing day, his agitation grew tenfold. He was actually already trying to come to terms with Hannah’s death and how he’s going deal with an infant afterwards. That’s what I meant by depressing as hell. And I couldn’t even blame him because the fear, though ridiculous when you think of said curse, was not entirely unfounded considering the era. Then the time grew nearer and given the environment, even Hannah begins feeling uncomfortable about it. The news of a baby has never brought so much tension and shadows on a family, when they should be celebrating the beauty of it wholeheartedly.
The last few chapters of the book were quite gut-wrenching. When Hannah finally goes into labor, to say that things didn’t go smooth would be an understatement. It won’t really express what I was feeling while I was reading that part. At one point, it did feel like she won’t make it....... I felt so sad and miserable for her, maybe because I have no children and what she endured seemed nothing short of superhuman. I could only imagine William’s feelings. Those chapters gave me goosebumps.
In the conclusion, I would’ve loved an epilogue. That’s my only complaint because the ending felt abrupt. But you just can’t NOT be happy for Hannah and William no matter. What a challenge it has been for them to prove everyone, and God, that they can make it! Personally, I’m quite impressed by Elise de Sallier’s efforts as this is my first try of her work. It certainly wouldn’t be the last! A solid 4 stars and recommended.
PS: A bit bummed that Grace-Loring’s book, Duty and Desire will be out in January 2015 but I’ll be eagerly waiting for it!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
William, Viscount Blackthorn has lived a horribly unhappy life. He was born to a cursed family, meaning that his mother died giving birth to him, like the previous 5 or so generations. His father was a lecherous alcoholic and had nothing but hatred and venom for his son. The neighbourhood despised and feared the family and he met with kindness only from the servants in his house and his only childhood playmate. As soon as possible, William was sent off to boarding school. There, he was ostracised by his peers for the curse. Not wanting to pass on the curse to future generations William determined never to marry, and therefore was able to make a career choice generally not available to firstborn sons – he joined the army rather than come home and tend to his estate after his father’s death. The Blackthorn curse is thought by many to have cursed the district too. Many families have moved away, both to avoid this, and to try and find a better landlord, because William’s steward has kept the harsh rules that the previous Lord Blackthorn imposed and William has never intervened. William is battleworn and battle scarred and in fact is gravely injured. Refusing to let his injured arm be amputated William has instead come home to die.
“His death would put an end to the curse that had plagued his family for generations, and it seemed fitting for that to occur at the place where it all began.”
Passing the local church on the way William is attracted by the music being played and he goes in to listen. He recognises the woman playing the music as his former childhood playmate, the vicar’s eldest daughter Hannah, the sole bright spot of his youth.
Hannah is having a very bad day. It is her twenty seventh birthday, which means she is now officially an old maid. She has had a busy and useful life for the past few years, helping her father tend his flock and raise her sisters after the death of her mother, but she would like a family of her own. She is trying to accept that her dreams of marriage and motherhood are going to remain just that – dreams. Later that day she goes to visit her mother’s grave and finds William has collapsed in the graveyard. She immediately goes to help him, but finds herself in a dilemma. The steward of the estate has dismissed nearly all the staff and is currently away on a ‘business trip’ so there is nobody to pay for medical care for William and nobody will go there from kindness due to the curse. Hannah decides to go and care for him herself with the naive hope that her status as an old maid will protect her reputation, and the reputation of her sisters by association. It probably would have made more sense for her to have nursed him in the vicarage, but she doesn’t realise how little assistance she will have at Blackthorn Manor.
William has been sorely lacking in tender care in his life, and becomes very fond of Hannah’s company. This is in addition to finding her extremely attractive, a feeling that is mutual. In these times unmarried men and women couldn’t really be friends and William can’t offer anything more, though he finds himself wishing that he could. When circumstances intervene William and Hannah find themselves thrown together once more, but will he be able to continue to resist her?
