The Amish Candymaker

The Amish of Mackinac County #2

by Laura V. Hilton

A letter brings him to Mackinac County. Can one woman make him stay?

Agnes Zook has found herself on her own after in small Amish community in Mackinac County after a tragedy took the life of her parents and siblings. Most of the Amish call her “off in den Kopf” (strange) since she’s starting her own business and forging her own way in the community instead of relying on the bishop to take care of her. Since she’s viewed as non-submissive and too-forward for an Amish woman she’s not courted by other young men in the area.

Isaac Mast is on the verge of leaving the Amish church. He’s become a sought-after Auctioneer and has a thriving business, but he feels confined by the strict rules. When his brother is severely injured in a wild fire, Isaac receives a letter from his sister-in-law, begging him to come to Mackinac County to help out while his brother is hospitalized for skin grafts and his wife is with him. They have young children that can’t be left alone. Isaac agrees but is unsure how to manage the children when he has weekend auctions he’s expected to attend. Agnes may be an answer to prayer.

When Isaac and Agnes meet, sparks fly, but everything changes. While neither of them fit within the structures of the Amish faith, could their differences be the one thing that helps them form a deeper connection to their faith...and each other?

Genres: Amish, Amish Fiction, Romance, Fiction, Christian Fiction, Inspirational

255 pages, Paperback

Published February 5, 2019

About the author

Award winning author, Laura Hilton, her husband, Steve, and their five children make their home in Arkansas. She is a pastor’s wife, a stay-at-home mom and home-schools. Laura is also a breast cancer survivor.

Her publishing credits include three books in the Amish of Seymour series from Whitaker House: Patchwork Dreams, A Harvest of Hearts (winner of the 2012 Clash of the Titles Award in two categories), and Promised to Another. The Amish of Webster County series, Healing Love (finalist for the 2013 Christian Retail Awards). Surrendered Love and Awakened Love followed by her first Christmas novel, A White Christmas in Webster County, as well as the Amish of Jamesport series, The Snow Globe, The Postcard, and The Birdhouse. Other credits include Swept Away from Abingdon Press’ Quilts of Love series. Laura is contracted for another three book Amish series set in the Jamesport area, with the first book, The Amish Firefighter, planned for April 2016.

She has self-published a Christmas novella, Christmas Mittens.

Laura is a member of American Christian Fiction Writers and a professional book reviewer and blogs for Putting on the New and Seriously Write.

Reviews

[Susan · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Amish Candy Maker

Laura V Hilton


THE AMISH CANDY MAKER is the second book in the Amish of Mackinac County series by Laura V Hilton. It is the story of Agnes Zook and how she is dealing with the tragedy of losing her whole family. She opens her own business which the community finds strange, instead of allowing the bishop to take care of her. The Amish think she is too head strong and not being submissive so many tongues are wagging about poor Agnes! When she meets Isaac Mast, an Amish man who is contemplating leaving the Amish faith, sparks are flying like crazy!


Isaac is on Mackinac Island to help his sister in law take care of his brother who was badly burned in a fire. Laura V Hilton sure knows how to make the reader feel as if they are right there at the kitchen table with the family dealing with all their troubles and THE AMISH CANDY MAKER is exactly that! She made me sad, then the next moment I was smiling and giggling out loud! You can never go wrong with a Laura V Hilton book if you are a fan of the Amish genre. All of her characters feel genuine and relatable and put your emotions on one heck of a roller coaster ride. As you are reading, you will find yourself cheering for all of them, praying they can work out their problems and be happy once again. You will also wonder how much heartache a family can stand before it completely breaks down and splits.


THE AMISH CANDY MAKER is a heart tugging story filled with grief, loneliness, heartbreak, and love that will hold you hostage until the very last page. Once I started this heartwarming story, it was very hard to put down! I really prayed that Isaac would be able to convince Agnes that she deserved to be loved and cherished and that he didn't think of her or see her as a spinster. Laura V Hilton isn't afraid to write about subjects out of the norm as far as the Amish genre goes. Oh, as a warning to the reader, keep the tissues handy! I'm so excited to continue catching up on all of Laura V Hilton's previous books. Even though this is the second book in the series, I wasn't lost by not reading the first one, Firestorm. But I will be reading it very soon. That is how much I enjoy Laura's writing!

I received a complimentary copy of this book through CelebrateLit. All opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given.

[Brittany · Rating 5 out of 5]

I thoroughly enjoyed this book! I felt sorry for Agnes, with all she had lost, and with the low expectations that her father had expressed for her. I loved reading about her interactions with Isaac and the way their relationship progressed through the book.

Isaac was such an intriguing character and different from the way many Amish men are portrayed in novels. He carried a lot of guilt, had one foot in the Englisch world, was dashingly handsome, and was definitely a flirt. I liked seeing his true character develop in this story. He really was such a caring man.

The children in the book were a sweet addition and definitely added quite a bit of humor to the story. There were also many interesting characters that created quite an enjoyable community to read about.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...

