What do you think?
Rate this book
Hush a Bye Baby
Dr. Nandita Rai is the gynecologist for the stars. She is on TV and radio every other week talking about women's issues. She is a South Mumbai feminist. Every woman wants her to be their doctor.
Until the Mumbai Police raid her clinic when they get a complaint that she does sex selective abortions. Is the celebrity doctor aborting female fetuses? If she is, then the police need to build a watertight case. Dr. Rai has friends in high places, her patients clam up and her paperwork is clean.
The case seems to be going nowhere until Sub-inspector Reshma Gabuji begins to dig up Dr. Rai s secret online presence and uncovers a ruthless vigilante group.
Until the Mumbai Police raid her clinic when they get a complaint that she does sex selective abortions. Is the celebrity doctor aborting female fetuses? If she is, then the police need to build a watertight case. Dr. Rai has friends in high places, her patients clam up and her paperwork is clean.
The case seems to be going nowhere until Sub-inspector Reshma Gabuji begins to dig up Dr. Rai s secret online presence and uncovers a ruthless vigilante group.
374 pages, ebook
First published February 1, 2018
2 people are currently reading
97 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews
September 4, 2020
Hush a Bye Baby is a novel about a staunch feminist gynecologist accused of gender selective abortions. In a country as populous as India, surgical termination of pregnancy may seem a minor procedure for busy gynecologists who in due course of time may think nothing of snuffing out another life. It was revealed early on that Dr Nandita Rai, had indeed committed female foeticide and the motive behind the henious act is what the mystery unfolds into. A slightly disturbing story but a fast paced thriller with an interesting plot and well developed characters. It gave much to reflect about but the story ended a bit before the ending and the sting in the tail was obvious.
April 19, 2018
Rating - 3.5 out of 5 stars
In Deepanjana Pal's Hush A Bye Baby, renowned gynecologist Dr. Nandita Rai, who is known for her upper class connections and standing up for women's rights, is accused of conducting sex-selective abortions. When this news spreads like wildfire, all of Mumbai is astounded. As the Mumbai Police chase leads left, right and center, they're forced to consider what is it that the elite in society are keeping hush about Nandita's supposed crime.
I had really high expectations from this book, especially because the plot sounded unlike anything I'd heard before. And so, when I finished reading it, I realized I had mixed feelings about it. The start developed a bad taste in my mind because, all that surfaced were just how static the characters were; many of them had morality issues, others simply couldn't perform their jobs properly. On the whole, all of them annoyed me! But once I crossed the first quarter mark, Hush A Bye Baby showed all the promise of a fantastic suspense novel. The clues were unraveled at a steady pace. I began to focus on the story that the author was trying to convey. And I must commend her for coming up with such a thought provoking concept, interlaced into a thriller.
So undoubtedly, a majority of this novel was definitely gripping! But then after all that build up, I felt that the climax was a little underwhelming; it fell flat against the tension and intrigue that the novel was able to maintain till the end. Nandita comes across as somebody who is very sarcastically witty and detached; totally uncaring of the allegations that have been made against her. But soon, you'll realize the reason behind her perspective. Themes of infanticide, rape, cult are explored. The deeply woven corruption within Indian society peeks out over the course of this book. Despite it's shortcomings, I believe this book will entertain a lot of readers, and so I do recommend it to those who enjoy thrillers.
What do you get out of it? A medical thriller that echoes some very pressing concerns regarding the future of our country with respect to gender security.
Thank you Juggernaut for sending me a copy of this book in exchange of an honest review.
In Deepanjana Pal's Hush A Bye Baby, renowned gynecologist Dr. Nandita Rai, who is known for her upper class connections and standing up for women's rights, is accused of conducting sex-selective abortions. When this news spreads like wildfire, all of Mumbai is astounded. As the Mumbai Police chase leads left, right and center, they're forced to consider what is it that the elite in society are keeping hush about Nandita's supposed crime.
I had really high expectations from this book, especially because the plot sounded unlike anything I'd heard before. And so, when I finished reading it, I realized I had mixed feelings about it. The start developed a bad taste in my mind because, all that surfaced were just how static the characters were; many of them had morality issues, others simply couldn't perform their jobs properly. On the whole, all of them annoyed me! But once I crossed the first quarter mark, Hush A Bye Baby showed all the promise of a fantastic suspense novel. The clues were unraveled at a steady pace. I began to focus on the story that the author was trying to convey. And I must commend her for coming up with such a thought provoking concept, interlaced into a thriller.
So undoubtedly, a majority of this novel was definitely gripping! But then after all that build up, I felt that the climax was a little underwhelming; it fell flat against the tension and intrigue that the novel was able to maintain till the end. Nandita comes across as somebody who is very sarcastically witty and detached; totally uncaring of the allegations that have been made against her. But soon, you'll realize the reason behind her perspective. Themes of infanticide, rape, cult are explored. The deeply woven corruption within Indian society peeks out over the course of this book. Despite it's shortcomings, I believe this book will entertain a lot of readers, and so I do recommend it to those who enjoy thrillers.
What do you get out of it? A medical thriller that echoes some very pressing concerns regarding the future of our country with respect to gender security.
Thank you Juggernaut for sending me a copy of this book in exchange of an honest review.
January 17, 2019
The rhythm of tiny heart still resounds in her ears.Her soul cries at the loss...
