What do you think?
Rate this book
Poison by Punctuation
High school teacher Emma Lovett is finally recovering from her first year of teaching when she discovers another dead body. As if that wasn’t bad enough, this time, someone has killed a student, Kisten Hollis.
Emma and her best friend, Leslie, are desperate to solve this murder. But suspects abound. The perpetrator could be a teacher, an administrator, a member of Kisten’s zealous church community, or even another student.
Emma must juggle her teaching responsibilities, her new romance with handsome Hunter Wells, and interest from a hunky second suitor, all while searching for evidence to bring a killer to justice before someone else dies.
Emma and her best friend, Leslie, are desperate to solve this murder. But suspects abound. The perpetrator could be a teacher, an administrator, a member of Kisten’s zealous church community, or even another student.
Emma must juggle her teaching responsibilities, her new romance with handsome Hunter Wells, and interest from a hunky second suitor, all while searching for evidence to bring a killer to justice before someone else dies.
243 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 24, 2018
3 people are currently reading
58 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews
June 10, 2019
Book Reviewed by Marcia on www.whisperingstories.com
Poison by Punctuation is the second book in the Chalkboard Outlines series by author Kelley Kaye. The first book, Death by Diploma I read back in April and really enjoyed it. Whilst reading the books in order was beneficial, I don’t think there would be an issue with reading book two without reading book one first.
Amateur sleuths, English teachers Emma Lovett and Leslie Parker are back to do their thing, solve mysteries. After an eventful first year at Jefferson High School, Emma was hoping for a more relaxed second year but as luck would have it another body is found.
Student cheerleader Kisten Hollis is found dead in the changing rooms by Emma. After helping to solve the murder of night janitor Melvin in book one, Emma and her best friend Leslie once again got back into the swing of being amateur detectives. They know that the cheerleaders have been sent threatening letters but who would want to kill a student?
With plenty of suspects to choose from, the duo has their work cut out. This isn’t going to be an easy case but these two ladies don’t give up that easily.
It was nice to see Emma and Leslie back doing their detective work. The story was enjoyable if a little darker than book one. It is a cozy mystery so alongside the women’s teaching jobs and their detective work we get to see how their love life is going.
The book was an easy read and I did love the banter that Emma and Leslie had, they reminded me of two school girls sometimes, they also complement one another perfectly. I am a little concern for the safety of the other pupils and staff now that more murders are being committed at the same school!! So I am wondering who will be next in book three? 🙂
The pace felt a little slower than book one but still captivating. If you like cosy mysteries then this is definitely a series to read.
Poison by Punctuation is the second book in the Chalkboard Outlines series by author Kelley Kaye. The first book, Death by Diploma I read back in April and really enjoyed it. Whilst reading the books in order was beneficial, I don’t think there would be an issue with reading book two without reading book one first.
Amateur sleuths, English teachers Emma Lovett and Leslie Parker are back to do their thing, solve mysteries. After an eventful first year at Jefferson High School, Emma was hoping for a more relaxed second year but as luck would have it another body is found.
Student cheerleader Kisten Hollis is found dead in the changing rooms by Emma. After helping to solve the murder of night janitor Melvin in book one, Emma and her best friend Leslie once again got back into the swing of being amateur detectives. They know that the cheerleaders have been sent threatening letters but who would want to kill a student?
With plenty of suspects to choose from, the duo has their work cut out. This isn’t going to be an easy case but these two ladies don’t give up that easily.
It was nice to see Emma and Leslie back doing their detective work. The story was enjoyable if a little darker than book one. It is a cozy mystery so alongside the women’s teaching jobs and their detective work we get to see how their love life is going.
The book was an easy read and I did love the banter that Emma and Leslie had, they reminded me of two school girls sometimes, they also complement one another perfectly. I am a little concern for the safety of the other pupils and staff now that more murders are being committed at the same school!! So I am wondering who will be next in book three? 🙂
The pace felt a little slower than book one but still captivating. If you like cosy mysteries then this is definitely a series to read.
July 10, 2018
This sequel is another thrilling yet cozy mystery that is set in the halls of a high school!
We continue on in this book with Emma and Leslie in yet another pickle. This time around, a student was murdered! The suspense is excellent in this story - I felt myself being pulled in even farther into the story as each page went by. It really hooks the reader and makes them feel committed! Throw in some A grade comedy, fantastic character development and lots of education allusions and you've got one epic book!
These two sleuths are basically the adult versions of Nancy Drew! The wittiness and cuteness of this book makes it the perfect relaxation novel. I also found it to be the perfect binging novel (although you could easily put this book down and jump back into it). It's also a G to PG rated book - there's nothing graphic or overly worrisome. Teens and adults alike will easily be able to read and enjoy this book!
It was a real delight seeing Emma and Leslie and their fantastic chemistry together again! The two of them make the perfect best friends for a fun, cozy story! I can almost feel them radiating their positivity off the pages! And on top of that, they are hilarious! I also have a strong love for the secondary characters as well! The other teachers are all interesting and truly characters.
Hunter was a real breakout character for me. I loved seeing more of him in this novel and I hope in any future books he's hanging around more!
I loved all the quotations between the chapters - that's one major part of this series that raises it above all the others! The Shakespeare quotes always get me! I love it!
My final comment - I loved that adoption became a big part of this book. The awareness of adoption, while out there, isn't spoken about enough (in my honest opinion). Thank you Kelley for expanding the conversation!
Kelley Kaye is the Queen of cozy, comedic mysteries! I will definitely be looking for more books by her and I highly recommend picking up this must read novel!
Four out of five stars!
I received a free copy of this novel from the author Kelley Kaye in exchange for an honest review.
We continue on in this book with Emma and Leslie in yet another pickle. This time around, a student was murdered! The suspense is excellent in this story - I felt myself being pulled in even farther into the story as each page went by. It really hooks the reader and makes them feel committed! Throw in some A grade comedy, fantastic character development and lots of education allusions and you've got one epic book!
These two sleuths are basically the adult versions of Nancy Drew! The wittiness and cuteness of this book makes it the perfect relaxation novel. I also found it to be the perfect binging novel (although you could easily put this book down and jump back into it). It's also a G to PG rated book - there's nothing graphic or overly worrisome. Teens and adults alike will easily be able to read and enjoy this book!
It was a real delight seeing Emma and Leslie and their fantastic chemistry together again! The two of them make the perfect best friends for a fun, cozy story! I can almost feel them radiating their positivity off the pages! And on top of that, they are hilarious! I also have a strong love for the secondary characters as well! The other teachers are all interesting and truly characters.
Hunter was a real breakout character for me. I loved seeing more of him in this novel and I hope in any future books he's hanging around more!
I loved all the quotations between the chapters - that's one major part of this series that raises it above all the others! The Shakespeare quotes always get me! I love it!
My final comment - I loved that adoption became a big part of this book. The awareness of adoption, while out there, isn't spoken about enough (in my honest opinion). Thank you Kelley for expanding the conversation!
Kelley Kaye is the Queen of cozy, comedic mysteries! I will definitely be looking for more books by her and I highly recommend picking up this must read novel!
Four out of five stars!
I received a free copy of this novel from the author Kelley Kaye in exchange for an honest review.
December 11, 2019
Someone has left a threat for the high school that seems to encompass all the students and teachers, but things definitely heat up when a student is found dead and someone is trying to kill off the teachers especially Emma and Leslie! Excellent characters that are well developed with unique personalities enhance an interesting and intriguing plot. Toss in some personal turmoil for both of our leading ladies and you have a well rounded book that will provide you with hours of entertainment. You don't absolutely have to read the first book in the series to enjoy this book, but you would be missing out on a fun and entertaining read that also allows you to get to know the characters even better!
April 21, 2018
Quirky and a little crazy, this cozy mystery will keep readers on their toes as murder hits close to home in the hallowed halls of education. High school teacher Emma Lovett and her best friend, Leslie are determined to find justice for cheerleader, Kristen Hollis. Will they be putting themselves in the cross hairs of danger?
How can they find a murderer when the murder weapon is far from normal? The plot thickens as the list of suspects grows. Was it the new teacher? The zealot preacher? A student isn’t out of the question, either, but the method for murder is like a snake in the grass, well-hidden and very deadly.
