being many years past middle grade age i will try not to be too hash with my review... i loved Gidwitz's "A Tale Dark and Grimm" series fabulously, they were so funny and ceepy and action-packed and informative... this book did not do that for me, sadly... kinda cute, kinda funny, kinda interesting, kinda quirky... kinda average though too... just not enough depth to get swept up in it... again, i am old (surely MG age children would say that, and wonder how i'm not dead already!!), but i have been entranced and amazed by plenty of children's books, so it's not like i'm too jaded to see magic and wonder and imaginative storycraft... this one just wasn't for me, and i won't continue the series either... but i will keep an eye out for other books by Gidwitz, as i know he has talent and his next offering(s) may be just what i want...