An eminent personality, a leading doctor is accused of Sex Selective abortions.She is the same person who actively work in favor of women rights and their freedom.Its really interesting to find out how the chain of events uncover many dark truths.
Lucid writing coupled with an engaging story-line and strong characters keep a reader glued to the book till the end.The story throws light upon the critical issues like sex selective abortions, domestic violence,rape,gender inequality and widespread corruption.The thrill factor increases with every new chapter, the twist and turns just draws me in the story like never before.One can easily feel the blood rush,the climax will leave you numbed and plague your mind with many crucial questions.
The embedded message echoes through the mind for a long time.
An eminent personality, a leading doctor is accused of Sex Selective abortions.She is the same person who actively work in favor of women rights and their freedom.Its really interesting to find out how the chain of events uncover many dark truths.
Lucid writing coupled with an engaging story-line and strong characters keep a reader glued to the book till the end.The story throws light upon the critical issues like sex selective abortions, domestic violence,rape,gender inequality and widespread corruption.The thrill factor increases with every new chapter, the twist and turns just draws me in the story like never before.One can easily feel the blood rush,the climax will leave you numbed and plague your mind with many crucial questions.
The embedded message echoes through the mind for a long time.
May 18, 2018
Review will shortly be updated on Women's Web. Shall share the link.
May 9, 2021
A fantastic crime thriller set in Mumbai. I was on the edge of my seat as the plot revealed. What wonderful writing and perfectly developed characters. I heard the author say in an interview that there is going to be second part, so...excited. Have to mention though, the ending was a little disappointing.
May 24, 2018
Fast paced thriller. But the ending felt a bit flat
April 20, 2018
Hush a by Baby is a story of the birth of a vigilante. It starts with Dr. Nandita, a well known gynecologist who places women's rights at the top of her priority list, being investigated for gender selective abortions. Suspecting foul play, the Mumbai police force launches an investigation only to discover that they may have met their match.
The book touches upon important issues such as gender inequality, pre-natal gender determination, gender selective abortions, female genital mutilation, cyber bullying and bullying in the name of tradition. It shows that even the highest echelons of society is not free of the perception that it is okay to do away with a foetus based on its gender.
We see how cyber bullies prey on vulnerable individuals, ply them with selective information to rile them up and have them do their bidding. The threat from untrained 'professionals' who act as Gurus or Life Coaches as a cover to attract naive and vulnerable people for their benefit is very real.
What I really loved about the book is that Reshma, a woman police officer plays an important role in solving the case of Doctor Death. She did not turn to her male colleagues for help even when things took a nasty turn. I was also very glad to see that the men did not treat her any differently (other than at one instance which the character himself admits). Both Nandita and Reshma are tech-savy, smart and witty and do not rely on a Prince Charming to get them out of any situation. It was a very refreshing read that kept me up way past my bedtime
The book touches upon important issues such as gender inequality, pre-natal gender determination, gender selective abortions, female genital mutilation, cyber bullying and bullying in the name of tradition. It shows that even the highest echelons of society is not free of the perception that it is okay to do away with a foetus based on its gender.
We see how cyber bullies prey on vulnerable individuals, ply them with selective information to rile them up and have them do their bidding. The threat from untrained 'professionals' who act as Gurus or Life Coaches as a cover to attract naive and vulnerable people for their benefit is very real.
What I really loved about the book is that Reshma, a woman police officer plays an important role in solving the case of Doctor Death. She did not turn to her male colleagues for help even when things took a nasty turn. I was also very glad to see that the men did not treat her any differently (other than at one instance which the character himself admits). Both Nandita and Reshma are tech-savy, smart and witty and do not rely on a Prince Charming to get them out of any situation. It was a very refreshing read that kept me up way past my bedtime
May 11, 2021
My video review: https://youtu.be/0BYzCQ5E5AQ
Not even in my wildest dreams I could have imagined the plot of this book. It revolves around a malpractice lawsuit against Dr. Nandita Rai, a famous gynaecologist. The investigation of this case reveals the dark side of humanity. I love how the author has taken the concept of sex selective abortions and not only made it a riveting thriller but has also send across an important message. Not to forget the awareness she has created about vigilante groups.
If you are looking for a good thriller book this one is it.
Not even in my wildest dreams I could have imagined the plot of this book. It revolves around a malpractice lawsuit against Dr. Nandita Rai, a famous gynaecologist. The investigation of this case reveals the dark side of humanity. I love how the author has taken the concept of sex selective abortions and not only made it a riveting thriller but has also send across an important message. Not to forget the awareness she has created about vigilante groups.
If you are looking for a good thriller book this one is it.
December 17, 2018
Deepanjana Pal's recently launched 'Hush A Bye Baby' is a fast-paced book with an interesting plot to boot. This work of fiction investigates the allegations of sex-selective abortions laid upon Mumbai's top gynecologist Nandita Rai. Over its course, the book explores many contemporary issues like corruption, female foeticide in India, state of women in society, power politics, etc.
Read the full review here: http://www.thedreamydryad.com/2018/04...
Read the full review here: http://www.thedreamydryad.com/2018/04...
April 10, 2019
Dr Nandita Rai is a successful gynaecologist, whose client list has some of the biggest names of this country. She is well known for speaking out about social causes and bringing the spotlight on issues many prefer to keep buried. Everyone wants to know her personally or be like her. That is until the police get a tip and raid her clinic leading to many questions. Does Nandita, the modern feminist actually enable female feticide? Good thing that Reshma is handling the investigation in this case.
