2.5 stars
Ginger's friend Rev. Oliver Hill is about to be married at long last! Ginger senses there is something not quite right and both the bride and groom have cold feet. Yet, they are both determined to go through with it, even after the choirmaster falls over the railing dead. Ginger has a murder to solve and a romance to make right. Her own love life is starting to pick up. Ginger is stepping out with Canadian naval captain William Beale, but her heart doesn't flutter the way it does with Basil. Basil has been in self-imposed exile but returns to solve the murder mystery with out without Ginger's help. Ginger is in-all in!
This story started off light enough but got really dark. I absolutely can not stand abusers or men who claim to be "weak" and "allowed" women to seduce them, especially in a situation like the one presented in the book. I dropped my rating because of this. I figured out who the murderer was by process of elimination. I thought it was someone else because I had guessed their secret early on. The end of the novel is SUPER rushed! I would have liked more courtship and romance with the focus on Oliver's wedding and not Ginger's love life.
The murder victim, Mr. Theodore Edwards, is a nasty man who will not be missed by most of the congregation. He was hard on his wife and everyone else. I couldn't believe his appalling treatment of his wife in public no less. I feel very sorry for her because she stays with him presumably because there is no other option and it would cause a scandal to divorce him. Esme is not the nicest of women or easiest to get along with but she and her husband bring out the worst in each other. A divorce, scandalous as it may be, may have been a better option. Of course there's always murder, which she claims she didn't do, but the motive is strong. Her sister-in-law Catherine is a nervous sort of woman who wants everyone to get along. She blindly worships her brother. Other ladies in the choir include Miss Marjorie Bertram, a singularly naive and silly young woman and Miss Anna Howard, another silly young woman. Mary Blythe, a quiet dentist’s receptionist, the bride to be, is mysterious and keeps her feelings to herself. She is shy and dislikes being the center of attention. I can relate but why is she marrying a vicar if she would rather elope? Mary has secrets which I found obvious. One male suspect, Mr. Piper, is a bit cantankerous and doesn't seem to like Mr. Edwards very much.
Oliver is such a sweetheart. He loves his congregation and is kind and chivalrous. His chivalry gets him into trouble sometimes because he must play rescuer. We finally meet Ginger's sister Louisa, who is even more immature and obnoxious that Felicia. Louisa's brash American speech, blatant flirtation and rudeness to everyone "beneath" her is enough to drive even Ginger crazy! Louisa makes Felicia look mature! Felicia has learned her lesson and decided to embrace the flapper lifestyle once and for all. Armed with newfound knowledge, she is ready for fun. I still find her vastly irritating and don't agree with her lifestyle choices. She still butts heads with her grandmother who is trying to put one tiny toe into the modern age while the rest of her is stuck in the Victorian era. Felicia needs to be sent to be a companion to some elderly relative even more annoying than her grandmother and that will cure her of her behavior. Matilda Hanson returns and shows that she's not just a pretty face. She's very kind and sweet but I disagree with the decision she makes in the end.
I was very disappointed Haley exits the story early on after receiving shocking news from Boston. The news didn't surprise me and I'm not sure she warrants her own spin-off series. It sounds too dark for me.
Ginger has two suitors in this novel. Captain William Beale, Ginger's new gentleman friend, is not right for her. He's too old-fashioned and snobby, not to mention very jealous. I didn't like his behavior when drinking. Basil returns with a personality transplant. He's no longer brooding but openly ready to declare his feelings for Ginger. She isn't sure how she feels. I didn't like how fast Basil moves. The resolution to their love story happens too quickly with too easy an out. One minute he loves his wife and she's still mourning Daniel and now all of a sudden the sparks have turned into love? Not my cup of tea.
One more murder mystery and one novella left to go in this series.