I thought this was a very entertaining read although there were a few times I had to suspend my disbelief a bit, I really don’t think he could have returned home from war abroad with his arm as it was and I also believed that if people were as happy and relieved to get servant work as they appeared to be they would have been more discreet – if they’d been my servants I’d have got rid of them all and rehired! Nothing is kept secret, and even allowing for servants gossiping things which they were never told somehow get to be common knowledge.
I really liked both the hero and the heroine. I deeply pitied William for how sad and unloved his life had been. Only in the army had he found acceptance, when he could leave his horrible family and the memory of the curse behind.
The thoughts of both William and Hannah are often really amusing, and I enjoyed their dry humour. Here is William with a hangover:
“He was clearly suffering some terrible, life-threatening malady.....There was no point to Hannah catching whatever dreaded disease had claimed him.”
Their attitudes in some respects seemed to be a little too modern in my eyes, particularly their attitudes to sex. Although some reasoning is given for this, considering both of them are virgins they seem to know an awful lot about sex and are happy to openly discuss it with just about anybody! There were a few words and phrases which jumped out as being too modern, or American, e.g. ‘darned’ and things such as William making a reference to his disabled left hand only noticing when he has to cut his food but it would notice anytime he eats because the custom in Britain is to have the fork in the left hand and the knife in the right at all times, not just when cutting food. I also am not sure whether a ‘sulky’ is a carriage that would have generally been found in England at the time, I would have thought a gig or phaeton would be more likely, depending on what class of person was driving, but these are small quibbles in the scheme of things.
There are some interesting secondary characters introduced in this novel, too. Hannah’s friend, Grace Daniels is the illegitimate daughter of a lord, who was cast out by her stepmother after her father’s death. She now provides apothecary care and herbal tinctures to the community and she was instrumental in saving William’s life by her work on his arm. She gets off to a very poor start with William’s new steward, and it’s a real mystery as to why, but Grace’s story seems set to be told in the second book in the series, Duty and Desire, due out in early 2015, which I'd certainly like to read. I thought Passion and Propriety was a very entertaining book and it was a lovely way to while away a rainy Sunday! This is better than a 3 star read but not quite a 4 for me. Please note, for those of you who prefer to avoid them, that this novel contains sex scenes.
*Many thanks to the publisher of this book, The Writer's Coffee Shop, for allowing me to have an e-ARC copy via Netgalley for my honest review.
Let's cut straight to the chase here, because if you've read my reviews of our authors other books Innocence and Protection, you'll know I abso-blooming-lutely LOVE her writing. And it's no difference with her latest offering, Passion and Propriety. Without further ado, I'm going to jump straight in and tell you what I thought, although, in all honesty, you should probably go and one-click first because I'm reckoning that by the time you've read this you'll be ready to lock yourself away in a secluded corner and devour this book like there's no tomorrow!
Firstly, something I love in this book is how well the story is told from both perspectives. Sometimes this can be a little tricky to accomplish well, but Elise de Sallier has mastered this, weaving a very detailed story using both views very clearly. We can never truly know what the other person in a conversation is thinking, but in this book, you always know what both Hannah and William are thinking, meaning you can get a little exasperated with them when they're both being so bull-headed and close-minded! This adds an incredibly readable quality to the tale though, and helps you as a reader invest more into the characters, which is always good in my books!
The characterisation, as always with Elise's books, is absolutely spot on in every respect. Hannah is a brilliantly strong female lead, resigned to her fate of spinsterhood and more of a mother than a sister to her family. She really is one of those characters you get behind and want things to work out for them, which is fabulous and adds a lot to the story. William, ah, dear William. Well, honestly, he can be a cantankerous old veteran at times, with good cause though, but the changes to his character after meeting Hannah, and his recovery is incredibly well written. He is such a tangible character, you feel for his family history, understand his concerns, yet still want to clobber him over the head sometimes to make him see sense! It's this emotional engagement with the characters that really sets the story above and beyond the others in this genre.
