6.7/10
Okay, allow me to preface this by saying Rein/The author is an old friend of mine. we chatted a lot before this book was even a glint in his eyes, and ironically I see a lot of our old interactions coming out in the early chapters but that is neither here nor there. So know that I'm trying to balance my duty as a friend to support my bud while also being as honest and fair as I can, applying the same logic and critique I would to any other book.
That said, I loved so many parts of The Gryphon Generation, but it feels like it's a prologue to a bigger story or the skeleton of a story. IT's missing the meat. the connective tissue. Now, I know this is book one of five (so far) so I do know that there is more coming and that the overall structure improves a LOT, but this is very clearly part 1 of a series where the author was still learning along the way.
As I've said before I LOVE Gryphon books. I love burds. Birbs. Berds. You name it. I'll read anything if a gryphon or some avian race is heavily featured. And as a result I do love the world that was built here. I love the idea that gryphons were 'made' and are becoming a part of human society. I love the ways the humans and gryphons interacted, I loved every gryphon character in this story, and it's clear Rein did too.
However...the problem was that it still took place on earth. I get that's sort of the POINT (To have gryphons show up on earth because the idea of having a fluffy, downy lover is definitely one I can get behind), but it kind of made a lot of the social commentary way too blunt and hit way too close to home. ESPECIALLY in 2025/2026. I know this book was written a long time before our current dumpster fire of a DSA (Divided States of America), but honestly the bigotry and clear racism is...well if we didn't live in 2025/2026 it'd be cartoonishly over the top. Add PDF Files to the list and you'd have a pretty accurate representation of the current political landscape.
That is neither here nor there. I don't intend to turn my reviews of what I wish was a cute, cozy gryphon book.
Because I think there's an excellent story here. Jonathan and Thyra are cute as hell. The story of struggling to be accepted in a world full of bigots is one most people can relate to. The conflict that comes with cultures clashing and how they resolve the issue is one that is always worth exploring. But it feels like there were a dozen great ideas thrown at the wall and none of them got enough muster to stick. I think all of these issues could have easily been resolved with a longer run time. Like I said, this is an excellent prologue or the skeleton of a story but with it being so short it doesn't have much room to flesh out the world or plot so a lot of the messages needed to be blunt with CLEARLY cartoonishly evil villains, and the story suffers for that.
It's a story about acceptance in a world of intolerance but it really only comes up with brazen speeches and bold hate speech. An early plot point involved a court case about assault borne of bigotry that is solved off screen. There's an in-world sport introduced that only gives the most basic explanation of how it works or how it's played. There's commentary about fake news and media manipulation. There's a brief subplot about a gryphon accidentally hunting the wrong thing and feeling terrible about it. And very briefly, we get hints as to the backstory about how the gryphons were made, and how they came into this world.
All of these things on their own are excellent stories I'm certain had room to be their own book. every single element of this book is a hint of an idea I'd LOVE to see explored (And I know some are in the later books). I want to see a story about a gryphon who delivers groceries (So much so I'm actually writing a vaguely similar concept of a hybrid gal who delivers potions and enchanted items). I want to see a story about a gryphon involved in an avian sport. I want to see a legal procedural about how human courts would adapt to dealing with gryphon situations. I want to see the civil rights movements of humans gaining the right to marry a gryphon. I want to hear about how the gryphons came to be. ALL of these are excellent ideas for a novel.
And none of them are properly explored (yet). Which is a shame. Because reading this has definitely made me want to read more. Heck, I'd be down for a cozy story about Jonathan and Thyra. Heck, I wanna see a HEated Rivalry styled smutty romance with Thyra and Aadhya (Spelling is probably wrong, I listened via audiobook, which was excellent by the way). I love the world that we're plopped into here and would love to explore it more. I just feel like, strictly on what we see here, in this first book of what is so far a 5 book series, none of those ideas are explored enough to really sink its claws into me.
I am so glad books 2-4 are already available on audible and book 5 is also out there, so I don't have to wait long to see where this goes, because I have to admit if I read this when there was no guarantee of sequels, it'd be a tough sell to keep my attention. As it stands, I see SO much passion and love and a world I want to visit with characters I want to meet, wrapped in a story that is missing a lot of the meat needed to fill it out.
If I had to sum it up, The Gryphon Generation is a hollow skeleton of an excellent story that REALLY needs to get some meat on those bones. (Get it? Because avians have hollow bones!)
6.7/10