POISON BY PUNCTUATION by Kelley Kaye pits a fledgling teacher, her Shakespeare quoting friend, their insatiable curiosity and dogged termination against the unknown as suspects are eliminated in this venomous tale of death and detective work.
Rapid-fire dialogue, uncanny luck and a little science make this tale an entertaining take on who-dunnits as Emma and Leslie are once again up to their chalkboards in solving the murder equation before the victim count rises. Can they balance the scales of justice by following the clues or will their journey lead them straight to the principal’s office for detention and a time out?
Kelley Kaye’s style is light, filled with some fabulous twists and hidden turns that will make a mystery lover take notice!
I received a complimentary ARC edition from Red Adept and Kelley Kaye!
Series: Chalkline Outlines - Book 2
Publisher: Red Adept Publishing, LLC (April 24, 2018)
Publication Date: April 24, 2018
Genre: Cozy Mystery
Print Length: 243 pages
Available from: Amazon | Barnes & Noble
For Reviews, Giveaways, Fabulous Book News: http://tometender.blogspot.com
How can they find a murderer when the murder weapon is far from normal? The plot thickens as the list of suspects grows. Was it the new teacher? The zealot preacher? A student isn’t out of the question, either, but the method for murder is like a snake in the grass, well-hidden and very deadly.
POISON BY PUNCTUATION by Kelley Kaye pits a fledgling teacher, her Shakespeare quoting friend, their insatiable curiosity and dogged termination against the unknown as suspects are eliminated in this venomous tale of death and detective work.
Rapid-fire dialogue, uncanny luck and a little science make this tale an entertaining take on who-dunnits as Emma and Leslie are once again up to their chalkboards in solving the murder equation before the victim count rises. Can they balance the scales of justice by following the clues or will their journey lead them straight to the principal’s office for detention and a time out?
Kelley Kaye’s style is light, filled with some fabulous twists and hidden turns that will make a mystery lover take notice!
I received a complimentary ARC edition from Red Adept and Kelley Kaye!
Series: Chalkline Outlines - Book 2
Publisher: Red Adept Publishing, LLC (April 24, 2018)
Publication Date: April 24, 2018
Genre: Cozy Mystery
Print Length: 243 pages
Available from: Amazon | Barnes & Noble
For Reviews, Giveaways, Fabulous Book News: http://tometender.blogspot.com
August 17, 2018
This is the second book in the series about an English teacher who's moved to a small town where the police isn't the brightest. At all. Along with her friends, they end up investigating happenings in their school on their own. This time, many students and even Emma herself have received threats when someone is actually killed. That's when Emma meets the forensics doctor Will, who'll join forces with her friends in finding out the culprit, and sway her heart from Hunter.
I've read the first number and I remember complaining a little about how the text didn't flow well. As I had already read her most recent release, I knew Bowles had improved a lot, and I confirmed the fact in this book. It's almost all fixed, though I'd say it's still not 100%, and the editor could have done a more radical work. Still, this is way above average and you'll find no problems. Also, it's just a problem with the flow; it's perfect grammatically. I think I wouldn't have noticed if I didn't remember the first one, to be honest.
As for the story, it took me longer to feel invested about the victim. This time, it's even a bigger mystery, so we learn about her little by little, while for the first one I was immediately crying for the poor guy. On the other hand, Emma's doubts about her relationship with Hunter seemed very real, to a point I didn't know which guy I'd choose. Bowles would also be successful writing romances about love triangles—then again I'm not into those; they drive me crazy from anxiety! She'd still excel there, considering how even I, the reader, couldn't decide which I'd choose if I were Emma.
Again, my favorite part, and I was glad it was also present here, was when Emma talked about teaching. She's now in her second year teaching but there's still a lot for her to learn (as a teacher myself in my fifth year, I'm not even halfway there). Anyway, these bits were always interesting!
Last, I wish there was more about Emma's past, even Leslie still seems to hide things, but the book never got into it. Is it being saved for the third? I don't think it'll be easy to give an excuse for a third murder in the same school without it being closed forever after that, so... Sorry, it's that I was already curious from the first and the second didn't help at all, lol.
I've read the first number and I remember complaining a little about how the text didn't flow well. As I had already read her most recent release, I knew Bowles had improved a lot, and I confirmed the fact in this book. It's almost all fixed, though I'd say it's still not 100%, and the editor could have done a more radical work. Still, this is way above average and you'll find no problems. Also, it's just a problem with the flow; it's perfect grammatically. I think I wouldn't have noticed if I didn't remember the first one, to be honest.
As for the story, it took me longer to feel invested about the victim. This time, it's even a bigger mystery, so we learn about her little by little, while for the first one I was immediately crying for the poor guy. On the other hand, Emma's doubts about her relationship with Hunter seemed very real, to a point I didn't know which guy I'd choose. Bowles would also be successful writing romances about love triangles—then again I'm not into those; they drive me crazy from anxiety! She'd still excel there, considering how even I, the reader, couldn't decide which I'd choose if I were Emma.
Again, my favorite part, and I was glad it was also present here, was when Emma talked about teaching. She's now in her second year teaching but there's still a lot for her to learn (as a teacher myself in my fifth year, I'm not even halfway there). Anyway, these bits were always interesting!
Last, I wish there was more about Emma's past, even Leslie still seems to hide things, but the book never got into it. Is it being saved for the third? I don't think it'll be easy to give an excuse for a third murder in the same school without it being closed forever after that, so... Sorry, it's that I was already curious from the first and the second didn't help at all, lol.
December 3, 2019
Poison by Punctuation by Kelley Kate is book two in her Chalkboard Outlines series. Prepare to embark on another mystery with Emma and Leslie while they work to discover who is sending threatening notes, the mysterious and tragic death of a teenage girl, and the three new teachers who seem less than interested in engaging in any type of friendship with Emma and the other teachers.
Punctuation by Poison is the first book that I have read by Kelley Kate and while it is the second book in this series it can be read as a stand-alone novel. The author does a fantastic job hooking me into the book from the beginning with the prologue. I was hooked and then heartbroken in no time flat. Then I was a bit thrown. Haha! I say this because the prologue is essentially a couple of days in advance and then the author steps back a couple of days to set the stage as to what is about to break the peace at the high school starting with graffiti.
The overall storyline is interesting, though it does slow down in places which at times made it a bit of a slog to keep going. During the slowdown moments, I tend to rely on the characters to keep me engaged, but I didn’t find myself overly liking Emma. My biggest issue with her was her wishy-washy attitude and the hammed-up Southern charm. I understand her hamming it up, but I feel like she seriously overdoes it which causes me to look down on her. Then in a couple of scenes she’s all gungho to go investigate…by herself! But when she has back-up, all of a sudden she’s wanting to act like NOW it’s super dangerous. I think I expected her to be more of a “take-charge” kind of character because that’s what I’m used to when it comes to cozy mystery novels I’ve read before. I found myself gravitating more towards her friend Leslie as she was more outgoing and engaging.
I will say this though when the story is engaging…it is ENGAGING! I was page-turning to learn what happens next and the author does a fantastic job keeping me in the dark as to who the killer is. The pieces are there, but the author keeps the exact clues hidden away so as to not tip off readers as to who the guilty party is. I like the multiple layers of mystery involved in this book as well. You don’t just get the murder mystery and the threats. You get a surprise mystery thrown later into the story, and a tragic backstory to go along with it.
My only other issue with this story is Emma’s beau…Hunter. I’m sorry, but I just did not like him that much. He may be a sweet guy, but he’s got some serious issues and I couldn’t deal with that. He immediately has an attitude the first time he’s around Will which I honestly found bizarre. To me, it screamed that he was insecure from jump. Hunter fluctuates between a whipped puppy, to a petulant teenager, to a doting boyfriend. I really need him to work on himself and get over his past issues, because at this point…tons of flowers or not…Emma deserves better in my opinion.
While I struggled with the sensibleness and maturity of a couple of the characters, I enjoyed this book’s storyline overall. So I am rating this book 4 out of 5 stars. I think that I’ll hang in there with this author and see where things go with these characters. I’m hopeful that they’ll grow, develop, and mature in future books.
