Overall, I found this memoir really interesting even though she's objectively an awful person.
(1) How does someone review a book for someone whose unlikable?
In the bonfire part she's straight up admited that the law can't touch her because of who her husband and son are and how deep they are in small town politics. So she's rich from land lording and the police chief can't touch her. Literally a villain.
How these people make money feels like something out of time. Oh he just founds a bank and hires his best friend? Oh he quits the bank and opens up real estate with his wife who has a great nursing career as his bookkeeper?
I think I would hate this woman. Landlord who got wealthy and then she's like “tree isn't good enough, get me a bridge” like wow okay entitled much.
Also just the whole “we have 4 kids but take 4 week vacations whenever because we have free child care and a black housekeeper” is some rich old time shit.
Clearly of a wealth class in Florida.
Part of this book is just her complaining. Sure why not have a 3 page chapter that you hate women who have tattoos! (no mention of men having tattoos of course).
This woman is deeply unlikable. Like the part about her nightmare of going to a dentist in Namibia because she didn’t believe Africa had competent dentists? And she was shocked the doctor was white and there was electricity. WILD to write that (and believe that).
“Whenever I went to the hospital, they gave me a baby” is legitimately funny.
Also, she talks about how she’s never sick but then needed 2 months of dental work in 2 weeks because she never went to the dentist. Ma’am that’s why we do regular check-ups! But then she admits that she knows it could be a problem, she doesn’t want to think about it now. WILD to live you’re life like that.
She has all these kids but doesn't spend Christmas with them, the people have to come to her.
The way this lady describes people is very self-aggrandizing “This girl knew nothing and then she calls me crying so that’s why I teach the needlepoint classes and she’s a great teacher from me” is very Trump-esque. Or like how her children chose their careers because of her, not because of their own choices.
Sometimes she's funny.
“I don’t need to be strong. On this ship I don’t even open my own water bottles”
“Mark Hamlisch was very nice, shame he’s dead.”
“My favorite holiday is my birthday.”
Sometimes she's just racist.
“I don’t know when the Eskimos stopped calling themselves Eskimos, but I don’t like it. I have a hard time remembering and pronouncing Inuits.” SHE DIDN’T EVEN SPELL “Innuits” RIGHT!
(2) Is she self-aware?
Like the part about her going on her scale 10 times a day. Ma’am are you just adding color to this story, or do you not realize you have an eating disorder?
Is she aware she lacks a lot of sentimentality? Like giving away or throwing away all of her photos except those she took with her. Or how when the map of pins fell down she threw it all in the trash and doesn’t keep count anymore. Or when she talks about her family.
“I adore babies, but I’m the baby now”
(3)Do you think the ship employees truly like her?
I just know this lady is horrible to be with. She says she sleeps with the tv on, but cruise ship walls are really thin. Like her neighbors can hear that!!!
The section where she’s talking about the crew she likes and only refers to them by their ethnicity instead of their name was insanely racist.
Okay that Thailand story was just that lady being anxious. I thought that she’d actually get extorted which is a real thing, but nah she’s just prejudiced. Like I wouldn’t want to be in a taxi with 2 men, with one of the men in the back, but she was so weird about it.
(4)Is this book helpful for people who want to do this life?
This lady has been cruising since 1961. Every cruise YouTuber I watch has only been doing it for less than 10 years. That's fascinating she was on ships from the 1930s.
From my YouTube watching, this lady has way more clothes than the average person and you can't get in house carpenters to make all these changes. The people with the 9 month Cruise bought magnetic shelving and did something really similar, but there wasn't like a carpenter. Also pretty sure they each only brought 3 shoes and like 12 shirts each. This lady said 75 blouses which is insane. Her cabin has got to be messy.
Also, the Crystal cruise line went bust and then was resurrected by investors. It all feels really shady, like instead of selling the line they ran up a ton of debt and then Royal Caribbean investors bought it through shell companies.
The part about shared dining and no sex politics religion for small talk at that shared dining is totally true.
The all-inclusive part is less true, every ship has add-on restaurants nowadays.
There’s a sweet spot in the history of cruising where there were the most ports open to ships during the Obama era, that does not exist anymore. I feel like she sorted of touched on this where she got to go to Iran on a cruise. My 9 month cruisers have talked about this a lot where they couldn’t see the middle east, Russia, or some of the Baltic because of current wars.
(5) Would you want this?
No, because I need an actual real medical team. LOL
No, because I don’t like this much small talk. She is consistently having to engage in small talk with semi-strangers but also fake familiarity.
No, I want to see more of the ports. I’ve watched this gay couple who have a balcony on Villa Vie and a straight couple who did the 9 month cruise and both complained the cruise didn’t stay in the ports long enough. This woman prefers the ship to the ports.
No, I would miss cooking. Like being able to just do a really elaborate meal or baked good.
HOWEVER, she did the Northwest Passage and she said it was amazing, which I’m totally jealous of.
How do y’all feel about most of the animal sighting she did on the Arctic cruise was a camerman out there with a live feed hooked up to tvs in the cruise ship. Like that’s more real than watching a nature documentary, but can she say she saw a polar bear in the wild?
Also, this woman says she never tires of the Panama Canal and all the youtubers I watch say the same thing. That it’s just a lot of fun to do the entire thing.
I’m fascinated she almost never gets off the boat except for cruise parties and to go shopping in Turkey. I feel like that’s how you can tell the age of this book, because Turkey has been having an economic crisis and isn’t the great financial shopping area it used to be. Apparently Kuşadası is the most popular cruise port in Turkey, beating out Istanbul.
