What do you think?
Rate this book
Ike and Monty: Generals at War
'A clear understanding of warfare and the politics of WWII.' Kirkus Reviews
The Allied invasion of Normandy was one of the greatest military operations of the last hundred years.
But although it was led by two great commanders, they seldom saw eye to eye.
Dwight David Eisenhower and Bernard Law Montgomery were men of such profoundly contrasting temperaments and strategic orientation that their relationship was bound to be stormy.
‘Ike and Monty’ is the first book to focus exclusively on how their often bitter relationship determined the fate of the Allied effort to liberate Europe in World War II.
From the invasion of North Africa to D-Day, from the Battle of the Bulge to the fall of Berlin, Ike and Monty draws a masterful portrait of a tortured union between two military giants.
It is also an account of how their clash of wills came to personify the historic moment when the United States assumed the role of superpower in the West and once-powerful Great Britain was obliged to accept that it could no longer aspire to such exalted status.
Norman Gelb has written several highly acclaimed books, including 'Desperate The Story of Operation Torch', 'The Allied Invasion of North Africa' and ' The Complete Story of the First Step in the Defeat of Hitler'. He lives in London and is a correspondent for New Leader magazine.
Praise for Norman
“Mr. Gelb has excavated beneath surface events, delved into political and psychological factors, and produced an intelligent, fast-moving narrative.” PROFESSOR ARNOLD AGES, Baltimore Sun
The Allied invasion of Normandy was one of the greatest military operations of the last hundred years.
But although it was led by two great commanders, they seldom saw eye to eye.
Dwight David Eisenhower and Bernard Law Montgomery were men of such profoundly contrasting temperaments and strategic orientation that their relationship was bound to be stormy.
‘Ike and Monty’ is the first book to focus exclusively on how their often bitter relationship determined the fate of the Allied effort to liberate Europe in World War II.
From the invasion of North Africa to D-Day, from the Battle of the Bulge to the fall of Berlin, Ike and Monty draws a masterful portrait of a tortured union between two military giants.
It is also an account of how their clash of wills came to personify the historic moment when the United States assumed the role of superpower in the West and once-powerful Great Britain was obliged to accept that it could no longer aspire to such exalted status.
Norman Gelb has written several highly acclaimed books, including 'Desperate The Story of Operation Torch', 'The Allied Invasion of North Africa' and ' The Complete Story of the First Step in the Defeat of Hitler'. He lives in London and is a correspondent for New Leader magazine.
Praise for Norman
“Mr. Gelb has excavated beneath surface events, delved into political and psychological factors, and produced an intelligent, fast-moving narrative.” PROFESSOR ARNOLD AGES, Baltimore Sun
413 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 1, 1994
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews
May 11, 2016
This is an excellent look at two of the biggest personalities of World War II. They didn't see eye to eye, and they didn't always agree. It made for tense times in an already tense time. The most interesting aspect was something I'd never considered before: That WWII was the first time England had to admit they weren't the world's foremost power anymore. That certainly added to the strain between these two. A must-read for WWII buffs.
August 18, 2015
This book aims to examine the relationship between the two main western allied commanders in World War two, Eisenhower and Montgomery.
For all practical purposes Norman Gelb achieves it by constructing two separate biographies, which he develops as the book unfolds, stopping from time to time to draw comparisons in the careers of both generals, or to examine the episodes, almost always contentious, that happened between the two. Such an approach has the advantage of allowing the reader to understand why the intervenients acted as they did when faced by particular problems and challenges. It also has the merit of covering a large number of events which are not central (or known) to the world war II student.
The book is incredibly well written, very easy to read and is filled with sometimes delicious accounts of particular episodes. I found myself laughing alone when I read about the time Montgomery organized a football team in India to win 40-0 against a team of tired German sailors. Against suggestions the he go easy on the poor sailors, he replied he could "never go easy on the Germans"; or sharing Eisenhower's indignation with Montgomery's dismissive treatment of him the very first time they ever met.