Punctuation by Poison is the first book that I have read by Kelley Kate and while it is the second book in this series it can be read as a stand-alone novel. The author does a fantastic job hooking me into the book from the beginning with the prologue. I was hooked and then heartbroken in no time flat. Then I was a bit thrown. Haha! I say this because the prologue is essentially a couple of days in advance and then the author steps back a couple of days to set the stage as to what is about to break the peace at the high school starting with graffiti.
The overall storyline is interesting, though it does slow down in places which at times made it a bit of a slog to keep going. During the slowdown moments, I tend to rely on the characters to keep me engaged, but I didn’t find myself overly liking Emma. My biggest issue with her was her wishy-washy attitude and the hammed-up Southern charm. I understand her hamming it up, but I feel like she seriously overdoes it which causes me to look down on her. Then in a couple of scenes she’s all gungho to go investigate…by herself! But when she has back-up, all of a sudden she’s wanting to act like NOW it’s super dangerous. I think I expected her to be more of a “take-charge” kind of character because that’s what I’m used to when it comes to cozy mystery novels I’ve read before. I found myself gravitating more towards her friend Leslie as she was more outgoing and engaging.
I will say this though when the story is engaging…it is ENGAGING! I was page-turning to learn what happens next and the author does a fantastic job keeping me in the dark as to who the killer is. The pieces are there, but the author keeps the exact clues hidden away so as to not tip off readers as to who the guilty party is. I like the multiple layers of mystery involved in this book as well. You don’t just get the murder mystery and the threats. You get a surprise mystery thrown later into the story, and a tragic backstory to go along with it.
My only other issue with this story is Emma’s beau…Hunter. I’m sorry, but I just did not like him that much. He may be a sweet guy, but he’s got some serious issues and I couldn’t deal with that. He immediately has an attitude the first time he’s around Will which I honestly found bizarre. To me, it screamed that he was insecure from jump. Hunter fluctuates between a whipped puppy, to a petulant teenager, to a doting boyfriend. I really need him to work on himself and get over his past issues, because at this point…tons of flowers or not…Emma deserves better in my opinion.
While I struggled with the sensibleness and maturity of a couple of the characters, I enjoyed this book’s storyline overall. So I am rating this book 4 out of 5 stars. I think that I’ll hang in there with this author and see where things go with these characters. I’m hopeful that they’ll grow, develop, and mature in future books.
November 25, 2019
Emma Lovett is an English teacher in Pinewood Colorado. She loves her job and her life. Emma and her friend, Leslie, like to help investigate crime. These two ladies have the ability to find clues that others miss I admired how well they work together. I had to laugh when Emma uses her Southern Belle charm to I get information. When a High School cheerleader was killed, I was shocked. Thank goodness! Emma and Leslie are there to help. I liked the characters and the Shakespeare quotes. Emma's romance with Hunter was special. He's a good guy, but I, also, liked his romantic competition. Will Capshaw, the Medical Examiner, becomes a key player in the investigation. He is a rebel who has an interest in Emma. Who will she choose? Kelley Kaye wrote a fast paced cozy mystery that was full of unexpected surprises and deadly twists. The ending was a shock I especially enjoyed the smart and sassy banter. It added a touch of humor. I'm looking forward to seeing what happens next. I want more stories in the Chalkboard Outlines series.
I received a copy of this book which I voluntarily read and reviewed. My comments are my honest opinion.
I received a copy of this book which I voluntarily read and reviewed. My comments are my honest opinion.
April 26, 2018
A must read for all whodunit fans!...
Author Kelley Kaye weaves a witty mystery adventure, with intriguing twists and turns that will easily captivate the reader’s attention from the beginning. The author paints a humorous and entertaining story in a very vivid and convincing way. In addition, the characters are drawn with great credibility and conviction. It’s a fast-paced novel that will keep you engaged from the first page to the last.
The book description gives a sneak preview: ‘High school teacher Emma Lovett is finally recovering from her first year of teaching when she discovers another dead body. As if that wasn’t bad enough, this time, someone has killed a student, Kisten Hollis.
Emma and her best friend, Leslie, are desperate to solve this murder. But suspects abound. The perpetrator could be a teacher, an administrator, a member of Kisten’s zealous church community, or even another student.
Emma must juggle her teaching responsibilities, her new romance with handsome Hunter Wells, and interest from a hunky second suitor, all while searching for evidence to bring a killer to justice before someone else dies.’
Now, if that’s not enough to get your curiosity juices flowing, I don’t know what will. But if you want to find out what happens, you’ll just have to turn the pages for yourself! However, I will say it was well worth the read. It’s my second time reading this author and I must say I was very impressed yet again. The first book in the series, Death by Diploma (Chalkboard Outlines Book 1) is also well worth checking out.
Poison by Punctuation had every element a good story should have. An intriguing plot, attention to detail, but best of all fleshed out, well-written and well-rounded character development. There’s an abundance of well-illustrated scenes that make you feel like you are right there in the story, and that’s something I really look for in a good book.
Very appealing and alluring, this work had me immersed from the beginning. The story flowed from scene to scene with ease, and the author shows exceptional ability when it comes to storytelling. There are plenty of whodunit moments in this page turner that will take the reader on a truly mysterious and intriguing journey.
It’s one of those books that come along occasionally that makes you want to read it non-stop until you get to the end. I’m giving nothing further away here. And this, I hope, will only add to the mystery and enjoyment for the reader.
I’ll certainly be looking forward to reading more from Kelley Kaye in the future. I would recommend this book and would love to see it adapted for Television. In my humble opinion, I honestly think this would make a great series. Five stars from me.
Author Kelley Kaye weaves a witty mystery adventure, with intriguing twists and turns that will easily captivate the reader’s attention from the beginning. The author paints a humorous and entertaining story in a very vivid and convincing way. In addition, the characters are drawn with great credibility and conviction. It’s a fast-paced novel that will keep you engaged from the first page to the last.
The book description gives a sneak preview: ‘High school teacher Emma Lovett is finally recovering from her first year of teaching when she discovers another dead body. As if that wasn’t bad enough, this time, someone has killed a student, Kisten Hollis.
Emma and her best friend, Leslie, are desperate to solve this murder. But suspects abound. The perpetrator could be a teacher, an administrator, a member of Kisten’s zealous church community, or even another student.
Emma must juggle her teaching responsibilities, her new romance with handsome Hunter Wells, and interest from a hunky second suitor, all while searching for evidence to bring a killer to justice before someone else dies.’
Now, if that’s not enough to get your curiosity juices flowing, I don’t know what will. But if you want to find out what happens, you’ll just have to turn the pages for yourself! However, I will say it was well worth the read. It’s my second time reading this author and I must say I was very impressed yet again. The first book in the series, Death by Diploma (Chalkboard Outlines Book 1) is also well worth checking out.
Poison by Punctuation had every element a good story should have. An intriguing plot, attention to detail, but best of all fleshed out, well-written and well-rounded character development. There’s an abundance of well-illustrated scenes that make you feel like you are right there in the story, and that’s something I really look for in a good book.
Very appealing and alluring, this work had me immersed from the beginning. The story flowed from scene to scene with ease, and the author shows exceptional ability when it comes to storytelling. There are plenty of whodunit moments in this page turner that will take the reader on a truly mysterious and intriguing journey.
It’s one of those books that come along occasionally that makes you want to read it non-stop until you get to the end. I’m giving nothing further away here. And this, I hope, will only add to the mystery and enjoyment for the reader.
I’ll certainly be looking forward to reading more from Kelley Kaye in the future. I would recommend this book and would love to see it adapted for Television. In my humble opinion, I honestly think this would make a great series. Five stars from me.
May 12, 2018
Poison by Punctuation - Bk 2 Chalkboard Outlines - Written by Kelley Kaye - Reviewed 5/12/18 - Read 4/23-24/18
I never realized that High School could be so dangerous!!!!!
