I came across this book on Twitter, where it was recommended by a friend who is a public librarian and an authority on middle grade books. Since a review copy was available on NetGalley, I logged my request and got the free eARC on my Kindle. Needless to say (but am still saying it!) this does not impact my review of the book.
Krista Kim-Bap is a slice of the life of twelve-year old Krista Kim who is a Korean-Canadian living in Vancouver. She has never been to Korea, cannot speak or read Korean and has little information about Korean history or culture. The one Korean thing she truly loves is Korean food. Sharing her love for bulgogi and kimchi is her best friend since preschool, Jason. Jason is Scottish Canadian, but adores the bold, punchy flavours of Korean Food. Krista and Jason are inseparable and have perfect understanding between them, without any sort of romantic feelings.
On the other hand, Krista has zero understanding with her elder sister Tori. Tori is in high school, tries to underplay her Korean-ness as much as possible, has a keen sense of fashion and always looks beautifully put-together with perfect hair, trendy clothes and the poise to match. Krista lives in jeans, tshirts and sneakers, her hair is always twisted up in a ponytail and she thinks that she and Tori just don't have anything in common to connect over.
The story begins with their class teacher Mrs. June announcing a new project for Heritage Month- they each have to make a presentation and submit a report about their heritage. Krista is lost, and has no idea how to talk to her classmates about what it feels to be Korean when she knows next to nothing about Korea and does not feel as Korean as much as she feels Canadian. But Jason comes to the rescue and suggests that she base her project on Korean food, since it is something she feels strongly about.
Thus begins the most tumultuous period of Krista's hitherto uneventful life. She approaches her stern and critical grandmother for help with her project. Grandma Kim had emigrated to Canada from Korea years ago, and still holds the views and opinions she had had as a young woman in Korea. She believes in girls dressing up, wearing make up and looking pretty- everything that Krista hates. Her compliments to Krista are all backhanded and she is mistrustful of her friendship with Jason. But she is very helpful (in her brusque way) and starts teaching Krista to make Korean food. She takes her and Tori to a Korean salon to get their hair and makeup done. Tori, coming to know of Krista's project, makes her a modern version of the traditional Korean dress hanbok that she can wear for her presentation. As Krista explores becoming more 'girly', all the popular girls in her class 'discover' her and invite her to join their clique. Suddenly it is as if there are too many changes happening in Krista's life and as she drifts apart from Jason, she feels like she is lost as she tries to find herself. The rest of the book is about how she finds her way to her real self, with help from her grandmother and mother.
I liked the book because it gave me a window into Korean food and culture. I had no idea that kim-bap was the Korean version of sushi (though never say that to a Korean!) or that saangapul tape or ssangapul surgery (to make the eyes look bigger) was a part of Korean beauty culture and almost a rite of passage there. I found myself looking up things online while reading the book which I think is the best thing a book can do- make the reader more curious and hence more informed.
I also liked the message in the book- be true to yourself. The talking-to Krista's mom gives to her and Tori about being comfortable in their own skins is one of the best advice I have seen being given to tweens and teens who are exploring their own identities- it is balanced and sensible, without any talking down. The advice Grandmother Kim gives Jason (and Krista) about being vocal about your feelings rather than expecting your loved ones to simply understand you is also important.
What I didn't like is the style of narration- it reads in a montone, like a boring, ceaseless ticking of words like the seconds hand of a clock. Writing should be a mix of long sentences and short, of vivid exclamations and patient explanations, of evocative descriptions and interesting conversation. It should not be a rhythmic endless barrage of words with little texture and emotion to bring it alive. The books suffers from this. Another the thing that irked me is that some of the dialogue is stilted and unrealistic. In several places, people address each other by name even while its just the two of them talking, which never happens in real life. For example:
1)
“Tori, you did this?” my mom was amazed. She looked pleased. “Yes, I did. Not bad, huh?”
“Tori, it looks amazing! I was wondering what you were doing last night. What’s it for?”
2)
”I’m going to tell you something else, Krista, because, I know I shouldn’t be, but I am totally shocked at how naïve you are."
3)
When I finally calmed down, I asked, half afraid, “Jason, are we good?”
"Krista, we’re good,” he said.
But according to me, these flaws in writing are more the editor's responsibility than the author's.
In conclusion, the book has a nice message and a great intro to Korean culture. A better, more thorough edit would have made all the difference.
Suitable for kids aged 10-12.