The book has it's weak points, however. It touches upon so many subjects and so many battles that many episodes are only mentioned in passing and without depth. The explanations offered for the fall of France in 1940 are a case in point: shallow and naive, one is left wondering that the british lost the campaign due to a lack of adequate antitank guns, which is very far off the mark.
Some other, seemly important, are not even mentioned. In particular I was annoyed at having been left wondering exactly what Montgomery did and in which battles he took place in four years in the trenches in world war I.
More seriously, the author does not seem to understand how fragile the British army in world war II really was, with their underlying problems of manpower and low morale. As explained elsewhere (Ex: "Colossal Cracks" or "Raising Churchill's army"), the British army really needed Monty's authoritarian ways of command to be successful, and the author misses that completely, relying too much, as he does, on the memories of hostile witnesses.
All in all a great book that sheds light on the relationship of two important generals and keeps the reader continuously turning the page.
Thank you to Endeavour press for providing me with a free review copy.
For all practical purposes Norman Gelb achieves it by constructing two separate biographies, which he develops as the book unfolds, stopping from time to time to draw comparisons in the careers of both generals, or to examine the episodes, almost always contentious, that happened between the two. Such an approach has the advantage of allowing the reader to understand why the intervenients acted as they did when faced by particular problems and challenges. It also has the merit of covering a large number of events which are not central (or known) to the world war II student.
The book is incredibly well written, very easy to read and is filled with sometimes delicious accounts of particular episodes. I found myself laughing alone when I read about the time Montgomery organized a football team in India to win 40-0 against a team of tired German sailors. Against suggestions the he go easy on the poor sailors, he replied he could "never go easy on the Germans"; or sharing Eisenhower's indignation with Montgomery's dismissive treatment of him the very first time they ever met.
The book has it's weak points, however. It touches upon so many subjects and so many battles that many episodes are only mentioned in passing and without depth. The explanations offered for the fall of France in 1940 are a case in point: shallow and naive, one is left wondering that the british lost the campaign due to a lack of adequate antitank guns, which is very far off the mark.
Some other, seemly important, are not even mentioned. In particular I was annoyed at having been left wondering exactly what Montgomery did and in which battles he took place in four years in the trenches in world war I.
More seriously, the author does not seem to understand how fragile the British army in world war II really was, with their underlying problems of manpower and low morale. As explained elsewhere (Ex: "Colossal Cracks" or "Raising Churchill's army"), the British army really needed Monty's authoritarian ways of command to be successful, and the author misses that completely, relying too much, as he does, on the memories of hostile witnesses.
All in all a great book that sheds light on the relationship of two important generals and keeps the reader continuously turning the page.
Thank you to Endeavour press for providing me with a free review copy.
August 8, 2015
This is an intriguing and fascinating look into the relationship between Eisenhower and Montgomery during the Second World War and the stresses and strains this went through as differences of experience, strategy, responsibility and opinion led to internal and external conflict and potentially catastrophic miscommunications and misunderstandings. The first few chapters follows the careers of each, showing them to be very different in experience and influence with the later chapters bringing the two men together as America enters the War following the bombing of Pearl Harbor. Gelb has kept the whole as well balanced as possible but I did feel that the writing was more sympathetic to Eisenhower as Montgomery's abrupt and straight forward approach was made one of the main drivers between the two men. This could be because I have a strange respect and soft spot for Montgomery though and I find his no nonsense approach to life rather refreshing, as it seems many of his men did too. I love his approach to his commanders even more as he was never shy of providing his honest opinion of their decisions, no matter how positive...or negative. Knowing very little of Eisenhower I was interested to learn about his rather humble beginnings and was surprised to learn how little battle experience he had given the important role he had in managing the Allied forces. This book even goes beyond the War and looks at their relationship afterwards and how despite attempts on both side to bury the hatchet, it never really happened as the honest approach of one didn't gel well with the more diplomatic approach of the other. A very fascinating read and insight into a key relationship of the Second World War.
