This book can be enjoyed on several levels, which all work together. On the most primitive level, it tells a wonderful story. The tale of Jeremy Corbyn’s rise to power is the stuff of fairy stories – the complete outsider whose candidature in a contest is regarded as a joke, but who wins the top prize. The tale is a gripping one: getting Corbyn on to the ballot with literally seconds to spare; the sudden unexpected taking off of his campaign; the hysterical attempts by horrified New Labour politicians and journalists to appeal to Labour Party members not to vote for him; the smear campaigns; the final unbelievable result. It is also a highly entertaining story, wittily told. There were many times when I laughed out loud; for instance, at this quote from an article put out by Progress, the New Labour equivalent of Momentum: “three candidates with a reasonable chance of winning made it through [to the ballot]. Jeremy Corbyn did also.”
On another and still rather basic level, the book satisfies curiosity and love of gossip by letting the reader into the detailed internal workings of the Labour Party, the unions and the Corbyn campaign team.
But beyond these somewhat primitive levels (important though they are to the reader’s enjoyment) is a deeply serious and complex analysis of the reasons for Corbyn’s victory. Though we were all left rubbing our eyes in disbelief, Jeremy Corbyn did not become Leader of the Labour Party because his fairy godmother waved a magic wand or because Labour Party members had experienced a fit of midsummer madness or the “collective nervous breakdown” that they were accused of suffering in the wake of Ed Miliband’s disastrous defeat in the May 2015 general election.
Nunns explains the historical and political reasons for Corbyn’s victory: the end of Blairism and neo-liberalism as a result of the Iraq War and the financial crash of 2008; a new voting rule – opening the leadership contest up to supporters who paid £3 - that ironically was intended to boost the Blairites, because of their delusion that voters from the non-existent “centre ground” would flood in; the ability of social media to galvanise the grassroots; the leftward movement of the unions, crushed by Thatcher and despised by New Labour - they had been moving left “under the radar” and were prepared to back Corbyn, and they also helped to bring about the new one member, one vote voting system which reduced the power of MPs; new social trends - led by the anti-austerity movement, and linked to similar campaigns around the world- that were looking for a focus and a leader.
Though Corbyn is the ostensible hero of the story, he is not, as he would be in a fairy-story, the individual hero who triumphs against the odds. He was a lowly backbencher for 30 years, but was involved in numerous left wing and human rights causes. He had gained the respect and admiration of adherents of these causes, who rallied to his support.
To take the Palestinian solidarity movement: on the one hand, Corbyn’s advocacy of the Palestinian cause left him vulnerable to a smear campaign, concocted by an alliance between the Blairite, Tory and Israel apologist press (such as the Jewish Chronicle), to try to discredit him on the grounds of associating with anti-Semites. On the other hand, Corbyn was bolstered by support from Jewish pro-Palestinian groups. Nunns quotes from two letters in defence of Corbyn: the Open Letter from prominent Jewish activists published in the Jewish Chronicle and a letter written on behalf of Jews for Justice for Palestinians that was printed in the Guardian.
Despite its title, “The Candidate” is not really about Corbyn, whose lack of personal charisma is actually an asset. The real hero of the book is the social movement itself, the grassroots that suddenly found itself empowered – the ordinary people who worked indefatigably and recruited more and more people as it became clear that Corbyn could win.
Nunns’s analysis leaves the reader with a sense of hope mingled with apprehension. The denouement was not a fairy-tale, happy-ever-after ending – it was only the beginning, as Nunns brings out in the Afterword about the failed coup after the 2016 Brexit vote. The story continues; we are still living it. Nunns is clear and realistic about the many threats that still remain. Attempts to discredit Corbyn continue, as was made clear by the recent Home Affairs Select Committee Report into antisemitism. The media remain hostile and Corbyn’s poll ratings among the general public continue to be low. But Nunns’s explanations leave the reader with a sense of hope that, founded as it is not in individual ambition and with roots that are not shallow but on the contrary deeply and broadly planted in the fertile soil of society, the Corbyn movement can survive, grow, flower and reach fruition.