High school teacher Emma Lovett is finally recovering from her first year of teaching when she discovers another dead body. As if that wasn’t bad enough, this time, someone has killed a student, Kisten Hollis. Emma and her best friend, Leslie, are desperate to solve this murder. But suspects abound. The perpetrator could be a teacher, an administrator, a member of Kisten’s zealous church community, or even another student. Emma must juggle her teaching responsibilities, her new romance with handsome Hunter Wells, and interest from a hunky second suitor, all while searching for evidence to bring a killer to justice before someone else dies.
What did I like? This was a cute and enjoyable read. I was down with pneumonia and needed something to get my mind off my troubles. This sure did it.
What will you like? An easy read with wonderful characters. The girls will keep you laughing and sleuthing for the killer. The action and characters are growing and developing with every page till you’re finished. I received this from the author as a member of the launch group for an honest review with no other compensation.
I never realized that High School could be so dangerous!!!!!
High school teacher Emma Lovett is finally recovering from her first year of teaching when she discovers another dead body. As if that wasn’t bad enough, this time, someone has killed a student, Kisten Hollis. Emma and her best friend, Leslie, are desperate to solve this murder. But suspects abound. The perpetrator could be a teacher, an administrator, a member of Kisten’s zealous church community, or even another student. Emma must juggle her teaching responsibilities, her new romance with handsome Hunter Wells, and interest from a hunky second suitor, all while searching for evidence to bring a killer to justice before someone else dies.
What did I like? This was a cute and enjoyable read. I was down with pneumonia and needed something to get my mind off my troubles. This sure did it.
What will you like? An easy read with wonderful characters. The girls will keep you laughing and sleuthing for the killer. The action and characters are growing and developing with every page till you’re finished. I received this from the author as a member of the launch group for an honest review with no other compensation.
April 20, 2018
I love cosy mysteries so much - this one featured the utterly and deliciously far-fetched murder of a high school student (actually very sad, come to think of it) and the clues are fed to you throughout, sending you in all directions until the conclusion which is a complete surprise!
Emma and Leslie are amateur sleuths of the highest order; they disregard all notions of personal safety and police procedure, jumping headlong into their own investigation of the suspicious death of a student. Their friendship is the highlight of this series for me, they're very funny together (are women allowed to be funny? Surely not.) and support each other unconditionally. They're an adorable combination of Shakespeare quotes for all equations and Southern belle cute-isms.
You can tell that the author has been a teacher, which is what makes the school setting for this series really authentic and compelling. The teachers write up lesson plans and have to attend anti-bullying seminars, they also flag up the issues of religion/bullying/sports bias in schools which got me thinking without distracting me from the plot.
I can't wait for the next book in the series!
**Thank you to the author for a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest and unbiased review**
Emma and Leslie are amateur sleuths of the highest order; they disregard all notions of personal safety and police procedure, jumping headlong into their own investigation of the suspicious death of a student. Their friendship is the highlight of this series for me, they're very funny together (are women allowed to be funny? Surely not.) and support each other unconditionally. They're an adorable combination of Shakespeare quotes for all equations and Southern belle cute-isms.
You can tell that the author has been a teacher, which is what makes the school setting for this series really authentic and compelling. The teachers write up lesson plans and have to attend anti-bullying seminars, they also flag up the issues of religion/bullying/sports bias in schools which got me thinking without distracting me from the plot.
I can't wait for the next book in the series!
**Thank you to the author for a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest and unbiased review**
June 9, 2018
Emma has survived her first year of teaching (and the fallout of finding a murderer!) and is starting the second year full of hope and plans. Some of the plans involve Hunter, and finding out why they seem to be dancing around each other (does he no longer want to be going out with her?), but a lot of this is derailed when graffiti is sprayed in the new gym complex, bullying letters are being sent to the cheerleaders (and some of the staff) and even more derailed when one of the Cheerleading team is found dead in the changing rooms.
Emma and Leslie dust off their virtual deerstalkers, combine sleuthing duties with Edward and Hunter again (and find out that Leslie isn't quite as well as she would like when she is poisoned by the punch at a party!) and in Emma's case try to avoid the rather nice new medical examiner!
Who would want to kill Kisten? Why don't the three new member's of staff seem to want to join in? and what is Emma going to do about her love life! (oh and can they track down the graffiti artist and the murderer as well), all in a teacher's job.
Emma and Leslie dust off their virtual deerstalkers, combine sleuthing duties with Edward and Hunter again (and find out that Leslie isn't quite as well as she would like when she is poisoned by the punch at a party!) and in Emma's case try to avoid the rather nice new medical examiner!
Who would want to kill Kisten? Why don't the three new member's of staff seem to want to join in? and what is Emma going to do about her love life! (oh and can they track down the graffiti artist and the murderer as well), all in a teacher's job.
May 2, 2018
Emma has made it through her first year of teaching and what happens next? Her friend, Leslie, and herself investigate the murder of a cheerleader. They want to see justice and they will. They are so great together and you can’t help but laugh. They don’t care about their own safety in goes out the door but these two always get the job done.
The characters in this book are ones you come to like and want to learn more. The pages will be turning in the readers hands. The author does an excellent job and knows her stuff.
The characters in this book are ones you come to like and want to learn more. The pages will be turning in the readers hands. The author does an excellent job and knows her stuff.
December 10, 2019
Poison by Punctuation by Kelley Kaye is the delightful second book in the Chalkboard Outlines series. Intrigued by the title, I was anxious to get a look at this book about two English teachers in a small high school, early in the school year. Leslie and Emma are the teachers who had solved a murder in the school the previous year. This year seemed to be all about bullying. At an in-service, the staff and faculty learned about bullying but only one of the activities address the long-term effects, which Leslie felt to be critical. Bullying did long term damage to people, as they were about to see for themselves. It started with some mean notes and then, sadly, on their first day swimming at 6 am to relieve stress, Leslie and Emma discovered a body: Kisten Hollis, a sweet, 16-year old cheerleader who had been dead long enough to be blue. It happened the week of homecoming and Tate, the principal, decided the best thing to do was carry on, keeping to normal activities so before long they found themselves chaperoning the Homecoming Dance. Emma and Hunter, her boyfriend, were having a good time and Leslie, along with Edward, another teacher were dancing up a storm causing Leslie to be really thirsty, so thirsty she downed at least four cups of punch. Not feeling well, she and Emma made a trip to the ladies' room where some of the female students were also complaining about food poisoning. Before they could deal with that, Leslie is on the floor, having convulsions. Arriving at the hospital, it was discovered that Leslie was so much sicker because she had an ulcer and the SNAKE VENOM they had all been poisoned with had escaped into her blood stream through the ulcer. Thankfully, the doctors there had everything under control. What would happen next? It was getting dangerous to go to school.
Poison by Punctuation is a lovely little mystery. Leslie and Emma are two good characters, each with pasts, and quirks and foibles. One of the fun things they did was quote Shakespeare when it worked and it seemed to work often. They like puzzles, and friends with good language skills, always a plus. The mystery is a good one, although it has already been pointed out that too many people die at this school. Could get to be a problem. I often wondered why no murder mysteries are set in a school and Kaye has solved that problem. It will be interesting to see it she can keep the momentum going. I enjoyed this book. I recommend it to readers of cozy mysteries and more.
I received a free ARC of Poison by Punctuation from Cozy Mystery Review Crew. All opinions and interpretations contained herein are solely my own.
Poison by Punctuation is a lovely little mystery. Leslie and Emma are two good characters, each with pasts, and quirks and foibles. One of the fun things they did was quote Shakespeare when it worked and it seemed to work often. They like puzzles, and friends with good language skills, always a plus. The mystery is a good one, although it has already been pointed out that too many people die at this school. Could get to be a problem. I often wondered why no murder mysteries are set in a school and Kaye has solved that problem. It will be interesting to see it she can keep the momentum going. I enjoyed this book. I recommend it to readers of cozy mysteries and more.
I received a free ARC of Poison by Punctuation from Cozy Mystery Review Crew. All opinions and interpretations contained herein are solely my own.
May 20, 2019
What a fun follow up to the first in this series. I am really enjoying the antics of Emma and Leslie and what they will go through to solve a murder. They remind me of Nancy Drew with their sleuthing and finding themselves on the edge of getting into more trouble than they had planned. In this book, there are a few times where the case and their efforts to solve the murder puts a small strain on their friendship but I also think it is Leslie overreacting in some situations.