February 1, 2025
Review of Ike and Monty: Generals at War by Norman Gelb
In Ike and Monty: Generals at War, Norman Gelb takes readers on an insightful journey into the complexities of the relationship between two of the most significant military leaders of World War II: General Dwight D. Eisenhower and General Bernard Montgomery. Despite their profound leadership during the Allied invasion of Normandy, their personal and professional relationship was marked by contrast, tension, and ultimately, rivalry.
Key Themes and Events:
• Eisenhower and Montgomery’s Contrasting Personalities: Gelb carefully dissects the stark differences between Eisenhower’s measured diplomacy and Montgomery’s often brash and confrontational style. The two generals, while sharing the same ultimate goal of defeating Nazi Germany, found themselves at odds on key military decisions. Gelb expertly portrays how their contrasting temperaments shaped the success of the Normandy landings and subsequent campaigns in Europe.
• The Invasion of Normandy and Beyond: The book focuses heavily on the D-Day invasion, a pivotal moment in history. Gelb reflects on how these two men, despite their differences, led the largest and most complex military operation ever undertaken in modern history. The narrative spans from North Africa to the Battle of the Bulge, and ultimately to the fall of Berlin.
• Political and Military Power Struggles: A theme running throughout the book is the tension between the United States and Great Britain, especially after the invasion of Normandy. Gelb explores the personal and political dynamics between Eisenhower, Montgomery, and their respective nations, highlighting how these played a crucial role in shaping the strategic direction of the war. The book goes beyond just military strategy to include the broader geopolitical implications of their decisions.
• Leadership and Legacy: Gelb contrasts the leadership styles of Eisenhower and Montgomery, offering insights into how their contrasting approaches shaped the outcome of the war and their legacies in history. While Eisenhower is often lauded for his diplomatic acumen, Montgomery’s forceful personality often led to friction within the high command. Gelb paints a compelling portrait of how the two generals ultimately had to reconcile their differences for the success of the Allied war effort.
Notable Quotes:
• “A clear understanding of warfare and the politics of WWII.” – Kirkus Reviews
• “The conflict between Ike and Monty personified the historical moment when the United States assumed the role of superpower in the West…” – The New York Times
Final Verdict:
Ike and Monty: Generals at War is a fascinating exploration of the rivalry and cooperation between two iconic figures of World War II. Gelb’s detailed analysis not only illuminates their relationship but also provides a deeper understanding of the strategic decisions that helped shape the course of the war. This book is an essential read for those interested in military history, leadership dynamics, and the politics behind the scenes of global conflict.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
In Ike and Monty: Generals at War, Norman Gelb takes readers on an insightful journey into the complexities of the relationship between two of the most significant military leaders of World War II: General Dwight D. Eisenhower and General Bernard Montgomery. Despite their profound leadership during the Allied invasion of Normandy, their personal and professional relationship was marked by contrast, tension, and ultimately, rivalry.
Key Themes and Events:
• Eisenhower and Montgomery’s Contrasting Personalities: Gelb carefully dissects the stark differences between Eisenhower’s measured diplomacy and Montgomery’s often brash and confrontational style. The two generals, while sharing the same ultimate goal of defeating Nazi Germany, found themselves at odds on key military decisions. Gelb expertly portrays how their contrasting temperaments shaped the success of the Normandy landings and subsequent campaigns in Europe.
• The Invasion of Normandy and Beyond: The book focuses heavily on the D-Day invasion, a pivotal moment in history. Gelb reflects on how these two men, despite their differences, led the largest and most complex military operation ever undertaken in modern history. The narrative spans from North Africa to the Battle of the Bulge, and ultimately to the fall of Berlin.
• Political and Military Power Struggles: A theme running throughout the book is the tension between the United States and Great Britain, especially after the invasion of Normandy. Gelb explores the personal and political dynamics between Eisenhower, Montgomery, and their respective nations, highlighting how these played a crucial role in shaping the strategic direction of the war. The book goes beyond just military strategy to include the broader geopolitical implications of their decisions.
• Leadership and Legacy: Gelb contrasts the leadership styles of Eisenhower and Montgomery, offering insights into how their contrasting approaches shaped the outcome of the war and their legacies in history. While Eisenhower is often lauded for his diplomatic acumen, Montgomery’s forceful personality often led to friction within the high command. Gelb paints a compelling portrait of how the two generals ultimately had to reconcile their differences for the success of the Allied war effort.
Notable Quotes:
• “A clear understanding of warfare and the politics of WWII.” – Kirkus Reviews
• “The conflict between Ike and Monty personified the historical moment when the United States assumed the role of superpower in the West…” – The New York Times
Final Verdict:
Ike and Monty: Generals at War is a fascinating exploration of the rivalry and cooperation between two iconic figures of World War II. Gelb’s detailed analysis not only illuminates their relationship but also provides a deeper understanding of the strategic decisions that helped shape the course of the war. This book is an essential read for those interested in military history, leadership dynamics, and the politics behind the scenes of global conflict.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
October 15, 2018
"Ike and Monty" eBook was published in 2018 and was written by Norman Gelb. Mr. Gelb has published nearly a dozen non-fiction books.
I received an ARC of this novel through https://www.netgalley.com in return for a fair and honest review. I categorize this novel as ‘G’. The book covers the entire period of World War II, focusing on the European Theater of Operations in general and on Generals Dwight David Eisenhower and Bernard Law Montgomery in particular.
This book examines both of these major figures from the war in depth. A fair assessment is given to both their strengths and weaknesses. Both made significant contributions to the Allied war effort, but each had their faults. This book is an interesting look at what was happening behind the headlines and how these allies were often at odds with one another.
I enjoyed the 13 hours I spent reading this 413-page history of World War II. This was an easy to read history. Certainly, I learned a lot about the politics and the conflicts between the Allies during the War. I think the cover art is a good choice. I give this novel a 4 out of 5.
Further book reviews I have written can be accessed at https://johnpurvis.wordpress.com/blog/.
I received an ARC of this novel through https://www.netgalley.com in return for a fair and honest review. I categorize this novel as ‘G’. The book covers the entire period of World War II, focusing on the European Theater of Operations in general and on Generals Dwight David Eisenhower and Bernard Law Montgomery in particular.
This book examines both of these major figures from the war in depth. A fair assessment is given to both their strengths and weaknesses. Both made significant contributions to the Allied war effort, but each had their faults. This book is an interesting look at what was happening behind the headlines and how these allies were often at odds with one another.
I enjoyed the 13 hours I spent reading this 413-page history of World War II. This was an easy to read history. Certainly, I learned a lot about the politics and the conflicts between the Allies during the War. I think the cover art is a good choice. I give this novel a 4 out of 5.
Further book reviews I have written can be accessed at https://johnpurvis.wordpress.com/blog/.
June 3, 2025
I really enjoyed this book. Monty really was an a-hole and Ike failed miserably in trying to concoct a productive working relationship. Both Ike and Monty had serious limitations, but their skill sets could have been complimentary. For this failure, Monty deserves most of the blame, as he just never could get over the fact that somebody he believed to be his inferior was, in fact, his boss.
It’s easy to Monday-morning quarterback all the decisions Ike made in the prosecution of the war in Europe though one can never fully appreciate the pressures of the moment and the lack of clear information available at the time decisions were made. Would the war have been won more quickly if Monty’s strategy had been employed? Maybe. But would Monty really have been daring enough to carry it out? We’ll never know for sure.
Well-written. Lots of good info. An excellent dual biography.
It’s easy to Monday-morning quarterback all the decisions Ike made in the prosecution of the war in Europe though one can never fully appreciate the pressures of the moment and the lack of clear information available at the time decisions were made. Would the war have been won more quickly if Monty’s strategy had been employed? Maybe. But would Monty really have been daring enough to carry it out? We’ll never know for sure.
Well-written. Lots of good info. An excellent dual biography.
February 28, 2020
Clear Analysis
The book gives a different view of the two primary military leaders in the Western Allied theatre of war than the one we have been fed over the decades since the conflict ended. Both are shown as Men with their good and lesser characteristics, but with particular focus on their personal and wartime relationship. It flows well without the points being over-labored. A very interesting approach to the period of the Allies defeat of Nazi Germany.
