Humans naturally acquire languages that connect meanings with pronunciations. Paul M. Pietroski presents an account of these distinctive languages as generative procedures that respect substantive constraints. Children acquire meaningful lexical items that can be combined, in certain ways, to form meaningful complex expressions. This raises questions about what meanings are, how they can be combined, and what kinds of meanings lexical items can have. According to Pietroski, meanings are neither concepts nor extensions, and sentences do not have truth conditions. He argues that meanings are composable instructions for how to access and assemble concepts of a special sort. More specifically, phrasal meanings are instructions for how to build monadic concepts (a.k.a. mental predicates) that are massively conjunctive, while lexical meanings are instructions for how to fetch concepts that are monadic or dyadic. This allows for polysemy, since a lexical item can be linked to an address that is shared by a family of fetchable concepts. But the posited combinatorial operations are limited and limiting. They impose severe restrictions on which concepts can be fetched for purposes of semantic composition. Correspondingly, Pietroski argues that in lexicalization, available representations are often used to introduce concepts that can be combined via the relevant operations.
Pietroski lays the groundwork for a new kind of semantic theory which is not concerned with the "facts out there" or one-to-one correspondence between words and the external world, rather, Pietroski tries to show how meaning is created within the context of natural language and primarily its syntax. According to this view, meanings are sort of instructions on "how to build concepts of a special sort". The author situates his theory within the framework of Minimalist Program which aims to show what sort of mental properties are inherent to human species that allow for language acquisition. This book not only achieves to develop a somewhat novel approach to theory of meaning, but also offers very interesting insights into "classical" theories of Semantics and exposes in great detail the philosophy behind it. It's just a brilliant work of passion full of interesting discussions and relatively easy to grasp even for non-professionals.