The mystery portion is well written because I did not suspect the killer at all! I didn't have anyone in mind and looking back I remember a few vague clues that might have pointed me in the right direction but there is nothing that really points to this character.
I enjoyed the different plot lines throughout the story and how everything came together in the end and made sense. There is some good news and bad news when the dust settles but it really brings out some discussion on some important topics like adoption.
It wouldn't be a book without some romance between Emma and Hunter and they are able to take their relationship a step further. However, Dr. Will has his eyes on Emma and while he knows she is taken that doesn't stop him from being interested in her and sharing those thoughts with her. Will she stay with Hunter or will Will have a shot?
We give this 4 paws up and really enjoy this series!
The mystery portion is well written because I did not suspect the killer at all! I didn't have anyone in mind and looking back I remember a few vague clues that might have pointed me in the right direction but there is nothing that really points to this character.
I enjoyed the different plot lines throughout the story and how everything came together in the end and made sense. There is some good news and bad news when the dust settles but it really brings out some discussion on some important topics like adoption.
It wouldn't be a book without some romance between Emma and Hunter and they are able to take their relationship a step further. However, Dr. Will has his eyes on Emma and while he knows she is taken that doesn't stop him from being interested in her and sharing those thoughts with her. Will she stay with Hunter or will Will have a shot?
We give this 4 paws up and really enjoy this series!
January 4, 2019
Poison by Punctuation is another highly entertaining and quirky cozy by the talented and imaginative author Kelley Kaye. I devoured the first book in this series, Death by Diploma, and was excited about its sequel. Thankfully, this book did not disappoint. What a fun bunch of adventures these two heroines, Emma and Leslie, get into while trying to solve yet another murder at the high school where they teach. The characters are intriguing and enjoyable to follow. My favorite is Leslie Parker, the English teacher with the panache for Shakespeare, love for anything food related, and quick-witted repartee that often left me laughing out loud. The author does an excellent job by balancing Leslie’s character with Emma, her partner in crime, who brings a Southern flair and a little bit more of a reserved but still feisty demeanor to their whole crusade to educate the youth and solve crime. What’s next from author Kaye? I don’t know, but I’m certain to read it.
March 31, 2019
"Emma scooted away from the side of the pool when Leslie started snapping her wet towel. She skidded around the corner of the locker room and stopped short when she aw the foot protruding from the corner of the gym lockers. The foot was encased in a short white sock with a blue paw embroidered on the side. Oh my God. Oh no. Oh no.".......
Emma and Leslie are back in Book Two of the “Chalkboard Outlines” series. Taking place a year after the teachers first adventure together.
This time Emma finds a body, and horrifying enough, it’s a student. Given their previous success in helping solve 2 murders last year, Emma and Leslie are determined to see this one solved as well.
Emma is finally settling in after moving from South Carolina to Colorado. Leaving behind a philandering ex husband, she finds herself in a fairly stable relationship with Hunter. Although, there is a bad boy that may turn her head. With a mix of characters, teachers, neighbors, cops, and parents, one of them has to have knowledge of Kirsten’s death.
I found this read enjoyable as the first in this series, maybe a little more so. This book felt more settled and comfortable. The characters are different and fun, not your usual sleuths. With quotes from Shakespeare, it really does remind me of high school.
There’s no question that the killer will be found, and brought to justice. Emma and Leslie won’t have it any other way.
Thank you Kelley Bowles
Emma and Leslie are back in Book Two of the “Chalkboard Outlines” series. Taking place a year after the teachers first adventure together.
This time Emma finds a body, and horrifying enough, it’s a student. Given their previous success in helping solve 2 murders last year, Emma and Leslie are determined to see this one solved as well.
Emma is finally settling in after moving from South Carolina to Colorado. Leaving behind a philandering ex husband, she finds herself in a fairly stable relationship with Hunter. Although, there is a bad boy that may turn her head. With a mix of characters, teachers, neighbors, cops, and parents, one of them has to have knowledge of Kirsten’s death.
I found this read enjoyable as the first in this series, maybe a little more so. This book felt more settled and comfortable. The characters are different and fun, not your usual sleuths. With quotes from Shakespeare, it really does remind me of high school.
There’s no question that the killer will be found, and brought to justice. Emma and Leslie won’t have it any other way.
Thank you Kelley Bowles
December 18, 2019
This book starts slow, but it picks up when Kisten’s body is found. Actually, it really gets better when the new medical examiner shows up. The two main characters, Emma and Leslie, are teachers at a small-town high school. Both are single and although their personalities are different are close friends. Having previously worked together in solving a murder at their school the year before, the pair do not easily believe Kisten’s death was accidental.
But who killed Kisten’s is not an easy guess. Jealous classmates, perhaps. But her cause of death turns out to be snake venom. Emma and Leslie navigate between high school cliques, snake-handling Pentecostals, and stand-offish new teachers trying to figure out who could have done this to a young girl. The plot keeps the reader guessing, making it a satisfying mystery with enjoyably humorous characters.
But who killed Kisten’s is not an easy guess. Jealous classmates, perhaps. But her cause of death turns out to be snake venom. Emma and Leslie navigate between high school cliques, snake-handling Pentecostals, and stand-offish new teachers trying to figure out who could have done this to a young girl. The plot keeps the reader guessing, making it a satisfying mystery with enjoyably humorous characters.
November 20, 2019
Kelley Kaye returns with a second book in the Chalkboard Outlines series with Poison by Punctuation. Emma has survived her first year of teaching only to find on another body. The synopsis and premise of the book and characters drew me in, but, unfortunately, did not deliver. The dialogue felt forced and not realistic. The characters seemed contrived and flat, and I was unable to feel any emotion or empathy for them.
The main character, Emma, is supposed to be in her 20s, but she uses old-school expressions such as Sam Hill and lucky ducky that don't seem to fit her age and character.
The plot had promise, and the mystery was good, but it was hard to stay invested in the storyline and care about the outcome. I also had a difficult time with the Shakespearean quotes, and it often pulled me out of the story or scene and became distracting with their overuse. Also, Emma's southern accent was a bit overdone.
If you like a light-hearted, cozy mystery, this book is okay.
The main character, Emma, is supposed to be in her 20s, but she uses old-school expressions such as Sam Hill and lucky ducky that don't seem to fit her age and character.
The plot had promise, and the mystery was good, but it was hard to stay invested in the storyline and care about the outcome. I also had a difficult time with the Shakespearean quotes, and it often pulled me out of the story or scene and became distracting with their overuse. Also, Emma's southern accent was a bit overdone.
If you like a light-hearted, cozy mystery, this book is okay.
December 14, 2019
Poison by Punctuation is the second book in the Chalkboard Outlines series by Kelley Kaye. It is however, the first book that I have read by Kelley Kaye. I must say, it was very easy to pick up at book two in the series as thee was sufficient background so that I never felt lost.
The tale begins with Emma Lovett (the main character) discovering yet another dead body. What makes this discovery poignant is that the deceased is a student of Emma’s at Thomas Jefferson High School (in Pinewood, Colorado). As is generally true to form with cozy mysteries, there was a myriad of suspects which Emma had to go through. As well, a few varied story lines thrown in just to muddy the waters. And that is what made this story worthy of a “4 star” in my opinion. As is often the case, cozy mysteries have a standard format but these additional story-lines and red herrings are what grab my attention and allows a book to stand out on its own. And this was accomplished with Poison by Punctuation.
As Emma whittled down the list of suspects it did get a bit nerve wracking as it felt that she was marching closer and closer to danger.
At times, the reading was as if I was talking to a friend as it was very casual:
“Okeydokey, artichokee. If you’ve got no love for my dinner idea, I’ll see you at school tomorrow. Toodles.”
Many interactions between Leslie and Emma left me chuckling and at times wondering, who quotes Shakespeare? At least for a while it was fun trying to figure out which one of Shakespeare’s work the quote was from. Maybe a few less quotes for the next book in the series, should there be another book.
I was pleasantly surprised to see that other current day school issues were briefly touched upon -> bullying and cyberbullying. And giving Kisten’s adoption a discussion was good to read.