The book gives a different view of the two primary military leaders in the Western Allied theatre of war than the one we have been fed over the decades since the conflict ended. Both are shown as Men with their good and lesser characteristics, but with particular focus on their personal and wartime relationship. It flows well without the points being over-labored. A very interesting approach to the period of the Allies defeat of Nazi Germany.
December 15, 2017
World War II Story
The author dotes a good and interesting job of explaining why it was that Montgomery did not get along with American Generals. I understood that he was arrogant and impolite but never before had I realized that his was so far from correct behavior. This author explains in a comprehensive way just how rigid and unthinking he could be.
The author dotes a good and interesting job of explaining why it was that Montgomery did not get along with American Generals. I understood that he was arrogant and impolite but never before had I realized that his was so far from correct behavior. This author explains in a comprehensive way just how rigid and unthinking he could be.
September 11, 2017
Initially I thought that I would be reading a very documentary & dry book. To my delight I found it to be extremely readable...much like a novel. It was, in my opinion, one of the best researched & enjoyable books about these two Generals during World war II. It was a book that I needed to read on a subject that I wanted to be educated upon.
Thank you Mr. Gelb for a wonderful & illuminating 'story.'
Captain D.J. Mody
Thank you Mr. Gelb for a wonderful & illuminating 'story.'
Captain D.J. Mody
December 29, 2017
Extraordinarily well written
Very thorough and balanced presentation of a complex subject. It treated both men honestly and fairly. Well worth the time.
Very thorough and balanced presentation of a complex subject. It treated both men honestly and fairly. Well worth the time.
July 10, 2018
Excellent history of two fascinating personalities
February 21, 2019
Great overview
Hjhff mhhi jhh khj jhgjjghjkghkjgj jhu8 hggouy jj kk kj jj jj jjkjjjjk oko kki jjj jkj kmm mnn nmm
Hjhff mhhi jhh khj jhgjjghjkghkjgj jhu8 hggouy jj kk kj jj jj jjkjjjjk oko kki jjj jkj kmm mnn nmm
September 7, 2015
fascinating book that reads mostly as a story of contrasting biographies who led the Western European front of WWII.
Overall, it starts very fast with interesting childhoods and military educations of each officer, Then it moves to The Africa campaigns and shows their battles against the Germans. Then it does slow down getting into deep details about the fight from Normandy to Gwtmany.Finally it details a little historiography trying to ask questions of importance on the war.
Overall, I think this was a good biography at beginning but it really gets a little distracted and detailed in the invasion of Western Europe.
Thanks to Endeavour Press for providing free book for review.
Overall, it starts very fast with interesting childhoods and military educations of each officer, Then it moves to The Africa campaigns and shows their battles against the Germans. Then it does slow down getting into deep details about the fight from Normandy to Gwtmany.Finally it details a little historiography trying to ask questions of importance on the war.
Overall, I think this was a good biography at beginning but it really gets a little distracted and detailed in the invasion of Western Europe.
Thanks to Endeavour Press for providing free book for review.
September 20, 2015
Firstly, I should say that I that I was given this book by the publisher. I really found the book interesting, being British I have not read much about American generals. This book confirmed many of the stories of Montgomery's behaviour and I was impressed with how Eisenhower did try his best in very difficult circumstances. A good book if you are interested in military command at the highest level and World War 2 military history.
February 20, 2016
I was given an ebook copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. this is about 2 generals and their Ike who is American and Monty who is British It is very informative and well writen. There is much detail regarding the campaigns and battles of the second world war and the relationship between the 2 generals. I would recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in military history
August 17, 2015
Ike and Monty is the tale of the senior American and British military leaders in Europe during World War II. There is a nice biography track for both Eisenhower and Montgromery in the work that explores the background and character of each. Ike and Monty is a good supplemental read about World War II. My e-book copy was a free review copy from Endeavor Books. I recommend this work.
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews