This one I am mixed about. Loved it as an older kid myself, and as always am a huge fan of Barbara Reid's plasticine illustrations. However I'm not big on books about bible stories, generally, nor do I love the fact that this one opens with God saying people are bad so "let them drown". We're not a religious family so I don't need my 3 year old freaking out about a vengeful god. So we usually change the words of that part. But otherwise it's a great one with good rhythm, bright, engaging illustrations, and so many creative perspectives (from above, a cross section of the boat, etc) that it totally holds up.