The Poem Is You: 60 Contemporary American Poems and How to Read Them

by Stephanie Burt

A Guardian Best Book of the Year
A Poets & Writers "Best Books for Writers" Selection
A Choice Outstanding Academic Title of the Year
A Harvard Book Store "Holiday Hundred" Selection
A Seminary Co-op Notable Book of the Year


"[Burt] approaches a stunning variety of verse with the obsessiveness and knowledge of a scholar and a fan. Burt is an ideal guide for this trip through contemporary American poetry...Burt's close readings are sharp and illuminating...The death of poetry has been proclaimed time and time again. But the sixty universes that Burt uncovers in these poems show us how alive poetry is, and how it needs to be read and appreciated for all its weirdness and cacophonous music."
--Gibson Fay-LeBlanc, Bookforum

"It is refreshing to find a book that gives equal weight and relish to avant-garde minimalism, New Formalism, and so many of the stations in between...Each essay is obviously a product of enjoyment, and encourages us to treat poems with the same enthusiasm--to embrace difficulty and difference in exchange for the articulate and involved pleasure that poetry, of all the arts, can best provide."
--Rory Waterman, Times Literary Supplement

Genres: Poetry, Nonfiction, Literary Criticism, Essays, Literature

432 pages, Paperback

First published September 12, 2016

About the author

Stephanie Burt is the author of fourteen books of poetry and literary criticism, including Super Gay Poems and Don’t Read Poetry. A past judge for the Pulitzer Prize for Poetry, she served as a board member of the National Book Critics Circle, is the recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship, and writes regularly for the New York Times Book Review, the New Yorker, London Review of Books, the New York Review of Books, Raritan, and other publications. She is the Donald P. and Katherine B. Loker Professor of English at Harvard University.

Reviews

[Crystal · Rating 5 out of 5]

Absolutely one of the best books ABOUT poetry I have ever read. I read a TON of poetry and Burt still introduced me to some fabulous poets who had apparently been flying under my radar all these years. It's a great joy to see such a flexible, acute mind at work!

[Jonathan Giles · Rating 4 out of 5]

An excellent book of poetry on contemporary American poets and the various poetic movements that have come to the fore since 1980. Some of the poets selected by Stephen Burt seemed chosen by a professor of English (or Poetry) at Harvard, i.e., way more academic than many readers wanting to connect with contemporary poetry, but one can't admonish Stephen Burt for the effort he has gone through to make this book informative and meaningful. I enjoyed reading each and every poem as Burt arranged them and, after following up with his commentary, returning to the poem for a second or third or more reading. (Even now, I have gone back to revisit a poem from his selection.) To be honest, some of the poems would have made no sense without his insight, others seems a little too, too precious to be on a list I might compile, but overall, I liked comparing my limited interpretation with his expertise. All in all a fun read and an enjoyable exercise in reading, studying, and just thinking about excellent contemporary poetry. What a great job Burt must have!

[Danielle · Rating 3 out of 5]

There are so many lovely contemporary poems in this book and I enjoyed identifying poets who I am excited to get to know better in the future. Also enjoyed learning about their careers and lives a bit. I got very tired of the analysis of each poem -- I don't want a professor to tell me how to interpret a poem before I've had time to digest it. I ended up skimming all the analyses by the end.

[Sungbin Kim · Rating 3 out of 5]

If you want to study poetry for the first time like me, don't start with contemporary poems. I would not have understood anything without Stephanie's commentaries. Here are my favorite poems from this anthology:

"The Ride" by Richard Wilbur
"Epigraph" by Allan Peterson
"Nature" by Rae Armantrout
"Moab" by Donald Revell
"The Blue Terrance" by Terrance Hayes
"Date: Post Glacial" by Dg Nanouk Okpik
"Class" by Rose Alcala
"Hide-and-Seek with God" by Brenda Shaughnessy
"Oulipo" by Brandon Som

[James · Rating 2 out of 5]

Oy.

I had a lot of feelings about this book. I think it's a good concept with a laudable goal: to make contemporary poetry more approachable. The execution has some real problems. In fact, I would say the execution makes contemporary poetry seem less approachable than ever.

If we took the book as a sincere illustration of "How to Read" contemporary poems, then every contemporary poem would require roughly 15 paragraphs of explanation to fully appreciate. Burt's essays on each of these poems are about the same length: four pages, regardless of the length of the poem. (Even the one-line poem "oh he got a shoe from the waves" gets this treatment. I must be really stingy to think it deserves less.)

It's not just that these essays are too long. A bigger problem is that they are too similar for poems that differ widely. The sameyness of the explanation--the length, the mildly to effusively appreciative tone, the just-so conclusions--does a disservice to the poems and to the reader, who, if they're like me, ends up slogging through the essays to get to the next poem.

The book would more accurately be titled "The Poem is Stephen Burt." The author often seems to be brandishing his knowledge rather than inviting readers into the poems. And the writing is sometimes sloppy. Of Terrance Hayes' "The Blue Terrance," he says "these sixty-nine lines also belong to a larger set." The poem in question clearly has 39 lines. Quite the margin of error there. In his essay on Ross Gay's "Weeping," he refers to "precise" and "tiny" as "adverbs." I suppose mistakes like this will slip through when there is just so much prose to edit.