The basic storyline and concept behind the book is very well developed from the first pages, all the way to the last, and is deeply integrated into the story. Elise de Sallier writes a unique twist on the whole Beauty and the Beast vs star crossed lovers theme and really makes it her own, taking a well used classic tale and making it something new and refreshing, enabling the reader to enjoy the delights in a completely different setting. The danger and undercurrents of tension throughout, as a result of the Blackthorn curse, add a fantastic edge to the story, and make it all that more readable and difficult to put down. Of course, the eventual 'happily ever after', of a sorts, is much needed by that point, but incredibly well written all the same. It's a beautiful, and very touching twist, at the end of the tale, all be it one that you may have already guessed at if you were following the clues in the final fifty or so pages, but that didn't detract from how wonderful and enjoyable it was to read.
Something I really need to mention is the attention to detail shown by Elise de Sallier in her writing. Her plot development, characterisation, and accuracy to the history of the times is all fabulously done and adds that extra dimension to the story, making it come alive that little bit more in the reader's mind. It's very clear from the off that a lot of time and effort has gone into researching the time period, societal norms, dress, households, it's all just got that extra attention that makes it more believable. This is even weaved into the very fabric of the story, with the whole plot taking a detailed, believable and much desired arc (by me at least!) that really pulls the reader in and gets them cheering for the characters, engaging with the story on a whole new level.
In conclusion, all there really is left for me to say is how wonderful this book was - oh, I've already said that..... Well, you get the point! It is most definitely Elise de Sallier's best book so far and one of the best regency romances I've had the pleasure of reading. She is most definitely an author of note in this genre and one I will be watching closely for new releases. I cannot recommend this author, or her book, highly enough to anyone who is a fan of regency romance or who would like to dabble in the genre to see if it's for them, because believe me, after reading this you would definitely be a convert! And after the little snippet into the next book in the series, I am eagerly awaiting a release date for that! *hint, hint*
This book was received as an ARC in return for an honest review as part of the release day celebrations. The review was first posted to Lily Loves Indie - http://lilylovesindie.co.uk/?p=493
Review of Passion and Propriety by Elise deSallier
I first became acquainted with the work of Elise deSallier when she was writing some of the highest caliber fan fiction I have ever read; her stories were positively addicting, and as I wrote review after glowing review, we began to correspond, especially regarding our experiences with chronic illness.
Then she republished my favorite fan fiction story, A Forbidden Love in two parts: Innocence and Protection. A few weeks ago, I reviewed these two volumes which together tell the tale of the lovely and brave Annaliese and her marquis. With such compelling characters and edge-of-the-seat plotting, I enjoyed the published novels just as much as (if not more than) the original fan fiction story.
After republishing her very popular and success fan fiction, Elise deSallier started writing a new series called Hearts of Honour, the first book of which is Passion and Propriety. When I read the opening chapter of this new book at the end of Protection, I was immediately hooked and quickly obtained a copy…which I read from first to final page in well under 24 hours. Yes, it was that good—and yes, it surpassed Innocence and Protection by a mile…even several miles. ;)
The unlikely heroine, Hannah, daughter of the village rector, nurses the cursed Viscount Blackthorn when he returns to his ancestral home to die from wounds encountered on the battlefield. Refusing to amputate his infected arm, William Blackthorn chooses to die rather than lose his limb and endure life as a cripple. Hannah enlists the help of her lifelong friend and talented herbalist, and together they save Blackthorn’s arm and his life.
Why does Hannah take on nursing a stranger in his ancestral home, unchaperoned? Hannah is nearly thirty and is considered by the townspeople to be a spinster; in addition, she recalls fond memories of playing with William when they were children. But William returns not only on the brink of death but also with a terrible curse: the wives of the last several Viscounts Blackthorn, including William’s own father, have lost their wives to childbirth. Thus, William plans to never marry and thus to carry the curse to his grave.
But thanks to Hannah’s dedicated nursing, he survives. And the events that unfold as the story progresses are riveting indeed. The characters are wonderfully human and believable; they stole my heart and my imagination immediately. The story lines are complex yet clear; each twist and turn is surprising yet makes perfect sense. (Caution: contains some detailed intimate scenes.) I was positively spellbound by this book, and I am thrilled that Elise de Sallier has at least two more books planned for this series. If they are as amazing as Passion and Propriety, I shall be a very happy reader indeed.
