The book is about two twin sisters, Victoria and Olivia. Their father’s name is Edward Henderson. They live in Croton-on-Hudson, New York. He owns a steel mills, but the person who is running it is his attorney, John Watson. Edward was sixty-five when he retired from the business, and his daughters were not allowed to run it. His had a health problem, and his daughters were never bored because they had many friends. They went to parties often. The Cortland Manor is near their home. It was her father’s home and many people come from all parts of the world to visit.
These two sisters were raised by the housekeeper. Her name was Bertie. She was an older lady, and she had poor eye side, but had a sharp mind. She knew which of the twins was who. She could tell them apart. She was like the mother who they never had. Their biological mother’s name was Elizabeth. She was the second wife who their father married. She had died from the birth of the twins, when she nineteen and he was forty. The first one died from diphtheria. That was when Edward took on the responsibility of the two girls and that was when he decided to build the Croton-Henderson Manor. His daughters moved into the home when they were only ten years old.
The twins were very different. Olivia was born eleven minutes sooner. She enjoys being the homemaker. She is the more serious and more responsible of the two. She does not like to go to parties or to the theater, nor does she like to socialize. She feels as if she were on stage, and she hates the attention. She loves to ride her horses, read books, take walks high on the cliff, and lie down on her neighbor’s field. And most of all, she enjoys taking care of her father’s home and him. These two sisters were inseparable, until one day, Victoria got into trouble with the police because she was demonstrating without a permit. Victoria was part of the Women’s Suffrage Association. This happened at the Fifth Precinct in New York. Victoria is for women’s suffrage, freedom, and independence. She wants to fight for women’s rights. She does not believe in marriage because she thinks it is barbaric and unnecessary. She likes to spend time on her own, to be mischievous, to smoke, to take her father’s car, and to go places on her own. She once told her sister that she was never going to get married.
The man who Olivia is interested in is Charles Dawson. Victoria met a man by the name of Toby Whitcomb. Olivia tells Victoria what a bad man he is; Olivia tells her that Toby would only use her and then would go back to his wife and three children. His wife was expecting her fourth one. Victoria does not care what Olivia says, so Victoria does not listen. Victoria starts to see him behind her sister’s back. Toby told Victoria that he did not want to be with his wife anymore and that he was going to divorce. While they are dancing, he is telling her all this, and she believes Toby. He says that he wants to live in Europe and to fight for women’s suffrage, but that was a lie. He uses her for sex, then gets her pregnant and leaves her alone. He wants nothing to do with her. She is a young beautiful girl, and he is an experienced man with sweet words. He is handsome and rich. She is very trusting, friendly, and innocent.
Olivia went to the bathroom, and she saw Toby’s wife who told her that he will play with her and leave her. Toby’s wife knows him and knows he will always come back to her. He had done this to her many times and most of the women were very young, unexperienced, and virgins. Victoria keeps seeing him. He would tell her that he made a terrible mistake and he had spent five years in a loveless marriage that was a lie because wealthy families do not get divorced. A divorce would be a scandal for the Astors. Victoria and Toby would meet by the library, where he would pick her up. Her father finds out that she is seeing Toby. He gets very upset with Victoria. How could she be with a married man who has sired four children?
Victoria gets pregnant by Toby. She loses the child the same way her mother did, by falling of a horse. She is in so much pain. She has to get transfusions. She is weak and confused. Olivia knows that she still loves Toby. The doctor says that the babies would have been twins. This happens when they go back to live in New York. Victoria feels betrayed by Toby. At that time, she was twenty-one, and Toby was thirty-two. They would always meet at the library. Her father does not want all the people talking about his daughter. Well, he also tells Victoria that she needs to marry Charlie. She does not want to, she is not in love with him, but the father tells her if she does not marry him, the father is going to disinherit her from his will, so she did marry Charlie. The name of Charlie’s son by another marriage is Geoffery, and he can tell Olivia and Victoria apart.
Victoria does not like to take care of the child or be in the house. She loves her freedom. Well, she got marry to the man who her sister has loved ever since she was a child. Olivia tells her twin about how she feels about him, but Victoria already knew. One day, Victoria has a serious talk with Olivia, and she explains to her how she hates to be with Charlie. Victoria does not love him, and Charlie does not love her.
Victoria tells her sister to change places with her. She will become Olivia, and Olivia becomes Victoria. For a while, Victoria wants to go to Europe and help the Allies in the war while Olivia deceives and violates her husband. Olivia says, come back in the summer of the next year: “You promise me.” “Yes, I promise,” Victoria says. So Victoria gets her things and goes on a voyage by ship in which she meets a sergeant named Morrison, who will give her a job as a nurse. So, Sergeant Morrison helps Victoria drive the patients to the hospital. She sees so many people dying in front of her. They become very good friends. She stays at his place, and they become so close that they start to have feelings for each other; she gets pregnant and has a boy. Also, Olivia has twins from Charlie, the man she loves. She names her daughters Elizabeth and Victoria and then has a boy whom she names Oliver. Sergeant Morrison dies in the war and Victoria is injured.
She is in a French hospital. Olivia goes to see her twin. When she gets there, Victoria is near death. Olivia tells her that they need to tell Charles the truth because he needs to know. Victoria says, “I will tell him,” so she does. He is angry at them for deceiving him, but then, now he loves Olivia, as well. Victoria dies, but tells Olivia to take care of her son, Oliver, so she does and Charles and Olivia marry on the ship back to their home. The End.
In my opinion, I believe that more of the story should have been set on the Titanic. It was OK to read about these two young twins who changed their identities. This would be an appropriate novel for young girls to read. It tells the truth about how naive young girls are. I would recommend it.
Belinda