The central core of this book, where the three brothers (with ample assistance from their kayaking cousin and plenty of others along the way) swim the River Eden, is pretty good. The journey is fun and fascinating as they explore new ground as well as farewelling their childhood haunts. The problem is that isn't all this book is about.
There are some good bits and Jack Hudson, youngest brother and author, throws in some really interesting bits and pieces about swimming theory, dipping into evolution and anthropology stuff, although it does often veer towards an almost evangelical zeal to get all people swimming all the time. But not all his side treks are interesting, or particularly well explained (he often presents things as accepted fact, when they're not always) and he does rather take it for granted that everyone is as lucky as he and his brothers were to grow up where they did and with such a wealth of family. Because these three have been lucky in many ways. I'm sure their childhood wasn't quite as idyllic as he often paints it, but it definitely sounds like they had an excellent time. I'm still not at all sure what the roller blading stuff had to do with anything, but still, there were definite advantages to growing up where they did and having such unfettered access to the outside world, not the mention the freedom and encouragement to explore it. Their childhood was supremely rich in opportunities that the author takes completely for granted.
I also felt cheated by the blurb, because we don't hear anything about their preparations for the swim. I'd have loved to have known more about how they set up their challenges, both the Eden swim and the Into the Maelstrom adventure. It also might have been nice to have had a little background about their Corryvrecken swim because that is thrown in without any warning and not much explanation. Not to mention how exactly they went about their training. If you're reading this hoping for advice about wild swimming and training up for a big challenge, don't bother. There are some hints and tips about swimming, but they're pretty obvious and basic, and the only real advice about wild swimming is to look up the Outdoor Swimming Society, which Google will tell me for free, and just go on and get out there, which again takes a lot of stuff for granted.
So it's not perfect. The beginning in particular is messy, starting with high drama of swimming the world's strongest maelstrom before throwing us into the heart of the author's family, which I'm sure is very interesting and affecting for those who knew them, but rather less so for those who don't. Then there's the Corryvreckan trip, which is sprung almost as a surprise. The whole book could have done with a better edit, reining in some of the self-indulgent and numerous side forays as well as clarifying a few things here and there, but once the Eden swim starts things mostly settle down and it becomes a readable adventure.
At heart, this book is really a memoir about the Hudson brothers, their family and their swimming adventures. Read it if you're interested in knowing more the Wild Swimming Brothers and their challenges. However, if you want to know how they did it, or how you can get out there and do something similar yourself, this is not the book for you. Sadly, I was in the latter category, so although I found parts of this book good it unfortunately didn't live up to my expectations.
(ARC provided by the publisher via Amazon Vine.)