"What's Behind the Door? Only One Way to Find Out!"
"Mythical Doorways" is a collection of fantasy stories from eleven authors associated with the Fellowship of Fantasy website and Facebook page. The settings, themes, and subgenres vary widely, but all have this in common. Integral to the plot is a door, in one sense or another.
I liked some stories more than others. But all are readable, and the variety means something for everyone. So I highly recommend this anthology. Disclosure: I received a free advance review copy.
1. "Everwild", J. M. Blackman: A moving coming-of-age fantasy. Flint, an orphan living on his own for the first time, gets a rare opportunity to train in his chosen field, art. But he also has the chance to learn about his mysterious origins. He might not be completely human. And to follow one course, Flint must give up the other. The author handles well the classic dilemma of heeding one's head or one's heart.
2. "Well of Fate", Savannah Jezowski: Excellent Tolkienesque quest adventure set in the world of Norse mythology. Ratatosk, Tosk for short, is the squirrel that inhabits Yggdrasil, the cosmic tree. He's a fine storyteller, but that's not enough. He yearns to become a hero. "I don’t want to tell stories. I want to have stories told about me.”
So Tosk sets out for the Well of Fate in the giant tree's roots in hopes of changing his destiny. And what an adventure awaits him! Weird mythological beings. Unexpected perils. Bizarre situations. And some neat surprises, including a real zinger at the end.
The author does an excellent job of packing so much into so little wordage. She well and truly makes Norse mythology come to life by using authentic figures and places in an original story. The result is not another myth-mash, but rather a fresh and imaginative work of fiction that should appeal to many. And how many stories are there in which the protag is a squirrel?
3. "Jericho and the Magician's Daughter", H. L. Burke: Jericho Carver is an apprentice to the sorcerer Master Spellsmith in a high-fantasy version of rural Victorian England. He's doing well at learning magic. But his best friend, his master's daughter Rill, isn't allowed to study it at all. Jericho and Rill are smarting over this prohibition. The sorcerer won't change his mind. But when there's a will, there's a way!
This story is a fun bit of whimsical adventure, with an elaborate but convincing system of magic. It serves as a prequel to the author's Spellsmith & Carver series.
4. "Dragon's Oath", Katy Huth Jones: Another story I highly recommend. Ethaniel is a young member of the Brethren, a religious sect and farming community. On the surface it looks like a bucolic Utopia. Dig deeper and it's a repressive, reactionary theocracy.
Ethaniel is forced out because of his love for a forbidden girl. Lost in the wilderness and near death, he stumbles upon the dragon Flavatorix. He too is an outcast from his own kind. Together the two fight for survival and forge a bond that can be broken only in death.
The author does an excellent job of characterizing Ethaniel. I found it easy to identify with him and felt moved by his plight.
The story is fast-paced fantasy adventure, but also deals with social and psychological issues. The two aspects work well with each other, rather than feel like one has been tacked on to the other.
5. "The Hallway of Three Doors", D. G. Driver: A surreal fantasy that just doesn't work for me. Seta, a luckless young woman, seeks answers from a soothsayer about what course she should take. Her decisions have so far turned out to be disastrously wrong. So she wants to learn what path destiny has already set out for her.
The soothsayer directs Seta to an abandoned castle, where she'll find three doors. Therein lies her answer.
I lost sympathy for the protag early on, when she expresses her desire to be free of personal responsibility for her choices. Of course she eventually learns better. But Seta and the other characters never really come alive.
Nor does their story. The places, situations, and events are bizarre, but still dull. The plot, such as it is, fails to make sense, let alone move the emotions.
6. "Door Number Four", Bokerah Brumley: In a futuristic world in which the science is magic and technology is spells, Rase Flannigan is a student at an academy. He's preparing for a career rescuing sick and wounded wild animals. Not in his own world, but in those accessed through magical doors.
Now it's final exams day, and his future depends on passing a rigorous test in a world on the other side of one of those doors. Rase expects it to be tough. But he's still in for surprises.
The author does a fine job of making the protag come alive and his stressful situation seem real. Her imagery of the settings and their magic work well. Recommended!
7. "Threshold", Laurie Lucking: Heidi Benson will soon turn sixteen. She's a typical teen, except for one thing. She has access to a world next door. A wondrous fantasy land called Lockwood, full of fairies, unicorns, centaurs, and trolls. And one mortal boy about her age named Shawn. Her happiest times are spent there.
But the door will slam shut on Heidi's upcoming birthday. Should she stay in this world or the other? At first the choice seems obvious; she loves her family and looks forward to further studies and a career. But Shawn was given the same choice, and remained in Lockwood. And Heidi is falling in love with him.
This story is quite remarkable. It's a poignant, moving coming-of-age tale with a fantasy twist. The author describes the alternate world vividly and the protag's inner world precisely.
It's easy to feel empathy for Heidi, to experience her dilemma along with her. And get set for a really touching final scene.
8. "Idiot's Graveyard", Arthur Daigle: Here's a sword and sorcery tale that manages to be both a fun adventure and a harrowing, grim horror story. Dana and Jayden are two guards on a caravan. It's a boring job until they investigate an abandoned tower, the scene of paranormal activity. More description would mean spoilers, so all I'll say is that they aren't bored any longer!
The author displays quite an imagination. He recounts his protags' adventures with a flair for the outré, the bizarre, the outlandish. All this with very down-to-Earth, relatable characters. Another story I recommend.
9. "Cosmic Cravings", AJ Bakke: A bit of whimsy involving a mouse mage named Bree living on an Earth-like planet. Its supply of chocolate has run out, so she creates a magic door to Earth, the source of her favorite treat. In the process she accidentally displaces Shade, a miniature dragon, and Alyn, and its elf-like rider.
All three wind up with an eight-year-old Earth girl named Katrina, who possesses a magical power she's unaware of. Which makes her the target of an unscrupulous mage. One her otherworldly visitors must protect her from.
If all this sounds a little mixed up, well, so is the story. The blend of disparate elements, including science fiction and fantasy, simply doesn't work here. The story features plenty of drama and action, but never seems real or even interesting. So it simply failed to engage me.
10. "Dragon Ward", Jenelle Leanne Schmidt: This reads more like a long excerpt or a fill-in story than a work its own right. Gwyna, a farm girl in an unspecified fantasy world, encounters a dragon. At first they're enemies. But once they enter a magic doorway their relationship changes.
The author does a fine job with descriptions. But overall this story is rather confusing. Why are these inexplicable events and odd situations going on? I assume the longer works it relates to provide answers. But with only this bit to go on, I felt unsatisfied.
11. "What Lies Ahead", Lauren Lynch: The shortest story in the collection and the most enigmatic. Set on a remote frontier of the Roman Empire, the unfortunate Vassus seeks his heritage. He's guided to a door on a cliff, one that seems to open onto thin air. Instead it leads him to another time. And encounters that might enable him to come to terms with his past and create his future.
The author creates a moving and imaginative tale, apparently part of a series. And raises intriguing questions about destiny and how to deal with it.