Having read The Poet’s Companion, I was initially excited to read Ordinary Genius. I was savoring hearing juicy advice and striking prompts rife with warm-hearted humor. However, the more I read, the more that my enthusiasm waned away
This isn’t a bad book, by any means. Kim Addonizio’s writing is warm and familiar. She disperses personal anecdotes about her life and experiences writing throughout, making her writing feel conversational. As a result, she feels like a kindly mentor rather than an authoritarian, which is beneficial for a poetry advice book. Nothing’s more threatening as a beginning writer than being barked at and made to feel like you’re dumb for being new to writing.
There are also some humorous bits that made me chuckle. My particular favorite has to be the line: “Poetry is a bitch” (Addonizio 57). Parts like that really make this book feel down-to-earth and for me, at least, show the human behind the pages. Swear words will never not be funny to me, especially when paired with a subject like poetry—which people often think of as being all proper and formal when it can be (and should be, in my opinion) the exact opposite.
The strongest part of Ordinary Genius is easily the fourth section where Addonizio gives advice on the business of poetry: reading it, revising your poems, sharing them–whether it’s reading them aloud or trying to publish them in a literary journal. She formats her advice for revision and close-reading as a list, which provides plenty of options for analysis and revision. In addition, she explains each piece of advice in great detail, making it easier to see where she’s coming from.
However, Ordinary Genius falters in the writing prompts. Most of the prompts in this book feel generic and lean towards safety rather than innovation. None of the prompts really grabbed me the same way they did while I read The Poet’s Companion. They just didn’t have that same original and artistic energy. So many of the prompts are so generic that they could easily be found online on some random site giving the same tired writing prompts. Many of them operate from very typical societal-mindsets: for instance, the sheer number of prompts that are romance-coded. As someone who writes on feminist themes a lot, the chapter on gender was especially disappointing in this. This book’s age really shows in this chapter. It has a very heteronormative approach to gender and sexuality. I think that Addonizio means well, but it comes off like a cishet person throwing around terms and concepts to show their progressiveness while inadvertently failing to be truly inclusive. There were a couple of gems, such as the one in the “start from language” section, but they were far and few.
This book also has the depth of a tide pool. Much of what she talks about in this book—I’ve learned about in previous creative writing classes. I’ve also been consistently writing poetry since 2022. Reading this book was constant deja-vu and not in the “wow, how amazing!” way, but the “*yawn* way. Addonizio pitches the same writing advice as everyone else and then doesn’t give sufficient depth in a way that could have at least enhanced my understanding or given me a new perspective. The advice she gives will only be striking if you’re a beginner. If you’re at least somewhat experienced in poetry like me, then what you read in this book will be nothing new.
Overall, this book is a mediocre rehash of The Poet’s Companion. It’s an okay book if you’re new to writing poetry, but even then, this wouldn’t be the first book that I would recommend. The Poet’s Companion does the same things as Ordinary Genius but better.