What I expected when I picked up this book was a healthy dose of drama, a section for preaching about social issues and maybe a pinch of thrill. But I was pleasantly surprised and I genuinely enjoyed reading a thriller by an Indian author after a long time.
Reshma Gabuji is an interesting character. A female sub-inspector with a curious mind and witty nature won me over. I liked how she worked the case and would certainly want this book to be just the first in the series for Reshma Gabuji. Nandita Rai is a complex character in certain ways because there were moments that made me question her character. I wished for a little more insight into her personality. The supporting characters failed to make any sort of impression on me. Somehow, even while contributing to the story, they came off as these grey characters that really deserve to be in the shadows.
The book has a steady pace wherein the author has expertly scattered clues for readers to pick up on them. That sure kept the pages turning and it built up the plot to the climax nicely. That’s where the book fell a bit flat as everything else in the book had indicated towards an explosive climax. But the final reveal fell a bit short in execution leaving me feeling slightly disappointed. I also have to mention that the author has delivered a book that talk about a number of social issues without being preachy about it. They are beautifully weaved into the story.
Overall, this book provided me a pleasant surprise in between the covers and I will be keeping my eye out for the author’s books in the future.
What I expected when I picked up this book was a healthy dose of drama, a section for preaching about social issues and maybe a pinch of thrill. But I was pleasantly surprised and I genuinely enjoyed reading a thriller by an Indian author after a long time.
Reshma Gabuji is an interesting character. A female sub-inspector with a curious mind and witty nature won me over. I liked how she worked the case and would certainly want this book to be just the first in the series for Reshma Gabuji. Nandita Rai is a complex character in certain ways because there were moments that made me question her character. I wished for a little more insight into her personality. The supporting characters failed to make any sort of impression on me. Somehow, even while contributing to the story, they came off as these grey characters that really deserve to be in the shadows.
The book has a steady pace wherein the author has expertly scattered clues for readers to pick up on them. That sure kept the pages turning and it built up the plot to the climax nicely. That’s where the book fell a bit flat as everything else in the book had indicated towards an explosive climax. But the final reveal fell a bit short in execution leaving me feeling slightly disappointed. I also have to mention that the author has delivered a book that talk about a number of social issues without being preachy about it. They are beautifully weaved into the story.
Overall, this book provided me a pleasant surprise in between the covers and I will be keeping my eye out for the author’s books in the future.
January 1, 2026
I have a weakness for bad women (mean women, flawed women, irredeemable women), and a female serial killer of foetuses is a great premise. Nandita Rai had all the makings of a good detestable-yet-sympathetic villain. I like the sense of the place too, it is rooted in Mumbai by someone who knows Mumbai fairly well (details like the JB Petit accent!)
I found the book started off well but, by the end, was rather disappointed by some plot twists. Pal seems to be leaving several things threads untied for a sequel, but it's been 7 years and there doesn't appear to be any more forthcoming.
In other minor grumbles, I didn't quite like the way the Bohri Muslims were written. Reshma disavows her traditionally Bohri name, Rashida, in favour of her more Hindu-coded name, not as strategic response to islamophobia and hindutva sentiment (which I would have found more interesting) but because she likes it and finds Bohri culture regressive and tiresome. The rida was treated as a costume not clothes, and in fact the author's note at the end calls it a 'traditional costume', and it is described in the text as a uniform. It is othering in a way I don't think the author intended. It feels unlikely the author would have applied "No one looked like their normal selves in a rida" to, say, a sari.
Despite all the quibbling, I did enjoy the book and read it in roughly a day. The wobbly motive and final resolution made me wonder if making this a 'why-dunnit' instead of a who-dunnit as someone described it, was worth the pay-off of the loss of suspense though.
I found the book started off well but, by the end, was rather disappointed by some plot twists. Pal seems to be leaving several things threads untied for a sequel, but it's been 7 years and there doesn't appear to be any more forthcoming.
In other minor grumbles, I didn't quite like the way the Bohri Muslims were written. Reshma disavows her traditionally Bohri name, Rashida, in favour of her more Hindu-coded name, not as strategic response to islamophobia and hindutva sentiment (which I would have found more interesting) but because she likes it and finds Bohri culture regressive and tiresome. The rida was treated as a costume not clothes, and in fact the author's note at the end calls it a 'traditional costume', and it is described in the text as a uniform. It is othering in a way I don't think the author intended. It feels unlikely the author would have applied "No one looked like their normal selves in a rida" to, say, a sari.
Despite all the quibbling, I did enjoy the book and read it in roughly a day. The wobbly motive and final resolution made me wonder if making this a 'why-dunnit' instead of a who-dunnit as someone described it, was worth the pay-off of the loss of suspense though.
April 26, 2023
I couldn't put this book down and I almost considered taking leave from work to finish it. However, i feel like my experience would've been perfect if the whole plot wasn't completely revealed when 25% of the book was still remaining.
September 16, 2018
3.5 actually.
April 18, 2020
Clever writing, interesting plot. All in all a pacy, whydunit crime thriller!
April 20, 2018
I actually downloaded the Juggernaut app and signed up there to read this book, because I've been a fan of Deepanjana Pal's work for some time. The premise sounded interesting, and I knew that the writing at least would be good.
