Rating: minus 15 on a scale of minus 15 to plus 5.
This revision made possible by YouTube - Twelfth Doctor/Without Reward, Ms Modeller, Drew's Model Bench, Greg's Models, Mann's Model Moments, Claus Kellerman POV, Leeja Miller, Keffals, The Ritual Kitchen with Laura May, Red Glasgow, Kozak Siromaha, Feminist Cat Lady Spinster, Eugenia from Ukraine, Lily Simpson,
AllShorts, Offizier Amira, Anka Daily News, Reese Waters, Yarmak, Mia Mulder, Twinshangout, Supertanskiii, Owen Jones, Cindy's Villa, Cruising Alba, Cruising Crafts, Sailing Melody, Irish Mytholgy, Kimberly Rogers, Shitty Book Club, Kyiv Independent, Jormungandr, Mercado Media, HBomberGuy, Verilybitchie, Tom Nicholas, Love Life Triumph, Dig it with Raven, The Enemy from Within, Tea amid Chaos,
Ro Ramdin, Bobbing Along, Crow Caller, Verilybitchie, Emma Thorne, Jess Owens, Planarwalker, Gary's Economics, May's Narrowboat Life, Dark Side of Russia, Gutsick Gibbon, Dr Ben Miles, Megalithhunter, Ukraine Matters, I'm Rosa, Jess of the Shire, Jen the Librarian, OrangeRiver, Wednesday, Shades of Orange, Biz, Dangerous Ones,
Kazachka, Jake Broe, The Military Show, NFKRZ, Riverboat Jack, Ship Happens, Some More News, FAFO, ATP Geopolitics, Queen Penguin, Eckharts Ladder, RFU News, Eileen, Lady of the Library, Renegade Cut, Belinda Carr, Barry's Economics,
Media Death Cult, Engineering Knits, Sanctioned Ivan, Quinn's Ideas, Alt Shift X, Fit 2B Read, Shannon Makes, Break and Remake, Ukraine Calling, Leftist Cooks, Dr Fatima, The Russian Dude, Geo Girl, Interesting Times, Ukraine Today, The Scale Modeller, Model Minutes, Art in the Corridor, The Gaze, The Great War, Jay Exci, DamiLee,
Reads With Rachel, Silicon Curtain, Mynameismarines, Rebecca Watson, Strange Aeons, Times Radio, The London History Show, Kings and Generals, History with Kayleigh, Turn Left, Munecat, Scotland History Tours, Parkrose Permaculture, Miniminuteman, Real Time History, Parkrose Permaculture, Sally's Economics,
Tom Nicholas, Karolina Zebrowska, Philosophy Tube, Asturia Quartet, A Very Casual Librarian, Think that Through, Econ Lessons, Maggie Mae Fish, Chris Norlund, Demetra Kaye, Gingers are Black, David Wiley, Aid Thompsin, Unlearning Economics, Gary's Economics, RevolutionarythOt, New Enlightenment with Ashley, Up and Atom.
I saw an idiot who whilst insulting an essayist whom I admire, complain to her that I list trans creators. I think that the Snowflake (idiotic, rabid, possibly MAGA related US tittie-baby) syndrome may have become epidemic. A trigger warning then.
I list channels with the sewist, communist, het, mathematician, Irish, WOC, asexual, archaeologist, military historian, trans, redhaired, German, military modeller, farmer, intersex, miniatures painter, pensioner, train modeller, military boardgamer, queer, Kenyan, physically challenged, communist, military historian, Van lifestyle, boat restorer, intersex, Canadian, sociologist, lumber yard worker, architect, other boardgamer, Australian, fashion historian, autist and other creators known as Women.
Almost as disturbing to wilfully proud ignorance are the channels with anarchist, tailor, Scottish, other BIPOC, boater, train historian, zoologist, chemist, other fashion historian, economist, atheist, ginger, Cornish, political commentator, philosopher, other LGBTQIA+, book reviewer, engineer, futurist, other fashion historian, wood worker, Indian, news presenter, game historian, other neurodivergent, paleontologist, chess instructor and other creators known (outside the US) as Human Beings.
If the voices be not stilled, seek emergency therapy and\or develop a new skill, such as critical thinking and\or beg for immediate pastoral counselling.