The budding (maybe) love triangle added another storyline which kept my interest. What a dilemma having to choose between Hunter and Dr. Will (or is there really a choice to be made)?
I am happy to report that I did not figure out “whodunit” until close to the end which is how I like my cozy mysteries.
The story was enjoyable enough and I found the writing of Kelley Kaye easy to read. I look forward to picking up other titles by Ms. Kaye.
*I would like to thank the author for supplying a free copy of this title in exchange for an honest review*
The tale begins with Emma Lovett (the main character) discovering yet another dead body. What makes this discovery poignant is that the deceased is a student of Emma’s at Thomas Jefferson High School (in Pinewood, Colorado). As is generally true to form with cozy mysteries, there was a myriad of suspects which Emma had to go through. As well, a few varied story lines thrown in just to muddy the waters. And that is what made this story worthy of a “4 star” in my opinion. As is often the case, cozy mysteries have a standard format but these additional story-lines and red herrings are what grab my attention and allows a book to stand out on its own. And this was accomplished with Poison by Punctuation.
As Emma whittled down the list of suspects it did get a bit nerve wracking as it felt that she was marching closer and closer to danger.
At times, the reading was as if I was talking to a friend as it was very casual:
“Okeydokey, artichokee. If you’ve got no love for my dinner idea, I’ll see you at school tomorrow. Toodles.”
Many interactions between Leslie and Emma left me chuckling and at times wondering, who quotes Shakespeare? At least for a while it was fun trying to figure out which one of Shakespeare’s work the quote was from. Maybe a few less quotes for the next book in the series, should there be another book.
I was pleasantly surprised to see that other current day school issues were briefly touched upon -> bullying and cyberbullying. And giving Kisten’s adoption a discussion was good to read.
The budding (maybe) love triangle added another storyline which kept my interest. What a dilemma having to choose between Hunter and Dr. Will (or is there really a choice to be made)?
I am happy to report that I did not figure out “whodunit” until close to the end which is how I like my cozy mysteries.
The story was enjoyable enough and I found the writing of Kelley Kaye easy to read. I look forward to picking up other titles by Ms. Kaye.
*I would like to thank the author for supplying a free copy of this title in exchange for an honest review*
November 30, 2019
This is a really fun cozy mystery! Even though it's the second book in the series, I had no problem jumping into this book first. The main character Emma is a high school English teacher. When several girls at school along with Emma and her best friend and co-worker Leslie receive threatening anonymous letters, Emma wants to investigate. Then, one of the recipients, a popular cheerleader is found dead. The threats don't stop, so Emma and Leslie start investigating.
I really enjoyed this book because I liked the camaraderie between Emma and Leslie and the teaching part of the book was reminiscent to me of several comedy TV shows based in a school setting. This book made me laugh out loud at times. I would highly recommend to anyone who enjoys a fun cozy mystery.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
I really enjoyed this book because I liked the camaraderie between Emma and Leslie and the teaching part of the book was reminiscent to me of several comedy TV shows based in a school setting. This book made me laugh out loud at times. I would highly recommend to anyone who enjoys a fun cozy mystery.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
December 12, 2019
This wonderful cozy immediately grabbed my attention and kept me glued to the book until I read the last word with a great mystery that included twists and turns, engaging and quirky characters so expertly written I feel like I know them. This is the first book I have read by Kelley Kaye but I like her style and the high school vibe so I plan to read more in this endearing Chalkboard Outline series. I really liked teachers Emma Lovett and Leslie Parker and can't wait to see what happens next in Pinewood, Colorado. I received an advance reader copy of "Poison by Punctuation" and am voluntarily leaving my review.
March 18, 2019
Kelley Kaye returns to her mystery universe with Poison by Punctuation. Teacher Emma has survived her rocky first year teaching only to stumble on another body, this time student Kisten. Emma jumps back on the case. She’s the same fun witty character from before, but you can see how the experience from the first book has affected her, and the loss of a student pushes her in whole new directions. Even though it’s a little darker than the first installment, Poison by Punctuation is a fun witty dive back into Kaye’s feel good mystery world that you should take!
December 7, 2019
High school can be a killer, but second year teacher Emma Lovett is hoping to enjoy a murder-free school year. Unfortunately, Thomas Jefferson High is starting the year with graffiti and threatening notes, admittedly an improvement over last year’s dead body. Shortly afterwards, cheerleader Kisten Hollis is found dead after an insulin injection and murder is suspected once again. Emma and her best friend and fellow teacher, Leslie Parker, are determined to uncover the culprit, especially since they’ve also received one of the threatening notes.
POISON BY PUNCTUATION is the second book in the Chalkboard Outlines series but can easily be read as a standalone. Kelley Kaye provides enough character development for the reader to appreciate and enjoy even things such as the troubles brewing in the love lives of Emma and Leslie. I have to admit that the first book is now on my TBR as it’s enjoyable to see an author so effectively write about a school.
And oh, did Kelley Kaye ever capture the high school teaching experience! I probably laughed more than I should have over Emma’s rants about the school board, particularly their approach to bullying, as Kelley Kaye sums it up so well. Between that and Leslie’s penchant for literary quotes, it was almost a given that I would thoroughly enjoy POISON BY PUNCTUATION but Kelley Kaye also writes a darned good story! POISON BY PUNCTUATION takes some intriguing twists and I like the depth she’s giving to her characters. I can’t wait to see what Kelley Kaye has in store for us next in the series!
POISON BY PUNCTUATION is the second book in the Chalkboard Outlines series but can easily be read as a standalone. Kelley Kaye provides enough character development for the reader to appreciate and enjoy even things such as the troubles brewing in the love lives of Emma and Leslie. I have to admit that the first book is now on my TBR as it’s enjoyable to see an author so effectively write about a school.
And oh, did Kelley Kaye ever capture the high school teaching experience! I probably laughed more than I should have over Emma’s rants about the school board, particularly their approach to bullying, as Kelley Kaye sums it up so well. Between that and Leslie’s penchant for literary quotes, it was almost a given that I would thoroughly enjoy POISON BY PUNCTUATION but Kelley Kaye also writes a darned good story! POISON BY PUNCTUATION takes some intriguing twists and I like the depth she’s giving to her characters. I can’t wait to see what Kelley Kaye has in store for us next in the series!
December 19, 2019
Kaye is definitely a new favorite author!
Poison by Punctuation features fun and quirky friends Emma and Leslie as they pursue another murderer. This time the victim was one of the students. Kaye has created characters that capture the hearts of her readers. Even minor characters are fun and engaging.
With a plethora of suspects, Emma and Leslie have their work cur out for them. Readers are kept guessing as clues are revealed throughout the story. The plot was interesting and kept the reader engaged in the story. I can't wait to read the next installment!
Poison by Punctuation features fun and quirky friends Emma and Leslie as they pursue another murderer. This time the victim was one of the students. Kaye has created characters that capture the hearts of her readers. Even minor characters are fun and engaging.
With a plethora of suspects, Emma and Leslie have their work cur out for them. Readers are kept guessing as clues are revealed throughout the story. The plot was interesting and kept the reader engaged in the story. I can't wait to read the next installment!
November 27, 2019
The second installment in the Chalkboard Outlines series. Taking on a tough subject, Poison by Punctuation starts with outrage over bullying. Bullying and its effects are themes through out this story. Emma and Leslie are great friends that just happen to teach High School English. As such they can speak to the problem of bullying. Leslie's Shakespearean quotes are hilarious and had me looking them up to see the context. The other sidekicks, Hunter and Edward have a lot of potential to be sleuths as well. Leslie and Edwards interactions are fun. Who doesn't know a couple that is as mismatched as the two of them. The ending had me slightly surprised. The murder weapon was unusual and slightly creepy. A good quick story for an evenings entertainment.
September 11, 2018
When I read the first installment, I was pleasantly surprised and was interested to see what other adventures Kelley Kaye had to share for these two teachers, Emma and Leslie.
Emma and Leslie are likeable and light women. Even when death looms above them, they continue to smile and investigate. However, like several of the characters, their characterization is quirky in a dated way. They talk more like 50 year old women than late twenties/early thirties ladies. So I guess you can call them old souls. But I predict their characterization would appeal to a slightly older, female audience instead of the intended age.