Quick plot summary before we go further. Prominent Mumbai gynecologist and socialite Dr Nandita Rai is taken in for questioning on charges of female foeticide. The police have received multiple anonymous Helpline calls with accusations against her, and one formal complaint by a distraught lady. But could somebody who generally preaches about women's empowerment be committing foeticide on the side? A team of three police officers investigates and tries to assemble the evidence needed to convict her.
I don't know how the physical book is, but on Juggernaut, the book was divided into eight parts, with each part apparently published a few days apart. Maybe because of the serialization, the book is gripping from the get-go, with dramatic reveals thrown in throughout like so many cherries. Unfortunately, that also becomes the book's biggest failing ultimately.
The basic thing about any thriller (IMHO) is that there should be something hidden, something murky that the investigators are trying to figure out. There should be tantalizing hints in every chapter that lead up to the final reveal. Unfortunately, Hush a Bye Baby reveals so many things in its initial chapters that the final chapters feel flat and underwhelming. Where was the action-filled climax I was expecting? Why do these final chapters even exist? Even the "twist" in the final chapter feels meh.
It's a shame actually, because Hush a Bye Baby has quite a few things going for it. A great idea, crisp writing and a well-sketched-out female police officer (I can't recall a similar female police officer in crime fiction, in fact!). If only the author had taken some more time to tie the last few chapters together a bit better.
Questions / points that I felt were left unresolved (skip this next part if you haven't read the book):
1. Why does Hadpude not allow Reshma to delve deeper into the website angle? Why does he suddenly and randomly suspend her? (Yes, there was a WHY given, but it wasn't enough.) Why in fact does Reshma get a raw deal throughout? Was it just to make the final twist more believable?
2. The Hush a Bye rhyme singing was super creepy and hinted that there were darker things underfoot. But it wasn't really taken further.
3. Who was the second woman at the table with Vikram and Anita? (I'm okay not knowing who exactly Chat is.)
4. Why was foeticide spelt feticide throughout??
Quick plot summary before we go further. Prominent Mumbai gynecologist and socialite Dr Nandita Rai is taken in for questioning on charges of female foeticide. The police have received multiple anonymous Helpline calls with accusations against her, and one formal complaint by a distraught lady. But could somebody who generally preaches about women's empowerment be committing foeticide on the side? A team of three police officers investigates and tries to assemble the evidence needed to convict her.
I don't know how the physical book is, but on Juggernaut, the book was divided into eight parts, with each part apparently published a few days apart. Maybe because of the serialization, the book is gripping from the get-go, with dramatic reveals thrown in throughout like so many cherries. Unfortunately, that also becomes the book's biggest failing ultimately.
The basic thing about any thriller (IMHO) is that there should be something hidden, something murky that the investigators are trying to figure out. There should be tantalizing hints in every chapter that lead up to the final reveal. Unfortunately, Hush a Bye Baby reveals so many things in its initial chapters that the final chapters feel flat and underwhelming. Where was the action-filled climax I was expecting? Why do these final chapters even exist? Even the "twist" in the final chapter feels meh.
It's a shame actually, because Hush a Bye Baby has quite a few things going for it. A great idea, crisp writing and a well-sketched-out female police officer (I can't recall a similar female police officer in crime fiction, in fact!). If only the author had taken some more time to tie the last few chapters together a bit better.
Questions / points that I felt were left unresolved (skip this next part if you haven't read the book):
1. Why does Hadpude not allow Reshma to delve deeper into the website angle? Why does he suddenly and randomly suspend her? (Yes, there was a WHY given, but it wasn't enough.) Why in fact does Reshma get a raw deal throughout? Was it just to make the final twist more believable?
2. The Hush a Bye rhyme singing was super creepy and hinted that there were darker things underfoot. But it wasn't really taken further.
3. Who was the second woman at the table with Vikram and Anita? (I'm okay not knowing who exactly Chat is.)
4. Why was foeticide spelt feticide throughout??
September 1, 2024
Deepanjana Pal in her book Hush a Bye Baby ( the title is inspired by a lullaby of similar name) brings out a story of abortions, police procedures and how abortions are carried over in Mumbai. The case baffles the police for lack of a motive and the accused is a high profile member of the society.
Dr Nandita Rai is the gynecologist for the celebrities and rich people. She is on television and radio every week talking about women empowerment and issues. She is from South Mumbai and a proud feminist. Every woman wants her to be their doctor. Until the Mumbai Police raid her Hope Clinic when they get complaints that she does sex-selective abortions from the Health Ministry. Is the celebrity doctor aborting female fetuses? If yes, then why?
Read the complete review on my blog
Dr Nandita Rai is the gynecologist for the celebrities and rich people. She is on television and radio every week talking about women empowerment and issues. She is from South Mumbai and a proud feminist. Every woman wants her to be their doctor. Until the Mumbai Police raid her Hope Clinic when they get complaints that she does sex-selective abortions from the Health Ministry. Is the celebrity doctor aborting female fetuses? If yes, then why?
Read the complete review on my blog
April 25, 2018
Originally published on Just A Girl High On Books
Favorite characters: Nandita Rai, Reshma Gubuji
Oh. My. God.