My feelings towards these members are similar to that of the 13 Ukrainian marines defending Snake Island, when their surrender was demanded by the Russian navy. Their response was "Russian warship, go f@ck yourself." Slava Ukraini. Slava Heroyam. Crimea is Ukraine.
Once more unto the book, dear friends. I did not like the book's opening, though it seemed almost interesting. There are no worldbuilding, character development, reasonable dialogue or plausible interactions. Plot hole and contrivance made identifying a storyline difficult. There are several underlying themes, which are probably the point of the book.
The three themes are "the USA logically dominates all human space", "Canada and Mexico only exist as countries at the sufference of the USA" , "The US produces the Best and the Brightest of humanity". These are the common underpinning of almost all Amazon spacey-space boom-boom books. These do not seem to have aged well. 😊
The system government had no explanation or politics because the writer seems to have had no clear mental picture. Based on other books he might have no mind but that is pure speculation.
The expedition is launched by an unnamed organisation possessed of unexplained resources and power, whether governmental, military or corporate is unknown. Their purpose is unknown.
This colony expedition is crewed by the "Best and the Brightest" of the human race, as usual all are US citizens. The character names are drawn as usual, from a smaller naming pool than that of the Roman Empire, There is diversity in that women are part of the crew, probably required for entertainment or breeding .
A YouTuber discussed an interview with Astronaut Glenn, wherein it was considered that it would be feasible to use the entertainment weight allowance to include a female astronaut. All but the female reporter laughed.
There is an unrealistic military plotline, if a plot can be said to exist. There is no evidence of editing and the book can best be described as forgettable, boring and poorly written.
Consider treating this as a hostile site. 🤔
Goodreads discourse does not exist. As example, four years ago now, I wrote a short negative review of Powers of the Earth by Travis Corcoran.
The book (in no way a novel) was originally blurbed as similar to a Heinlein classic but was instead a bad imitation of "Atlas Shrugged" set on the Moon.
My opinion was that a story of a rich twit enlisting the military in overthrow of a US government in order that he not pay taxes was dangerous, unhealthy and now prophetic.
The writer Travis Corcoran, self-described as libertarian (now more posh, anarcho capitalist without millions), employee of an unnamed US agency, veteran,
advocate of the return of chattel slavery (popular opinion in the US with prison labour to be supplemented by forced labour prisons for the ICE detained and the unhoused, including poor Van and RV citizens and children. With their poverty now criminalised, I see no pathway to their release.
Given that these are being designed to include special furnaces for disposal of biologicals, the disappearances of thousands already, no objection by either Party, US history, the suggestion having been offered by a Republican candidate for federal office in 2010 with no scandal, a Fox news presenter less than a year ago offering execution as an alternative and generational enslavement and\or Nazi population reduction seem on the cards.),
admirer of Putin (popular in the US which is surprising as Russia do have prison colonies with associated cruelties but no death penalty).
Travis and six patriotic fellows were outraged by my seeming defence of their democratic system. They spent almost a year and pages demanding my response. No mention of the book's overlooked qualities was made, though many thoughtful insights were gifted me.
Among things I had not known included that my refusal to engage was narcissism, slavery is a social good, white European men created all history, my intelligence was deficient, women readers have limited ability to understand "hard" science fiction and more.
Their generosity did not extend to an opinion on the spread of proto Indo-Aryan languages. i was disappointed. The levels of irony pained my poor communist soul.
Claes Rees Jr aka çgr710 now ka Clayton R Jesse Jr (now longer identifying as Nazi) delivered the final comment. After referencing the contents of my last message exchange with a Goodreads friend, he declared that They had "won" (?).
It developed that They had launched a year long flood of vile sexual, anti-LGBTQIA, racist and anti-socialist comments against channels which I mentioned. It continues still.
The economist, mathematician, historian, political commentator and other female creators were not impressed by what must have been a charm offensive..
Despite that, the global overabundance of unpleasantness was successfully increased and an accurate self-portrait of the snowflake (stupidly vicious, barely literate, emotionally stunted US man-child) was delivered to a multinational audience.
On balance, quite the Victory. If the least bit disturbed by the above, there are BookTubers to direct you to saner, safer, useful reader forums.
That comment stream was more intense but little different to other comment streams until the Australian intervention.