Spoiler Alert First of all Congratulations on this new adventure, you've done such a great work I didn't doubt this would be any less. Ok, William, William, William. *sighs dreamily* At first I saw William as an old big Teddy bear with a missing eye and an arm and leg hanging by its thread, that needed a big hug and you want to cuddle him to show him the love he missed for many years!! And then how cute was he at his blushing and feeling embarrass to have Hanna care for him and then now the knight in shinning armour saving the village!! Also I thought he might be a bit more difficult with Hanna but he kept that Teddy Bear persona through the book that you couldn't help but love him more. Hanna is my favorite heroine, despite how a lady was suppose to behave and what the people thought she didn't care as long as she had William by her side. She a strong person and doesn't take crap from anyone, especially her husband. Let me tell you, Elise is the first author I ever read historical romances and not even the "classics." I tried to read Pride and Prejudice to see what the big fuss was about Mr Darcy but I just couldn't go any further. Her mother was driving me insane at her views of what was to be expected of her daughters and all the views they had about women in general. Like here in PP if girls didn't have a decent amount of money on their name they couldn't get a decent husband or how scandalous would be if a woman went to travel and see the wonders their is to explore (let me tell ya if the ladies back then will see how we live now they'll die of a heart attack) But what has draw me to Elise books was the romance, the passion her characters share and of course happy endings!! And she didn't disappoint with William and Hanna. Hanna was simply the cure for William, because of her he became a better man and will be an excellent father. I don't believe in their "curse" but one think that lack in the past 6 Viscounts and will make up for many more in the future is their love for one another and now their children. I loved their interaction with each other, when they were arguing, being flirty or just having fun!!! I cannot wait for Johnathan and Grace story. I had a feeling those two will end up together and even as they don't get along...at all...it'll be fun to see them try.
What first drew me to this book was the fact that both leads were virgins, not just the girl. I was intrigued by this break away from the "rake" stereotype. What I got was a very enjoyable romance that I enjoyed to the hilt. The connection between Hannah and William is very palpable. From the beginning, it's a relationship that defies societal norms and a tragic curse to become a strong and respecting bond between two scarred individuals. The author takes a lot of time to develop the actual romantic connection and the characters before the sexy times hit.
Unfortunately, it's those sexy times I have an issue with. It's not them by themselves I have a problem with. It's the amount of them and the way it which some are used. It seems to me that by the time Hannah and William are married and a little time has passed, the curtain falls on relationship building and opens onto a porn set during the Regency. These two go at it in various different positions, in various locations, and at various times to create a second book half that is focused on sex and little else. What little there is in relationship or character building always comes back to the sex and the consequences thereof. Yeah, I can see some of that with the nature of the curse. But really, the whole thing revolves around their sexual relationship?
I think I might have gone on a bit with the sex issue, but that's almost pretty much how I left the book. Visions of sexy times is NOT how I want to remember a romance, it's the emotional connection I want to be left with. So while the connection between the two leads was beautiful and I enjoyed immensely what was there, the author's overuse of sex, sexual issues, and the use of it to resolve the curse as well as other issues has left me cold. I don't if I'd recommend this romance. It's sweet and tender relationship wise, but you'll definitely need a cold shower afterwards...
Finding her childhood friend almost dead in the local cemetery, Hannah Foster decides it is her job to nurse the wounded Viscount Blackthorn back to health. Being a confirmed spinster, Hannah doesn't see anything wrong with her staying at his home with the elderly servants.
Coming home to die, William is surprised to find himself still alive with an angel tending his wounds. Determined to end the curse that has plagued his family for generations, he fights his growing attraction for Hannah.
When they must marry to satisfy society's dictates, they decide not to consummate their marriage. Will their marriage survive without the intimacies that would bring them closer to each other?