This was the first reaction that I had as soon as I finished reading the book. A thriller at its best and that too, by someone who makes a debut with this, marveled me with its beauty. Not only did the book leave me wanting for more, but also left me pondering over the values we have been taught so far. “Is female foeticide then, good or bad?” This is the biggest question that passed through my mind as I sat there in the dim light of the early morning hours after finishing the book.
A captivating fast-paced thriller, this book is about a group of people who decide to take law in their hands. In a manner as beautiful as one could, it features issues like gender inequality, gender selective abortions, female genital mutilation, and cyber bullying. There were, of course, a few things I, as a reader, wondered and never got the answer to, but over all, the book turned out to be fabulous.
Now, here are the things that I loved about the book:
The plot. It was probably the strongest part. The hypocrisy in the actions of a renowned gynecologist who supports women everywhere was what kept the book going.
The suspense. Of course the suspense. The suspense I felt all through the book was another thing that kept the story going. Why did she do what she did? Did she feel no shame? Did she not wonder how this is against the law and that she can be behind bars? Why was she so sure of her husband’s influence? (Of course, I know the answer to that *now*!)
The thrill. The thrill of reading what would happen next. It could possibly come under the previous point, too but I just wanted to include it differently. I don’t know why.
The pace. The book was fast-paced. Things were revealed at almost the right points. Of course, there are a few mysteries still left behind and so I honestly hope there will be a sequel. *fingers crossed*
The style of writing. That was another thing that helped, perhaps. The book was easy to read. There were no editing errors, and the way Pal wrote only made me want to read more and more. I was like that kid with the chocolate cake, who wants more and more and more.
The cover. It complimented the book a lot.
The relatable characters. After all, isn’t a character that is more relatable to you given a higher priority other than the one who isn’t?
The strong female characters. Reshma and Nandita were my favorite. They fought for what they believed was right, no matter what the price of that was. Unlike her senior, Reshma did not stop to give the ‘why’ of the case zero significance. And well, we all know what Nandita was charged with after all.
The truth. Aah, how it made me smile when Anita – the one who got Nandita to do whatever she did – found out that Nandita had, in actual, been back-stabbing her. Aaah, the joy of it all.
And finally, the pain. Yes, the pain at what the world is like. The pain at to which extend the world has fallen. Not only because animals rape women, but also because of how people use vulnerable people for their fun, how they use them to do their measly tasks themselves. Yes, it pained me to see all that in Pal’s book. But the truth, in the end, is that this is the harsh reality of it all.
And now, some of the things that irked me:
Why did you end it at such a standstill? I want to know more. *sobs silently in a corner*
Who were the two women Vikram always met? (Provided, my assumption of him being Chat is right.) I’m guessing one of them was Anita, but who was the other one? The one who could not even come to meet Nandita when she was released?
What was the role of the other female officer in the beginning? (I cannot even remember her name now. Something from D, I guess.) We had a few scenes from her but did they have any significance? Or was it all to tell us that she had missed Nandita reveal her true nature?
Will there be a sequel? Please tell that to me, else I might have to bang on your door and beg you to write on. (Of course, not literally. So you don’t have to worry about that, Pal. Or do you? *raises an eyebrow with a devil smile on face*)
P.S. I read the book for free on the Juggernaut app. You are free to download and read more such books on your own. [Especially now that they have collaborated with HarperCollins, which is a huge boost. I believe.]
Favorite characters: Nandita Rai, Reshma Gubuji
Oh. My. God.
This was the first reaction that I had as soon as I finished reading the book. A thriller at its best and that too, by someone who makes a debut with this, marveled me with its beauty. Not only did the book leave me wanting for more, but also left me pondering over the values we have been taught so far. “Is female foeticide then, good or bad?” This is the biggest question that passed through my mind as I sat there in the dim light of the early morning hours after finishing the book.
A captivating fast-paced thriller, this book is about a group of people who decide to take law in their hands. In a manner as beautiful as one could, it features issues like gender inequality, gender selective abortions, female genital mutilation, and cyber bullying. There were, of course, a few things I, as a reader, wondered and never got the answer to, but over all, the book turned out to be fabulous.
Now, here are the things that I loved about the book:
The plot. It was probably the strongest part. The hypocrisy in the actions of a renowned gynecologist who supports women everywhere was what kept the book going.
The suspense. Of course the suspense. The suspense I felt all through the book was another thing that kept the story going. Why did she do what she did? Did she feel no shame? Did she not wonder how this is against the law and that she can be behind bars? Why was she so sure of her husband’s influence? (Of course, I know the answer to that *now*!)
The thrill. The thrill of reading what would happen next. It could possibly come under the previous point, too but I just wanted to include it differently. I don’t know why.
The pace. The book was fast-paced. Things were revealed at almost the right points. Of course, there are a few mysteries still left behind and so I honestly hope there will be a sequel. *fingers crossed*
The style of writing. That was another thing that helped, perhaps. The book was easy to read. There were no editing errors, and the way Pal wrote only made me want to read more and more. I was like that kid with the chocolate cake, who wants more and more and more.
The cover. It complimented the book a lot.
The relatable characters. After all, isn’t a character that is more relatable to you given a higher priority other than the one who isn’t?
The strong female characters. Reshma and Nandita were my favorite. They fought for what they believed was right, no matter what the price of that was. Unlike her senior, Reshma did not stop to give the ‘why’ of the case zero significance. And well, we all know what Nandita was charged with after all.
The truth. Aah, how it made me smile when Anita – the one who got Nandita to do whatever she did – found out that Nandita had, in actual, been back-stabbing her. Aaah, the joy of it all.
And finally, the pain. Yes, the pain at what the world is like. The pain at to which extend the world has fallen. Not only because animals rape women, but also because of how people use vulnerable people for their fun, how they use them to do their measly tasks themselves. Yes, it pained me to see all that in Pal’s book. But the truth, in the end, is that this is the harsh reality of it all.
And now, some of the things that irked me:
Why did you end it at such a standstill? I want to know more. *sobs silently in a corner*
Who were the two women Vikram always met? (Provided, my assumption of him being Chat is right.) I’m guessing one of them was Anita, but who was the other one? The one who could not even come to meet Nandita when she was released?
What was the role of the other female officer in the beginning? (I cannot even remember her name now. Something from D, I guess.) We had a few scenes from her but did they have any significance? Or was it all to tell us that she had missed Nandita reveal her true nature?
Will there be a sequel? Please tell that to me, else I might have to bang on your door and beg you to write on. (Of course, not literally. So you don’t have to worry about that, Pal. Or do you? *raises an eyebrow with a devil smile on face*)
P.S. I read the book for free on the Juggernaut app. You are free to download and read more such books on your own. [Especially now that they have collaborated with HarperCollins, which is a huge boost. I believe.]
May 19, 2018
The book starts on a high note setting the premise for the crimes and within a few pages, the suspense is almost revealed. This seems to be a trend as I observed recent books revealing the end at the start and then trying to hold the reader’s interest by taking them along the journey.
It doesn’t feel like the author’s debut novel as the narrative flows with a tight grip on the story and happenings, almost till the end. The protagonist Reshma is an intelligent and smart cop whose no-nonsense attitude is the major positive for the book. Her characterization is almost flawless and the main reason to engage the reader. Lad who is unintentionally witty has to be my next favorite. The author never wastes time with unnecessary deviations or descriptions or back stories, which helps the story to never lose momentum. A number of present day issues in the society have been dealt with in a sensible way and what is more appealing is the fact that it showcases that even the rich and highly educated are no exceptions.
What could have been better — there are too many hints dropped in the first few pages and the first half, there isnt much left for guessing. Shravan who shows much promise initially is not explored to the calibre of the character. Reshma also doesnt explore some important aspects of the case as her investigation becomes uni-dimensional towards the end. The pre-climax and climax doesnt live upto the promise the story shows mid way.
Overall, the book has some strong, well developed characters, and explores important issues faced by modern societies, like corruption and emotional vulnerabilities. With a better ending and more taut suspense, this could have been an extraordinary book which just falls a bit short. Even with those few flaws this is a must read and bet you can’t stop reading midway!
Full review on my blog:
https://medium.com/@kiranmayi.g/book-...
It doesn’t feel like the author’s debut novel as the narrative flows with a tight grip on the story and happenings, almost till the end. The protagonist Reshma is an intelligent and smart cop whose no-nonsense attitude is the major positive for the book. Her characterization is almost flawless and the main reason to engage the reader. Lad who is unintentionally witty has to be my next favorite. The author never wastes time with unnecessary deviations or descriptions or back stories, which helps the story to never lose momentum. A number of present day issues in the society have been dealt with in a sensible way and what is more appealing is the fact that it showcases that even the rich and highly educated are no exceptions.
What could have been better — there are too many hints dropped in the first few pages and the first half, there isnt much left for guessing. Shravan who shows much promise initially is not explored to the calibre of the character. Reshma also doesnt explore some important aspects of the case as her investigation becomes uni-dimensional towards the end. The pre-climax and climax doesnt live upto the promise the story shows mid way.
Overall, the book has some strong, well developed characters, and explores important issues faced by modern societies, like corruption and emotional vulnerabilities. With a better ending and more taut suspense, this could have been an extraordinary book which just falls a bit short. Even with those few flaws this is a must read and bet you can’t stop reading midway!
Full review on my blog:
https://medium.com/@kiranmayi.g/book-...
April 28, 2018
Fast Paced Captivating Thriller
Hush a Bye Baby is a crime fiction authored by Deepanjana Pal. This is the author’s debut novel and it’s Wow! The story starts with the poplar socialite gynecologist Dr. Nandita Rai, getting arrested for interrogation of female feticide. The team of police working on this case, under several pressures, have to prove their point and get the culprit to accept the crime and bring her to justice.
Whether Dr. Rai commits the gender-selective abortions or not is no secret. The thrill is built when the Team of police – Hadpude, Lad and Reshma begin hunting for clues and work along their way through strenuous interrogation.
What is revealed in the process is a sneak peak of inner lives of the rich and famous, pre-natal gender determination, female genital mutilation, in addition to gender selective abortions. There is definitely more to the story than what meets the eye.
The buildup is killing and intense. As a reader you feel helpless, when you see the protagonist going nowhere with the case and the available information. The conclusion however, is a little flimsy compared to the rest of the story. Having said that, when you read it, you can’t deny this could be the reality of the society. The kind of events we witness in the present day world, depression, inability to speaking up could lead to a mind-set wherein one may not be able to identify the rights and wrongs.
Overall this is a riveting thriller that keeps its readers turning pages anxiously. It is not a women centric story but both the genders get equal treatment here. The writing is fluent and enjoyable; the characterisation is flawless, you can actually see what’s going inside the characters head.