This next made possible by YouTube - Doctor\Be Kind, Brigitte Empire, Ukraine News TV, Silicon Curtain, Mynameismarines, Truth to Power, IzzzYzzz, Veritas et Caritas, Filaxim Historia, Ancient Americas, Artur Rehi, TIKHistory, Authentic Observer, Bellum et Historia, Dan Davis History, Military Aviation History, Dust and Glory,
Emperor Tigerstar, Matriarchetype, LuckyBlackCat, Fun Size Reader, Patrick(H)Willem, Linguoer Mechanic, Yankee Farm Wife, Vasya in the Hay, Historical Fashion, Break and Remake, Books N Cats, The Cosy Creative, Lily Alexandre, Shannon Makes, Bernadette Banner, Boat Time, Scotland HIstory Tours, Mr Newberger's AI Funnies,
Reads with Rachel, Austin McConnell, Book Furnace, Scifi Odyssey, Delamer, Jean's Thoughts, Lily Simpson, Fall of Civilisations, No Justice, Novara Media, Jessie Gender, Kayla Says, Cecilia Blomdahl, Hoots, ScaredKetchup, Dreamloop Cinema,
Hannah Fry, Amie's Literary Empire, Ponderful, Stam Fine, Savy Writes Books, Table Top CP, Unlearning Economics, Joe Brennan, Lore Reloaded, Quinn's Ideas, Joe Blogs, Rebecca Watson, Dark Brandon, KernowDamo, Military Rated, Olga Mieleszuk, GothamChess, Lindsay Ellis, Mary Trump Media, Led by Donkeys,
Media is Fay, Gabi Belle, Azul Crescent, Science Fiction with Damien Walter, Tardis Central, Strange Aeons, Oceanliner Designs, Star 17, JimmyTheGiant, Contrapoints, Philosophy Tube, Secret Sauce of Storytelling, Alexa Donne, SK Media, Rowan Ellis, Rina Sayama, MGW Studios, MechWest Show, Liz Webster, Queen City Minis,
Cold Fusion, Victoria Rose, DylanBurns TV, Make Better Media, Pike and Shot Channel, Sarah Dawn Moore, Cleo Abram, Not Even Emily, Library Ladder, Discourse Minis, Players Aid, Horses, Adam Something, Certifiably Ingame, ThunderFoot, Amadeus Quartet, Scholars Shelves, Feral Historian, Tara Farms, Farm to Taber,
Perimeter Institute, World Science Festival, AllShorts, ScaredKetchup, Steve Shives, Engineering with Rosie, Jesse Dollemore, Tom Powell, Fraser Cain, Stefan Milo, Peter Stefanovic, Military History Visualized, Paul Whitewick, Luke Sherlock,
Brothers Gwynne, Invicta, Atun Shei Films, Nomadic Crobot, Nikki Carreon, Chris and Shell, Answer in Progress, Epimetheus, Told in Stone, Jabzy, The People Profiles, Red Glasgow, aidan knight, Gittemary Johansen, Cruising on the Border.
Ominous music begins. 😊 The comment gangs are a feature of Goodreads. They are quite active in both speculative fiction and romance/romantasy spaces. Amazon do not discipline mental members, punish writers who organise Them or dismiss employees who enable both. The exception being if a reader should have issues with misogynistic, racist, ableist or other problematic elements, it is very possible that your review will be deleted as being the "Hate Speech". Very American.
My limited message history was given over to these madmen, which resulted in Australian Intelligence through a Pine Gap request interrogating the one friend whom I occasionally messaged. The attempt at my personal history failed.
Amazon was unresponsive until we began sharing our bizarre experience. In place of explanation or other, Amazon returned my page format and options to normal, masked all comments healthy and insane both, disappeared all Lurkers whom I had not been Allowed to remove, even stopped bricking my Kindle periodically, for kicks I imagine.
I did receive a notification that Kindle no longer support Goodreads and icon was removed. I am much relieved. 😀
I suggest several precautions. Remove any personal information from profile and avoid the messaging. Remove the lurker, those who never post. They are likely gang monitors or employee dummies.
With the Goodreads penchant for Altering customer pages, screenshots of the odd, ugly and threatening are invaluable.