I really enjoyed this story, the first that I have read by this author. The heroes of romance novels are not often physically wounded and that was a nice change of pace (not that I have anything against a perfectly formed male body, LOL!)
I really liked Hannah, probably because she was a little bit bossy. She was use to running her father's household, so when she is nursing the Viscount the "woman in charge" just kinda kicked in. I loved that the author had the H/H both be virgins and that William got tips from his father's book collection (how else is a guy to know, LOL!)
I'll definitely be picking up more books by this author and can't wait for the next installment of this series which stars Hannah's friend, Grace.
Thanks go out to The Writer's Coffee Shop Publishing House for a copy of the book in exchange of an honest review.
Elise de Sallier is a master at Regency era romance! In an age where even a furtive glance was considered scandalous, this story conveys believable sexual tension while staying true to the time and setting.
In Passion and Propriety, the first book of Ms. de Sallier’s new Hearts of Honour series, we find William Blackthorn, the Viscount of Blackthorn Manor, returning from war to presumably die from the wounds he received in battle. But before he can even make it to his childhood home that he’d abandoned ten years prior, he is captivated by the beautiful voice of the vicar’s daughter, Hannah Foster.
With no one to care for the ailing Viscount, most of the manor staff having long since been dismissed, Hannah volunteers to help William. Assuming that her spinster status (at the ripe old age of 27) would protect her reputation while nursing the Viscount back to health, Hannah helps to bring William back from death’s door. However, that circumstance alone presents itself with a host of additional problems. Not to mention the “Blackthorn curse” that William vows to avoid by never marrying, let alone producing an heir. Seems hopeless, but it’s far from it. The growing affection between William and Hannah just can’t be stopped. And the sexual tension is palpable!
Elise de Sallier weaves a tale of friendship, love and awakening sexuality, while maintaining the integrity of the genre. It’s classic in its storytelling but modern in its romance. Everything a romantic reader of this age could hope for!
What a nice Regency romance, but not the typical London balls/ton/entertainments type. This one takes place in a small village and our heroine is the vicar's eldest daughter, 27-year-old spinster Hannah. When she finds William, Lord Blackthorn, collapsed and suffering from recent war injuries, she nurses him back to health, but not without scandal among the townsfolk. This book spends less time on action and a lot more time in character building, which is refreshing and enjoyable. Because of their close proximity for the first section of the book, we get to know the two main characters very well, understanding their innermost thoughts and motivations. They fall in love but have to fight their worries about the Blackthorn Curse where the wives die after childbirth, having borne a son. There were some very nice steamy scenes as well as many romantic moments. Secondary characters of Grace, the local midwife/medical professional, and Hannah's sisters are enjoyable and entertaining. This was a very good story, and I look forward to reading more in the series.
I really don’t know where to begin except………..I LOVED this book!!!! And if you know me you know this is a genre that I almost NEVER read. But I got hooked on Elise’s writing after reading Innocence, so much that I immediately read Protection. And then I jumped up and down with excitement when I got to read Passion and Propriety early.
I am such a big fan of Elise’s now, especially since her writing has lured me into reading books I don’t normally read!
Beauty and the Beast has always been one of my favorite stories and Disney movies, so that made me like this story even more. I adored Hannah, but William really stole my heart :)
I am so excited to read the next book in this series.
AND DRUMROLL……………………if you keep up with my reviews you know how rarely I give 5 stars. BUT I’m giving this one 5 stars because it has definitely earned it, to me! I hope you read and enjoy it as much as I did!!!
I was given this book to read in exchange for an honest review... and I'm so happy I was!
No one can write historical romance like Elise de Sallier. The flow of the language, the description of the settings, the essence of the period—she does it perfectly.
I love all her books, but had a hard time putting this one down. When my kindle ran out of battery, I sat beside it, tapping my fingers waiting for it to return to life, so I could keep reading.
The story between William and Hannah was beautifully told and caught me up in the time period and the constraints couples faced in that era. I was cheering for them from the very first introduction.
Hannah’s unique spirit was so refreshing to read and I loved how she handled William and his cantankerous ways. His approach to hiding his caring heart was touching and I loved seeing him slowly awaken and respond to her.