(6) How different from a nursing home?
Needlepoint, dancing, afternoon tea, lecture classes, Like ya that actually sounds like a really nice life. However, the whole always meeting new people sounds exhausting you’ve got to be a sort of extrovert person but I guess in a nursing home you’ll get cliches and this way this lady can terrorize new people all the time. Also, a cruise ship probably has more classes and food than a nursing home. I do think it’s more lively and more attentive in care.
“I’ve been away from home so long, I’m a novelty” is kinda of sad? Like on one hand, I don’t want my parents around all the time. I do only see my brother on holidays. But there’s something sort of tragic about her life that I can’t quite describe. Maybe it’s because a boat feels more remote than a 6 hour drive?
(7) What did you think of her husband?
I know this lady had the love of her life and whatever but his insistence to not dance makes me side eye. My father hates musicals but who took our family to multiple musicals?
In a different life, she would have been a rich lady who did ballroom dance but was constrained in her primary hobby because of her husband.
I'm a little confused on why her husband wasn't sent oversees to Korea but I guess don't think about it?
The story of him giving a woman a can to drink out because she clumsy and her son sleeping in his clothes for a week straight all give me vibes this was not a great home to grow up in.
(8) Can we talk about the sex work?
The way this lady describes dance hosts, it’s not like “oh learn how to ballroom” in the same way people talk about watercolor classes. No, these men are ESCORTS. The fact that she keeps the tuxedo of one of the men in her closet? And pays sometimes for these men? They are GIGILOS. Sure, she’s not having sex with them, but the companionship, flirting, etc, is all a form of sex work. That’s not something I think is at most nursing homes LOL. One of the dancers said Mama Lee doesn’t actually dance as much as she says she does, and I think that’s a subtle hint that her main thing is the company.
Omg she paid her friend Marianne to come with her, that's like olden times of a woman's companion!!! That was before she found these dance hosts.
From my understanding, Cunard is the only cruise line that has dance hosts still but they're part of the entertainment crew (so more like ballroom instructors than gigolos). I've never heard a YouTuber mention them but I'd love to learn how to waltz. I also just want to do a transatlantic trip in general to feel like I’m living on the Titanic.
And she’s a groupie for a 50 year-old lounge singer? LOL.
(9) How did you like the writing of the book?
In the first chapter when she's like “my granddaughter said that this smells like luxury” I didn't realize that was separate from the fire story for a bit so I was like “wait is she on here either her granddaughter?”. However, overall I liked the style, especially the themed chapters.
It very much felt like her voice and when she had other people write in parts, I thought that was fantastic. More memoirs should have experts from other people being like “hey yes that was true”. They’re obviously a little glazing, but this lady is a narcissist anyways so it makes it a lot of fun.
(10) Is she a reliable narrator?
I do not believe that 5 days adrift at see because of engine fire would end that pleasantly. Like I'm sorry, no flush for 5 days??? Insane. Poop Cruise is on Netflix and they lost their minds. Maybe it was different back then, especially with fewer people on board, but 5 days of shitting into a bag would not be fun.
To be honest, I think she’s probably pretty reliable but we don’t remember traumatic stuff that well as humans.
For instance, she almost died when she was 16 falling off the yacht. That's the way most people die - the ship is going so fast they don't know where they lost the person and by the time they turn around it's unclear where the person went. It's why if someone does fall over, start throwing things over oard that float so that (a) person has something to float on and (b) at least a general concept of where the waves are taking the person. But I think since it’s been so long, she has this very detached feeling to almost dying. And also can’t admit how close she got since she spends all her time on that ship.
I’m not annoyed she didn’t tell us a number she spends, after reading her self-absorption and rudeness it’s exactly what I expect.
Last thing - the 12 rules, the woman catches an apple as a proposal is an old myth that is how people in Greece did proposals, coming out of the Kypria poem where Aphrodite, Athena, and Hera fight over an apple from Eris. Feels fitting this woman’s book ends on misinformation.
edit: The news articles estimate $170,000 a year. Obviously inflation means that's changed to $220,00 which seems accurate looking at Crystal's current prices. Crystal currently has a 150 night cruise that's $460 per night but that doesn't include a single supplement. I had a woman at work who was paying $430 a night to live in a nursing home (that included food, night nurse, diapers, trip to Packers games, etc). So I don't think this woman is too off on the money but I do think she's choosing something where she gets more attention and feels younger than a nursing home where you have to confront your aging.
edit 2: "Poverty to Paradise" on Youtube vlogs living most of her life on a cruise ship and she recently put out a video saying why she doesn't think it'll work for most people: (1) people burn themselves out, you've got to disengage from all of the offered activities and ports because if you did do every port you'd never have time to do stuff like go to the doctor, pay bills, go to the gym, etc; (2) having less control, you leave when the ship leaves or the weather, (3) always in the public, hard to be alone, but all those connections tend to be shallow or more long-distance based when you can see each other so dependent on your expectations/personality, (4) some people don't have enough money (she pulls it off from casino deals which I'm very skeptical of, and she even admits she sees people with gambling addictions and it can quickly go south), (5) she at least does talk about how not everyone can do this because it requires a certain level of medical fitness. She says she gets decision fatigue but she's also hoping around from ship to ship using these casino deals. That's very different from this author who had the money to stay in the same room.