It's a shame, because the 60 poems in the collection are, with a few exceptions, really, really good. And Burt clearly does love poetry. In that ridiculously long essay on the one-line poem, he says, "We go to a poem, or to poets or to schools of poetry, not as we show up for a standardized test but as we go to the beach." That's just the right attitude. Unfortunately, with his highly standardized approach to each poem, he doesn't practice what he preaches.

[James Murphy · Rating 3 out of 5]

This is a collection of 60 contemporary poems, each accompanied by a Stephen Burt essay explaining "how a given poem works, why it matters, and how the poem speaks to other parts of art and culture." I loved the essays. Except for a handful, I didn't care for the poems.

[Madeline Riley · Rating 4 out of 5]

Really rewarding reading experience! It took me forever to get through - poetry is so hard! But I loved many of the poems and found the essays analyzing them extraordinary. I am amazed by the depth in the poems - the interesting use of language, the commentary on poetry itself, the references, the interesting perspectives on the world - I wouldn't have picked up on half of it without the essays.

Top poems in no particular order:
- tito madera smith, Tato Laviera
- Saxophone, Liam Rector
- Facing It, Yusef Komunyakaa
- Domestic Mysticism, Lucie Brock-Broido
- Haylley's Comet, Stanley Kunitz
- Our Lady of the Snow's, Robert Hass
- [when he comes he is neither sun nor shade: a china doll], D.A. Powell
- Oversized T-Shirts, Gabby Bess

[Vyla · Rating 3 out of 5]

Read this for school- an intermediate poetry workshop. Honestly, I only read some of the actual critiques/ analysis, but I read all the poems.

I thought this book was a cool concept. It introduced me to new poets and new styles of writing. I think it serves as a good introduction to American poetry, but could also be a desirable read for people who have already read a lot of poetry.

Some of the poems I did not like, some I loved. I found the critiques kind of long and sometimes pretty boring and repetitive (why I did not end up reading many of them).

Overall, I'm happy my professor assigned this book, but I am not sure I would have read it outside of class.

[Peggy · Rating 5 out of 5]

A helpful reference book that contains the text of sixty poems arranged chronologically from 1981 to 2015. The author discusses each poem in a 3-5 page essay, describing poetic techniques used, placing the poem and/or the poet within larger literary movements, and mentioning the poet's literary influences and followers. Informative, fascinating, and a must-have source for anyone who wishes to better understand contemporary American poetry.

[Gerald Greene · Rating 5 out of 5]

I read this book hoping to develop a taste and appreciation for modern poetry.

Perhaps I don't try hard enough, I've thought, but after reading this book, I'm convinced modern poetry is not meant to be understood in a casual setting.

Stephen Burt's knowledge covering so many topics is truly impressive as he guides the reader through the maze that would otherwise remain a kluge of confusion.

I'm glad I stumbled across this book at the local library and recommend it highly.

[Karen Boyle · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love the way Burt discusses each of the 60 poems first published between 1981-2016. He poses questions implied by the poems, presents possible answers and gives in depth background information about the poets.

[erin · Rating 4 out of 5]

I thoroughly enjoyed this read, both the poems were incredible, and the content was phenomenal. it's very well-written, and the poems are EXPLAINED IN SUCH DETAIL. if you are like me, and find it so difficult to understand and analyze certain poems, read this.

[Ren]

I would recommend it for people who have read a ton of poetry, understand lots of poetry, and love deep deep analysis of poetry.

I as a beginner and casual dabbler found it too dense for me but can see how someone else might love this book.

[T.J. · Rating 3 out of 5]

...and Emma must have flown away for good,
judging from the not brutal silence at breakfast, as Mikayla chewed

the waffle goofily with her one front tooth gone, and weakly smiled

[Zach · Rating 5 out of 5]

Rare to find a collection of poetry curated by a poet that showcases obscure poems from well-known poets. A lot of gems.

[Jordan]

I gave it 50 pages. I was hoping for a more approachable text to guide me into the world of understanding poetry— this wasn’t a good fit.

[Ron Cruz · Rating 5 out of 5]

Excellent and delightful way to learn more about understanding contemporary poetry

[John · Rating 4 out of 5]

I'm a complete novice with poetry so this was a wonderful start to dip my toes into several decades of American poetry. Burt's essay on each poem and its author were wonderful teaching tools, helping to understand the more difficult poems, appreciate the structural beauty that I was unaware of, and give background on what informed the poem itself in the author's life, world politics, and the poet scene. Definitely introduced me to some poems and poets that I thoroughly enjoy and appreciate, and plan on reading more of.

[World Literature Today]

"Since nobody reads poems, we are reminded often enough, it’s better, the editors assume, to knock down than put up fences. Predictably so, Stephen Burt, the noted poet and Harvard professor, apologizes for not being more inclusive, too, but he really shouldn’t. Despite its limited scope and explicit preference for work championed by the editor himself, this is the best anthology of American poetry out there." - Piotr Florczyk

This book was reviewed in the May 2017 issue of World Literature Today magazine. Read the full review by visiting our website: https://www.worldliteraturetoday.org/...

[Diane Reynolds]

This book is in the subcategory of "taking my sweet time with it." Some books you fly through, others, you read like a normal human. And some, you study, very carefully and very slowly.