The Belted Galloways are trapped in a vicious cycle. Every year their bossy neighbors, the Herefords, win the Cow Wrestling Contest. The winners get to graze on the best pasture. The losers have to wait till next year. Can a beltless Belted Galloway do anything about their plight? He can if his name is Clancy.
The message in this story is one to be admired. The book teachers tolerance and acceptance to young children; therefore, by understanding this message they will hopefully appreciate everyone’s’ differences and learn not to pass judgment on others because of these differences. What makes this book more remarkable is that the author of this book wrote the book when he was just 12 years old. The story depicts a cow that is picked on and feels left out because he does not have a white line going around his stomach like all of the other cows do; he is picked on and often feels ashamed of not having this white line like everyone else. In the end, the other cows learn to appreciate him when he is able to win a wrestling match against the enemy cows. Therefore, this cow teaches all of the other cows about acceptable and that nobody should be judged because they may be different than everybody else. Teaching students about theme and acceptance by using this book to start off the unit would be a great way to use this resource.
Again with the male cow; do people not understand that a cow with udders is female? That mammals rarely lactate until they've actually been pregnant at least once?
Is it unreasonable of me to expect cows to be female and bulls to be male? For bees and ants to be female? I realize that people write stories for kids all the time that use animal characters without any basis in the animal nature. I know that Little Bear's father doesn't wear an Edwardian suit. But one of the cool things about nature is all the different kinds of society there can be, and many are matriarchal. And I'm really tired of the females just not existing. Quit it. That stupid Barnyard movie got on my last bloody nerve, and don't even think about mentioning the TV show to me, I will scream.
No, anthropomorphized critters in children's story books do not have to act exactly like their real world counterparts. But let's try to get some of the facts right, okay?
A very interesting story about two sets of cows who have a wrestling match to see which herd will get the better grass. In the Belted Galloway herd a boy is born without the white belt, which gives him the advantage of being able sneak across the the better grass at night without being spotted by the Herefords.
And interesting story about how an uneven playing field tends to perpetuate itself - i.e. the Herefords always win the wrestling match because they have access to the better grass which makes them bigger and stronger, which in turn gives them another year of grazing on the better grass.
The belted galloways are trapped in a vicious cycle. Every year their bossy neighbors, the Herefords, win the cow wrestling contest. The winners get to graze on the best pasture. The losers have to wait till next year. Can a beltless belted Galloway do anything about their plight? (Book jacket)
Great for raising discussions about bullying, peace studies, and sportsmanship.
This is a story to teach kids about bullying, war, peace, sportsmanship, being different, etc, etc...
It's not the greatest picture book every made - but it is pretty fantastic work for a 12-year-old. It probably helped that children's book writing is in the family - with Lachie's mum being Alison Lester.