So, this is a world where robots exist and you can buy them for various purposes. Including sex or housework? Or maybe not? I don't know, I'm very confused on that point. Also, some robots seem to be more sentient than others? Anyways, in this world a man named Robert Percival buys two robots, one named Elle and one named Summer, with the help of a friend named Vivaan. He uses Elle for sex and feels affection for her, and uses Summer for housework and thinks of her sort of as an "artificial wife". Basically he's fucked up. Elle and Summer are supposed to be kept separate but they eventually meet and ally themselves against Robert. Oh, and fall in love.
It's quite a didactic book. I felt like the whole "women are robots dehumanized for male use" thing was played a little hard, but on the other hand it doesn't seem like all society behaves like Robert--he's more the outlier--but I still feel like it was pretty overboard.
Robert's character is an odd one. He's given many POV sections (he and Vivaan are given as many as Elle and Summer), and his tone is always affably academic but his actions towards Summer are cartoonishly abusive. His Madonna/whore complex toward Summer and Elle is obvious, but it's a little inverted from the norm: usually you'd see the whore treated as trash and the Madonna venerated, but Robert views Summer as a mindless tool and Elle as an actual lover who reciprocates his feelings. I thought that was interesting. Incidentally, it really needs to be mentioned that Elle (the pseudo-whore) is black, and Summer (the pseudo-wife) is white. Which is kind of weird because they're both robots, but somewhat lines up with expectations for women from those two races--stereotypical black women being more sexualized and seen as exotic whereas stereotypical white women are pure, non-sexual and submissive. So...hm...
Robert is also given a backstory of a not-great father and a lesbian mother who left the family. Which seems to be partly the reason for his misogyny and eventual homophobia. He resents his mother but you can tell that the hatred is born of sadness over his mother leaving him.
Can you tell I thought Robert was the most interesting character? I feel awful about this. He's an abusive asshole and terrible in a hundred different ways, but he still felt the most three-dimensional. This book is as much about him as it is about Summer or Elle, certainly.
So, onto Summer and Elle then. Elle's pretty interesting. Her backstory confuses the heck out of me: she was in a whorehouse with other robots apparently? But she also seemed to be living a relatively independent life despite her robothood? And she had a love affair with the brothel owner but also maybe said owner was just using her. Also she's lesbian (and so is Elle) which is interesting and confusing because these are robots and you'd think that kind of thing wouldn't be programmed in--though at least it makes more sense for her than for Summer, since she's meant to be used for sex and thus should have sexual desire for her clients (most of whom were women) while Summer is definitely meant for male use. This "but they're robots" thing kept on tripping me up with them disobeying their programming and rebelling too, or changing because of gaslighting rather than changes to their programming. Idk, I picture my robots as more mechanical than humans and it just gets so confusing. I have to suspend my disbelief a bit harder I guess
On the other side of our lesbian robot relationship as well as our Madonna/whore complex we have Summer, who unfortunately was kind of boring. It's too bad--I like a rebellious Madonna figure, but while I didn't dislike Summer there just wasn't that much to her. Still glad she eventually escapes life with Robert and gets to be with Elle but that girl and I did not connect.
Finally, in our group of MCs there is also Vivaan, the man who thinks he's so much better than Robert but really is not. Even at the start he's complicit with Robert's actions and by the end he's shown that he has a dark side too. I think he kind of demonstrates that standing by while somewhat commits heinous acts doesn't absolve you. But again, I'm like.... you did creepy stuff but also Summer and Elle are literally robots? I know they're a metaphor for marginalized people but also, they are literally robots. I guess what it comes down to is that Summer and Elle are apparently sentient, which brings up a question of how they're sentient and what sentience really is and blah blah blah blah...
I get way too caught up in the mechanics of robot stories to enjoy a good metaphor.
Anyways, I would say that this is a book that made me think more than most lesfic I've read lately, so that's good, and I enjoyed the dark suspense of it all, but the world building is a bit muddled (for example, is keeping a robot as a sex slave legal or not? I want answers??) and the sense of didacticism can be a bit strong. Made for a nice change of pace, guess I'd recommend, especially since it's currently free and generally available through KU. Now I'm gonna go read some other reviews to see what others thought!
Content warnings: Rape, sexual slavery, abuse, misogyny, homophobia, violence. A lot of stuff.