[Kay Garrett · Rating 5 out of 5]

THE AMISH CANDY MAKER by Laura V. Hilton is the second book in The Amish of Mackinac County series.

THE AMISH CANDY MAKER is the story of Agnes Zook and Isaac Mast in a small Amish community in McKinac County about how they struggle with the past, find their way back to their faith with the help of each other and few nudges by Bishop Miah, and a story of growing love that sparks from the first touch.

Agnes Zook is an unmarried woman who feels condemned to be an old maid as prophesized by her Daed. Because of her upbringing, she feels no self-worth with a heavy dose of guilt added in for having survived the fire that took the lives of the rest of her family. She’s also been labeled off in the head because she choose to open a candy shop on her own. No marriage of convenience for Agnes or having the menfolk telling her what to do. With no suitors in sight, she knows she must find a way to support herself. All she’s ever dreamed of was a handsome man beside a natural Christmas tree with snow crunching under his feet to say three little words – I love you. Will her Prince Charming ever show up?

Isaac Mast is a well-thought of and sought after auctioneer who spends his time going from auction to auction through the United States - no time for a real relationship. He’s stayed away from his twin brother’s family for years carrying the heavy guilt of being responsible for killing not one but three people. It was only after receiving a letter from his sister-in-law pleading desperately for help after a tragic fire had destroyed a lot of the area leaving his twin hospitalized with major burns. He returns, against his better judgment, to help with his niece and two nephew, all less than 5. How can he maintain their farm and keep his livelihood? Most of all, how can he take care of kids after what he did?

Agnes and Isaac first met when Isaac went in to buy some candy for the Bishop and his wife for having taken care of the brother’s children for weeks before he heard about the fire and was able to make arrangements to come. During that first meeting, Agnes was robbed at gun point. Isaac was able call for help and to keep Agnes from harm becoming her hero. During a spell of what she calls verbal vomit, she speaks of her attraction for Isaac who finds great joy in teasing and flirting with Agnes. However, sparks flew from their first touch and feelings grew fast for both of them. In a business agreement, they decided to help one another - one supplying labor and the other providing childcare.

Bishop Miah and his wife were instrumental in helping both find their way back to their faith while being strict but loving and offering a quote or scripture from time to time for them to think on. I think everyone needs a Bishop Miah in their life!

Through their trials of taking care of the candy story, tending to three little ones running at full speed in different directions at the same time all requiring constant attention, and Isaac traveling back and forth across the country for auctions leaving Agnes in full charge of everything - Agnes and Isaac finally learn about each other’s past and the guilt they carry. Will their growing affection for each other be able to survive it all? Or will another tragic accident have them going their separate ways? Can they both find peace in their faith knowing God has all the answers if we just hand all our problems to him in faith? Will love find a way or will they each go their own way? Will Bishop Miah ever allow them to marry?

THE AMISH CANDY MAKER is an amazing love story of an Amish couple living in the English world trying to hold on to their faith while dealing with a difficult past. Laura V. Hilton has a way of telling an Amish story while reminding us that we are all human with flaws and emotions bound to make mistakes. Then she shows us through faith, prayer and God’s grace that all things are possible. In the course of the book’s pages she will have you laugh, cry, fearful, smiling and hopefully finding a reason to be thankful or lifting up a prayer yourself. I highly recommend this book to anyone that loves a wonderful written story, the Amish genre, or simple a wonderful romance. Pick it up and read it – you won’t be disappointed.

[J.E. Grace · Rating 5 out of 5]

Agnes Zook and Isaac Mast meet under unusual circumstances when he comes to her aide during a robbery. Agnes, conflicted by her past, feels she will never find her true love and marry. Isaac, is carrying guilt of his own and has no intention of becoming serious about any woman or settling down.

With Isaac's brother injured in a fire at the hospital with his wife by his side, Isaac needs to care for their children. He is reluctant, being a bachelor, with no knowledge of how to take care of children. He's worried about being able to continue his job as an auctioneer and enlists the help of Agnes who lives with Bishop Miah and his wife. Agnes has been helping them care from his brother's children until he arrives.

There are lots of surprises in this story and some suspenseful moments I didn't see coming. I had a hard time putting this one down. The main characters were well-fleshed out and humorous. I found myself grinning or laughing at their playful banter. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this one.

I received a copy from Celebrate Lit and willingly chose to review it.

[Marilyn · Rating 5 out of 5]

Overcoming the past, action, budding romance, Amish proverbs, and Biblical scriptures filled the pages of The Amish Candymaker by Laura V. Hilton. I couldn't stop reading this book until the end. The main characters Agnes Zook and Isaac Mast met in her candy shop with an unexpected turn of events before Agnes showed him where Bishop Miah lived. Isaac’s life was busy auctioneering all over the United States with his nieces and nephew to care for in Mackinac County maybe he could enlist Agnes to assist. After all, they had been residing at Bishop Miah’s home together since the fire that ravenous their community. The characters lives and background is deep with layers to peel away throughout this gripping and winning story. There’s twists and turns with some heartbreaking moments, blaming, caring, courage, determination, faith, love and resilient from the primary characters to secondary characters that brought life and realism to the story. Will Agnes belief of “Nein drop-dead-gorgeous, clean-cut hero is going to rescue me near a live Christmas tree while the snow crunches pleasantly under my feet” ever come true once Isaac fled Mackinac County when he was blamed for his nephew’s situation?