This second tale continues Emma and Leslie’s investigative night job of solving murders and threats made within the school.
The beginning was slow and I had to push through to get to the meat of the tale. I often felt there were many sections that could have been cut altogether, making a more concise story without so much down time. Once I was halfway in, I started to enjoy the story and the the revelations that ensued.
If you enjoy light, chic-lit murder mysteries then you may enjoy this series. For me the tale was just okay. This is perhaps due to my age or the fact that I prefer my stories a bit heavier on the character development. Also, I prefer more darkness than light.
https://cellardoorbooks.wordpress.com...
Emma and Leslie are likeable and light women. Even when death looms above them, they continue to smile and investigate. However, like several of the characters, their characterization is quirky in a dated way. They talk more like 50 year old women than late twenties/early thirties ladies. So I guess you can call them old souls. But I predict their characterization would appeal to a slightly older, female audience instead of the intended age.
This second tale continues Emma and Leslie’s investigative night job of solving murders and threats made within the school.
The beginning was slow and I had to push through to get to the meat of the tale. I often felt there were many sections that could have been cut altogether, making a more concise story without so much down time. Once I was halfway in, I started to enjoy the story and the the revelations that ensued.
If you enjoy light, chic-lit murder mysteries then you may enjoy this series. For me the tale was just okay. This is perhaps due to my age or the fact that I prefer my stories a bit heavier on the character development. Also, I prefer more darkness than light.
https://cellardoorbooks.wordpress.com...
August 15, 2019
DISCLAIMER – I received a free advance copy of this book in exchange for an impartial review
Emma Lovett is an English teacher at Thomas Jefferson High School (established 1906, part of the Pinewood School District). She and her co-worker/best-bud Leslie Parker (also an English teacher) were instrumental last school year in solving 2 murders, along with Hunter Wells (then a fed, undercover in the school on an athletic scandal, and now a newly-minted history teacher). Now it’s the start of a new year (Emma’s 2nd year at the school), and Emma is finding her footing both at school and in her relationship with Hunter.
In the first weeks of the year the school’s primary gymnasium is vandalized with a cryptic slogan, one that has a rather creepy undertone. Neither the school, the district, or the cops seem all that overly concerned, so Emma and Leslie start looking into it. Next thing you know several people receive equally-creepy anonymous notes left for them in various places. And then, to top things off, our intrepid English instructors find one of the students lying dead on the floor in one of the school locker-rooms. Oh, and it’s also Homecoming Week.
I liked the characters, though I now SERIOUSLY wished I had read the first book in this series (“Death by Diploma”) because at first I had a hard time keeping straight who the characters were. It was like sitting down in a theater 20 minutes into the film. Once I had straight who was who, and what their relationships and back histories were, I started the book over from the beginning and found I had a much easier time getting into the story. This book can be read as a stand-alone, but if you’re like me you might find it easier to read book one first.
The story was a fast read for me, but with enough twists (and one red herring) that I didn’t figure everything out until nearly the end. Even by then though, the actual “reveal” still contained the unexpected – just what you want for a mystery.
My score: 4 out of 5. There were only 2 minor things that I REALLY had a problem with in the book, but they both stuck in my craw. Emma and Leslie have NO respect at all for the local law enforcement, and don’t seem to have much more respect for their own administration. Granted, the chief detective seems to be a bit of a dufus, but the ladies started their snooping (which grew to a full-on investigation) with the flat-out assumption that they were the ONLY ones who had enough brain cells to put things together. Along those same lines, Emma and Leslie at times seemed to put higher priority on solving the mystery than they did on teaching – both of them were perfectly willing to skip classes (though they had others cover for them, so as not to leave the students totally hanging) in order to investigate. To my idea they were acting as detectives first and teachers second, when I felt it should have been the other way around. That being said though, I did like it enough that I will probably be buying the first book in the series, and I will probably actually buy a finalized copy of this book.
Emma Lovett is an English teacher at Thomas Jefferson High School (established 1906, part of the Pinewood School District). She and her co-worker/best-bud Leslie Parker (also an English teacher) were instrumental last school year in solving 2 murders, along with Hunter Wells (then a fed, undercover in the school on an athletic scandal, and now a newly-minted history teacher). Now it’s the start of a new year (Emma’s 2nd year at the school), and Emma is finding her footing both at school and in her relationship with Hunter.
In the first weeks of the year the school’s primary gymnasium is vandalized with a cryptic slogan, one that has a rather creepy undertone. Neither the school, the district, or the cops seem all that overly concerned, so Emma and Leslie start looking into it. Next thing you know several people receive equally-creepy anonymous notes left for them in various places. And then, to top things off, our intrepid English instructors find one of the students lying dead on the floor in one of the school locker-rooms. Oh, and it’s also Homecoming Week.
I liked the characters, though I now SERIOUSLY wished I had read the first book in this series (“Death by Diploma”) because at first I had a hard time keeping straight who the characters were. It was like sitting down in a theater 20 minutes into the film. Once I had straight who was who, and what their relationships and back histories were, I started the book over from the beginning and found I had a much easier time getting into the story. This book can be read as a stand-alone, but if you’re like me you might find it easier to read book one first.
The story was a fast read for me, but with enough twists (and one red herring) that I didn’t figure everything out until nearly the end. Even by then though, the actual “reveal” still contained the unexpected – just what you want for a mystery.
My score: 4 out of 5. There were only 2 minor things that I REALLY had a problem with in the book, but they both stuck in my craw. Emma and Leslie have NO respect at all for the local law enforcement, and don’t seem to have much more respect for their own administration. Granted, the chief detective seems to be a bit of a dufus, but the ladies started their snooping (which grew to a full-on investigation) with the flat-out assumption that they were the ONLY ones who had enough brain cells to put things together. Along those same lines, Emma and Leslie at times seemed to put higher priority on solving the mystery than they did on teaching – both of them were perfectly willing to skip classes (though they had others cover for them, so as not to leave the students totally hanging) in order to investigate. To my idea they were acting as detectives first and teachers second, when I felt it should have been the other way around. That being said though, I did like it enough that I will probably be buying the first book in the series, and I will probably actually buy a finalized copy of this book.
September 22, 2019
This is my third time reviewing a book by Bowles on The Rebel Christian; I’m very used to her style of writing and I know what to expect from her witty and quirky characters so I knew what I was getting into when I first opened this book.
Poison by Punctuation is the second installment in this series and it certainly does not disappoint. Like the first installment, the humorous duo Emma and Leslie are back with another murder mystery. Bowles is an expert at cozy chick-lit fiction, but I’d have to disagree if you called this book cozy. The first book in this series featured a member of the school’s staff being murdered, this one was a student. I wasn’t very comfortable with the idea of a child’s death being the center of a murder mystery, especially one that’s as silly and unorthodox as this one. Then again, I think it’s fair to mention that Bowles had a very respectful approach to the case and handled it as well as a comedic detective novel could be handled.
Naturally, I enjoyed the wit and banter between the iconic duo; Emma and Leslie are the source of both humor and serious detective work, though there are definitely times where the two avenues cross paths. I appreciated their interactions with one another as well as their dedication to solving this case. Additionally, the writing was decent—just as it was in the last book—and the mystery itself was an interesting and even emotional ride.
If I had to complain, I’d say it is awfully weird the same woman continuously stumbles upon dead bodies—especially ones that are so closely tied to her workplace. I understand this is a murder mystery, murder must happen at some point or else there wouldn’t be a book, right? But does the victim always have to be someone from the same school? Does their body have to be discovered by the same person? It seems like this might be a cheesy theme in these books; if that’s the case then I’ll have to just get over it but I’d definitely like a little more creativity in the next installment, if there is one.
Despite my little complaint, I have to say this book is worth reading. I don’t think it is fit for YA readers—not because of the content, just because of the style. The main characters feel very old fashioned and dated, this is definitely more of a chick-lit or beach read for adults rather than a YA mystery novel. After reading three books by this author I’d say, as a 26-year-old woman, I would hand any book by Bowles to my mother before reading it myself or giving it to someone younger than me.
