What do you think?
Rate this book


352 pages, Paperback
First published January 23, 2018
Review:
Disclaimer: Super salty review coming up, due to massive generalizations by the author. These are my opinions, if you don’t agree; feel free to not tell me your views.
I would strongly like to believe that I am what the author calls “YouTube Generation”. I have grown up, in and around the time when YouTube was getting its big break, and had already established itself as one of the most entertaining apps in the history of the internet. With this in mind, let me state my argument, but one last note, I don’t have enough quotes from the book, so you’ll just have to take my word for it or read it.
My initial issue is with the fact that Allocca says that if Aliens would want to know about the human race he would give them YouTube. As it is slowly becoming a space t0 understand a “global culture” by uniting people by “showing them what they want but can’t find”. Well, okay. As of 2015, ten countries have actually banned YouTube, I am sure there might be more but who knows. Want to know how many US, Canadian and West European people make videos? Almost close to 63%. So you are telling me, 63% people, from first world countries, make up the total population of YouTube?[1] Brilliant. Moving right along, I can bet my best friend’s left arm that rural population in India won’t even know what the heck YouTube is. So what about those people? Are they not part of the culture? Is there “ignorance” towards Youtube not valid? What about places where there is an internet ban? What about very poor countries, or poor areas with no electricity? What about the hunter-gatherers tribes present in contemporary times? Yeah, where are these people?
This brings me to my next issue, which I call “The Sunny Side”. It’s all well and good that Jimmy Fallon and Kimmel knew how to use YouTube for their benefits, or how Pranks are the most viewed channels on the Tube or some other fun stuff. However there is no mention of the seemingly “dark side” of YouTube. And mind you, within the first thirty pages, he gives us categories of what sort of videos are there, but no mention of rape uploads, butchering animal videos, Beheading people or extremely hate generating videos. Everything is on the sunny side of things, oh! Look Fine Bros, or Yay, K-pop representation.
There are, however, some valid points in the book, I cannot and will not deny that. However, my issues are related to the certain generalisations, the sweeping statements and the vomit worthy homogenisation. These are “trends” yes, I mean who doesn’t like the “Why the Fuck You Lying” vine? It is relatable, peppy and useable in everyday life, but at the same time YouTube is a space for a specific culture. A culture of the privileged. It is made up of people with somewhat similar backgrounds, reacting to certain videos in a certain way, have almost the same wavelength of thought.
What about the silent voices? Where are the other people? What about other genres within YouTube, even? What about the dark side? What about communication and the lack of it?
No matter how much you feel you can connect with someone, via discussions or talks or I don’t know, personal vlogging. It is voyeuristic, and more than it being voyeuristic, it is one sided. They will never hear me, and I in turn will only end up copying or dreaming about the kind of life they have. One starts imitating, and from person experience, losing their own sense of self worth and love. But Hey! Whenever you feel like this, just watch some white dude talking about self worth and self love and you’ll be great again.
Uh, no, thanks.
Also, totally cringe worthy quote of some dude whose name I can’t remember, saying (and I am paraphrasing), that the world has to reconcile with the fact that all communication is now going to happen online and how “cathartic” it is. This is an absolutely dreadful situation, (which is partly true), and the root cause for alienation, loneliness and mental illness too. Try contesting me on this.
So to sum up, the argument in the book, did not sit well with me, a brown, female, young adult from a developing country. And truly this isn’t even about race or gender, this book is pure evasion of obvious facts. So tread carefully.
[1] These percentages might be a little 10-20, but most sites agree on this number.