I'm glad this exists. Ever since reading The Grimscribe Puppets it seemed that something like this certainly _could_ exist. That collection proved that there are more than enough talented authors who understand Ligotti's dark themes and his surreal atmosphere, and can make it their own in many creative ways.
But the work here is far from mere simulation. These works all come from a similar mindset of an uncomfortable angst and a rejection of the collective illusions that make the human condition bearable.
I think the obvious standout fictional works were "The Theatre Of Ovid," "Nervous Wares & Abnormal Stares" and "Singing The Song Of My Unmaking." Although it lies in a nebulous territory between fiction and a non-fiction philosophical essay, I would place Christopher Slatsky's "Affirmation of the Spirit: Consciousness, Transformation, and the Fourth World in Film" right along with them. The poetry and art in the collection helped break things up and add a little variety.
I enjoyed the non-fiction entries here more than I expected to. The line between fiction and non-fiction isn't always entirely clear in some of them, which makes for a unsettling experience in itself. A few of these essays explored film, I particularly liked Colby Smith's essay on Eraserhead in an antinatalist context. The best analysis of Ligottian fiction here in my opinion would be Michael J. Abolafia's essay on "The Last Feast of Harlequin" which was quite illuminating.
There's many stories and essays here I wouldn't re-read, but there wasn't anything I downright disliked. That combined with the uniqueness and boldness of this project -- five stars it is.
--------------
The Gods in Their Seats, Unblinking by Kurt Fawver
This is a unique story, in the form of a one-act play, with a brief introduction about how it is seemingly cursed. It's a great way to start the issue out, it explores Ligottian themes in a fairly original way and is well-written. An inmate in an asylum tells his psychiatrist that he believes unseen entities are watching and studying him -- and much more.
The Nightmare of His Art: The Horrific Power of the Imagination in “The Troubles of Dr. Thoss” and “Gas Station Carnivals” by W. Silverwood
This is a well-written essay on the role of imagination in these two Ligotti stories, with more emphasis on the former. Imagination is explored as a source of one's own undoing -- and perhaps for some explorers of horror, this is precisely what they wished for.
Affirmation of the Spirit: Consciousness, Transformation, and the Fourth World in Film by Christopher Slatsky
This is one of my favorite entries in this issue -- it's part essay, part deeply philosophical story. Slatsky explores the idea of a film being an independent entity, a consciousness in itself. This makes for an interesting analogy to our own lack of a self, and our predetermined nature. "There is no evidence of reality outside the domino effect of chunks bashing into bits and the resulting physical processes being revered as something other than the mechanistic drudgery they are." Hear! Hear!
Try the Veal by Robert Beveridge
A brief, somewhat darkly comic poem of cannibalism.
How to Construct a Gun from Your Own Flesh by Michael Uhall
Probably the shortest prose entry, yet there's a good deal to think about here. Perhaps my favorite idea within this sort of "thought experiment" was the idea of something being constructed from the body, entirely involuntarily -- all of our bodily functions are already such.
“Eccentric to the Healthy Social Order”: Inversions of Family, Community, and Religion in Thomas Ligotti’s The Last Feast of Harlequin by Michael J. Abolafia
This is another non-fiction essay, this time on Ligotti's "The Last Feast of Harlequin," and how the themes of that story undermine the ideals of traditional Americana; of health, independence and productivity, through a sacrilege anti-natalist festival.
“They say I should kill myself and not try to spoil their enjoyment in being alive”: An Interview with Thomas Ligotti by Wojciech Gunia
This interview appeared in 2014, and appears here for the first time in English. Ligotti makes some good points about euthanasia and an appeal for how sensitivity leads to pessimism. He also mentions many authors I love, or have wanted to explore for some time. "They fabricate all kinds of false reasons for why they stand in the way of euthanasia, but they won’t tell you the truth about it. [...] The truth is that once you allow that living can be so terrible it has become a nightmare, then where do you draw the line?"
Wraiths by Wade German
Another poem, seemingly about letting go of life.
Eraserhead as Antinatalist Allegory by Colby Smith
This is quite an illuminating essay, and convincing in its arguments, on a film I really need to watch again.
The Theatre Of Ovid by Aaron Worth
This is one of the best stories in this collection, perhaps the best of all. This one kept me guessing, all the way to the end and it ties together some very strange elements in a clever fashion that makes for a unique tale with a Victorian-era tone. The director of an asylum cures and marries a beautiful young woman who suffered from a strange malady that makes her write false histories. On their honeymoon he learns that she isn't fully cured at all.
The Alienation Of The Self: Marx, Polanyi, And Ligottian Horror by S. L. Edwards
This is an essay on a topic I've actually thought about myself -- politics and the implications of a Ligottian worldview on the possibilities of real human freedom. A Marxist analysis compared with a cosmic one.
Strange Bird by Ian Mullins
A poem, seemingly about the endless recycling of matter for life's purposes.
Solar Flare by Paul L. Bates
This is one of the strangest stories here, not among my top favorites, but it does have a disorientating atmosphere and some eerie moments that stayed with me. A man travels through the night to a town that is seemingly decaying before his eyes.
Night Walks: The Films Of Val Lewton by Michael Penkas
This was a fun read, but mostly it just recounts scenes in Val Lewton's films, without a lot of analysis. As someone who has seen some of these subtle horror/noir films so many times it could almost be considered "studying them," there wasn't much new for me here.
Infinite Light, Infinite Darkness by Martin Rose
This story has a different feel from many others here, it wasn't among my favorites. I liked the "idea" of the plot, but not how it was executed. A poor old Vietnamese farmer who has lost his wife and son in the Vietnam War takes in an American soldier who deserts. The soldier is fascinated by a nonexistent temple which his son also claimed to have visited.
Nervous Wares & Abnormal Stares by Devin Goff
This was a fun story that's quite humorous. It might not feel especially deep, but when it's over I went back and noted that it was quite suspenseful and original. A woman opens a ceramic shop in a small town that starts to slowly die all around her.
My Time At The Drake Clinic by Jordan Krall
Funny, Kafka-esque, absurd and weirdly circular. This is the only story in the bunch that made me laugh out loud. This story explores the theme of a seemingly contagious madness, and is a strike at the idea that everyone secretly "has it together." A "instructor" at a clinic is taunted by a troublesome student with a strange form of "panic."
Notes On A Horror by Dr. Raymond Thoss
The last non-fiction entry, by a psychiatrist using an alias. This is a deeply sympathetic and compassionate look at the denial of trauma from child abuse compared with to the denial of the conspiracy Ligotti writes of in his works. There were some fascinating scientific studies cited that showed interpersonal trauma can cause parts of the brain not associated with the most basic bodily functions to "turn off," causing a losing of the self. This was my favorite non-fiction essay here.
Singing The Song Of My Unmaking by Christopher Ropes
Wow, last but certainly not least. This is part-story, part-poetry and part-personal reflections that express what depression is really like better than almost anything I've read before. I'm hesitant to say this is the best story in the book, but it's certainly the most emotionally impactful. A town is engulfed in a slow apocalypse, but one man yearns for his own doom.