I really enjoyed this, and Elise de Sallier is fast becoming one of my favourite authors. I love a good bodice-ripper, and this reminded me very much of the series I enjoy by Courtney Milan, Tessa Dare and others. It’s well-written with interesting, fleshed-out characters the reader can feel for. There is UST in spades, and it's nicely done with lots of good showing rather than telling.
William is just lovely. The absence of love in his childhood made him prickly at the start, but Hannah's caring brought him around. His willingness to help his fellow soldiers showed he wasn’t such an uncaring brute even in the army. I love his arc, coming to accept the curse is broken. And he’s yummy.
I cannot wait to read the next book in the series. Now that there are a few ex-military men at the big house there’s bound to be one to catch a girl’s eye ;) Rawr!
I really liked this novel! Two characters that see themselves as flawed, but not the other. A whirlwind love match that they didn't expect, and a lot of sweetness. I spent most of the novel trying to figure out whose side I was on. First Hannah's, but as soon as William brought up his fears I realized that of course he had good reason for those as well, and so I went two and fro between the two.
I'm excited to read the novels that will come after... Grace's story, and of course that of Hannah's two sisters. They all seem very interesting and fun.
But most of all, I hope that the curse has truly been lifted.
I finished this Amazing story with a sense of joy and love in my heart. William Blackthorn comes home after a decade convinced his has done so to die. Hannah Foster the Vicar's daughter,convinced a life of spinsterhood is on the cards. Life has other ideas. I thoroughly enjoyed this story.The characters, some loveable ,others you can't help but dislike,take you on a journey that will help you believe that with Love,all things are possible. I highly recommend this story to all lovers of historical Romance. I was honored to receive an ARC of this story and to share my Honest review. Thank you Elise and The Writers Coffee Shop
Passion and Propriety is a story that follows a man named William. William has a death wish. He has come home from the war and has little interest on continuing life. He is covered wit scars and injuries that won't heal and wants to be left alone. But all of that changes when his childhood friend, Hannah, finds him on the brink of death. Instead of listening to the rumors of William's cursed family, she gets close enough to save him. They both realize they have feelings for each other, but society and superstitions have other plans.
I am really in love with de Sallier. When I saw her name attached to this book on Netgalley, I jumped on it as quickly as possible. Her writing is just so engrossing. I find myself easily lost in her books. You immediately get attached to the characters and their world. I don't read a lot of historical romances, so I am extra happy I landed on de Sallier and her work.
I loved Hannah. Hannah is a self-proclaimed spinster. Spinsters are unmarried women who intend on staying unmarried. Men don't take an interest, so she doesn't bother. She is a woman not afraid to speak her mind and stand up for herself. These are character traits that, of course, may not make a suitable wife. William however, finds her captivating even though he shouldn't. He is of a higher class than her and would be expected to find someone of equal class to be with. But he also is not that interested in marriage given his family curse. Any woman he ends up with will be met with a terrible fate. I really loved William. He does come off quite the jerk in the beginning. But as the story goes on, you can't blame him for being bitter.
The best thing about this book was the connection between Hannah and William. The way it was paced and how they came together was simply perfect for me. Nothing was rushed and unrealistic. The reasons for their doubts were appropriate for the time period. I loved it. Another aspect I found interesting was the descriptions of the characters. They are immediately referred to as "gorgeous" and "perfect". William has scars (both internal and external) as well as a limp. Hannah is not considered traditionally beautifully, but still attractive. I just thought that was an interesting change not having characters that are basically supermodels. Hell, they were both virgins before being together. Yeah, you read that right. I have to say, it is nice when the hero of the story isn't a manwhore. Maybe it is just me, but it gives the story something extra. It makes it more intriguing. Again, maybe just me.
