Mandrake, my old friend, you have not aged well. Though the exact same thing can be said of me as well, especially in this context.
When I was a little girl, “Mandrake the Magician” was among my preferred forms of entertainment. Never my very favourite, not something I would go wild about, but I did like the comic rather well (as opposed to lots of cartoons, comics and fairy tales that I despised). Adventures, travels, wild animals, even wilder and crazier humans, hypnotic powers, the occasional old-school punch, and the man is wearing a tuxedo at all times. What’s not to like?
Actually… The plot might be something to leave an adult reader in quite a meh state of mind. It is insanely naïve, blunt and repetitive. At its best, “Mandrake the Magician” is still quite fun to read, albeit with a condescending chuckle. At its worst, it comes down to a banal and terribly overbearing melodrama. While the stories are more often than not poorly written, the artwork still retains its charm. The dandy illusionist with his pencil mustachios à la Clark Gable, striking a movie star pose in every single panel, the precise lines, the elaborate, yet doll-like features. Such a delight!
Another thing is that I quite easily came to terms with Mandrake and me having grown apart. I cannot really explain this change of heart, since there is enough god-awful nonsense from my childhood which I still love fiercely and passionately. Among others, I will never get over “Flash Gordon” (the comic) or “He-Man” (the animated series), just like I would fight anyone who has an objection to those, and fight dirty if I have to. With “Mandrake” everything turned out just fine: the tender memories are fine, the lack of fresh excitement is fine too. No sting in the heart, no melancholic regret.
And one final remark, just to prove that the way it has always been is not always the best option: For me personally, “Mandrake” works much better when in full colour. Somehow, black and white artwork goes well with those sophisticated graphic novels and memoires. But the pulpier a story, the more it gains from all the blue, red, green, yellow etc. it can get.