The picturesque descriptive scenes placed me right in the middle of Mackinac County as well as the various states Isaac traveled to for his auctioneer services. The Amish Candymaker is the second book in Hilton’s series, The Amish of Mackinac County. However, it may be read as a standalone, but I highly recommend reading Firestorm to gain a love and respect for the residents of this Amish community and all they had experienced.

There’s a bonus at the end of this book with candy recipes. The Amish Candymaker is a phenomenal story by Laura V. Hilton. Her books never fail to disappoint with new adventures, Amish proverbs and Biblical references similar to situations that these charming Amish characters face.

I received a complimentary e-book of The Amish Candymaker from Celebrate Lit. I have expressed my sincere opinion and look forward to many more Amish stories with a strong faith message by Hilton.

[Betti · Rating 5 out of 5]

It's almost be scary how words said can affect the rest of a life. Such is the experience of young Agnes Zook, who has been told by her father that she is not worthy of any man's love. A robbery in her candy shop brings a true life hero to her rescue, but is it even possible that she might believe some of the things he is saying? Poor choices bring consequences, but can forgiveness be found?
A most enjoyable Amish story with scripture and many sayings woven nicely into the narrative. Perhaps most noticeable in my reading was 'People don't lack strength, they lack will'! I expect there are many areas in our lives that this would this ring true.
I received this wonderful book through CelebrateLit. All impression and opinions are my own.

[Kav · Rating 5 out of 5]

I've come to really enjoy Laura V. Hilton's Amish novels because she always puts such an interesting spin on them. You might say she writes outside the box and I love the challenges that fresh perspective bring to her characters and her readers.

Agnes wasn't my favourite character in Firestorm (the first book in this series -- The Amish of Mackinac County) so I wasn't sure what to expect within these pages. Might have put off reading it for a bit because of my trepidation but I needn't have worried. Of course Hilton delivers! With depth and compassion and a whole lot of heart. Because Agnes was...well annoying...in the first book. And I loved getting the chance to see beyond the facade into the fragile heart of a woman who just wants to be loved and appreciated.

She's an individualist living in a conforming society and always seems to be just a bit out of step. Talks to plants, has a penchant for pink, is endearingly awkward and..."wears her heart on her sleeve, and she tends to talk without filtering her words." (p 78) As Isaac says, "I've known a lot of Amish women, Agnes, but none of them has been as know-it-all and bossy as you." (p 101) You might say Agnes is a paradox.

Which is definitely appealing to Isaac. As a traveling auctioneer, he's experienced a vast number of Amish communities and has a tendency to pick and choose the rules he's willing to live by. He's a flirt and has way too much fun flustering Agnes. Always popular with the women, he's had a carefree bachelorhood with plenty of female companionship until Agnes stirs up the longing for something more. Love the banter and playfulness, sharp retorts and teasing. Definitely an unorthodox un-courtship!

And Bishop Miah is back and just as beguiling. One of my all-time favourite secondary characters. Equal parts wisdom, compassion and stealthy spy! Which makes The Amish Candymaker that much more of a delectable read. Ohhhh -- and there are candy recipes in the back! Might have to issue a Sweet-tooth Warning because there's a lot of droolworthy candymaking and eating going on here!

[Susan · Rating 4 out of 5]

Amish fiction. I've read quite a bit of it, and generally it's light-hearted, easy-to-read fun. Sometimes it can descend into cliche, with all the "ach" and "gut"-ing. I decided to review The Amish Candy Maker (thanks, Celebrate Lit) because it looked a little different from the typical, and of course -- it's hard to turn down a book about someone who makes fudge :)

I enjoyed The Amish Candy Maker overall. Agnes and Isaac were very likeable characters -- flawed, but vulnerable. I enjoyed the candy shop setting, with all the talk about fudge. I found it interesting that the story was set in Michigan's Mackinac County, which is famous for fudge -- although not a lot was mentioned about the area. The writing was good for this type of book. It's a bit steamier, I thought, than is typical for Amish fare. There's lots of kissing between Isaac and Agnes (including one scene where she emerges from a pool wearing a tankini), talk of her "sexy" movements, etc.

If I were making suggestions for the book, I'd bring in a bit more about the beautiful Mackinac area. I'd cut the book by 50 pages or so (I found myself becoming weary of the romance between Agnes and Isaac going on and on and on with little change), and I wondered about the frequent use of "nein" as an adjective. I know that the Amish speak Pennsylvania Dutch rather than German, but in German it would be "kein" rather than "nein," and this pinged my reading radar every time. I wondered if the Amish really do use "nein" in this way?

Worth giving this one a try if you like Amish fiction.