Recommended Read!
Awaiting for the sequel, Deepanjana :)
My takeaway: What is right, what is wrong, who are we to decide.
My rating: 4 out of 5.
Hush a Bye Baby is a crime fiction authored by Deepanjana Pal. This is the author’s debut novel and it’s Wow! The story starts with the poplar socialite gynecologist Dr. Nandita Rai, getting arrested for interrogation of female feticide. The team of police working on this case, under several pressures, have to prove their point and get the culprit to accept the crime and bring her to justice.
Whether Dr. Rai commits the gender-selective abortions or not is no secret. The thrill is built when the Team of police – Hadpude, Lad and Reshma begin hunting for clues and work along their way through strenuous interrogation.
What is revealed in the process is a sneak peak of inner lives of the rich and famous, pre-natal gender determination, female genital mutilation, in addition to gender selective abortions. There is definitely more to the story than what meets the eye.
The buildup is killing and intense. As a reader you feel helpless, when you see the protagonist going nowhere with the case and the available information. The conclusion however, is a little flimsy compared to the rest of the story. Having said that, when you read it, you can’t deny this could be the reality of the society. The kind of events we witness in the present day world, depression, inability to speaking up could lead to a mind-set wherein one may not be able to identify the rights and wrongs.
Overall this is a riveting thriller that keeps its readers turning pages anxiously. It is not a women centric story but both the genders get equal treatment here. The writing is fluent and enjoyable; the characterisation is flawless, you can actually see what’s going inside the characters head.
Recommended Read!
Awaiting for the sequel, Deepanjana :)
My takeaway: What is right, what is wrong, who are we to decide.
My rating: 4 out of 5.
April 15, 2018
A captivating fast paced thriller, this book revolves around Dr. Nandita Rai a gynecologist for the stars. She is a famous South Mumbai feminist figure who is on TV and radio every other day talking about women’s issues. Every woman wants her to be their doctor. Until the Mumbai Police raid her clinic when they get a complaint that she does sex selective abortions or rather female foeticide. Is the celebrity feminist doctor aborting female foetuses? Were all her feminist campaigns a cover up? The language was modish and comprehensive. The pace was perfect for the plot and so were the characters. Read it till the end, and I promise; it’ll take you by surprise. The way the sudden twist was incorporated, and how the author kept hinting all the way made the book even more interesting. Nandita’s alluring and equally mysterious personality was like a cherry on the top of the cake. Her sarcastic reply to her caller on the radio show was a complete killer. I also liked the way Deepanjana characterized Vikram. However, the book could have ended much better if the book didn’t have the last three pages. It seemed like a desperate attempt to make the book stand out and to show that it was not a run-of-the-mill, which wasn’t necessary, because the very concept and the way it turned out, went really well. Perhaps it could better end with the culprit’s verdict. Also there are a few questions which remain unanswered; like who were making those anonymous calls? And what was hidden motive of the vigilante online messaging board? Nevertheless, ‘twas a memorable read overall. Best wishes and good luck to Deepanjana Paul, looking forward to read more from her.
April 20, 2018
In a patriarchal society, a woman’s agency over her own body is overridden by other actors in the system – her husband, her children, extended family, workplace members. How does an educated, rational woman react to these injustices that have seeped into the psyche of our society?
Deepanjana Pal’s novel – Hush a Bye Baby explores these questions in the form of a fast paced, police procedural thriller that explores a celebrity doctor – Nandita Rai who is soon accused of conducting sex selection tests. Ms. Pal does find a voice of her characters and the novel moves at the breathtaking speed.
From a POV standpoint, Dr. Nandita Rai is portrayed as an enigma. The characters and the reader have a hard time reading into her intentions, her thoughts. This makes it a bit hard to empathize with her. Ms. Pal is in good form while handling Reshma – the ex-cyber wing, sub-inspector. We understand her aversion to interviews, love for finding digital trials that further cracks the case, and her frustrations of working with colleagues who have a hard time understanding technology, but also treat her like she needs protection and guidance. Hence, her action towards the end of the novel makes much sense compared to Dr. Nandita Rai or any other characters in the story.
The novel manages to make it to the finish line but for me the ending left you feeling empty. There were a lot of questions that were unanswered, POV characters and expositions that doesn’t receive proper resolution. I wonder if there a sequel to the book where Ms. Pal would further explore the open ended questions.
Deepanjana Pal’s novel – Hush a Bye Baby explores these questions in the form of a fast paced, police procedural thriller that explores a celebrity doctor – Nandita Rai who is soon accused of conducting sex selection tests. Ms. Pal does find a voice of her characters and the novel moves at the breathtaking speed.
From a POV standpoint, Dr. Nandita Rai is portrayed as an enigma. The characters and the reader have a hard time reading into her intentions, her thoughts. This makes it a bit hard to empathize with her. Ms. Pal is in good form while handling Reshma – the ex-cyber wing, sub-inspector. We understand her aversion to interviews, love for finding digital trials that further cracks the case, and her frustrations of working with colleagues who have a hard time understanding technology, but also treat her like she needs protection and guidance. Hence, her action towards the end of the novel makes much sense compared to Dr. Nandita Rai or any other characters in the story.
The novel manages to make it to the finish line but for me the ending left you feeling empty. There were a lot of questions that were unanswered, POV characters and expositions that doesn’t receive proper resolution. I wonder if there a sequel to the book where Ms. Pal would further explore the open ended questions.
October 3, 2020
I came to know about this book on YouTube channel Books on Toast. Where the author was a guest more than a year ago. Wanted to read this book ever since.
A big thanks to author Deepanjana and Juggernaut to let me access this book free on their app.
This book is crime fiction I have no regrets about . Enjoyed reading it.
The strong introduction of Dr. Nandita Rai was enough for me to hook to the story.
Each character is elaborate and multi-layered. Despite having so many characters you aren't confused anywhere.
Reshma Gabuji/Rashida/Zinat is a sweetheart.
Each and every character is someone we know from Sravan to Lad to Anita to Shetty to Hadpude.
How do you pronounce "Hadpude" anyway? That's a strange name to me because the only marathi friends I had was Ahire and Kulkarni.
My guess is the club mentioned in Calcutta is none other than CCFC.
A song by Tagore that I like so much is ruined because of the like "dukho bole roinu chupe tahar payer chinho rupe"
Also reminded me of Sydney Sheldon's never let me go due to "hush a bye baby"
Aboud the Rida, you can spot people in rida in Kolkata but I admit that they are very few.
A big thanks to author Deepanjana and Juggernaut to let me access this book free on their app.
This book is crime fiction I have no regrets about . Enjoyed reading it.
The strong introduction of Dr. Nandita Rai was enough for me to hook to the story.
Each character is elaborate and multi-layered. Despite having so many characters you aren't confused anywhere.
Reshma Gabuji/Rashida/Zinat is a sweetheart.
Each and every character is someone we know from Sravan to Lad to Anita to Shetty to Hadpude.
How do you pronounce "Hadpude" anyway? That's a strange name to me because the only marathi friends I had was Ahire and Kulkarni.
My guess is the club mentioned in Calcutta is none other than CCFC.
A song by Tagore that I like so much is ruined because of the like "dukho bole roinu chupe tahar payer chinho rupe"
Also reminded me of Sydney Sheldon's never let me go due to "hush a bye baby"
Aboud the Rida, you can spot people in rida in Kolkata but I admit that they are very few.
December 23, 2020
3.5 Stars!
Usually the feeling after reading a book is between excellent and bad. Hush A Bye Baby evokes a completely different spectrum of emotions!
There are parts where you’re intrigued, horrified, repulsed and down right stumps. The book has an intriguing premise with a murderous OBGYN and the journey to uncovering her motives. And largely the book is well executed and a fast paced. I quite loved the theatrics and drama. The twist was pretty good and intriguing. Its also a powerful commentary on society and feminism, making you truly question: are any of us right? Or are we all fighting for our own interpretation of things?
My only problem with the book is the way the characters are etched out. Maybe its on purpose, but aside from the villainous doctor, not much is known about the other characters. Even the female cop (protagonist) who is investigating her. There are brief references to a strained relationship with her father but the genesis is unclear. This makes it a little difficult to invest in the protagonist or any other characters. There are also some characters who add very little to the arc of the story.
Aside from that, its an intriguing plot and a pretty decent attempt at executing it!
Usually the feeling after reading a book is between excellent and bad. Hush A Bye Baby evokes a completely different spectrum of emotions!
There are parts where you’re intrigued, horrified, repulsed and down right stumps. The book has an intriguing premise with a murderous OBGYN and the journey to uncovering her motives. And largely the book is well executed and a fast paced. I quite loved the theatrics and drama. The twist was pretty good and intriguing. Its also a powerful commentary on society and feminism, making you truly question: are any of us right? Or are we all fighting for our own interpretation of things?
My only problem with the book is the way the characters are etched out. Maybe its on purpose, but aside from the villainous doctor, not much is known about the other characters. Even the female cop (protagonist) who is investigating her. There are brief references to a strained relationship with her father but the genesis is unclear. This makes it a little difficult to invest in the protagonist or any other characters. There are also some characters who add very little to the arc of the story.
Aside from that, its an intriguing plot and a pretty decent attempt at executing it!
June 30, 2018
The book makes for an excellent read. The thoughts behind the decisions made by the investigation team is very well put forward. The painstaking methodology adopted by the investigating team is well articulated and is convincingly written.
https://nairsudhir.wordpress.com/2018...
https://nairsudhir.wordpress.com/2018...
July 8, 2018
Decent thriller read for a weekend. The plot reveals the criminal within the first 50 pages and the rest of the book is more on the investigation. The plot development weakens however in the last 50-100 pages. Overall, decent read for a debut novel. Language is unremarkable.
June 27, 2018
If you want to know how the upper class about the female fetus read it. However I found it flat, boring, constantly looking for excitement which never came
December 12, 2019
Reminded me of Robin Cook's medical thrillers. Good one.
April 13, 2020
Poorly written...Fails to engage the reader in the story and empathise for any of the characters.. Everything falls magically into place..too convenient for a crime thriller
January 6, 2023
Very weak plot and articulation.
Not something I would recommend people to read.
Not something I would recommend people to read.
December 8, 2025
The story of a feminist vigilante driven by a misguided notion of justice. Sort of simplistic in plot but engrossing and racy enough.
Rating: More like 3.5 stars.
Rating: More like 3.5 stars.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews