Beautiful cover, lots of stories and interviews, a comprehensive look at gaming on the Mac in the pre-Intel era. I think this is an invaluable reference. But I didn't really like reading it. A few things bugged me:
* The organization is chapters dedicated to mainly genre, game, or publisher. Because each chapter spans the same ~20 year period repeatedly, I had no good sense of any timeline continuity. Devs would leave one chapter and show up in another as they moved companies. Sometimes things referred to in one chapter would have a note "see the next chapter for more about this". Expanded edition adds a timeline section, but doesn't change the organization of the book itself.
* I didn't get a good view of the changes to Mac hardware during the time. The B&W -> color, 68000 -> PowerPC -> Intel, and OS9 -> OSX shifts should have been (or were!) seismic upheavals for every developer, but the author waited until the very last chapter to mention their impact. It was hard to know which system a game was made for, what features it could or couldn't use, and the surrounding landscape of the industry.
* A lot of the dev stories just weren't compelling. No shade to the author here but I read so many indie startup stories that led off like "I was mowing laws and drinking beer all day while skipping college classes, when I discovered a Mac, and after seeing the holy computer mouse for the first time I dumped my life savings into a machine. Within months I had made the first (Tetris, Centipede, Arkanoid, etc) for the Mac and the shareware checks just rolled in." It's important to tell these stories but it's tedious to read.
* No mention of MECC / The Learning Company or any educational market, though school computer labs were often the only way a lot of young people were ever exposed to these expensive machines
* Would have liked more images (expanded edition probably corrects this).
Again, I'm glad this book exists, it's a wonderful historical reference and retrospective, but it just isn't compelling as a cover-to-cover read.