This isn't a story with a villain or anything like that. Instead, de Sallier uses circumstances as the real "antagonist" of the story. William's family is cursed. His family were very greedy and vicious. That viciousness is in the blood now. The women die at childbirth and William's bloodline is now non-existent. You also have their social classes. William is an officer and an aristocrat. Hannah is the vicar's daughter. They shouldn't be anywhere near each other. It is bad enough that Hannah has been taken care of William's every need without someone around (specifically a man). People are bound to talk.
I really loved this story. de Sallier definitely has a voice and i must be heard. It is refreshing and intriguing. The characters are impossible not to love. They are the kind of characters that you will cling to. Their insecurities and personalities make them unforgettable. This story is unforgettable. Despite the time period, I think we can all find something to relate to in this book. I recommend this even if historical romance isn't your thing. Add de Sallier on your authors to watch list. You will be glad you did.
I wish I had known this is a Christian romance; I’m not a fan of those, and would have passed it over. I liked the beginning, with the wounded hero wooing the somewhat-insecure spinster, but the book dragged on too long after
If you like Christian romances with anti-abortion messages, this book is for you. Not my cuppa.
As I've said before, Ms. de Sallier knows how to write historical romances.
This one, told from third person point of view, was about the unlikely relationship that blossomed between William Blackthorn, an English viscount, and Hannah Foster, the eldest daughter (a self-proclaimed spinster) of the village vicar. One of the main points of conflict of the book is borne about from the so-called Blackthorn Curse. So then how do these two get together? Read and find out.
Looking forward to the story of Jonathan and Grace next.
Not normally a fan of "God"/church in books, and that featured heavily here. Still rated it high because the story was good and the faith parts were part of the landscape.
I love the idea behind this HR beauty and the beast retelling! A wounded hero x an independent woman who nurses him back to health, they have to fight a family curse, there's angst and angst and angst...it's a good recipe!
Despite the interesting premise, there were a few things that pulled me out of the story.
One is the seeming inconsistency in Hannah's characterization. She's supposedly selfless and loving, except almost every interaction we see on page (that isn't summarized) shows her as bitter and selfish. I completely 100% think her reasons for feeling that way are valid, but it shows a side of her personality that isn’t fully addressed. She's quick to think lowly of the women around her, though it's dressed up as concern. I don't imagine this was an intended trait for her to have, but it could've been interesting to explore that a bit more: what happens when a society rejects unmarried women as spinsters, then punishes them for playing the part? Hannah is sensible, but she argues against William's help to the point of ridiculousness. I mean, arguing she wants her sisters to have the financial ability to choose their own husbands, then complaining that their gifted dowries are too high, then complaining when William promises to protect them against fortune hunters because that implies he will protect her just as fiercely and she doesn't want him to worry about her safety? Really. And then there's the matter of her trying to seduce him even though he's made it clear he doesn't want to consummate their marriage because he doesn't want to be responsible for her death, or to raise a child alone. That made me uncomfortable, though I felt she redeemed herself somewhat by feeling guilty about it. And she didn't lie when he asked her about her intentions.
Another is the heavy-handed preaching. Just a preference, but yeesh.
My final complaint is that the problems William and Hannah face aren't treated with the nuance they deserve. Like how marriage-- or, more to the point, sex--doesn’t necessarily need to lead to children. Like how a marriage can in fact be an intimate and valid relationship without childmaking as a central aspect. Like how womanhood isn't defined by one's status as a daughter, wife, or mother, or how well she can clean a house, any more than manhood isn't defined by one's status as a son or father, or how physically adept he is. (That could have been such a good parallel to draw!) Like how a desire to care for children can be shown in more than one way, such as, oh, I don't know, volunteering at the orphanage that's mentioned about a dozen times but that Hannah apparently has nothing to do with??? Of course, this is the Regency era and the MCs are both sheltered and/or ostracized virgins, so one must grant them some leniency here. I don't expect these topics were ever discussed at length with either of them, and my perspective is obviously colored by modern bias. I just think it could've been really interesting to dive deeper into these issues, even without disregarding the historical context.
Overall, this is a sweet story and I'd recommend it. I may return to it at a later date. I'm just currently feeling thrown out of the story so I'm putting it on hold.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.