I think ol' Tom has jumped the shark.
(Note that the copy I have shows the author as N.T. Wright, but I've also seen books with the authors name of Tom Wright. Maybe he's trying to be more relatable?)
I just have to say how disappointed I am in this book. Especially after I liked Matthew for Everyone.
This is supposed to be a guide to John for everyone. But at best, it's vague, doesn't expand on the text, or clarify anything. At worst it uses jargon that anyone outside evangelical Christianity will find hard to follow.
On Jesus coming to earth:
He laid aside the clothes of glory, and put on our human nature, in order to wash our feet.
On the resurrection of Lazarus:
And the dead man comes out - a heart-stopping moment of shuddering horror and overwhelming joy, mixed together like dark mud and liquid gold.
Instead of explaining things in this
commentary
, he says things like:
The only way forward is to allow all the different ideas and levels, the clashes of meaning and misunderstanding, to echo around until they produce prayer, awe, silence and love.
(I just noticed - no Oxford comma. *sigh*)
Also:
Stand in your mind's eye with the disciples in the boat. What projects have you been labouring over, and getting nowhere? Watch for the dawn. Watch for the figure on the shore. Listen for his voice. And then do whatever he tells you.
It just doesn't read like it's for everyone.
It sounds more like the Daily Devotional books that Donald Miller talks about than a commentary. Cute stories that only barely illustrate the points in the scripture. Unanswered questions. Vague emotional inspirations.
He uses "I think" too much and fills in the blanks with speculation instead of using good scholarship.
I wish I could count how many times I wrote in the margins, "doesn't make sense" or "Really?" or "WTF?!?"
It's like Wright is trying to do a Max Lucado knockoff. Now, I think Lucado has his place, but it's not in a scholarly commentary intended to be accessible to anyone.
My first note in the book (on page 1) is: "How old is Wright? Is it possible he's starting to lose his edge?"
By the time I finished it, I felt like he'd lost it completely.