[Deanna Stevens · Rating 5 out of 5]

Most of the Amish call her “off in den Kopf” (strange) and he's almost ready to leave the Amish faith.. Wow, the sparks fly with these two and not necessarily romantically! They seem to clash often but I really liked this story as they both find a way to confront the past and tackle the problems of today. Faith, family, forgiveness and a just plain good story made it hard to put down! Highly recommended!
I was gifted a copy, no review was required. My review is voluntary...

[Maureen Timerman · Rating 5 out of 5]

The author has given us a compelling page turner, and once you begin the pages begin to fly, the story is that good, and I needed to find the answers.
We are back in Mackinac and with some old friends, and this is Agnes Zooks story, as she is beginning her endeavor to have her own candy shop. We also meet Gabe’s brother, Isaac, and see him deal with his daemons.
Can there be a relationship between these two main characters? Surprises abound here and there are new relations and many make me wonder why I really liked some of the previous characters, yes this is the second book in this series, but you can read this as a stand-alone, but you might want to read the first book in this series!
The theme of forgiveness is prevalent here, both by others and by oneself, this needs to be one before anyone can move on.

I received this book through CelebrateLit and was not required to give a positive review.

[Carrie Schmidt · Rating 5 out of 5]

Readers may want to invest in a big bag of gourmet chocolate or their favorite candy before indulging in this latest sweet-with-a-little-sass-mixed-in story from Laura V. Hilton. The author delves deeper into Agnes’s personality, a character previously a little difficult to connect with, and delivers a heroine who is engaging and very easy to like. Isaac will weaken knees with his winks and flirty behavior, and like Agnes he becomes even more likable as more of his story is revealed. Delightful banter and swoonworthy kisses between the two, as well as the adorable scenes with Isaac’s young charges, will leave a perpetual smile on readers’ faces from start to finish - even though a few tears may be shed as well. Another delicious visit to Hilton’s Mackinac County, in more ways than one!

[Emily Yager · Rating 4 out of 5]

The likeable characters fit in perfectly with the well crafted and detailed setting. The story is filled with everything that one would expect of Amish fiction without being cliched. Amish proverbs and Biblical Scriptures are tastefully sprinkled in.

If you love Amish Fiction, this book is definitely for you. Or if you’ve never read one this is a great introduction to the genre.

[Ruth Hill · Rating 3 out of 5]

I was sent a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. I was not financially compensated, and all opinions are 100 percent mine.

First of all, this is a clean romance with nothing offensive within its pages. Also, there are definite Christian principles included in the framework of the story. Furthermore, if you are not familiar with the Amish vernacular, the author has included a nice dictionary/glossary for your convenience at the beginning of the book.

I consider myself a lover of Amish fiction, and I have read quite a few of these Amish romances in my time. While it is true that there are some tender moments (and even some that are rather sultry but still squeaky clean in nature) and some moments of high tension, I cannot call this book one that I would place on my absolute favorite list. The characters are indeed likable, and redemption and forgiveness are emphasized. I appreciate those themes. And there are a few cute moments throughout.

However, I was expecting a little more of a traditional Amish community that pushed the boundaries a bit, but didn't completely overthrow the basic rules. Yes, it was an Amish community, and I know things are changing, but for me, the charm of Amish fiction is reading about communities that come together and learn how to live within this modern world. I have no problem with them implementing some modern technology or interacting with the Englisch, but I felt like this Amish community was filled with so much non-traditionalism that I struggled to see the principles of the Amish culture within it. This was not a deal-breaker for me, by any means. But I suppose I have been spoiled by other Christian authors in this genre.

Something else I wish had been emphasized more was the plan of salvation. I realize that many Amish communities are traditionally a bit more works-based, and some are far too legalistic to even discuss the gospel in great detail. But since this was a non-traditional Amish community, I was hoping for more emphasis on the plan of salvation. I appreciated the Biblical passages included, and I understand the spiritual journey the characters were taking. Yet if there had been a little more emphasis on the gospel message, I would have been a bit happier.

As a disclaimer, I was not aware that this was book two in the series when I began reading. I now understand why the book seemed to be so abrupt in the beginning and dove into the action. While the book can be read as a standalone book, I do not recommend doing it that way. No doubt, if I had read the first book in the series, I would have had a richer experience in reading.

I am comfortable in giving this book a three and a half star rating. There are many redeeming qualities, and the story was entertaining enough for anyone. But perhaps my expectations were a bit skewed. Nevertheless, if the issues I raised do not bother you, I would recommend starting this series from the first book rather than this one.

[Karla · Rating 5 out of 5]

I must admit that I am a lover of the Amish Fiction genre, so when a new book comes out, it goes on my "to read" list. Laura Hilton is one author that I have grown to love. After reading a few of her books, I was hooked!! She is a talented storyteller who puts deep meaning within her works of fiction. The story may be about the Amish but in no way is their life as simple and peaceful as many think. Laura addresses the fact that these Plain People experience every bit as much conflict in life as you and I do.

