What do you think?
Rate this book


352 pages, ebook
First published October 18, 2018
(This review concerns Book of the Year 2018, by James Harkin, Anna Ptaszynski, Andrew Hunter Murray, Dan Schreiber, in case Goodreads does this stupid thing where it collapses multiple entries into some type of anthology edition)
General impressions
NB: This book is part of a series. I may or may not have focused my efforts in reviewing the last part of the series.
Rating (Intuitive*): 4
Rating (Weighted**): 3.29
RMSE***(Intuitive,Weighted): 0.51
Mean error***(Intuitive,Weighted): -0.01
Format: Audiobook
Language: English
The audiobook versions of No Such Thing as a Fish's Book of the Year ("Audiobook of the Year" are basically bonus podcast episodes. So much so that some entries are recorded at live podcast events during their various tours. I guess this gives me the opportunity to review a podcast on here.
Anecdotes and data
Numeracy and epistemic hygiene: 1/5 [w:3]
Interestingness: 5/5 [w:2]
Since this book is 100% just a collection of amusing trivia, I guess you really shouldn't expect much apart from entertainment value (which it delivers), but it irks me to no end that they try to present this air of credibility or intellectual-ness but whew do get reminded of Gell-Mann amnesia whenever they approach a subject with which you are familiar. This may or may not be especially egregious in this specific volume, but is evident throughout their podcast back catalog. What is (maybe) worse, is that the anecdotes are specifically editorialised to be as surprising as possible. Granted, they sometimes explain why an anecdote that seems very unusual on its face isn't all that unexpected.
Presentation
Clarity & disposition: 4/5 [w:2.5]
Prose: 4/5 [w:1.5]
Design, layout and gimmicks: 4/5 [w:1.5]
The structure is that of an encyclopaedia, with each chapter being a letter, and then listing amusing or unusual events during the year in question in (roughly) alphabetical order. Much more than in the case of most other audiobooks, there's a lot of stuff going on "off script" as it were. In a lot of audiobooks, you have the reader doing voices, you may have some sound effects or a short music score or something. But since Audiobook of the Year is read by a regular podcast ensemble, there's also a lot of banter going on, as well as some entries being recorded at live podcasting shows.
Additional modifiers
Page turner factor: 4/5 [w:3.5]
Mind blown factor: 3/5 [w:2.5]
Author credibility: 1/5 [w:1]
Recommended related reading*****:The No Such Thing as a Fish podcast.
*The rating I felt this deserved before thinking about it too much.
**Weights displayed next to each applicable scoring criterion. (Weights version 3.1)
***Root mean squared error and mean error calculated for all reviews using this format for books read from 2020-07-12 up until this book (24 reviews).
*****With a bias in favour of stuff I've read more recently, so stuff might be missing.