It was good enough that I will read another one in the series, but I don’t think I’d read this one again (I’m a chronic re-reader, for context).
The story was reminiscent of Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen- just enough to follow the 10,000 foot view of the story. In some ways, I appreciated the loose accuracy to the original in that it gave some excitement at new plot points. In the character development and traits, I did not appreciate straying from the original.
Catherine is not a flighty, sporadic, over-emotional woman like Kathy. She is very steady, honest, and extremely innocent, again, unlike Kathy. Don’t get me wrong, Kathy was engaging and spunky- but NOT Catherine. My interpretation from Northanger Abbey was always that Catherine saw Tilney as a good friend until she lost his trust. Only then did she see him as a lost love. In this story, Kathy sets her romantic and marital gaze at Ben Tilman from the very start. She is constantly frustrated at her thwarted attempts to woo and impress him. This frustrated me as I saw it as an assault on Catherine’s good name. This Kathy was spineless at times-allowing Ron to touch her non-consentually and coerce her to do things she did not want to do. Kathy is like a typical modern female main character: bold, quirky, and lovable. She is nothing unique. Catherine is innocent, kindhearted, and has the character and a development arc I’ve never seen in anything else.
Ben was a flighty people-pleaser who I loved immediately, but was constantly frustrated by. I liked the pastoral angle as it gave Ben a reason to be overly concerned with what others thought of him. I did enjoy his character growth and him beginning to stand on his own two feet. Tilney being one of my favorite Austen men, I did like Ben. He was sweet and thoughtful, but a bit less strong and caring than Tilney. The author did a better job with his retelling than with Catherine’s.
Overall, if you take this book as its own story, it’s like a Hallmark film: cute, clean, and a bit cheesy. If you take it as an Austen retelling, it misses the mark in the most important areas.
Content Rating: 0 chili peppers- squeaky clean
Trigger warning: suspicion of murder; familial abuse; antiquated marital viewpoints and gender roles