The main character, Agnes , did not have pleasant memories of her childhood. I felt deeply for her as it became clear that words spoken by her father that she would never be "worthy of any man's life" have a lasting effect on her adult life. How could God love such an insecure, unforgiving person??? Agnes felt totally unlovable!! What a horrible way to live life! As her character developed, my empathy increased for this poor young woman. I felt her every hurt and challenge. She definitely needed to forgive, both the past hurts and herself. Only God could do that for her. Poor choices had been made, however nothing is unforgivable. Isaac also faced many challenges! He is torn between the Englisch and Amish worlds! Although at times, he frustrated me, I learned to love him as someone who also needed forgiveness. Would he and Agnes be able to bond and help each other heal?? Would he be able to stand a woman who very definitely had an opinion and easily expressed each one? Isaac faces his own demons, past events that separating himself from his family that filled him with grief and guilt. This book is NOT just a simple romance! This author deals with mystery as well as the need to be forgiving to others and self.

The plot moves at a steady pace and keeps the reader totally engaged from beginning to end. Twists and turns appear when you least expect them. It is the kind of novel that makes one think and reflect on one's own life. Yes, this is about the Amish community, but how different are we?? Really, not at all.

I highly recommend this book to all readers!!
A five star book that leaves one pondering how we need to change our lives to overcome past events. Looking forward to Laura's next creation!!


This book was received as a gift. The thoughts and opinions expressed are honest and my own.

[Carla · Rating 5 out of 5]

 This is a new author for me, but she is now one that I will be checking out her backlist, especially the first book in this series, Firestorm.

I loved the character of Agnes Zook. She was a strong woman who had endured a lot of hardship in her short life. Living in Mackinac County in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, the Amish District has recently survived a terrible Wildflower that killed and/or seriously injured many, with several homes being destroyed. Resigned to being a spinster, she needs a way to support herself, thus the opening of her Candy Shop. She has no filter, so says what she is thinking, often getting herself into trouble. She also wears her heart on her sleeve and everyone can see what she is feeling just by looking at her face.

When Issac Mast stumbles into her store, they have an immediate connection. He is another wounded character who plays the field, is a terrible flirt, yet guards his feelings. From their first meeting, I was rooting for these two to get together. Issac's nieces and nephew were adorable. As children do, they love deeply and become very attached to both Onkle Issac and Agnes, even calling her Aenti Agnes. It takes a while to find out what happened in Issac's past to cause him to become estranged from his family, but as it is revealed, my heart broke for this man.

I have read many books about Amish couples and romance, but Bishop Miah (Jeremiah) was different from any I have come across. He was their spiritual leader, but he was a caring and highly intelligent man. It was almost like he could read their minds. He carefully leads Agnes and Issac towards each other, with them thinking he is actually trying to keep them apart.

Throw in some jealous females, a few farm animals, an armed thief and several roadblocks and you have a wonderful Amish Romance. I really enjoyed this story and definitely recommend it to any Romance lover, as well as those who enjoy Amish stories and/or Christian stories. 

[Nana · Rating 5 out of 5]

I loved this installment in the Amish of Mackinac County series. Numerous emotions were evoked throughout this book, humor not the least of them. Both Agnes and Isaac were somewhat overcome with obstacles in their future, but Ms. Hilton has woven a seriously difficult and life altering situation into a successful livelihood for Agnes and her candy shop. Isaac, however, was thrust into a challenging situation in taking over the care of his twin brother's three small children. His job as an auctioneer made it necessary for him to travel, but Agnes is sweet talked into helping with his nieces and nephew during his absence.

The characters in this novel are numerous and varied, and run the gamut of personality traits! Bishop Miah is one very special character who warmed my heart. His wit and godly leadership combined in making him a favorite with me. Isaac and Agnes were like magnets with a strong magnetic field! They couldn't leave one another alone for long before sparks fly in all directions! Unlike traditional Amish fiction, Ms. Hilton uses numerous real life situations, and doesn't hesitate to spice up the lives of her characters. I love that about her books! There is never a dull moment, and this book was very difficult to put down. Don't miss this one!

Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this book. All expressed opinions are my own.

[Jane · Rating 4 out of 5]

I was born and raised in Western Michigan. I like reading books set in my home state. Laura Hilton seems to have gotten the geography correct which I appreciate. Her acknowledgements at the start of the book also make mention of the research she did, and those who helped her, in preparation for a book. Thorough research is always important when writing a book about a specific place or people group. Laura Hilton appears to have done her homework in this area. I also appreciated her list of Amish terms and their meanings at the start of the book. 

Insecurities are something many of us face. The two main characters of The Amish Candy Maker are no exception. Agnes and Isaac learn to overcome some of those insecurities. Faith in God is expressed throughout the book as is the lack of faith at times. Whether you are Amish or not, you may see yourself in some of the problems, insecurities, and even lack of faith of the characters and be encouraged that all is not lost. Growth is possible for all of us. Laura Hilton, as a pastor's wife, understands struggles and her story helps guide struggling people into realizing they are not alone in their struggles. 

I want to thank Celebrate Lit Tours and Laura Hilton for the complimentary e-copy of the book which I received in exchange for this honest review. 

[Cecilia · Rating 5 out of 5]

Laura Hilton has not disappointed in this latest novel in her The Amish of Mackinac Island series. Agnes Zook is trying to put the past behind her and forge a new life for herself in the after-math of the tragic fire that took the lives of her family. Isaac Mast has a past he would rather forget as well. He has enjoyed his nomadic lifestyle as an auctioneer, never having to put roots down too deep in any one place. The fire that took Agnes' family, also placed Isaac's twin the hospital. When he returns to Mackinac Island to care for his niece and nephews, he heroically steps up to Agnes aid.

The story is well written and it was easy to fall in love their story. They are quite the pair and despite their differences and their banter makes the book hard to put down. Ultimately, with the love and support of the other, they are able to find forgiveness in their own hearts and discover the path back to God.

I love the Mackinac Island series and cannot wait for the next novel.

I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author and publisher in return for my honest review. All thoughts and comments are my own.

[Virginia Winfield · Rating 5 out of 5]

Agnes and Isaac are not the typical Amish young adults. Neither of these characters conform to what a perfect Amish person would be. These two meet after each had family members injured or killed in a tragedy. Can these two help each other while caring for three small children. I loved the characters and the story. I especially loved the Bishop. He is a great character. This is not as clean as most Amish fiction stories. This definitely has a bit more flirting than usual. I received a copy of this book from Celebratelit for a fair and honest opinion that I gave of my own free will.

[Melody Kennedy]

This is a great book! Laura V Hilton has a way of making you feel like you’re in the story. I loved the relationship between Agnes and Isaac.

[Beth · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Amish Candy Maker is the latest book in Laura V Hilton's series, The Amish of Mackinac County, and it is fantastic. As a huge fan of Amish fiction, I have had the pleasure of reading
Laura V. Hilton's books and I couldn't wait to read this one. Laura V Hilton writes with authority about The Amish Faith and life, their different communities around the U.S., firefighters and fires, auctioneers, candy making, and taking care of children. From the start of this book until the end I couldn't put this book down. This is the second book in this series and picks up not long after the first book ended, but this book can definitely be read as a stand alone. Laura V. Hilton has written this second book with enough background for those who didn't read the first one, but not to the point that the book lulls for readers of the first book. Laura Hilton puts her readers right there in the thick of the story, I always feel like I am right there in the story. The characters in this story are well written and relatable. I found myself drawn in this story to Agnes Zook. Agnes Zook lost her whole family to the fire that happened in Mackinac County and has been living with the Bishop and his wife, helping care for three children whose father was hurt in the fires. Agnes is different from the other Amish girls. Her character speaks her mind and her imagination is vivid. Her faith has been shaken and she is angry with God. I loved being part of her transformation. This book and series is a must read for anyone who enjoys Amish Fiction, you will not be disappointed. I cannot wait to read more in this series. I give this book 5+ Stars.

I received this book from Celebrate Lit Blogger Program and the author for no charge in exchange for my honest review of this book. The opinions expressed here are my own.

[Jessica Baker (A Baker's Perspective) · Rating 4 out of 5]

I always enjoy reading stories by Laura Hilton. Her characters are fun, her stories are different from the norm, and they make me smile. This story had me hooked from the very beginning. First of all, Isaac may be “Amish”, but he kind of beats to the sound of his own drum. That is definitely a plus in my book. What really sparked my interest was during his and Agnes’ first few scenes together. One word – robbery. It was the start of a relationship I could not get enough of. Isaac handled himself exactly like I wanted him to, and this hero easily captured my attention.

Then you meet his nieces and nephews, who stole the show a few times. Calling him Onkel Daed……how clever! Isaac and Agnes both had some things they needed to sort out and go through before they can totally be together. But there was a surprise a little over half way through that made this reader smile. I can’t say more than that or it’ll ruin it!

Once again Hilton gives readers an enjoyable story that has you grinning from ear to ear. And don’t read if you are hungry – you’ll want to go raid your nearest candy shop! All in all this is another win from Hilton. I look forward to more stories from her in the future! I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Amy · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Amish Candy Maker is the second installment from Laura V Hilton’s series, The Amish of Mackinac County. Even though it is book two of the series, I believe it can be read as a stand alone. I did not feel like I was missing anything from not reading the first book. It tells the story of the town outcast Agnes Zook. Her family has been killed in a tragedy and she chooses to take care of herself instead allowing her bishop to do so. Isaac Mast has found success away from his hometown, but is summoned to come back home after his brother needs help. This is when Agnes and Isaac’s paths cross.

I enjoyed The Amish Candy Maker. I, especially, loved Agnes. I found her a brave, courageous, admirable and inspiring woman. I loved it when she begins to interact with Isaac. They were so fun together. I liked how the story tells the power of forgiveness, letting go of the past , and how to have faith.

I am giving The Amish Candy Maker four and a half stars. I would love to read the first installment from The Amish of Mackinac County series, The Firestorm, to see what happened before this one. I recommend this one for readers who love clean romances and Amish Fiction.

I received this book from the publisher. This review is 100% my own honest opinion.

[Vicky Sluiter · Rating 4 out of 5]

Author Laura Hilton has developed a sweet story that isn’t syrupy but has characters with spunk, making this a fun read. A non-submissive Amish woman and a man afraid of commitment make for an interesting combination. Because of words spoken over them, both fear they are unlovable. Coming to grips with God’s plan, while learning a new way to see ourselves, isn’t always easy but always worth it.

Amish proverbs such as “Your past doesn’t stay in your past” and scripture verses pertaining to whatever situation the characters were facing, help to tie a good story together with God’s heart.

If you enjoy Amish stories with depth then I highly recommend this book.

I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review.

[Bree · Rating 5 out of 5]

Laura V Hilton takes readers into the thick of the Amish world and provides engaging characters that become instant friends. Agnes is delightful and kind. An instant hit for me. She is unique in the community which means that many see her as strange. She is far from strange. I think that her craft and story are special and make reading this book as delightful as the chocolate covered strawberries you should eat while reading this book.

[dorothy turner · Rating 5 out of 5]

enjoyed very much

[Kristina Anderson · Rating 3 out of 5]

The Amish Candy Maker by Laura V. Hilton has us traveling to Mackinac County, Michigan. Agnes Zook lost her family and her home in the recent fires that went through the area. After selling off the property, Agnes has opened Sweet Treats. Agnes is known for being a little odd since she tends to talk without thinking and is frequently found talking to herself. She feels that she is destined to become an old maid because her preacher father planted that thought firmly in her head. Isaac Mast has come to town to look after his brother’s children while he is in the hospital recovering from severe burns with his wife by his side. Bishop Miah Brunstetter and his wife, Katherine along with Agnes have been caring for the three kids for the last six months. Isaac is an auctioneer who travels around the country. He is ill prepared to work his brother’s farm and care for three kinner on his own. Isaac stops in at Sweet Treats on his arrival in town and is instantly taken with Agnes who he finds talking to the plants on her windowsill. Agnes could be just the person he needs to help him with his dilemma. Agnes is attracted to Isaac from their first encounter, but he is not the type of person to settle down. God has brought these two different individuals together, but how the situation plays out is up to Agnes and Isaac.

The Amish Candy Maker is a sweet Amish romance. Agnes Zook lost her entire family the night of the fire along with her home and is now living with Bishop Miah and his wife. The proceeds from the sale of her family’s land has helped her start Sweet Treats, a candy shop that features her fudge and rock candy (recipes at end of book). Agnes’ father was a preacher who frequently told her that if she did not marry Gabe (who picked another) then she would remain single. Agnes is determined to provide for herself and not be a burden on others. The night of the fire, Sam Mast suffered devastating burns and has been in a hospital ever since then. Isaac Mast is a traveling auctioneer who is in demand and his sister-in-law’s letter just caught up with him. Jenny, Sam’s wife, has not left her husband’s side and their three children need Isaac along with their farm. The last thing Isaac wishes to do is watch children after the tragic accident several years ago. Plus, Isaac has many weekend auctions lined up and cannot watch the kids full-time. When Isaac encounters Agnes, he believes they can reach an amicable solution. Agnes is an entertaining character who speaks without thinking which leads to some humorous and embarrassing situations. The electricity between Agnes and Isaac is immediate, but they each have issues standing in the way. Bishop Miah is a wise man who provides insightful and thoughtful advice along with his snarky quips. I like that the people do not have a smooth road on their journey. They must deal with a robber, medical emergency, flirtatious women and their own internal demons and insecurities. Agnes and Isaac need to learn that God is always there for them in good times and bad. He never leaves us nor forsakes us. I liked the inspirational thoughts and scripture verses included in The Amish Candy Maker. The Amish Candy Maker has mischievous children, a wise Bishop, a busy auctioneer, mouthwatering confections and a quirky candy maker.

[Alex Jacobson · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Amish Candy Maker by Laura V. Hilton is a sequel to Firestorm and it was the perfect read for a snowed in Valentines Day week! Yes here in the Pacific Northwest we have had a historic snow storm that left the shelves of local grocery stores empty the days leading up to its arrival, and kids home for upwards of a week. I was delighted to be stranded with a stack of books needing to be read (another review coming tomorrow) and this one did not disappoint for a fun, easy, and engaging read. I mean you can't argue with a story all about fudge and rock candy set in a budding candy shop during the week that is all about spoiling those we love with sweet treats and sweater words.

Having some insights to Hilton's writing style beforehand really helped me enjoy this story even more. This is quite different than a traditional Amish fiction because it is set in contemporary times and the language, characters' personalities, and the plot itself reflects a more modern setting. Previously when reading Firestorm this really threw me for a loop. The setting, life choices the Amish characters made,  language characters used, and even the strength (particularly in the female characters') personalities initially felt too modern, or not truly Amish, based in my previous experience with Amish fiction. However, reading these stories reminds me that Amish people live in the same world I do today.

The independent, outspoken, strong-willed Agnes is pursuing life as a single woman and business owner, and that basic premise alone is not as "Amish-like." That said I found those very characteristics in Agnes to be what created a believable story that is all the more interesting. Then you add in modern language, pet names like "Beautiful" and compliments that include modern terms like "sexy" and just like last time I read one of Hilton's books I found myself stopping in my tracks. But, the truth is just like the world has changed for all of us, it is also changing for the Amish. They still adhere to many of the original standards, faith based expectations, and lifestyles that reflect their traditional faith while living in a changing world and therefore will be influenced by it. 

I loved the candy shop setting, the idea of an Amish man as a traveling auctioneer, the rapid pace of the story and romance and overall it's just a fun change of pace for Amish Fiction.

I found myself invested in the characters and really rooting for Isaac Mast as he returns home and wrestles with his past and his hopes for the future. I love the potential for future stories in this community, the recipes in the back are so fun, and I thoroughly appreciate the research that Hilton has done to stay true to the Macinack County Amish life. My take, the book is a really great twist on the traditional Amish story, is a quick read, and I am so glad I had it as a companion on these gorgeous snow days. I hope you'll check out the recipe and giveaway below.

Thanks to Celebrate Lit Bloggers for providing me a copy of the book and for always bringing fun and new reads and authors my way. I love getting to share my honest opinion with you and sharing titles I love. Are there any authors or books I need to add to my 2019 list? Do tell.

[Stephanie Norton · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Amish Candy Maker is the second book in Hilton's The Amish of Mackinac County series. The story all about true love, faith, and determination. We are taken on Agnes Zook and Isaac Mast life journey of their struggles with the past and finding their way back to their faith.

We see Agnes Zook an unmarried woman who has no self-worth and has survival guilt that took the lives of the rest of her family. She decides to open up her own candy shop. Her community looked down on her for that. She dreams of having a husband and a family.

Isaac Mast a well sought after auctioneer. He travels all over the United States holding auctions. Due to all of his traveling he doesn't really have time to settle down and get married. He is full of guilt for being responsible for killing three people. After receiving a letter from his sister-in-law begging him for help when a fire caused major burns on his twin brother. He returns.

Isaac first meets Agnes when he goes into her candy shop. During the first time they met, Agnes was robbed at gunpoint causing Isaac to be the hero. They start flirting. They created a business agreement to help one another - one supplying labor and the other providing childcare.

Will things work out? Will another tragic accident have them going their separate ways? Can they both find peace in their faith? Will they get married? If so, will Bishop Miah allow it?

The Amish Candy Maker contains likable and relatable characters. As well as faith, love, determination, perseverance, and even moments of sadness. It is full of twists and turns. It is a heartwarming love story. We see growth in both the main characters, Agnes Zook and Isaac Mast. She even gave the character a humorous side.

Hilton is great at taking you into their world. Her descriptions of the locations and characters made it very easy for me to see the story in my brain. One of the locations in the book is Mackinac County.

Throughout the book, there are Amish proverbs and Biblical references.
I would suggest reading the first book, Firestorm, to get an idea of their Amish community and all they experienced. just because Hilton's books are really good, but this book can be read as a stand-alone too. I love how Hilton threw in a special surprise recipe at the end of the story. If you love Amish Fiction stories and Christian Fiction then these books are for you. I would highly recommend reading this series.

I received a complimentary e-book of The Amish Candy Maker from Celebrate Lit. This is an honest opinion.

[Phyllis · Rating 5 out of 5]

A sweet arrangement

My rating is 4.5 stars

Agnes struggled so much with the concept that Gott could love her. She felt that her prayers were not heard, especially after her family died in a fire. Not only that, she felt she was unlovable. Her very own father, a preacher, had told her that no man would want her - she was too independent and outspoken.

I loved Agnes' endearing habit of talking to inanimate objects, such a plants and dishes. You get the idea. Maybe I thought it was so fun because I've been known to do exactly that.

I wasn't a fan of Issac at first. He was a bit brash and overconfident. His smooth-talking ways that made him a much-demanded auctioneer also had him popular with the Amish women in the communities he visited. Not that anything ever happened beyond perhaps a few kisses, but still. . . He had no intention of making any commitments or settling down.

Yet as time went by, Isaac became more lovable. The way he embraced taking care of his nephew and nieces despite being so incompetent was very sweet. And the way he really did honor and respect Agnes; being able to see past her quirks to appreciate the wonderful woman she is.

Yet a Laura V. Hilton novel wouldn't be complete with ""just"" a romance. Her stories are much deeper than that! Issac carried deep guilt over an event that occurred several years earlier, separating him from his only remaining family - his twin brother. The grief and guilt he experienced caused him to live the life of a nomad and made him feel he wasn't worthy of the love he craved.

There was also a mystery surrounding the drug addict who had attempted to rob Agnes' candy store. While it was not a prominent theme of the story, it carried an undercurrent that added a little more drama.

Yes, this is part of a series and has characters returning from other stories, and yet it does stand alone quite well. Then again, Laura V. Hilton's books are all so good you should treat yourself and read them all!


Read my full review with a Preview at Among the Reads


I was given a copy of this book. I was not required to give a favorable review nor was any money received for this review. All comments and opinions are my own.