— • 4.5 • —
I started writing this review straight after finishing this book at like 3am so apologies if I get carried away with words at some points because I was in the moment. It did take me about a week to finish this review though as the more I thought about it, the more things I would come up with to add. And I would just keep on coming back without finding a way to end it. I did however decide to add a summery of the whole series at the end so well done if you make it all the way down to that.
So first things first, I was quite concerned when I first saw the size of the book since it is probably over 100 pages shorter than the previous two books and probably the length of a couple chapters of Game of Thrones (ha), which I finished just before. I thought this was weird for a final book in a trilogy, you would expect it to be bigger right? and so I was worried Derek Landy had kinda gotten fed up with the series (probably since it didn’t take off in popularity like Skulduggery did) and so just wanted to wrap everything up as quick as he could and get back to the Skeleton Detective. I think while writing this review I will work out if this was the case or not.
Now as expected this book was fast paced as hell from start to finish, and when I say fast paced I really mean it. There wasn’t many times where you could take a breath from all the action, and whenever you thought you could there would be even more action. Conversations were quick and simple to follow and there wasn’t ever any heavy descriptions. Everything felt like a smooth well oiled machine with only one goal in mind, ditch the unessesary and speed through this story. Which is contrary to a complaint I made on the previous book, that we’d occasionally be bogged down by side plots with characters that didn’t interest us as much as Amber and Milo. But here it seems Derek heard my call from the future because now we get the story from Ambers POV all the way through, and any sidetracks that do go on add to the story and more importantly, still involves the main characters. This makes the journey a great thrill with lots of memorable moments to pick out, reminiscent to what I said was so special about the first Demon Road book.
Throughout I could feel myself being pulled towards the finale. We get to reunite with characters good and bad from the previous books, (though it doesn’t end well for many of them...) and we got our resolution with Glen that I was so desperate for at the end of Desolation.
Some random moments that stood out for me was when we discover why Amber kept taking selfies now and again without any explanation, I thought it was a really bizarre thing to do at the time, but finding out why was awesome and clever writing. I also peaked during the final fight when I literally shouted (in my head of course) ‘USE THE HORN’ and boom she used the horn. It was at that moment I knew I was connected with Derek Landy on a deep creative level...
Talking about Derek, he really outdid himself with the damn shocks and cliffhangers in this book. I mean you would think by now that I would have grown to expect that something crazy might happen at any point. It is the way of the Derek Landy. It’s something I’ve grown accustomed to in the Skulduggery books. You would think. But no, he still manages to catch me off guard. A reminder that he is in full control of this story, and these characters and my emotions and nobody is safe. And that leads me on to the ending... we’re into big spoilers here... Just when you thought everything had been resolved and that we got the ending we all wanted, just when you thought you were safe... Heartbreak. It’s not often that a book makes you physically sit up saying ‘no no no’... I had barely forgiven Derek for the gruesome shock earlier on in the book that left me gobsmacked to the point I had my head in my hands. But this... This was just Derek laughing at our poor souls. This was just unfair.
Now from here my review turns into a bit of rant... because hindsight 20/20. Now what I keep asking myself is, was the fast pacing and the small size of this book a good thing or not? Part of me liked it because as described earlier, it’s a page-turner and so I wanted to see what happens next and get to the end as fast possible... But on the other hand you lose sooo much depth by speeding through a story. I feel like we definitely could have gotten much more, more meaningful character interactions and more explanations. There was room to do so. But instead we’re left filling in the gaps with our own presumptions.
I would have liked there to be more development between Amber and her Demon self. Yes it’s alluded she won’t be consumed by her because in their last conversation it’s said that if she drinks the last vial she will lose control, and she never does. So Amber no longer see’s her? I mean I presume not, because it was the blood that was bringing on those hallucinations in the first place and now there isn’t any. But it’s still part of her. Yes we see her beginning to accept herself as Amber, but I would have liked to see how she’s come to terms with her Demon self too. Also her dreams of her brother and sister, what was the overall purpose of that? Reading the blurb ‘her future lies in her families past...’ But did it though? Sure it was a nice touch but for something so intriguing I was expecting it to accumulate to something more exciting than what we did ultimately find out. It wasn’t anything super crazy. Idk maybe I skimmed through an important part too quickly and missed it.
The building to the end is also worth discussing. I usually quite enjoy when Derek gets creative with his structure, like giving us cliffhangers followed by a 2 word chapter just to really mess with us. And I could see the purpose of this short chapter jumping as it built up the pace even more towards the grand finale we were all eagerly waiting for. You often see scenes like these in movies and it’s an interesting touch to wrap up loose ends in a simple manner. But part of me feels like this was a bit of a cop out. Like he couldn’t be bothered to go into these parts because he thought we wouldn’t be bothered with them. Some of the characters I couldn’t even remember who they’re were, and we had a longer conversation with one of them at the start of the book then at the end during their actual death scene. In this case it all happened a bit too quickly and the fact that we had basically empty pages was a bit suspect when the book is already tiny as it is. I could see that I didn’t have much of the book left so I felt like I was loosing pages that should have been used for a more fulfilling ending.
Now for the ending (pre-shock). It was an great ending but I was expecting more for a finale to a trilogy. Everything started feeling like the last season of Game of Thrones where even though some parts are really epic, it just doesn’t hit the spot. Firstly I really couldn’t really be bothered with these ‘Foundation of Light’ people. Their reveal at the end just felt like a teaser scene you get after the credits of a film. All of the sudden they’re not cops hunting her and they’ve been ‘good guys’ all along?... doing basically the same job as the the group of Scooby Doo guys in the previous book just more authoritatively? The family relations part of it was interesting but we didn’t really gain anything from finding that out other than it conveniently helping during the final fight. There’s also the whole final charade of Amber fooling her parents and completely confusing me in the process. I get that Derek was leaving us out of the loop/plan so that the double cross/triple cross, idk how many crosses there were, would surprise us as much as the characters, and it did. But there was 2 points where I actually had to stop and go back to see if I had missed a chapter or some important detail I might have skimmed over. I’d have liked more info on Clarissa too and before I forget, which I almost did, the reveal of who the Priest is....? I mean how are you gonna drop that surprise on us with no explanation at all. Nothing. It was epic, don’t get me wrong, but I want to know more! Why was he there to meet her before? Was this his goal all along or is he just cleaning up the mess? Why does he show kindness towards Amber? It just leaves us with more questions than answers.
Then we return to the heartbreaking shock that I mentioned earlier. I won’t say his name, though you’ll probably be able to guess who it is, but like jokes aside... He did not deserve to die. (Okay yes I get that he kinda did because of all the bad things he has done in the past) but no, you do not give us that character development, the fact that he was now free to live a normal life and find some sort of happiness and meaning, just for you to kill him like that. Out of nowhere. By a side character that I didn’t even care to care about. And how dare you put us through the pain of not being able to save him. He was twice the character Amber is.
The subsequent Epilogue was a ‘nice ending’ for the characters that remain but it was overshadowed by what had just happened before it. We didn’t get any time to grieve and we didn’t get to hear any of the characters thoughts. Nothing about how Amber felt after her loss, nothing about how important their friendship was or how she will cope without him. It was just oof he dead, here’s 1 year later where they’re just living their best life now like nothing happened. The ending just left me heartbroken instead of fulfilled.
Look, this wouldn’t be the first time that my rant reviews make a book look terrible when in reality it was still very enjoyable. I just like being critical. Now it’s all over I just wish those conversations were a few pages longer, or those descriptions a little more detailed. Because I was really into it, the world and the characters, and of course if something’s awesome you want more of it! It’s just a shame it has come to an end because I feel like there’s a whole lot more to offer with this series.
I honestly thought the first book was one of the best books I read last year and I would gladly pick it up again some time. It had the Derek Landy charm that I was used to but in a new world with new characters, a story that had so many memorable moments and most importantly a lot of depth to it. I only have good things to say about it which is why I rated it so highly. The second, struggled from the classic issues of a sequel. It was detailed and action packed but simply not as good as the first. Then here, the third and final book gave us a no nonsense race to climax that everything had culminated to. I guess we got what we came for.
I loved the series as a whole but the problem is it’s always going to be compared to Skulduggery Pleasant. Firstly because it’s the only other thing Dereks written but also because he’s made them so similar. - A teenage, female, main character who has to fight her powerful inner demons, with a wiser partner who is ‘magical’ in some way and shows her the ropes, with a 3rd sidekick who’s a bit of a goofball. Even down to the fact that both main characters in each series come out as bisexual! At this point Valkyrie and Amber are practically the same person, as though Derek just couldn’t escape his beloved characters and the tried and tested formula he’s already created. That’s where the problem lies because side by side this trilogy expectedly isn’t as good as Skulduggery. It lacks the depth, it lacks the level of character chemistry that you get after 12 books, and even though it’s supposed to be darker and more gruesome, you’ve still got the same witty storytelling that Derek is accustomed to.
For these reasons l would rate the overall series a 4 or maybe even 4.5 stars and I’d strongly recommend it to anyone I know. It really was a mad ride down the Demon Road.