If you own a Kindle, things become interesting. Do Not use Kindle Files, Contacts, Calendar or Email. Kindle Sign Into customer emails without notice or permission. Make of that what you will.
Do Not purchase Amazon ebooks, as you own only the device (if Kindle, even that is conditional). Your purchases may be deleted at whim. If pirchased download titles immediately. There are YouTubers to guide you to alternative ebook and tablet vendors as well as alternatives to ebook purchase altogether.
Silk searches should of course, be non-critical and innocuous.
Any temporary immunity rests on the whims of seriously damaged employees. These employees and crazed members both, embrace no non-Randian morality, have contempt for their fellows/customers and are US patriots with all that implies. Elbows Up! Ominous music ends. 😊
Be safe and may we all discover Good Reading. 🤗
This next is courtesy of Ash L G, Electro Swing, Hat Historian, The Chloe Connection, Sci-Fi Odyssey, Geo Girl, AllShorts, Some More News, The Histocrat, The British Museum, Simon's Modelling Shed, Riley Knoxx, Paul Warburg, Hannah Fry,
Mythology and Fiction Explained, Art Deco, Interior Design Hub, The Who Addicts, Rachel Hardy, Hannah Lee Kidder, Amy Lee, The Historian's Craft, Books and Things, Library Ladder, The Closet Historian, Morgan Donner, Aditu Laudis, Agro Squirrel Narrates, Postmodern Jukebox, 3rd regiment SOF, The Book Leo., Josh Johnson.
I began spending time on YouTube a bit more than 4 years ago, searching for useful science fiction commentary. I found those channels and also quickly became a fan of educational, hobby, essayist and lifestyle videos. After discovering Lindsay Ellis 😍, I accidentally found my first book channel. 😍 The book channels host communities of thoughtful readers, enamoured of all things bookish and are very different to whatever Goodreads have become.
Some of my favourite YouTube channels.
National Centre for Military Intelligence, Russian Media Monitor, Ash L G, Sabine Hossenfelder, Maggie Mae Fish, Some More News, Oceanliner Designs, Novara Media, Tom Nicholas, EarleWrites, TVP News, Kiko1006 - Empire of Angels, What Vivi did next, J Draper, Planet D, Odin's Call, Literary Archaeology,
Boat Time, Well Deck Diaries, Driftwood Folk, Tara Mooknee, Elvira Bary, Brandon Fisichella, Council of Geeks, Real Time History, Tom Nicholas, Snappy Dragon, Abney Park, Bobbing Along, Mech West Show, WokeGardener, Oliver Lugg, DW News,
Dungeons and Discourse, Belle of the Ranch, Paola Hermosin, Kathy's Flog from France, Dominic Noble, Jessica Kellgren Fozard, Jessie Gender, Spacedock, Military & History, Biz, Kris Atomic, Leena Norms, France 24, Then & Now,
Elina Charatsidou, Isaac Arthur, Adult Wednesday Addams - 2 seasons, The Book Leo, J Life of Lit, Deerstalker Films, Guard the Leaf, Lorna Jane Adventures, Travelling K, Olga Mieleszuk, DUST, Tank Museum, Vlad Vexler, Prime of Midlife, Eileen, Ponderful, ContraPoints, ConeOfArc, Kozak Muzon, Cossack and Caucasus Sword Dance,
Tank Encyclopedia, Central Crossing, Alizee, Alice Cappelle, Just Write, Of Herbs and Altars, Amanda The Jedi, Dr Becky, Strange Aeons, JuLingo, BookslikeWhoa, Elizabeth Filips, Read Rant Review, RevolutionarythOt, Kaz Rowe, Shaun, OliSunvia, Xiran Jay Zhao, The Leftist Cooks, T. A. Summers, Alex Fleev, Red Viburnam Song,
Octopus Lady, Quinn's Ideas, OrangeRiver, Jess of the Shire, Engineering Knits, Omeleto, It's Black Friday, NerdForge, Artur Rehi, Sanna Vaara, RevolutionarythOt, Bookish Chas, Hardy's Books, Valhalla Drums. ExtinctZoo, Chem Thug.
I wish you a splendid morning, a fantastic afternoon, a cosy evening, a pleasant night and may we all continue learning.
If Another speaks for you, Adopt their sins.
My Grandmother