Topside depicts Ella’s experiences going topside on Earth for the first time and fighting Wreckers there. For anyone who is already familiar with Moore’s world, this amounts to quite a simple premise—but it all came together much better for me on my rereads! Topside sets up for the uprising in Disintegration beautifully, as Ella vows at the end of the narrative to endeavor to “find a way to win” against those controlling her. Moreover, the work is short enough that the constant action does not at all become tiresome for me; it remains engaging throughout.
One particular intriguing and clever aspect of Topside is how Moore always refers to Ella by her Biobot number in narration—up until the point when Ella receives affirmation and moral support from Viktor. After having been thus validated as a human being, Ella begins being referred to by her actual name.
Admittedly, I would still probably Topside as my least favorite story in the Malfunction universe. While very likable, Ella and Viktor are nowhere near as engaging for me to follow as the likes of Bas, Cowl, Menrva, and Starke are. And although reading about a Borg’s first trip topside proves absorbing, I do not necessarily feel that reading about Ella’s experiences gave me much of a glimpse into the Borg condition that I had not already acquired from reading about Bas’s experiences.
Nevertheless, Topside delivers as a riveting short story—not to mention a welcome addition to the Malfunction Universe! I am so thankful that Moore has deepened her universe by writing short stories and novellas. These stories simply make the worldbuilding and character arcs feel so much richer. Topside proves no exception. For a series as consistently impressive and enjoyable as Malfunction, “least favorite” is hardly a disparagement. Because “least favorite” is still really good!