*I was given a free copy of this book, on behalf of The Rebel Christian, in exchange for an honest review*
Poison by Punctuation is the second installment in this series and it certainly does not disappoint. Like the first installment, the humorous duo Emma and Leslie are back with another murder mystery. Bowles is an expert at cozy chick-lit fiction, but I’d have to disagree if you called this book cozy. The first book in this series featured a member of the school’s staff being murdered, this one was a student. I wasn’t very comfortable with the idea of a child’s death being the center of a murder mystery, especially one that’s as silly and unorthodox as this one. Then again, I think it’s fair to mention that Bowles had a very respectful approach to the case and handled it as well as a comedic detective novel could be handled.
Naturally, I enjoyed the wit and banter between the iconic duo; Emma and Leslie are the source of both humor and serious detective work, though there are definitely times where the two avenues cross paths. I appreciated their interactions with one another as well as their dedication to solving this case. Additionally, the writing was decent—just as it was in the last book—and the mystery itself was an interesting and even emotional ride.
If I had to complain, I’d say it is awfully weird the same woman continuously stumbles upon dead bodies—especially ones that are so closely tied to her workplace. I understand this is a murder mystery, murder must happen at some point or else there wouldn’t be a book, right? But does the victim always have to be someone from the same school? Does their body have to be discovered by the same person? It seems like this might be a cheesy theme in these books; if that’s the case then I’ll have to just get over it but I’d definitely like a little more creativity in the next installment, if there is one.
Despite my little complaint, I have to say this book is worth reading. I don’t think it is fit for YA readers—not because of the content, just because of the style. The main characters feel very old fashioned and dated, this is definitely more of a chick-lit or beach read for adults rather than a YA mystery novel. After reading three books by this author I’d say, as a 26-year-old woman, I would hand any book by Bowles to my mother before reading it myself or giving it to someone younger than me.
*I was given a free copy of this book, on behalf of The Rebel Christian, in exchange for an honest review*
December 19, 2018
A cozy mystery …the sequel
~First, I’ll state that I received this book as a gift from the author to read and review.
~Once again, I enjoyed this book. The characters are engaging and the author, Kelley Kaye, is beginning to fill them out. Reading between the lines, we learned a bit more about what makes them act and react the way that they do. I am beginning to see real loyalty between several of the main characters. Even some of the satellite characters are becoming more interesting.
~Being that this is a “cozy” novel, beside a murder there needs to be a certain amount of romance. We were given that amount…and a little bit more! Not is a bad way…the description of the book mentions the phrase “…interest from a hunky second suitor…”. So, I’m not giving anything away if I say that there was enough fun and romance to go around.
~While we lost a bit of Emma’s Southern Belle accent, she did maintain certain Southern colloquiums that definitely placed her roots in the South.
~There were a few surprises and a few “red herrings” tossed at the reader. The story moved along at a fairly good pace. It kept me wanting to read it. I thought that, without being overly preachy, the element of bullying was introduced into the story. This added a bit of real-life drama into the fictional Thomas Jefferson High School.
~My only fear is the potential repetitiveness of the stories. How many murders can occur within the confines of a school building? As a teacher, there are plenty of other places in town where Emma would encounter students…the burger joint, public library, concert hall, sports arena, where the students have part-time jobs, local lover’s lane.
~This is a fictional story, with that in mind, the Epilogue was thought provoking and very well done.
~I would recommend this story to anyone looking for a fun, little bit light, murder mystery / cozy, romance novel. I am definitely looking forward to the next book in the series.
~First, I’ll state that I received this book as a gift from the author to read and review.
~Once again, I enjoyed this book. The characters are engaging and the author, Kelley Kaye, is beginning to fill them out. Reading between the lines, we learned a bit more about what makes them act and react the way that they do. I am beginning to see real loyalty between several of the main characters. Even some of the satellite characters are becoming more interesting.
~Being that this is a “cozy” novel, beside a murder there needs to be a certain amount of romance. We were given that amount…and a little bit more! Not is a bad way…the description of the book mentions the phrase “…interest from a hunky second suitor…”. So, I’m not giving anything away if I say that there was enough fun and romance to go around.
~While we lost a bit of Emma’s Southern Belle accent, she did maintain certain Southern colloquiums that definitely placed her roots in the South.
~There were a few surprises and a few “red herrings” tossed at the reader. The story moved along at a fairly good pace. It kept me wanting to read it. I thought that, without being overly preachy, the element of bullying was introduced into the story. This added a bit of real-life drama into the fictional Thomas Jefferson High School.
~My only fear is the potential repetitiveness of the stories. How many murders can occur within the confines of a school building? As a teacher, there are plenty of other places in town where Emma would encounter students…the burger joint, public library, concert hall, sports arena, where the students have part-time jobs, local lover’s lane.
~This is a fictional story, with that in mind, the Epilogue was thought provoking and very well done.
~I would recommend this story to anyone looking for a fun, little bit light, murder mystery / cozy, romance novel. I am definitely looking forward to the next book in the series.
May 11, 2019
Forgive One Mistake
Review of Poison by Punctuation
by Helen Hogan
Kelley Kaye (Bowles) has a good novel in Poison by Punctuation, the second in a proposed series of cozy mysteries about Emma the new English teacher in a small Colorado high school. Her character uses clear thinking to analyze various facts as they appear. She has occasional weakness as she admires her mentor fellow teacher Leslie, who is experienced and sophisticated in comparison. Readers like Emma. Even her kindness to the three new teachers who sit aloofly away from the other faculty.
Emma observes the Pentecostal ceremony of snake handling without judgment while connecting snakes to the poisoning at the school. Unfortunately, Ms. Kaye’s content editor dropped the ball. The offending snake in the terrifying finale is supposed to be a coral snake. Right colors, but no one read to the description of size. So, a snake as thick as a pencil and only two feet long in most cases, is not very frightening unless someone knows it is the second most venomous snake in the world. Emma sees a huge snake as thick as her upper arm and over four feet long writhing in her bed and hissing at her and her pets. Coral snakes strike by sinking their short teeth into prey and holding on and chewing. She got that right as Emma shakes her leg to try to fling the snake off. The story is so good and the characters, even minor ones, so well motivated that surely readers can suspend disbelief during the well written exciting scene.
One of my favorite episodes is Emma’s use of her creative writing students to figure out Otto. She describes for them a character named Otis and urges them to create a background for him. One student’s “wildly imaginative”
cliche turns out to be pretty accurate.
I’d give five stars with a one star penalty for letting a serious inaccuracy get through, so total score of four stars. Look forward to the next whenever it comes.
Review of Poison by Punctuation
by Helen Hogan
Kelley Kaye (Bowles) has a good novel in Poison by Punctuation, the second in a proposed series of cozy mysteries about Emma the new English teacher in a small Colorado high school. Her character uses clear thinking to analyze various facts as they appear. She has occasional weakness as she admires her mentor fellow teacher Leslie, who is experienced and sophisticated in comparison. Readers like Emma. Even her kindness to the three new teachers who sit aloofly away from the other faculty.
Emma observes the Pentecostal ceremony of snake handling without judgment while connecting snakes to the poisoning at the school. Unfortunately, Ms. Kaye’s content editor dropped the ball. The offending snake in the terrifying finale is supposed to be a coral snake. Right colors, but no one read to the description of size. So, a snake as thick as a pencil and only two feet long in most cases, is not very frightening unless someone knows it is the second most venomous snake in the world. Emma sees a huge snake as thick as her upper arm and over four feet long writhing in her bed and hissing at her and her pets. Coral snakes strike by sinking their short teeth into prey and holding on and chewing. She got that right as Emma shakes her leg to try to fling the snake off. The story is so good and the characters, even minor ones, so well motivated that surely readers can suspend disbelief during the well written exciting scene.
One of my favorite episodes is Emma’s use of her creative writing students to figure out Otto. She describes for them a character named Otis and urges them to create a background for him. One student’s “wildly imaginative”
cliche turns out to be pretty accurate.
I’d give five stars with a one star penalty for letting a serious inaccuracy get through, so total score of four stars. Look forward to the next whenever it comes.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews